Scalability School

Marin Istvanic joins Scalability School for a deep tactical session on what it actually takes to scale e-commerce brands to nine figures with paid media on Meta. Marin is one of the most hands-on media buyers in the DTC space, managing upwards of 5 to 7 million dollars a month in ad spend across his agency clients and his own internal brand (and this episode reflects that).

The conversation launches right into the hard hitting questions with the debate around ABO versus CBO and when each actually makes sense. Marin's full whitelisting flywheel (300+ influencer profiles, authority pages, dark posts running through multiple handles in the same session), cost cap weekend scaling and what he calls the "gladiators arena" ad set, how he uses different attribution settings as a signal to Meta that a campaign is structurally different, and why he still manually picks every thumbnail across all his accounts. He also shares how he used AI to synthesize his full YouTube library into a 50-page media buying philosophy document and then how he fed his top-spending ads into a landing page template that outperformed the control by 10%.

Key Takeaways

  • ABO vs. CBO - is the debate actually settled, or does the right answer depend on something most people never measure?
  • Is whitelisting dead - or are you just running it wrong?
  • What does a "cost cap weekend scaling" actually look like in practice — and how to spend $25K on a Saturday without blowing up your CPA?
  • How changing this window actually tells Meta this is a different campaign.
  • Why Marin still manually picks every thumbnail - If the "hacks" everyone is chasing are mostly noise, this is what actually moves the needle at scale.

This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It's a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they're offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you!

To connect with Marin, send him a DM at https://x.com/IstvanicMarin

To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com

To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch

To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck

Learn More about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com/

Learn More about the The Hive Haus Creators Community at http://HiveHausUGC.com

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

If your hit rate of the tests is high

enough, I think you can

squeeze more with ABO.

If your hit rate is

bad, then stick with CBO.

It never happens that a

good ad is not running.

You know, it's always running somewhere.

Maybe if it died in testing,

it's running somewhere else.

So like often the first thing that I do

when I take over a new ad account,

I go like a year or two back and I find

all ads that are above the target ROAS

that spend significantly.

I take their post ID and in most cases,

like seven or eight out of ten,

like ends up being performers.

People just forget that they had a winner

like, you know, a year ago.

That winner is a still winner.

Obviously, it's not

going to scale massively,

but I have some ad accounts where like

those old ads are like

running for like a few years.

It felt like I got a recognition when

Facebook confirmed

that a different thumbnail

actually means different entity ID

because like I was, I did not know why,

but like four or five years went back in

the day when I worked with Yudi,

I realized that a different thumbnail can

impact the performance of the same video

in a different way.

So still me and all of my media buyers

and my junior media buyers,

everybody are picking

thumbnails manually.

I think it has a positive impact.

And now let's take a listen to the

Scalability School podcast.

Welcome to another episode of the

Scalability School podcast,

your favorite podcast for tactical advice

on running your

e-commerce brand or agency

or agency accounts under that are brand.

So here's the thing.

We have a legend on the podcast today,

and I'm going to pronounce publicly his

name properly or attempt to.

Marin Ishtvan Itch.

Did I get close?

This is perfect.

Okay.

Who I have been mispronouncing my good

friend's name for three years

since we've known each other

or four years actually

we've known each other.

So I also, this is a theme of my life

because I also have the owner of socio,

Karen.

I've been calling Karan for six years.

And he recently just had the guts to tell

me that I was mispronouncing it.

So anyway, here we

are pronounced properly.

Everybody knows and loves this guy.

I've sent so many people to your YouTube

channel to learn how to do Facebook ads.

And an absolute legend.

Marin, welcome to the show.

Yeah, I appreciate it.

I'm not sure how I'm going to

justify all these big words,

but I definitely want to return the

gratitude because like I

was listening to your podcast,

you know, 2019, the e-commerce influence,

probably like I've stumbled upon it

randomly during one of my,

I know, searching on the

internet for a good content.

I was like, wow, how did I

did not know about this guy?

It was like in the early beginnings of my

media buying when you

were definitely a role model.

So I appreciate that.

I mean, welcome to episode

one of Glazing the Podcast,

where we glaze each other and talk about

all the good things.

Brad, Brad's really smart.

Brad's smarter than me.

So there's the pride glaze.

So let's just jump right into it.

By the way, Marin has spoken at three

events now for the

Foxhole founders in Europe.

And everybody always comes to me and is

like, that was so great.

Because you're such a tactician, Marin,

with your hands on the wheel.

So as a tactician, let's get into the

debate that everybody

wants to know right away,

which is ABO versus CBO.

Okay.

What are your thoughts?

We're only going to spend a few minutes

on this, but everybody wants to know.

What are your thoughts?

So if your hit rate of

the tests is high enough,

I think you can squeeze more with ABO.

If your hit rate is

bad, then stick with CBO.

Yeah.

I think I don't disagree

with that for what it's worth.

Like I know I'm on the

opposite side, generally speaking,

when it comes to the ABO versus CBO.

I think if I had to

add my little summary,

I think the bet that you're making when

you choose between them

is that you are going to either be right

more often than meta

or at a bigger scale that kind of offsets

maybe the downside of being wrong.

And I think you've

said this before, right?

Like that's a function of hit rate, but

it's also a function of scale.

