The cost & courage of caring - stories that spark resilience.
I love them, but I don't want to
be their caregiver anymore.
What do you do when that is the
truth and admitting it makes you
feel like a terrible
person?
I'm Dr.
Mark Ropaleski and this is The
Caregiver's Podcast.
Today, Elaine K.
Sanchez returns to explore guilt,
resentment, and the thoughts
caregivers
are afraid to say out loud.
How do you give generously to
someone you love without giving up
the life you want for
yourself?
And why can wanting both leave you
feeling just so guilty?
Please subscribe or follow The
Caregiver's Podcast wherever you
watch or listen.
It takes just a second and it
really helps the show reach more
caregivers in need.
Elaine, welcome back.
Elaine, welcome back to The
Caregiver's Podcast.
As always, we're delighted that
you're here with us today.
I'm so happy to be with you, Dr.
Mark.
Thank you for inviting me back.
Well, let's jump into it.
Elaine, a caregiver says, I love
them, but I don't want to do this
anymore.
I want my life back.
Why can admitting that just feel
like admitting that they don't
love the person enough?
Well, one step is admitting it and
being able to say it out loud.
Because I think anyone who has
been doing 24-hour care, or even
if they are trying to balance
the needs of their care receiver
with their family needs, with
their work needs, everybody's
going to feel that way.
You know, you love them.
But there comes a point when you
give so much to your care receiver
and to everybody else
that you just want to have some
time and some space, some
emotional space for your own
needs.
And that's not selfish.
It's not just a question of
wanting the whole life, the whole
package like it was back, but
the power to carve little parts
that are aligned with me that I
can call my life.
Right, right.
So I've got a story about that.
I had a dear friend whose husband
was diagnosed with cancer, and he
was given a diagnosis of
a very short time to live.
And he agreed to do some very
aggressive treatments.
And once a month, he would have to
go into the hospital, and they
were horrible side effects,
you know, chills and nausea and
just awful side effects.
And then he would come home for a
week, and he would still be like
that.
And after three years, one day, I
met his wife at the church.
We were going into an exercise
program.
And I said, oh, Judy, I'm so happy
to see you.
And I said, has something changed?
And she said, yes, I have.
I decided I cannot continue to not
live my life while I am waiting
for Robert to die.
And I said, good for you.
So she said, I'm going to the
exercise class.
I'm doing that for myself because
I just have to.
And it had been three years.
And he was expected to live for
six months.
So, you know, when people talk
about guilt, and she had passed
that, you know, she had really
struggled with it, you know, can
you go off and leave your husband
to go to an exercise class
or do something for yourself when
they're only going to live for
this much longer?
So I was really happy to see her.
And I don't remember how much
longer he lived, but it was at
least a year.
I can hear a caregiver saying, I
miss the old me.
I miss who I was before caregiving
took over.
How can missing your own life turn
into resentment towards someone
you love and guilt about feeling
that way?
Oh, it, it, I don't know how you
could not.
Um, it's, it's so, well, for one
thing, I think it's easy to
remember the past, the good parts
of it.
Uh, none of our lives are perfect.
We always have, we always have
challenges every day, you know,
whether it's the computer or a
delivery package, you know,
something.
We, we live with frustration.
Um, but we, we remember backward,
I think, remembering the great
times.
And so you not only miss that
freedom, um, you miss who your
partner was or who your partner
was.
And what you were able to do with
them.
And of course that leads to
feelings of sadness, uh, feelings
of resentment.
And it's important to deal with
those because if you're constantly
dealing with anger and resentment
and guilt, that is a fast track to
depression.
But caregivers are sort of often
told, oh, you're so strong.
Yeah.
But often they have to be strong
because there is no other choice.
They're offloaded onto constantly
and they have no help.
Yeah.
So why does a caregiver often feel
guilty for resenting
responsibility?
They really never had the freedom
to refuse, let alone negotiate.
I think that's just human nature.
How do you not feel resentment?
Um, and I think they do feel
guilty.
And I, this, can I, can I talk
about the difference between
earned guilt and unearned guilt
here?
Oh, I think that would be really
important for listeners to
understand.
Yes.
So earned guilt is, um, it is a
response to, well, let me, let me
restate this just a minute.
Earned guilt is what you should
feel if you intentionally inflict
physical or emotional pain on
another person.
That's a really horrible thing to
do.
And if you do that, then you do,
you should do what you can to make
amends, you apologize, and then
don't ever do it again.
Unearned guilt comes from taking
on the responsibility of managing
problems or trying to solve
problems that don't have
solutions.
And even more pernicious, I think,
is taking on the responsibility
for making other people happy.
And this is, this is a really, um,
common situation with most
caregivers, that they feel like
it's up to them to make their care
receiver's life better,
or to solve the problem, or to
find a cure for the illness, uh,
and they want to make them happy.
And if somebody is living with a
progressive and degenerative
disease or constant pain, they're
not going to be happy.
And you can't, you just need to
accept that.
So, um, I think that's the first
step.
Recognizing the difference between
earned guilt and unearned guilt.
Does that make sense?
I think so.
And, I mean, we're all human.
And in certain moments, we may
snap and lose our patience and be
rude.
And, you know, a simple apology in
those, um, instances certainly
prevents a cascade of brewing
events and brewing guilt that can
then become hard to deal with
later on.
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
I find your point interesting
about taking on the burden of
other people's happiness, which
can be a pattern that begins long
before caregiving, but then can
just be amplified by caregiving.
