10 minutes of expert insights every weekday. Your morning ritual for staying ahead in retail media.
Ep 4 - Speed beats size
===
[00:00:00] Kiri: This is part four of Arming the Rebels, a Retail Media Breakfast Club series with Anthony Rotio, co-founder and co-CEO of Growth Loop, brought to you courtesy of Growth Loop
[00:00:12]
[00:00:14] Kiri: back to the Retail [00:00:15] Media Breakfast Club. I'm Kiri Masters, and today I'm joined again with a special guest, Anthony Rotio, the co-founder and co-CEO of Growth Loop.
[00:00:24] Welcome back, Anthony
[00:00:26] Anthony: Oh, thank you, Kerry. It's great to be here. Really appreciated your time on this series[00:00:30]
[00:00:30] Kiri: Yeah, and this is, I've saved the best for last because we've kept touching on this throughout the series is this concept of speed and why does speed matter? And here is how I'm gonna tee this up for you. We've talked throughout this series [00:00:45] about arming the rebels. Look, you might not be the biggest retailer out there.
[00:00:49] You might not be the biggest retail media network out there. You're never going to be the size of Amazon and that's not the point. It is about competing for budgets [00:01:00] from your brand partners. And if you're a smaller network and a smaller retail, you can't win on scale, but what you can win on is speed. And I want to understand from you, Anthony, because this came up [00:01:15] time and time again in the research that you did, the Commerce Media Investment Index where you, uh, polled a bunch of, uh, brand side media buyers to find out what was important to them when it comes to actually, you know, investing with retail [00:01:30] media networks.
[00:01:30] And speed was a big, um, factor. Speed of getting an audience live, getting reporting back. And so I wanna understand from you, is there a time that you can think of where a brand asked a network for an audience it [00:01:45] couldn't deliver in time? Or like why, tell us about a time where this, you know, speed actually killed investment in a retail media network
[00:01:55] Anthony: Yeah, I mean, 86% of, uh, of buyers say they [00:02:00] would walk if the fulfillment is too slow. And this is the-- this is a huge, uh, time for, you know, could be mid-market networks that can move with more agility, right? Four-plus days is the average turnaround time for a custom audience. And we see this time and time [00:02:15] again is if you do, like, the Pareto analysis of, uh, 80/20, you know, 80% of the budget comes from 20% of the buyers.
[00:02:22] Those get the white glove managed service treatment, but even then it can be slow to turn custom audiences, right? And then the rest, that long tail, that middle [00:02:30] tail is ripe opportunity for folks to be able to serve better with technology. And this is the-- some of the capabilities we've added where a brand can upload a brief, and then the brief will be matched to the retailer data, and within a minute or two, you know, the, [00:02:45] the retailer will have an audience that they can review and approve to go out to the, the retailer.
[00:02:51] Like, this is the type of technology that can disrupt, um, and, and help capture some of that, um, that pain that the brand buyers [00:03:00] are feeling, right? It, it's, uh... I was, I was on the brand side, right? Is when you have this giant activation and part of it is activating through your partners, a lot of times you're late internally, right?
[00:03:10] And you have a lot of, uh, you know, agency partners to manage and operational things to [00:03:15] manage, media budgets to manage. You gotta get those dollars activated when-- in the right window when you're trying to activate this campaign, right? And if you're not getting served quickly, you're gonna take those dollars somewhere else.
[00:03:25] So I think this is a, it is a real opportunity for folks to [00:03:30] come in and, and disrupt, um, you know, even, even when we're talking about a few days' difference in response time can make the, make, make the difference for these budgets walking.
[00:03:39] Kiri: So just to sort of flesh out some examples here, you'd have, as a, as a brand side media buy, [00:03:45] you'd have some audiences that would be sort of always on. Like we're always gonna be targeting a youth sports audience, right? Or, you know, if you're a, a s- a sports brand. But what about like, you know, there's a, the, the weather, [00:04:00] the weather changes or there's like a really important cultural moment that happens in youth sports and you wanna get behind that.
[00:04:06] These are the kind of scenarios that we're talking about, right? Where you wanna really jump behind a moment in culture, in, [00:04:15] um, you know, w- what's going on in the real world.