If you hit a winner that

meta missed on and it can scale

and weigh in excess of what you spent on

the creative test that didn't hit,

it probably doesn't

actually end up mattering.

The only reason I

generally start with CBO is,

and for a lot of people is maybe their

hit rate isn't great.

And it kind of prevents the downside,

especially as brands are

kind of getting to scale.

Yeah, definitely.

So CBO is like more conservative.

And like when the budget is not high,

when we have too many

tests or the hit rate is low,

I use CBO when I'm into scaling.

And I know that like from 10 tests,

I will get like at

least three, four winners.

That means I'm getting three, four

winners every week from the 10 tests.

If I test 20, I get seven, eight.

Maybe I will not be able to scale them

like, you know, from 100 to 2K.

But like if I scale it from 100 to 500,

and I have like seven

of those ads a week,

that adds up.

And I don't need to scale every ad.

I need like, I don't know,

I need one, two great ads.

And then I need like

10, 15 supporting winners.

And ABO allows me that

a bit more than the CBO.

But I definitely agree.

Yeah, sorry.

No, I didn't mean to cut you off.

I was just going to ask, like, have you,

have you gone down the route or do you

have a kind of a tactic for,

I saw somebody on Twitter X recently say,

you know, they will

run their creative tests.

And then if they don't work,

they'll still maybe throw

them in to a cost cap campaign

or kind of keep it live somewhere else.

Like when I go CBO, it's

generally, I'm keeping the ads on.

I just don't generally turn them off

unless there's a good

reason to turn them off.

Maybe they do end up sucking

or they're super out of season

or something like that.

But I'm just wondering

if there's like small,

little tactical things

that you pull forward.

Yeah, so I don't have that

kind of like zombie campaign.

The reason is anytime

ads shows attraction,

I would take it post ID and I

would run it somewhere else.

So I never, it never happens

that a good ad is not running.

You know, it's always running somewhere.

Maybe if it died in testing,

it's running somewhere else.

So like often the first thing that I do

when I take over a new ad account,

I go like year or two back

and I find all old ads

that are among the target rows

that spend significantly.

I take their post ID and in most cases,

like seven or eight out of 10,

like ends up being performers.

People just forget

that they had a winner,

like, you know, a year ago.

That winner is a still winner.

Obviously it's not gonna scale massively,

but I have some ad

accounts where like those old ads

are like running for like a few years.

Yeah.

Do you have a cadence for like going back

and revisiting old ads?

Cause like maybe you guys

even have turned things off

in the past.

Yeah, that's a good thing.

As I said, like there's always,

this ad that was decent,

it's always running somewhere.

So when I take over,

I find those ads and

they're always running

with some kind of budget,

with a different audience,

with a different attribution setting,

with a different bidding.

You know, they're

always running somewhere,

at least with some budget.

So I don't get into position

that there's an ad that was good

that is currently not active.

Yeah.

Well, you said

something interesting there.

I don't want to, you know,

we can start to deviate off the ABO

versus CBO a bit here,

but you mentioned the different audience.

And so I think some people hear audience

and they're like,

wait, you're actually doing,

like you're doing more than just broad.

And so maybe,

maybe just want to

spend a couple of minutes

talking through that.

Yeah, I know it's 2026.

And like,

if I said that,

like I'm using interest,

people are saying like,

okay, what, why?

But the thing is,

like I find they can have cheaper CPM,

they can get me lower frequency,

and it's my way of

amplifying the winners.

So let's say if I have

an ad in testing that,

I don't know,

it was running for two months,

then it died,

I would take it post ID,

I would group it with some other winners

that also died,

and I would run them with

some interest audiences.

And as I said,

like it's,

it's a nice addition.

It's not something that's scalable.

It's not something that like,

you know,

is massive unlock.

But let's say if I'm

spending 20K in testing,

I'm spending 20K in scaling.

And then like,

there's like 5K a day

that's running in interest audiences

where I badge the winners.

Are these ads that

you're running predominantly?

So I would say 70% of my clients are US,

10% is Canada,

10% Australia,

10% UK.

Yeah, yeah.

Yeah,

it's,

I,

so it's interesting about the,

the interest thing.

I think I agree with you

that there tend to be marginal wins,

especially when you're spending

at a really high level with interest.

And I don't think

that's necessarily wrong

to do that.

So I appreciate you calling that out.

So let's talk,

let's transition to talking about

tactics that are working right now.

There's a lot of

things that you talk about

on a regular basis.

One of them is whitelisting at scale.

This is talking about

a ton of whitelisting profiles

that are running,

you know,

not partnership ads,

dark posts that don't show

on the influencer's timeline,

multiple influencer touch points

in the same session.

Yeah.

So you went and said,

whitelisting,

you spent 1.2 million versus brand

and the cheaper CPC,

it was a dollar cheaper CPC

and a way better North Beam ROAS

at 1.29 versus 0.76.

Talk about whitelisting scale

and your sauce there.

Yeah.

So basically we realized

that no matter the client,

when we introduce whitelisting,

especially from the authority pages,

so let's say if you're in pet space

and you find a veterinarian,

if you're in,

I don't know,

pain,

then you find a like pediatrician,

if you're like in a

skincare dermatologist,

so like those people

tend to have like bigger influence

on regular users.

They add credibility.