Oh, so much.
I was, um, I was speaking at a
conference in California several
years ago and we'd had, you know,
I had done my presentation and
then, um, we were just doing kind
of a group discussion and question
and answer.
And this young woman raised her
hand and said, um, yes, I have a
question.
Can you tell me how I can make my
mother happy?
And I said, well, we can, let's
talk about that.
I said, first of all, has your
mother ever been happy?
And she said, oh no, no, she's
always been a piece of work.
And I said, okay, so what's going
on right now?
And she said, well, she called me
last week and she said, um, that
she wanted to move in with me.
And I said, do you want your
mother to live with you?
And she said, no, no, it would be
terrible.
And I said, okay, so tell me about
the conversation you've had so
far.
And she said, well, when she
called and told me that, I
thought, um, oh, that can't
happen.
And so I said, oh, mom, um,
there's a really nice active
retirement community that's just
about five minutes from our house.
And I think it would be great if
you would come and take a look at
that place.
And she said, well, no, there's
only old people there.
I don't want to move someplace
like that.
And then the daughter said, but,
you know, they have activities and
they do things every day and they
bring in people and entertainment.
And they have, they have a bus
that can take you places.
And her mother said, what,
activities like bingo?
You think I'm going to play bingo?
What's wrong with you?
And it just kept going on and on
like that.
And so then I said, okay, time
out, time out.
You need to change the narrative
here because you're trying to
convince her with logic and
reasonable choices that work for
you.
You're trying to convince her that
those are good.
And if she's only ever thought
about herself, if she's always
been a guilt tripper and a
manipulator, she is not going to
change.
And so you're going to have to set
some boundaries with her.
And I'm a big advocate of using I
statements.
So she said, well, what should I
tell her?
And I said, well, the first thing
I would tell her is, oh, mom, I
love you way too much to have you
move into my home with my family.
That simply will not work for us.
And I said, you'll say that and
then she'll come back and she'll
say, after all I've done for you.
And then you say, I love you, but
that will not work.
You cannot move into our house
with my family.
It simply will not work for us.
And then you just stop explaining
or apologizing.
You set the boundary.
You stick to it.
And, you know, as it progresses,
you can just gently respond that
way.
And then when you get to a point
that you aren't wanting to talk
about this anymore, you say, mom,
I've told you my answer.
My answer is final.
I'm not going to talk about this
anymore.
This topic is done.
And then if she comes back, which
she probably will, then when she
starts to bring it up, you say,
I've told you the answer is no.
I love you, but I'm done talking
about this.
And then I said, walk out of the
room or hang up the phone.
And she said, she's going to get
so angry.
I said, let her.
You know, her response is her
response.
It's her responsibility.
It's not up to you to manage her
emotional responses or feelings.
And that was radical for her.
I hope it worked.
Does that kind of work?
Go ahead.
Perhaps radical approach, at least
for the individual who's not used
to establishing boundaries, work
across different economic
circumstances?
Because the reality may be that
there may be no other option than
that individual moving in.
But can you still apply that same
approach, even if they've had to
move in?
Of course.
And you can do that on an everyday
basis, on an every issue basis.
You know, it's like, mom, you
cannot play the TV at full volume.
You know, we can get you some
earphones or something like this.
Or I need to have this time with
my husband and kids.
So if you set up the boundaries at
first and put them in writing, I
would recommend then you have an
agreement to what is okay and what
is not.
And what you need to protect your
own sanity and your own space.
So, Elaine, as I think about
things a little bit more, it just
keeps sort of coming back to me
that caregivers are potentially in
a vulnerable spot because they may
not be used to teasing out how
guilt arises and where its origin
is from.
And how do you distinguish as a
caregiver where the guilt is
coming from within as opposed to
from external manipulation?
Secondarily, you're feeling it.
I think most caregivers experience
both, Dr.
Mark.
You know, it's been my experience
that it doesn't matter how much
you give, how much you try, how
much you sacrifice as a caregiver.
You still think you should be able
to give more.
And I see that over and over and
over.
And so, you know, I want to talk
about changing your emotional
vocabulary.
But first, let's talk about how
you know if you're dealing with a
guilt tripper.
And this is, it's pretty easy if
you know what to look for.
A guilt tripper, people use
different tactics.
And sometimes it's anger.
And sometimes it's accusing you of
being selfish, of not caring for
them, not loving them.
And you only care about yourself.
And those, that's just
mean-spirited.
But they can be really good at it.
My dad was never angry.
I mean, he didn't get mad.
But he would just get so sad.
And if my mother had to be gone,
like for a meeting or something
like that, and she would leave
food for him,
he wouldn't eat it because he just
didn't know where it was or how to
put it on a plate and get it to
the table.
And he was just like, just stop
it.
He could be, he could just be so
sad.
And she didn't want him to be sad.
So she would do almost anything
that he wanted so that he would be
happy.
But I think for caregivers who
have used anger or guilt or
antagonism as a tool.
Caregivers or care recipients?
I'm sorry, what did I say?
You mentioned caregivers who've
used it as a tool.
I think you meant care recipients.
Thank you.
I meant to say care recipients who
use this as a tool.
Thank you for catching that.
You know, you just think if
something bad happens to you as a
caregiver or something great
happens, you know,
and let's say that you get a
promotion and it's going to take
more of your time and energy.
Or maybe they're just, maybe your
employer is sending you to a
conference.