[00:04:18] Anthony: Yeah, and even a simpler one that I think applies probably to a lot of folks too is we have a, we have a large customer in Europe that, um, has a lot of brand partners that [00:04:30] suddenly media budgets open up around the end of the year, right? And suddenly there was a November 29th request for, I think it was seven or eight briefs came in on the same day for Christmas campaigns, [00:04:45] and these were multilingual documents coming in.
[00:04:48] Some were media budgets, some were, um, some were brand briefs and, like, the, the content, content briefs and things. And this-- They said, "We just can't do this in time." And I said, "Well, [00:05:00] have you tried to just dump them into AI Studio and see what comes out?" And they did it, and they, and mean- and meanwhile, they had some that were built by hand by the team, you know, anxiously working over the weekend and things.
[00:05:11] And in this case, we actually had measurement turned on for some of [00:05:15] these brands, and, um, the CPM performance, the ROAS performance of the ones that the agents generated, and this was last Christmas, so think about the, how, how much better all the AI technology has gotten since then, out- outperformed the hand-build au- built audiences by [00:05:30] 20% to 30% in some cases on these metrics.
[00:05:32] So it's something where, you know, it's, it's speed, but also you're seeing, like, if you can act well with the speed as the technology gets better, the quality may, may be better too, as you have access to all of this rich data sitting in [00:05:45] the data warehouse. Um, and you know, it's, uh, it's wild times. This is not, not things we had seen previously, uh, if you go back 18 months or more, that only now have been kind of unlocked for some of these folks who do wanna come in and disrupt.[00:06:00]
[00:06:00] Kiri: That's a, that's a great example, and I, I wanna get into ... 'Cause we have, uh, retailers listening to this show as well as brands as well who are curious about what goes on under the hood and, and why do, why do all of these things matter. What actually, what, where does the [00:06:15] time go between a brand's request like that and getting a campaign live?
[00:06:20] Like, what, what's happening to slow all of this down?
[00:06:23] Anthony: Yeah. I mean, I'll, I'll, I'll spell it out and what will probably be painful to some listeners 'cause it'll sound all too familiar or maybe even [00:06:30] faster than internal processes sometimes is, you know, requests will come in from the brand. Um, that request will be in a different format than the last seven requests have been that came in, and someone will manually input that into a form or maybe you have an agent try to map it to a [00:06:45] form.
[00:06:45] The form will go to a Jira ticket. The Jira ticket will go to the tech team. Uh, there'll be someone who's writing SQL to build this audience and get it, you know, get this, uh, query and this code to represent what they think is there in the form. That'll go [00:07:00] back over the fence on the Jira ticket to the, to the managed services team.
[00:07:04] They'll take a look at it. It'll be wrong. It'll go back again, right? And four days actually gets, is, doesn't sound that slow when you think about the manual steps that go into this in a lot, in a lot of, um, [00:07:15] in a lot of these places. But, um, but it can, it adds up really quickly, right? Um, especially at these, these pivotal times of year that may be close to holidays, you know, maybe around weekends and things is suddenly it's a week, two weeks, and you haven't, you haven't gotten this back [00:07:30] to, you know.
[00:07:30] Then you gotta, then you gotta, you know, if you're using an onboarding partner, you're gonna add 30, 40 hours in some cases there to get it onboarded and matched, right? And then you're making it available there. You gotta actually point somebody to it. They have to go ahead and go in and select it. There's a [00:07:45] lot of processes here.
[00:07:46] Forecasting the avails and the impressions on it, and is this actually enough budget for me to spend based on my campaign? So that, you know, the end-to-end steps, I think when we looked at this, uh, with Mark and team at Costco, for example, the map, it [00:08:00] gets really long really quickly. And, and what we try to do as partners is see where we can help cut down some of that map and make the, make the response time a little bit quicker.
[00:08:10] Kiri: So have you seen sort of smaller networks [00:08:15] punching above their weight by being faster than their larger counterparts? Is that actually a dimension that some retailers are competing on?
[00:08:25] Anthony: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, GoPuff is a great example of this. They move really fast. I've, I've [00:08:30] used an example a couple of times of them building, uh, hundreds of audiences in, in an hour or two after going live with us. But we see this in some of our sports media partners as well. Um, when you're able to respond really quickly to those folks who aren't [00:08:45] used-- especially those who aren't used to getting responses quickly on the brand side, suddenly they're leaned in, right?