The fact that

when you're running through

the multiple pages

at the same session,

you can see different ads

at the same time,

although it is the same advertiser

just running through

the different pages.

When you run through

the brand page,

you can see one ad per session.

So it creates that sense

that everybody's using the product.

So we then just like

built a massive flywheel

of these influencers

that we actually put

into our ad account.

So like for our internal brand,

I think we tested

more than 300,

400 whitelisting profiles.

So basically every week,

I'm testing like between

five and 10 new profiles.

And like, again,

it creates a sense

that like every single authority

in this space

is using our product.

Obviously, this is quite expensive

at the scale

because, you know,

these influencers

that are authorities,

like I have some girls

that we're paying

like 20K per video

plus usage, right?

But those are like,

you know,

those are proven influencers.

Those are authorities.

Those are people that I know

no matter the ad I launch,

it will be a winner.

So I pay 20K,

but I spend 20K a day.

So basically I offset that

in a week, you know.

Yeah, there's,

and there's a bunch of different

like levels to this.

So I'm curious,

like does the,

does the partnership,

whitelisting,

however,

like all of that,

does that differ

depending on the scale

that the brand is at?

Like if they're spending

less than 2K a day

or less than 5K a day,

are you approaching

in a different direction?

It sounds like maybe

you try to go

for the expert and authority people

first,

regardless of scale.

Yeah,

obviously in clothing,

you cannot,

there's no expert.

So you just go people

that fit your avatar.

Obviously the less you,

the less you're spending,

the less people

you can actually have

because they're

sometimes more expensive.

But we try,

I would say like

as you scale,

you get actually

more of those people.

So that's the,

that's the main,

it kind of like

goes with the volume.

Yeah.

And the two follow-up

questions to that,

how are you finding

these people in general?

And then the follow-up

to that would be,

how are you,

and I know it depends,

you just,

you just said it depends

based on the person,

but like,

what does the general

partnership agreement

look like with that person?

It's fixed plus percent

to spend,

it's just percent to spend,

who cares what that

would look like?

Okay,

good question.

So first question,

how do we find them?

So we have,

for our internal brand,

we have like four people

in the influencer team

that is just like

finding people

and negotiating.

We leverage some tools

like Facebook

Creator Marketplace.

It was a terrible tool

until a few months.

Now it's amazing tool

and my influencer team

tells me that like

they find more people there

than any other software.

Also,

we started using,

I think it's Super Bloom.

It's an agency

that helps that.

Basically,

but like we're on that level

that we can pay,

you know,

four or 5k

for an influencer

because we know

there's a script

that works.

Obviously,

when you're smaller,

it's just like,

you know,

reaching manually

to people on Instagram

or to create a marketplace.

Facebook marketplace

is better

because you know

these people already know

what that process looks like.

They already have

the pages set up.

So it's easier

in terms of the payment.

It's mostly,

so initially we have deals

that we pay them

for content

and then we repurpose

that content

for an ad.

Now we are just paying them

to get the content.

So you don't even have

to post it on your page.

I just want your handle

and I just want

to be able

to run the ads

through your page.

They give us video,

raw video.

We chop it up

into three,

four different hooks.

We send it for approval.

We send the ad copy

for approval.

We send the access

to get the,

a request

to get the access.

Once they approve

that,

I have the access.

I launch that ad

as a new ad set

in my testing campaign.

And literally,

there's no brand

that we work with

that did not have

a positive impact

from introducing

whitelisting.

Yeah.

Do you see

that there's,

does the,

does the type

of influence

or maybe type

is the wrong question.

It's like,

does the scale

of their following matter?

Have you seen

any correlation

or not really?

So,

the big ones

definitely work better,

but

smaller ones

can surprise

and can also,

you know,

get you

some surprising wins,

especially if the,

if the video is good,

but I still think

the sauce is in the script.

It's just like,

this is like

amplification.

Why I don't like,

you know,

running partnership

because when I see

a person

with brand,

it screams

that this is an ad

to me.

Like,

it's just,

I know this is an ad

and I scroll past it.

When I see just a person,

okay,

this like looks something

that I could,

I could engage with

and I think

that's why it works.

Well,

I forgot to ask

and answer the question

about the pricing.

So,

it really depends.

Usually,

it is,

it is a fixed fee.

We try to get them

on an affiliate,

like on a percentage

of spend

because that's better

for me.

There's a lower risk

and I'm okay paying

you more

if you're actually

getting me the results.

It will be

hypercritical for me

because I charge

percentage of spend.

So,

you know,

I think that's a fair deal

to get to the influencer,

but majority of them

are still like,

I don't know.

I would rather you pay me

and then like

in 30 days,

we evaluate.

If we have 30 days access,

we evaluate

whether

the ROAS

that they got

and the spend

is like revenue,

whether that offset

their fee

and whether we actually

made money.

If yes,

then we kind of like

trade to negotiate.

I have some person,

I have some people

that like we are extending

rides from July

last year,

you know,

because it just works.

So,

it's like running

for like nine months

and we're just extending

every month.

Yeah,

I have one more question,

Andrew,

and then I'll pause

and shut up for a second.

But this might transition

actually into one of the

follow-up questions here

or the next topics,

but are you doing anything

special with the

account structure

for these tests

or are they just going

into their own,

they're going into

their own creative

testing campaign?