So then they're starting to say
things like, well, that's good for
you, but it's going to be kind of
hard for me, isn't it?
I mean, who's going to, who's
going to, who's going to take me
to the doctor?
You know, how am I going to get,
um, the, how am I going to get the
yard mode?
How, who's going to take care of
getting my car serviced?
You know, and, and so they start
saying, laying this guilt trip on
you, um, because you're not going
to be able to do all of the things
for them.
Um, or they're afraid that you
might not, or let's say, you know,
let's say you step off of a curb
and you break your leg.
Um, if their thoughts are, oh,
this is going to be so
inconvenient for me, you're
dealing with a guilt tripper.
It's pretty obvious when they only
think about themselves and they
don't think about you as the
caregiver.
Um, and this isn't, this isn't,
certainly isn't limited to, um,
the care receiver.
Um, it can be siblings, um, you
know, it can be spouses.
Um, there are all sorts of people
who will put a guilt trip on you,
um, to get you to do what they
want.
And, and, and, and it's, they
don't care about you, they care
about themselves.
They always put themselves first.
I suspect those are usually
patterns that are well entrenched
long before.
Yes.
Caregiver assumes that role.
Absolutely.
And they get into the grind.
Absolutely.
So with my parents, if I can tell
another story there, um, my dad
had a stroke and, um, it was one
year after their 50th anniversary.
So it was their 51st anniversary.
On their 56th anniversary, his
prostate cancer had advanced.
He was often, it was, it was
really hard.
My mother frequently had to get up
in the night, change his sheets.
Um, he would forget to take off.
I mean, he would get the depends
down to his knees and then he
would let go.
And it would be all over the bed,
um, all over him, all over the
floor.
And the night before their 56th
wedding anniversary, which fell on
a Sunday, she had changed his
sheets three times and changed his
clothes.
And when she woke up in the
morning, um, she, she simply did
not have the energy, emotional or
physical, to get him ready to go
to church.
And she knew it was going to be a
special event.
There were going to be, uh, former
members.
There were special music, former,
former pastors, all that sort of
thing.
And, uh, she just, she got him
breakfast and then she got him set
out in the yard in the sunshine
and she, she went to town.
And she started feeling guilty
before she got to the end of the
driveway.
And by the time she got to the
church and parked in front, she
was beating herself up saying,
I could have gotten some of the
young guys to come out.
They would have helped get them
into the stairs.
They would have got them in this
chair and up to the sanctuary.
And, and, um, so then the, um, the
minister read a poem during the
service that was called Look at
Me.
And it was about an older woman
living in a nursing home.
And she was saying, you know, look
at me.
I'm, I'm not just a cranky old
woman.
And it was, it, it was my mother's
undoing.
She, she just started crying.
And, um, she felt so guilty.
And she went downstairs and she
went up to the beloved baritone of
the congregational church in
McPherson, Kansas.
And she said, don't you dare sing
happy anniversary to me.
And, uh, he said, but I've already
been told by two people to do it.
And she said, if you do, I will
lose it and I will never get it
back.
So he didn't.
She cried all the way home.
She got my dad into the kitchen
table.
She sat down, she cried, she
cried, she cried, telling him how
guilty she felt.
And he said, well, I feel like
crying too.
And that surprised me because it
surprised me that he didn't cry.
Because he could watch a
commercial.
If it had any emotion to it, he
would cry.
If he was listening to one of his
talking books and somebody was
going to get in trouble, he would
sob.
And it took me a while to figure
it out.
But then one day it was like, I
know why he didn't cry.
Because he knew if she was that
upset, she was not going to leave
him at home alone anymore.
She was either going to stay there
with him or she was going to take
him with her wherever he, wherever
she went.
So my dad used his sadness and his
helplessness to get my mom to do
whatever he wanted.
And that's, I think that's, that
is not an untypical, it's not
untypical behavior.
It's just unfortunate.
Worked out great for Quentin, just
not so good for Madeline.
Yeah, I've witnessed that too,
growing up with extended family
members.
It's kind of wild to see it
unfolding in front of you.
Uh-huh, it is, it is.
You know, Elaine, caregiving can
just condition a person to keep
looking for the next thing that
needs doing.
Yeah.
Then comes one of those rare
moments where everything's done
and your loved one's safe.
For five minutes, nothing really
needs your attention.
But instead of taking that moment
for yourself, guilt shows up.
You start searching for another
task, something else that you
should be doing.
How does guilt become a command to
keep going even when the caregiver
is exhausted?
And in the moment, no one really
needs anything of them.
Oh, that's an interesting
question.
I think we condition ourselves to
not think about ourselves and to
really only think about the
caregiver.
And we allow their needs or, you
know, I've seen so many times with
a lot of family members and
friends
continually looking for solutions
to problems that cannot be fixed.
And I know one couple, he was
fairly young and was diagnosed
with Parkinson's, and they just
would not accept that this was a
progressive degenerative disease.
And so they tried every single
option for treatment, whether it
was thoughtful and medically
approved, or whether it was some
off-the-wall thing.
I think when I talk about the
three steps of creative
indifference, I think that there
are times when we have to accept
that we can't solve every problem.
And that if we don't take care of
ourselves, we're not going to live
long enough to maybe see our loved
one through the end of their life.
So I think there is a lot that
needs to be done there to help
caregivers understand that taking
care of themselves is actually a
gift to their care receiver.