[00:08:50] And suddenly they see a difference. And then if you do have some new offering on measurement or you have some new offering on maybe micro-segmentation for some of your audiences where they might have [00:09:00] been l- just looking for scale originally, now they'll, now they'll pay attention and lean in with you on some of the more custom things that you're trying to do with them.
[00:09:07] So speed is an indication of partnership in most cases, right? And when they see speed, they see someone who cares about them, and that makes them [00:09:15] much more open to you being a strategic partner for them, uh, as a retailer instead of just being another marketplace to go grab something from.
[00:09:23] Kiri: So I had this like cheat when, when I wrote up, um, a piece that covered your commerce media investment [00:09:30] index, which is where we're getting a lot of these stats from, I said, "Well, sure, I would, I would like a Porsche, but, um, I'm not willing to pay for one." Like, uh, yeah, this, this sounds great. Speed sounds great.
[00:09:42] Um, is there a trade-off [00:09:45] between speed and cost,
[00:09:48] Anthony: It's funny
[00:09:49] Kiri: your world?
[00:09:50] Anthony: yeah, when you actually look at the, the stack simplification that comes with a composable solution, often they're getting-- they're having their cake and eating it too, right? In terms of the, [00:10:00] the, the TCO of their, their retail media technology stack. And when, when you talk about media network margins, right?
[00:10:07] It's like the technology is kind of the costs of goods sold. There's not a whole lot of o- and you have your teams obviously, and your people, but in [00:10:15] terms of the levers you have to pull, in terms of margin, like this is the place where you can also get back that bottom line too. So it's, um, it's something where like GrowthLoop's not gonna come in and knock out your whole stack.
[00:10:26] Like that's not what GrowthLoop does. We're not the full, and you, you know, we're not, we're [00:10:30] not doing every single piece of the retail media stack. But you should really look at the stack and sometimes these things look like spaghetti diagrams on the architecture page and ask, "How can I simplify this?" Or, "Am I being held hostage anywhere by any, any [00:10:45] specific partner?"
[00:10:45] Or my u- it's usage-based instead of platform-based, uh, fees, right? It's like, are your costs scaling the more, the more you're using the network or the more buyers that you have? And those things can add up quickly too, and those are, those are ripe opportunities for increasing [00:11:00] your margins as a retailer as well.
[00:11:02] Kiri: Yeah, that's a great point. And, and just hearing you talk about, well, you got the Jira ticket, and then that ha- the SQL query has to be written, and then there's some amendments to that. Like, those are real costs. So, um, yeah, I can, [00:11:15] I can pick up what, what you're talking about here. All right, Anthony, we've just, uh, wrapped our four-part series about arming the rebels and how, um, the, the, the challenger retail media networks can compete, like, [00:11:30] versus, uh, you know, not just on size, but on speed, on capabilities, on staying what is true to them and true value proposition.
[00:11:39] Is there anything else you wanna leave the audience with before we wrap up?
[00:11:43] Anthony: I think the biggest thing [00:11:45] is, um, find, find a few places where you think you can have an edge as an organization and get started quickly, right? Is, uh, it's never as messy as you think it is. There is a mess, and I don't wanna discount that, you know, we talked in one-- another episode about d- you [00:12:00] know, data mess in some situations.
[00:12:01] And, um, we've, we've seen time and time again that there can be a clear path when you have a, when you have a clear vision and the right partners in the room to help you execute, uh, against it. So I love the, I love the name of Arming the [00:12:15] Rebels. Um, I think that's the right positioning is if you're a maverick in your organization and you want to e-enable change, um, there are partners out there that can help you do it.
[00:12:24] And, you know, look to Kiri and her content. She's, uh, she's great at showing [00:12:30] the, showing the way and showing the light, um, for some of these challengers that are out there. So I, I just really appreciate the time, Kiri, and thank you so much for, for this series, and we'll look forward to speaking again soon.
[00:12:41]
[00:12:43] Kiri: And that's the end of [00:12:45] Arming the Rebels. Thanks to Anthony Rotio and to Growth Loop for bringing us this series. Most of the numbers that we used across these four episodes came from Growth Loop's Commerce Media Investment Index, and a [00:13:00] link to that report is in the show notes. Each episode stands on its own, so if you missed one, start with whichever problem your network has right now.
[00:13:10] I'm Kiri Masters, and I'll see you next time
[00:13:12]