They're just going

into their own ad sets.

So,

each creator

is in its own ad sets.

So,

if I'm launching

20 tests a week,

I have 20 ads

a week

that I set

and I launch

tests from

Wednesday or Thursday.

I avoid launching

stuff on Monday

and Tuesday

because my goal

is to get

at least one

winning variation

of these

video that they

get me.

So,

I know it can

sound overwhelming

because like,

I know,

in a month,

I could potentially

have 100 tests,

which is 100

ad sets.

So,

someone could see

that and like,

okay,

what is this?

But actually,

out of those 100,

I'm getting like,

you know,

40 that are

decent performers.

Very good background

on whitelisting

and how it's

working for you.

So,

I appreciate you

getting into that.

One other thing

you've talked about

is cost cap

weakened scaling,

which is

ASC

with cost cap

using different

attribution windows.

seven-day click

versus seven-day click

plus one-day view.

And,

essentially,

the different

attribution forces

people kind of

Facebook to find

different types of people.

And,

with the cost cap,

your point is like,

look,

Meta does the scaling

for me.

You talk about

this strategy

and what else

is how you do it,

how you set it up

more specifically.

All right,

friends,

quick break.

This episode

is brought to you

by Northbeam,

the marketing

attribution platform

that we love

over here

at Scalability School.

If you're a marketer,

I mean,

you probably agree,

right?

Incrementality testing

is broken.

These tests require

tons of labor,

spreadsheets,

statistical reference,

and the designing

of a test

is slow and error-prone.

How are you supposed

to know what to test

in the first place,

right?

There's a million factors

that can make

incrementality testing

difficult.

But,

the good news is

Northbeam has completely

changed the game

and they fixed this.

Only Northbeam

incrementality

automates your

incrementality test

design and monitoring

while protecting you

from the major mistakes

that plague

incrementality testing.

Northbeam builds tests

using your own

MTA data,

launches them directly

in ad platforms,

and automatically

monitors them

throughout.

If something

threatens validity,

you're alerted

before it ruins

the result.

With Northbeam,

you can launch

tests in platform

with a single click,

saving you tons

of time and reducing

any chance

for errors.

And when the

test concludes,

your results flow

straight into your

MTA,

meaning you can

easily see results

alongside the rest

of your data.

Incrementality

was broken.

Northbeam fixed it.

Point is like,

look,

Meta does the scaling

for me.

You talk about

this strategy

and what else

is how you do it,

how you set it up

more specifically.

Yeah,

so everybody

knows that I don't

like Cost Cap

for testing,

but I really,

really love them

for scaling.

I realized that

two years

for one Black Friday

and I was like,

okay,

I have this scaling

campaign,

but I realized

that I don't want

to have the same ad

in a different campaign

without a reason.

So,

okay,

if it's different

optimization,

okay,

highest volume

or highest volume,

value,

yeah,

yeah,

so if I move that

or if I change

the attribution setting

or if I add interest,

that in my eyes

tells Facebook,

okay,

this is slightly different.

So,

I'm okay

with kind of like,

I have the tests

in my testing

and I keep scaling them.

Sometimes I get

from 100 to 300.

Sometimes I get

from 100 to 5K

just because tests work

and I continue

to increase the budget.

When I move the winners

into scaling campaigns,

so my scaling campaign

is on 7 Day Click,

I call this

winners of the winners.

It's like a gladiators arena.

It's just one ad set

and all of the winners.

I don't care

which ad is going to win

because all of them

are winners

and I'm comfortable

using cost cap

because all of them

are winners.

So,

if I put cost cap

of 50,

Facebook spending 55,

I'm cool

because it giving me volume

but I know

it will never spend 80

because this is a proven ad.

So,

I'm okay,

you know,

leveraging manual bids

for scaling.

What you mentioned,

Advantage Shopping Plus,

the fact is

that's the old

Advantage Shopping Plus

where we could define

that percentage

of spend for buyers.

The thing is,

like,

I never turned it off.

So,

in 7 out of,

like,

say,

10 ad accounts,

I still have that OG

Advantage Shopping Plus

running.

If I do not,

then it's just one campaign

with one ad set.

As I said,

I limit it to 7 Day Click

because I found that

that old Advantage Shopping Plus

was doing a bit more retargeting

regardless,

you know,

similar setup.

So,

I don't want Facebook

over attributing

on view sales

that is not

responsible

and what's the beauty

of this weekend scaling?

I realized that

conversion rate is better

because more people

are on the phone.

So,

there's,

I never knew

to what extent

I can scale on a weekend.

I know I can scale

but I don't know

whether I can increase

from 1K to 2K

or from 1K to 5K

and how to increase

that budget

without actually disturbing it.

So,

if you would,

like,

look a graph

of my campaigns,

Andrew,

I think I shared that

on the Elizabethan presentation.

My testing campaign,

like,

goes like this

because I,

like,

I just increased

the budget

of what's working.

My interest campaign

is,

like,

it's always steady.

It's always on,

like,

let's say 5K

but the cost cap one

is,

like,

you know,

it's like this.

On Tuesday,

it spent,

I don't know,

3K.

On Thursday,

it spent 7K.

On weekend,

it spent,

like,

25K

just because it can.