Because if they get sick, if they
get sick and if they die, then
their care receiver is going to be
in a world of hurt.
So when you keep thinking about,
is there one more thing I can try?
I admire the desire to do that and
the willingness to keep trying and
the willingness to keep giving.
But you really do have to give to
yourself and take care of yourself
if you want to be able to do this
long term.
I can see where caregivers can be
very determined and strong-willed
to pursue every avenue, look to
every nook and cranny for a
solution.
But there's something implicit
there where you kind of think that
there might be some balance that's
still present.
But there's something that guilt
does to throw off the balance,
even in the most determined
individuals.
It does.
What does guilt truly exert to
throw people off and not be able
to find five minutes or neglect
five minutes and choose something
else?
It's more than just a
problem-solver.
Like, I'm a problem-solver,
therefore I can't.
There's got to be something more
that guilt is playing and weaving
into that self-discussion.
Let's go back and just take a look
at earned guilt and unearned
guilt.
Okay, so with earned guilt, you
know, you intentionally do
something.
Unearned guilt is, again, feeling
responsible for making someone
happy.
So this would probably be a good
time to bring in the three steps
of creative indifference.
You know, we talk about this in
our program, that the first step
is to become aware.
And so if they have five minutes,
if there's anybody listening and
you have five minutes to spare,
sit down and write about what is
making you feel guilty.
And when I'm doing like a
presentation for a conference or
something, I say, pick one
situation that made you feel
guilty and just put it right here.
And then let's see if we can work
through that using this process.
So that's the first step.
You become aware of a specific
situation, event, or person that
made you feel guilty.
And then acceptance, when we talk
about it most of the time,
acceptance is accepting that there
are some things you cannot fix,
control, or change.
But when it comes to guilt, I want
people to accept that guilt may
not be an appropriate response.
And then that takes us to the
third step, which is action.
And I like to encourage people to
change their emotional vocabulary.
And this has made a huge
difference with so many people.
So guilt, yeah, guilt is a sense
of having done something wrong or
having failed in an obligation.
And so you take guilt, and I want
you to replace the word guilt with
the word regret.
Regret is a sense of sadness and
wishing that something could be
different.
So then you look at all of the
situations that cause people to
feel guilty.
So it might be, so you're
changing, you're just changing out
this word, okay?
So instead of saying guilt, we're
going to say regret.
So I regret that I sometimes lose
my temper and I say things that I
wish I could take back.
I regret that I resent how much
money it takes to provide for
their care.
And that sometimes I think about
the financial impact before I
think about the benefit.
I regret that our relationship has
changed and I don't enjoy being
with them anymore.
I regret that I just can't do
everything that they would like
for me to do or that I feel like I
should do.
I regret a lot of things, but
mostly I regret that there are
times I wish they would just die
and get it over with.
And that's a hard one.
It's hard for people to admit that
to themselves.
But I think when they know that it
doesn't make them a monster and
that they can still love their
care receiver with all of their
heart and still wish for this to
be over.
That feels very, very selfish.
And it isn't.
It isn't because you can feel like
a monster, you know, if you're
wanting somebody you love to die.
But the truth is there comes a
point when there is no quality of
life left for the person and there
is no quality of life for the care
receiver.
So I encourage people to say, I
regret that I feel this way.
I regret that my mom has dementia.
I regret that my dad can never get
well, that there's nothing I can
do to make him better.
But I don't do guilt anymore.
And then I ask people, you know,
take a look at yourself in the
mirror and think about all of the
good, kind, loving things that you
are doing to take care of them.
And then just imagine for a minute
how grateful you would feel if
someone else was doing that for
you.
So don't feel guilty.
Feel validated knowing the gift
that you are giving to that other
person.
And don't expect perfection.
That is not, it's not an
achievable goal.
So what I'm hearing is that there
are a range of opportunities to
express regret as an antidote to
guilt.
But more importantly, when
caregivers are experiencing
burnout and some element of
compassion fatigue,
but yet they still show up every
day, validate their own offerings
they're giving to their loved ones
still in real time to help offset
some of that crushing guilt that
could arise when we sometimes find
ourselves wishing,
I wish this would just end.
That doesn't make you a bad
person.
And I think looking at it from the
perspective and thinking, just
think about one day what you do
for your care receiver.
Just one day.
And think about all of those kind
acts, all of those things that you
do to provide for their comfort,
for their happiness, for their
needs.
And then, again, just think about
how you would feel if someone were
doing that for you.
Five minutes of
self-acknowledgement could be as
valuable as five minutes of
self-care.
Maybe they're synonymous.
That's really a good point.
Yeah.
So, Elaine, when siblings could
share a parent's care but don't,
the caregiver may watch everyone
else just keep their lives that
seem to go on as they choose while
caregiving takes over theirs.
Why can the person doing most of
the care end up feeling guilty for
resenting the people that aren't
helping?
Well, I don't think they should
feel guilty at all.
I think they should be holding
those siblings or whoever that is
accountable.
We had this in our family.
And it was tough.
I had a brother that lived very,
very close to my parents.
And I lived 1,500 miles away.
And I was the primary caregiver.
So, it is, you know, I've known
two families, Dr.
Mark, where all of the siblings
shared the care evenly and settled
the estate without any battles.
Two families.
So, I know it can be done, but I
can't tell you how many dozens of
families I've encountered.
Dozens?
I was going to say thousands,
probably, with the experience you
have.