And I'm okay

giving it,

getting a higher,

slightly higher CPA

because it brings me volume.

I have a million

follow-up questions

and,

like,

randomly specific things.

So,

I might be bouncing

around a lot here.

You mentioned

the attribution settings.

You mentioned

a bunch of different things.

Like,

you could change something

about the campaign

or the targeting

or whatever.

Like,

some of those settings

to tell meta

there's something

different about this.

Exactly.

Do you actually

scale by changing?

Like,

are you setting up

maybe new ad sets

with 7-day click,

7-day click,

1-day view,

7-day click,

1-day engage view,

1-day click?

Are you actually playing

with those

as a scale mechanism

at all?

So,

my first campaign

is ABO testing

on highest volume

on 7-day click,

1-day view

unless there's

too many view conversions.

So,

basically,

when I check

into the ad account,

if there's more

than 25% view conversions

and AOE is not 400+,

I would use

exclusively 7-day click.

If,

you know,

everything looks fine,

I would use 7-day click,

1-day view.

Then,

I would move

the winners

into that audience campaign

as I mentioned.

So,

that's kind of like,

okay,

that's a different direction

because I'm using audience.

And then,

the third direction

is this 7-day click

on manual bids,

which is combining

two different things.

So,

I think I pretty much

covered that.

Sometimes,

recently,

I started playing

with incremental

attribution

or when the AOE

is higher

or there's,

like,

a lot of skews,

then I would play

with the volume.

But I think I cover,

like,

four out of five things

in those three campaigns

of mine.

So,

you mentioned

the OG AFCs

and,

like,

the ability

to set the percentage.

Do you have,

do you have,

like,

a playbook

for retention campaigns

or actually trying

to go and reacquire customers?

Most of my customers

do not

want to,

like,

reacquire customers.

Some,

I'd say,

like,

okay,

but,

like,

if someone did not

bought from you

for,

like,

I don't know,

six months,

do you consider

that person

a new customer?

If they say yes,

then I would create

a campaign,

but I would create

a separate campaign

that's targeting.

I would never allow

that to be

into my prospecting

campaign

because you can

never trust

Facebook with that

if you just go

for the lowest

conversion.

So,

I would set up

a different campaign

going only

for those customers.

And that's mostly,

you know,

in some skincare

or clothing.

And also,

during the promotions,

people are,

brands are okay,

they're fine

with going after

those customers.

So,

then I would set up

a campaign like that.

Yeah.

I have a question

about just overlap

in general.

Like,

you have multiple campaigns,

you have a ton

of different ad sets

going on.

Do you concern yourself

with overlap?

Or is like,

hey,

the number is going up,

I'll pay attention

to CPMR

or something like that,

but like,

otherwise,

the number is going up,

it's fine.

Yeah.

So,

I think,

like,

I definitely track

CPMR and frequency

and like,

I'm cool with

leaving an ad

active if it has

a bad CPA,

but it has a very

low frequency

because it tells me

that it's feeding

top of the funnel.

But I'm not going

to turn off an ad

that has a good

performance just because

it has a bad

CPMR.

And I think

that it is

healthy conversation

that like,

everybody are starting

to measuring that.

But I think

we are going

like in a bit

like too extreme

that like,

okay,

CPMR is better

than the CPA.

That like,

that's not the case.

Obviously,

it is important,

but it's also important

that people see

your ads

multiple times.

And when I have

like,

you know,

30 different influencer,

I have 10 different angles,

I have,

you know,

that creative diversification,

they're not actually

seeing one ad

for eight times.

They're seeing like seven

different ads.

So I think that actually

also is beneficial

to an extent.

Obviously,

I'm tracking that

with a tool

that Andrew and Kurt

built,

which is super helpful

for net new reach.

And that's obviously

one of the metrics

that I measure,

as well as the percentage

of new visits

in Norbeam.

But it's not,

you know,

I'm not going to turn off

a good ad just because

it has a bad frequency.

Yeah.

Okay.

Then my last question

related to this is,

I mean,

it's kind of overlappy,

but are you using

the actual like experiments

tab in Meta

at all for anything?

No.

Okay.

Really interesting.

So no holdout tests,

no A-B testing

directly in Meta?

No,

no.

If you're doing holdouts,

it's mostly through

House or WorkMagic.

When you've done

holdout tests,

what have they

shown you

that's been useful?

Cool.

I ask because

there's a lot of

discussion about this now

and, you know,

Northbeam has

an internal tool

that is doing this,

which I think

is actually pretty good.

And it's,

I think it's something

that as,

especially as budgets

go up and complexity

starts to get bigger

that like,

it's huge for people

to understand like,

okay, look,

you know,

so much of our traffic

from YouTube

is actually converting

on Amazon or whatever.

So like,

what types of stuff

are you,

have you seen

that's been surprising

or helpful to you?

Yeah,

potentially I can touch

base on the incremental

attribution.

Again,

like I know this is

like a hot topic now,

but when I do the breakdown

in my ad accounts,

like incremental

turns out to be

90 to 95%

of seven day click attribution.

So it's not really,

you know,

something game changing.

I think it's like

a tool in a toolbox,

but I would not necessarily

change my whole ad account

to incremental

just because

Twitter is talking about it.

In terms of the tests,

so I did try,

you know,

add to cart

and view content,

never worked for me.

Like I did five tests

with two different platforms,

never worked for me.

So I'm not sure what,

how come that's working

for Ridge,

but I mean,

I guess it's working.

In terms of the other channels,

we found out definitely

what you mentioned,

YouTube has a way bigger impact

on Amazon

compared to just Shopify.

We found that

Google third-party pages,

third-party funnels

have bigger impact

on overall performance

than if it is visible

in the ad account.

We also had some success

with Vibe

on the CTV,

but we realized

that it's very hard

to, you know,

understand whether Facebook,

which is spending like,

you know,

20, 30 times more

than the Vibe,

has an impact

on good performance

of Vibe

or Vibe has a good impact

on the Facebook.

So we are going to do

some additional tests there.

Besides that,

still did not do

app loving tests,

but that's on one

of my clients' maps.

So interested to see that

because I know everybody

are, again,

think how they scaled

app loving.

I never managed

to scale it.

No matter if I'm spending

50K a day on Facebook,

I could not get app loving

to spend more than 2, 3.

So I'm not sure

if I'm missing something

or,

but yeah,

those are kind of like

the main takeaways,

at least from,

you know,

a couple of clients

that are doing those tests.

The only thing I would say

on app loving,

the only,

we've seen,

we've seen similar things

to you where it's like

most people just don't hit scale.

But we had a conversation

with Miranda months ago

and that was like,

I wrote down a whole,

I had a whole notebook

of notes,

which I'm about to have

with you.

And I went back

and I just like picked

a couple of things

and the thing that hit

the best for us

was changing the hooks.

We did port over

the meta

creative directly

and she said,

she basically said,

don't do that.

But she says like,

as a starting point,

it's fine to do,

but that's not where

you're going to get

the biggest bang for your buck.

The biggest thing

that made a difference

for us from a creative perspective

was literally just

swapping out the hook

to like be something

about addressing the fact

that we just interrupted

their game.

Like, hey,

we'll get you right back

to your game

or sorry to interrupt your game

or like something

literally directly calling it out

and it made a huge difference.

Like the top performing ads

were all starting

with that hook

and the rest of the,

the rest of the,

the video is the same.

So interesting.

I'll be curious

to hear what you...

How did you then try

to get that creator

to film a hook

or was it the hook

totally unrelated

to the creator?

Yeah.

Because if you get

like 20 winners

and then like you get to,

you have to ask

like 20 people

to actually refilm the hook.

So was it just generic hook?

Yeah, that's a really good question.

In this specific case,

the ones that stood out the most,

it was an AI voiceover

with creator B-roll.

So we just,

we were able to,

the videos that were working

in general

were just kind of like

B-rolled with voiceovers.

So we were just able

to swap out

the messaging

with an AI voiceover.

That's...

But I bet you'd have

more success

by like maybe taking

your five best creators

and asking them

to film something

really specific.

That could be interesting.

I haven't been able

to do that yet.

So if you do,

you have to let me know

how it goes.

Sounds good.

Yeah, you should start

with like,

hey loser,

get off your phone.

Yeah, you're just

close to life.

Yeah, exactly.

Your kids in front of you,

like why aren't,

you know,

make them feel really bad.

That usually works.

So let's talk about

the hack segment

a little bit briefly,

which is like,

what's the closest thing

right now to a hack

that you've seen

inside meta?

So you change this,

it's like,

and it is a dramatic shift.

What are like one

to two things

that you,

that you're adjusting

that you're like,

man,

that's really an unlock?

I mean,

I like,

I like hacks,

but like,

I don't think like hacks

are just a nice addition,

you know,

like having a proper exclusion,

having not reliance

on existing buyers,

no viewed conversions,

like knowing when to scale,

knowing how much to scale,

that matters the most.

And although I'm a media buyer,

like,

you know,

product,

offer,

funnel,

creative,

they have way bigger impact

than the media buying.

I can make results

when like client is spending,

like everything else

is dialed in,

then the media buying

again makes a difference.

But you know,

at like,

at lower level,

probably like focus

on the offer,

offer,

like I've seen tremendous changes

in the hit rates

just by changing the offer.

So that's definitely

one thing outside

of the ad account.

Also remember,

everything else

outside of the ad account

has a tremendous impact

on the ad account.

In terms of the ad account,

I still pick

all of my thumbnails manually.

And like,

I just kind of like,

it felt like

I got a recognition

when Facebook confirmed

that a different thumbnail

actually means

different entity ID

because like I was,

I did not know why,

but like,

I like for four or five years

when back in the day

when I worked with Yudi,

I realized that

a different thumbnail

can impact the performance

of the same video

in a different way.

So still me

and all of my media buyers

and my junior media buyers,

everybody are picking

thumbnails manually.

I think,

I think it has

a positive impact.

Although I must say,

Facebook is getting better

and picking that

automatic thumbnail

compared to,

let's say,

a year before.

Yeah.

It's funny.

You basically don't like hacks

and I agree.

Like we put it in there

intentionally

because it kind of like

pushes you to say,

like pick,

pick,

have an opinion about hacks.

And it's,

it's hilarious

because like you probably feel

like you're repeating yourself

pretty often

and maybe the content

that you make

and you still get people

that are like,

they don't have exclusions.

They're not using,

you know,

it's like you still see

a million people

who are just doing crazy shit

and wondering why nothing's working.