And so, I ended up writing a
letter to my brother.
And I just expressed exactly how I
felt and how I thought his actions
or lack of actions had impacted my
parents.
And, you know, I didn't expect him
to change.
I wrote it because I thought, I'm
not going to let him get away with
this unscathed.
And miracle of miracles, it did
make him change.
And it did make him accept some
responsibility and do the right
thing.
I don't, I will never understand
why some people make the decisions
that they do or that they can feel
no responsibility and no guilt
about it.
How does that happen?
You know, not all siblings are
created equally.
That's just, that's just the fact.
Some of us care and some of us
don't.
And I will never understand that,
but it is more frequent.
Just as you said, it's, you know,
you may know a handful of families
that do it well.
And that's, you know, hats off to
them.
We've had a lot of caregivers
write in and send us comments
about how they've tried these
different techniques.
And it's come up in different
conversations over the last year.
And they're just saying it doesn't
work.
Why do we keep hearing that?
Just keep asking, keep demanding
when it doesn't work.
And you aptly point out that
there's some individuals who are
not hardwired to help.
So how does a caregiver find the
peace?
How do they let go and not wake up
every day to expectations that are
just going to be denied?
I went through a really horrible
divorce many years ago.
And I went to church one Sunday
and the minister was talking about
forgiveness.
And he said, the only things you
have to forgive are those things
that you cannot possibly accept,
understand, or rationalize away.
Because if you can understand
something that a person did, if
you can accept it, if you can
rationalize it away, you don't
have to forgive it.
But those are the things that we
have to forgive.
That was very helpful to me as I
was going through a divorce.
It was very helpful as I was
caring for my parents and settling
their estate and settling the
estate of my aunt.
And I just, when I would wake up
in the middle of the night, I
would say this, I would say their
name.
And I would say this over and over
and over.
I forgive you.
I let it go.
I forgive you.
I let it go.
And the reason that you forgive
someone is that you can stop being
their victim.
As long as you allow their actions
to really cause you a lot of
agitation and anger and, you know,
have it be the first thing you
think about when you wake up in
the morning,
the last thing you think about at
night and have it wake you up in
the middle of the night.
As long as you are dwelling on
those things and their bad
behavior and the things that they
have done to hurt or disappoint
you or let your parents down or
whatever,
you are their victim.
So if you want to stop being their
victim, you have to let it go.
But I think that holding them
accountable first and letting them
know how their actions or lack of
affect you and affect, you know,
the parent or whoever, let them
know.
If you get that down on paper and
you aren't holding anything back,
you don't, you know, don't call
them names, but just call out the
behavior.
And then that will help you accept
who they are and, you know, that's
on them.
But if you allow them to keep
controlling your mind, your
thinking, your feelings, your
happiness, then that's on you.
You can choose to let it go.
I think what I'm hearing also is
that forgiveness doesn't depend on
the other party.
It comes from you and it comes
from within.
That's right.
Do you think that prayer for the
strength to forgive is a valuable
exercise?
Yes, yes.
And it can be with both fists
clenched.
God, give me the strength to
forgive them, you know.
And I have said, not trying to be
blasphemous here or sacrilegious,
but I'm glad that God loves
everyone because there are some of
His children that I do not like at
all.
You know, let God deal with them.
But if we can forgive them, if we
can truly let it go, we will be so
much happier.
And that's one less emotional
piece of luggage that we don't
have to carry with us every place
we go.
That's very well put.
Yeah.
You know, a caregiver may not be
able to manage a parent's needs at
home anymore, but when they
arrange residential care, the
parent says, you're abandoning me.
Yeah, yeah.
How do they live with the guilt of
a decision that they truly believe
is necessary, but when their
parent experiences, is that
betrayal?
I think that goes back to the I
statements and, like, setting
boundaries, you know.
It would be, my response would be,
I will never abandon you.
I will always love you.
My job as your daughter is to make
sure that you're safe.
I can't do that anymore at home.
I need for you to be here so that
you can get the appropriate care
and so that I can continue to live
my life and take care of my
spouse, my children, my work,
whatever.
It's not about love.
When it gets to that point, it is
not about love.
It's about keeping them safe and
about protecting your own life.
And I know that some people would
say that feels selfish, and it's
not.
It's preservation.
It's self-care.
My mother wrote me one letter, and
I'll never forget.
She says, well, I finally decided
the other day that I will be of no
use to Quentin if I end up in the
hospital or in the morgue.
So I'm calling the doctor on
Monday and going to go in and see
what this thing is with my heart.
And, you know, she was pretty
plain spoken, but it's absolutely
true.
You are going to be of no use to
your care receiver if you end up
in the hospital or in the morgue.
You know, that's pretty plain
spoken, isn't it?
Some caregivers are terrified to
admit this thought, Elaine, that I
wish they would die because I want
my life back, because I need my
life back.
How does a caregiver begin to work
through the crushing guilt of
wishing someone they love would
die while still caring for that
person every day?
I think that goes back to the
regret.
You know, I regret this.
I regret that they are this ill.
I regret that they're suffering.
I regret that I am worn out with
this.
And just say regret, regret,
regret, instead of I feel guilty.
You know, I love them, and I
regret that I can't fix this, but
I'm doing everything I can to take
care of them, but I also have to
take care of myself.
And acknowledging the regret that
perhaps you've been pushed to that
point, not by the care recipient,
but by the system and all of the
organizational issues, which make
caregiving such a challenge.