And sometimes it's just like

those simple things

ends up being the hack for them

because they weren't doing

in the first place.

Yeah.

So no,

that's funny.

One thing that we've,

I'll throw in,

I'll throw in one little hacky thing

just as something

that continues to work for us

is just like customers

that are uploading images

as reviews,

just taking them as is

and uploading it as an ad

gets you creative volume,

gets you creative diversity.

They're probably super blurry

and that's the point.

Like it,

it just works really well

and we just keep doing that on repeat.

Yeah.

Now that you mentioned that

there's like something thing,

like usually I found that

for most problem solving product,

images do mostly retargeting.

We just do top of the funnel

while like on,

you know,

on clothing,

jewelry,

images actually do the prospecting.

So we found that like,

I could not,

like there's one client,

like we're spending 50K a day,

like 99% of my ads are videos.

I could not get images to work

and then we just replicated.

It's a beauty client.

We just replicated,

you know,

it felt like a story.

It was like a text,

organic text overlay,

like what you would put on a story

and it was just an image

and like those ads are getting,

I would say like 50% of delivery

on story and reels

and they feel organic

and this is something

that we finally managed to break out

with images

and got some traction.

Again,

I can't think because it looks organic.

It's so interesting.

I've been literally in the last,

I mean,

I've been thinking about it

for longer than this,

but like in the last two weeks,

I've had this like weird obsession

with like formats

where like you can communicate

the same message

in a bunch of different ways,

but also the type of content

that somebody is consuming

to your points,

like stories and reels

is different.

Like Zach's a great example of this.

Like they have compression socks

for Holo

and there's probably 80 year old dudes

that are buying it

and 30 year old nurses

and the type of content

that they're consuming

is very different.

It's like they expect

a different format

and so maybe it's the same,

it ends up being the same message

which your legs are going to hurt less

or whatever it is,

but how you communicate it

and just even the style of creative

can unlock different pockets

of audience.

So I like that.

That's a good one.

Nice.

And those are easy to make too.

Like those are easy.

Yeah, exactly.

They're super easy.

Slap a question and answer on it.

Exactly.

So how are you just,

how are you using AI by the way?

Like, and by the way,

if you haven't checked out

the new Foxhole podcast,

releasing or will be released

by the time this comes out,

AI D2C WTF,

which is a new podcast

I started up to talk about

all this stuff even more deeply.

But how are you using AI now?

Is it with reporting

or creating different variations

or is it all that stuff?

And if so, like what are you doing?

Yeah.

So I'm not on the level

that Will is.

Like when I see his conversation,

Will, that was on some of your podcasts

and like when I see the presentation

that he did in this,

I was like, okay, wow.

Like I would never be able to do that.

I did actually follow his template

and I managed to get close,

but I'm personally nowhere near that.

What I like to do it

is like for research,

for like synthesizing the data.

For example,

I gave it my whole YouTube video

for my whole YouTube channel

and like I told it to create

my media buying philosophy.

It created like 50 pages document

and then I uploaded that to Claude.

And now like, you know,

whenever there's a question,

I can get an answer from that

or like I can get a new script

for YouTube based on my whole knowledge.

That's one thing.

The other thing is

in terms of the ads,

I gave it my top five spending ads

and then I gave it one of my template

of a listicle page that we are running

and I told it to change the reasons

based on the reasons,

based on the angles from the ads.

And that landing page is currently

like that listicle is outperforming

our current listicle,

you know, by 10% of click rate

and like it's getting a nice traction

in Orbeam as well.

So that would be one

like practical example

of me using AI.

Besides that, you know,

like when you're doing media buying,

there's not much you can do

compared to when you're a copywriter

or developer or creative strategist.

So it's just like mostly trying

to kind of like improve my workflow

and save some time either on analysis

or on the reporting or

synthesizing the data.

I might be leaking something here.

What do you use for creative reporting?

It's mostly Motion or Atria

depending on the client.

Yeah.

Motion has an MCP connector now.

This is what I'm potentially leaking.

I don't know if it's

available to everybody,

but they gave me access to it.

It's awesome.

It's like, I don't know if you use

the chat feature inside of Motion at all,

but it's really nice.

You should reach out to them

and just ask if they can turn on

the MCP connector for you

because it can pull all those AI tags.

So like here's an example.

You mentioned landing pages.

You could say,

hey Motion, can you go grab

the top trending tags for me

in the last 30 days

for my messaging angle?

Okay, so it's going to grab that

and it's going to say,

here's how the spend breaks down

as a percentage of your ad account

for this angle, this angle, this angle.

You take the top spending one

and then it can grab the messaging.

So it can pull the scripts for those ads

and it can give you the scripts

and then it can synthesize it

and write a landing page

in the customer language

from those top ads.

If you wanted to,

if you could set up a schedule in Cloud,

like you could have that do it,

just like present you

a new landing page every week.

That's a little overkill probably,

but it's been fun.

Yeah, basically that's what I did,

but I did manually through Manus.

Hey, here are the ads.

Hey, can you transcribe me?

Hey, here's the landing page.

Hey, make it a landing page.

So basically it was me involving,

but if I can do that without me actually

instructing all of that,

that would be amazing.

So I'll definitely check that out.

Manus.

I haven't played with Manus too much,

but I feel like Zaka is going to

ban me from the world

if I don't start using it.

You know they're going

to be talking about it

at the Meta Performance Marketing Summit

quite a lot.

So outside of the things

that we've talked about,

you know, I think one of the things

that people look to you for

is very, you know,

deep tactical knowledge

and deep understanding of this.

How do you recommend people

upskill themselves on these things?

Like, I think there's so many sources.

I mean, and,

but I know that you sort of set out

in building your name around education

as well, right?

Like you're, you're very good at that.

How do you recommend people

start to get better at this

and really start to dive in?

So, I mean,

I don't know when I started,

I went through the like whole Google

and Facebook literature support

to understand how the auction works.

Obviously you don't have to do that.

I did that like eight years ago,

but like now I'm like spending five mil,

seven mil a month

and I'm still listening, you know,

to five different

podcasts on media buying.

I'm going to probably not heard

probably 90% of the stuff I already know,

but you know,

hearing Zach,

hearing Brad,

how he does,

you know,

that overlay of a testimonial image.

Okay.

That's a cool idea.

Hey,

doing this with MCP with Twitter,

you basically just need one good idea

because there's not

much that you're missing.

Obviously,

if you're on a lower level,

you have communities besides the podcast,

obviously,

Voxfield founders,

shout out.

If you're not there,

you have to be there

if you want to be serious

about DTC and e-com

and you have a library

of free content on YouTube,

like there's literally,

you can start a brand tomorrow.

You can start being,

I don't know,

whatever you want

because the information

is already out there.

You just have to,

you know,

stay disciplined,

stay consistent

and try to like put it into action.

It's not enough

that you just like read about AI.

You just have to try

to build something with it.

And I think that like,

you know,

transition from just absorbing

the information

to using information

is actually what makes a difference.

Well, Martin,

thank you so much for joining us.

A very rich episode

full of so much knowledge

and so much information.

And, you know,

I'm so grateful to you

for all that you've taught me,

all that you've taught founders

and all that you've now taught

listeners to the podcast.

So thanks for coming on.

And for those of you

that don't know Martin,

I recommend following him

on all the channels

that you can

because I always learn

something from your content.

So thanks for putting it

out there, my friend.

Yeah, I appreciate you having me.

I really enjoyed this episode.

It was really good conversation.

I think we covered

a lot from the technical stuff

and tactical all the way

to the holistic.

And yeah,

if you have,

if you guys have any questions,

just hit me up on Twitter.

I'll promise I'll respond

unless you try to sell me

your DM setting service.

Maybe,

maybe,

maybe throw in a couple arguments

on X as well.

You know,

a little banter back and forth.

All right,

take care.

This episode is brought to you

by the Foxwell Founders membership

that Andrew and his wife,

Gracie run.

It has been absolutely pivotal

for not just the Homestead team,

but the Easy Street Brands team.

We've had,

I don't even know

how many members

are currently in there

that are part of our ecosystem.

But when it comes to anything

from learning ads

to understanding what's going on

to building an agency

to knowing retention,

it's been absolutely useful

for our team

when they get stuck

or they need help

to just go there

and resource all the other experts.

So definitely would recommend it

for anybody that's looking to,

you know,

take it a step deeper,

try to get a little bit more knowledge

on growth marketing

and all the world DTC is.

Yeah,

I think one of the most

incredible things about it

is you can just like

open up the Slack group

every single day.

You can pin your favorite channels

for the topics

that you care most about.

And like every day,

there's going to be somebody

who just like,

because they want to contribute

something valuable

to the group,

you can go learn something

every single day

and it's going to be

extremely useful.

There's some ballers in there

that you just get like

the benefit of learning from

that like for the cost,

like you couldn't pay them

that for their time,

but through the membership,

like you get access

to some incredible people

and tons of resources.

Yeah,

I mean,

I think the biggest resource

to me too

is like the events

that,

you know,

Foxwell Founders does.

They've been able to do some,

even in Wisconsin,

even in the boring state

of Wisconsin,

which is pretty awesome,

getting people together

in person

and able to have really

just like honest conversations

of what's going on,

what's working for them now,

you know,

where they're at

in their business

and knowing that

there's going to be,

like Brad said,

some real killers

in the space

in this membership

that can help

and are willing

to take the time

and help.

So that's been

a huge part of why

a lot of our team

have really enjoyed it as well.

And the applications

are now open

if you're looking to join.

Foxwell Founders,

yeah,

foxwellfounders.com.

Go check it out.

Go apply.

The only way

that we grow this podcast

is by you sharing it

with your friends.

Honestly,

like reviews kind of

don't really mean anything

too much anymore.

They're really meaningful,

but they don't do a lot

for the growth

of the podcast.

And so sharing YouTube links,

sharing Spotify links,

sharing Apple,

whatever we call it

under the podcast app now,

anything you can share,

the better we're going to be.

Guys,

anything else

you want to say on this?

Yeah,

please go check us out

on YouTube.

Rack up those views for us.

We'd love to see it.

And then subscribe.

Make sure to subscribe

on YouTube as well.

And I relentlessly refresh

the YouTube comments

because it dictates

my mental health for the day.

So please say something

nice about all of us.

Thank you, everyone.

Thanks for listening.

Honestly.