But regret that you would be
brought to that point and regret
so in a humble way.
I have one woman that had taken
care of her husband.
It was, he had Parkinson's, and
she cared for him for 26 years.
And people were always saying,
you're a saint, and that would
just make her so angry.
And she'd say, I am not a saint.
You have no idea of some of the
awful feelings and thoughts that I
have sometimes.
I am not a saint.
And it just, you know, to me, she
was incredible.
She was so, she was so kind.
And she worked so hard to take
care of her husband.
And her health declined, you know,
over those years.
And her career, you know,
collapsed and everything else.
You know, she gave so much.
She really gave up the best years
of her life to take care of him.
So nobody should feel guilty about
that.
A caregiver can give more and more
of themselves and still feel like
they're not doing enough.
Yeah.
What do they need to understand
about guilt when no amount of
sacrifice seems to make it go
away?
You know, you know, you know, we
are human beings and there is a
limit.
I mean, even you as a doctor, you
know, there are limits to what you
can do to change, fix, control, or
cure a person, right?
I mean, we don't have, we don't
have the ability to make some
things different.
Doing more and more and
sacrificing more and more to try
and combat guilt.
I think it goes back to your point
of understanding the difference
between earned and unearned guilt.
Are there more granular strategies
that individuals in that
circumstance can turn to just to
even parse out the different types
of unearned guilt to make it just
that bit easier?
Maybe you just ask your question,
did I do anything intentionally to
hurt them?
And if the answer is no, then,
okay, I'm going to regret this.
Did I intentionally try to inflict
pain?
I think it is important.
We talked about forgiveness,
right?
Sometimes we have to forgive other
people, but as caregivers, we have
to forgive ourselves as well.
Because there are times that you
will be pushed to the limit and
that you will lose your temper and
you will say something because
you've reached that point of
exhaustion and exasperation where
you just, you just can't, you
can't bottle it anymore, right?
So that's when you have to forgive
yourself.
So I have two stories about that.
And when I, it took me a long time
to figure this out.
As you know, I've talked about, I
went through a really difficult
divorce and I had three teenage
children.
And my oldest son was 18 at the
time and he was pushing every
limit and pushing every button.
And we were just like this.
And there was one situation that I
handled very, very poorly.
And I felt guilty about it
immediately.
And then I carried that guilt for
years.
And then, oh, it was probably 20
years ago that a friend of mine
was having a summer solstice
party.
And I said, oh, sounds fun.
What can I bring?
And she said, bring something to
eat, something to drink, and
something to burn.
And I said, what would I bring to
burn?
And she said, do you have any old
guilt or anger or resentment or
anything that you'd like to get
rid of?
And I said, you know, I do.
So I sat down and I wrote about
this situation.
I wrote everything that had
happened.
I wrote Eric's part in it.
I wrote my part in it.
Took it to the bonfire, you know,
to this party.
Put it in an envelope.
Threw it on the fire.
Watched, you know, watched it go
up.
And I felt lighter.
You know, it was, I just felt
lighter by doing that.
And then, it was about 10 years
ago, I took Eric out for breakfast
one morning.
Now, Eric is now 50, right?
So he has teenage daughters.
And we were talking about guilt as
a parent.
And I, you know, we had never
talked about this situation.
And I told him, you know, how
guilty I had felt about that.
And he just, you know, it was just
right here.
And you know what his response
was?
He had no memory of it at all.
So I had carried that guilt, you
know, at different levels for 30
years.
And it was like, that was
ridiculous.
And it meant nothing at all to
him.
Now, if you ask him what other
things that I did that may have
screwed up his life,
he could probably tell you some
stories, but not that one.
And so I really encourage people,
if you do something that you
really wish you hadn't,
that you wish you could take back,
write about it, and then have a
burial for it.
Burn it, or shred it, or do
something with it, so that you can
let it go.
That sounds like some really wise
advice.
You know, a caregiver will at
times finally take five minutes
for themselves.
Yep.
Their loved one is safe.
Yeah.
But that guilt is still telling
them to get up and do some more.
What can they actually do in a
moment like that to stop guilt
from taking those five minutes
away?
I'm an advocate of deep breathing.
Or, you know, my survival depends
on my ability to get outside in
nature and walk.
So, I know.
Wait a minute.
I hear guilt knocking, though.
Guilt saying you can't do that.
No.
How can you do that, Elaine?
There must be something to do that
they need.
I will do it when I get back,
because I need this for myself.
And if you can give yourself
permission, you know, it doesn't
really matter what it is.
It could be a walk around the
block.
It could be going to take a bath
and locking the door.
It could be listening to music
with your earphones on.
I mean, whatever it is.
And I think five minutes is not
enough.
I think 30 minutes.
If you can take 30 minutes to do
something just for yourself, and
if you can let everybody else know
that this is your time, and you do
not want to be disturbed, you have
to set that boundary.
And we've talked about setting
boundaries.
My mom loved to read at night, and
so she would do everything she
could for my dad during the day.
And she would get his pajamas on,
get him into bed.
They would say their prayers.
She would tuck him in.
She'd kiss him goodnight.
And then she would go out to the
living room where she would read.
And this was her escape.
She could get totally lost in a
book.
And so it was about four months
after Dad had his first stroke
that he came out to the living
room one night, and he walked up
to her, and he looked down at the
book in her lap, and he said,
Madeline, the light being on out
here and the noise of the turning
pages, it's keeping me awake.
And she said, well, you know what,
Quinn?
You don't have any trouble
sleeping in the morning when I am
up and working, and the television
can be on, the washing machine and
dryer can be going.
I can have the dishwasher running.
People can be coming and going.
The telephone can be ringing, and
you can sleep like you are dead.
So you know what?
If you can't sleep while I am up
reading, you will just have to
stay awake.
And that was, you know, she set
that boundary, and he knew from
then on, yeah, from then on, that
when she had done everything she
needed to do for him, she needed
this time to herself.
And unless his hair was on fire,
he was not to bother her.
And that's the way that I have
been with my early morning walks.
My husband's had five back
surgeries.
And, you know, you never leave a
person when you think that they
might be in danger or they might,
you know, they might really,
really need you.
But as soon as I got him home and
I felt like he would be safe for
whether it was 10 minutes or 30
minutes, I got outside.
And that was my, that's how,
that's what I needed to do for
myself.
So I think whether it's
meditation, whether it's music,
whether it's a cup of coffee, you
know, sitting in a room that you
love in your favorite chair.
But if you have something that you
can do for yourself, just for
yourself, every single day, it
gives you something to look
forward to.
And if you have five minutes, it's
like, okay, let's do this, you
know, let's take this time.
And, and do that without feeling
guilty about it.
This is how you maintain your,
maintain your emotional and
physical strength.
I think it's done in little steps.
You know, 30 minutes sounds like a
pretty solid target for me, but
you probably need to start with
five and then maybe after a couple
of weeks, go for 10.
Because I think it's a skill that
needs to be learned and there
needs to be space created in
reinforcement of the effort and
the success.
Because a lot of individuals don't
know how and a list of 10 things
to do to prove that you know how
to take care of yourself is pretty
self-defeating.
But just that one act of five
minutes that's very self-informed
and that, you know, it's something
you choose that makes you feel as
authentic as possible in the
moment.
Yeah.
Because it's truly your five
minutes.
I think those are the things that
will compound over time and
actually make individuals who feel
like maybe they could never pull
it off actually have a shot at
success.
Oh, I think so, too.
We had one lady in one of our
support groups and she was just
this dainty, lovely older woman.
And she had a boxing, what do you
call it, a bag, hanging from the
rafters in her garage and she
would go out and put on her gloves
and box, box.
It was, she would just smack the,
you know, and it really helped
her.
I mean, she was fit and that's how
she would get rid of her anxiety
and her fear and guilt and
whatever.
Anytime she was emotionally
overwhelmed, that's what she would
do.
I mean, that's better than smoking
a cigarette or pouring a shot of
whiskey, right?
Mm-hmm.
But it has the same, well, it has
a better effect, but it's a way to
manage.
It is exercise, too, and exercise
helps reset a lot of.
It does.
Chemicals as well in those
moments.
Yeah, yeah.
So, Elaine, I like this idea about
building space for yourself, but a
caregiver needs to be vigilant as
to how they're making that happen,
but I think they also need to look
around them in those moments and
also sort of study the person
they're taking care of for any
signs that there may be a little
bit of unearned guilt being thrown
their way or there may be some
manipulation.
How would you recommend taking
those steps towards finding 5, 10,
15 minutes, but also sort of
getting a sense of the dynamics at
play?
And what can a caregiver do to
make sure that they have the best
chance of achieving those parsed
pieces of time for themselves?
So, I think announcing it first,
and, you know, like my mother
said, I need this time to myself.
I'm that way with my walking.
And I think that you don't make
any explanations.
You don't need to defend it
because if you feel guilty about
this, then your care receiver or
whoever is your guilt tripper is
going to use that against you.
So, you know, let's just say,
let's just say I'm going to go
have lunch with a friend, okay?
And I know one woman who was
caring for her father, and when
she would leave and she would say,
I'm going to go have lunch with my
friend, he would say, well, it'd
be nice if you'd take me out for
lunch once in a while.
Or I wish I had a friend who would
come and take me out, and I never
get to go any place, you know?
So, he was playing on her
sympathy.
Now, someone else might respond by
saying, you know, let's say you do
go out for lunch, and you come
home 10 or 15 minutes or half an
hour after they expected you.
I was so worried.
I thought something might have
happened to you.
I've just been a wreck.
When you said you were going to be
home at 1 and then you weren't
there at 1.15, I was ready to call
the police.
You know, I need you.
And if you aren't there to take,
if you aren't there, you know,
what's going to happen to me?
And so, you know, that's one way
that they can act like they were
afraid.
The other way is to be angry.
You know, you said you were going
to be here at 1.15 or at 1
o'clock, and now it's 1.20, and I
was by myself, and I didn't know
how to do this, or I couldn't take
care of this, or the phone rang,
and I didn't know how to answer
it.
You know, they will throw all
sorts of things on you, but it's
your fault, and they get angry.
So, you know, once again, if it's
all about them, that's when, you
know, it's a guilt tripper.
And so, I'm sad because you don't,
you know, you don't love me, or
I'm sad because I never get to go
anyplace, and you do, you know,
all of those things.
And it just comes back to setting
that boundary and say, this is
something that I need to do for
myself.
This is non-negotiable.
It's just non-negotiable.
I need to do this.
Do you think when you're starting
to plan to try to start doing
something for yourself again, you
should give them a week's notice?
Or do you think you should just
drop it cold and say, today I'm
going out?
Yeah, I think just saying, you
know, I have discovered that if I
do this one thing for myself, I
feel better about myself.
I feel better about you.
You know, I need to have a little
space for myself.
And I think if you tell them, I
mean, I kind of saw you do this a
little bit, you know, that I need
a little space.
I need some time for myself.
I need some time away.
And it doesn't have to be much,
but it has to be some place where
I'm just not taking care of you.
Place where you can try and almost
brain off for a little bit when it
comes to that.
And that might include creative
approaches in terms of, if you're
so fortunate to be able to hire
out for a four-hour block.
Or maybe even ask your best friend
to really step up for you because
you really need it.
Yes.
I have done these support groups
for, I started it in COVID 2020.
And I have learned that when
women, it's been mostly women,
that when they finally agree to
hire somebody to come in a couple
hours a day, a couple times a
week,
in the beginning, they do not know
what to do with themselves.
You know, they feel wracked with
guilt.
They get in the car and it's like,
I don't know where to go.
I don't know what to do.
And they end up calling, you know,
the respite care provider maybe
half a dozen times.
And it's really hard in the
beginning, but then they get used
to it.
And then they learn how to do
something in that time that they
can enjoy.
And maybe it's just going to the
grocery store.
But it seems to me that once they
can, you know, kind of make, take
that first step,
and they might have to do it two
or three times before they
actually feel comfortable with it.
And then they get to the point
that it's like, I need this.
I feel better about my spouse.
I feel better about being a
caregiver.
I feel better myself.
And so, you know, you have to tell
them over and over and over,
this is not selfish.
It's self-care.
And you will be a better caregiver
if you are better yourself.
So give it a chance.
Try it out a few times.
Recognize that, you know, the
respite care worker may give you
five calls the first couple of
times
until they get in the groove.
And the hope being that as you
practice that sort of self-care,
that respite worker is actually
the same person each time
and not a new individual each time
because that could affect the
learning curve as well.
But it's usually the caregiver
calling the respite care provider.
You know, the respite care
provider is just fine.
You know, they're fine.
It's not easy to unplug.
You're right.
Yeah.
So, before we wrap it up, I just
had one last question.
How does a caregiver begin letting
go of guilt when part of them
believes that feeling guilty
is actually proof that they still
care?
Ah.
Oh, that's a good one.
Feeling guilty is proof that I
still care.
I would like to say that's
nonsense.
But, you know, I'm not a
psychologist.
I just think that you prove you
care every day by getting up, by
fixing their breakfast,
by managing their medications, by
getting them to their doctor's
appointments,
by making sure that they are safe,
by all of the things that you do.
That's how you show you care.
And guilt, if you can embrace the
idea that guilt is a form of
self-harm,
that it is not an appropriate
response when you haven't done
anything intentionally to hurt
somebody,
then it's just, it's a waste of
emotional energy and it will, I
think it will really limit
how long you can do this and how
well you can do it.
You're right.
Guilt is erosive.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And there's so much proof, I
think, for many that when they do
step up to the plate,
they do accomplish a lot.
So what I'm hearing from you is
that taking that inventory of all
you do is a great antidote to
guilt.
Right.
And so if you can take, if people
can take away from this,
the generosity of being a
caregiver and all that you do for
another person,
and then changing your vocabulary
from guilt to regret and forgiving
yourself.
You know, forgive others, just let
it go and then forgive yourself
and let it go.
It sounds like being a carefree
giver is a good place to be.
Yeah.
Yeah.
A guilt-free caregiver.
I like that.
We should have stickers that they
can put on the bumpers of their
car or something.
Thank you for joining us this week
on the Caregivers Podcast, Elaine.
You always bring so much value to
our listeners.
That wraps up this week's episode.
I'm your host, Dr.
Mark Ropaleski, and we'll see you
again next time.
Elaine, thank you for making room
for a conversation caregivers may
have been afraid to have.
I hope this helps you question the
guilt rather than automatically
obeying it.
You can want to care generously
for someone you love and still
want a life of your own.
Your needs deserve consideration
in that conversation too.
Please subscribe or follow the
Caregivers Podcast or whatever you
watch or listen.
It's free and it really helps
support the show and make sure
that caregivers who need to hear
it get a chance.
And if these conversations have
helped, please consider buying the
team a coffee.
The buy me a coffee link is in the
show notes.
Thank you for listening.
I'm your host, Dr.
Mark Ropaleski, and we'll see you
next time.
Before we wrap up, I wanted to
remind you of something important.
The conversations you hear on this
podcast are here to inform, to
support, to spark reflection.
You're not a substitute for
professional medical advice, care,
therapy, or crisis services.
Listening to this podcast does not
create a doctor-patient or
caregiver-client relationship
between us.
If you're facing a medical
concern, health challenge, a
mental health challenge, or a
caregiving situation that needs
guidance,
I encourage you to reach out to a
qualified professional who knows
your story.
If you're ever in crisis, please
don't wait.
Call your local emergency number
or recognize crisis hotline right
away.
You deserve real-time help and
support.
The views you hear on this show,
whether from me or my guests, are
our own.
They don't necessarily reflect any
organizations we work with or are
part of or have worked with or
been part of in the past.
This podcast is an independent
production.
It's not tied to any hospital,
university, or healthcare system.
Thank you for being here, for
listening, and most of all, for
taking the time to care for
yourself while you continue to
care for others.
I look forward to hearing from
you.