Hosts David Nicolai and Seth Naeve discuss the progress and challenges of Minnesota's agronomic crops. They are joined each week by a diversity of specialists representing all crops and agronomic disciplines to discuss their research and its impact on Minnesota crops. Dave Nicolai is a crops Extension educator and Seth Naeve is the Extension soybean agronomist.
Good day, and welcome to the University of Minnesota Extension and CFANS podcast, Minnesota CropCast. I'm Dave Nicolai, University of Minnesota Extension crops educator,
Seth:Okay, folks. Welcome to Minnesota CropCast with Seth and Dave here today. And we're really excited. We've got Laura Lindsey, Extension soybean and small grain specialist from the Ohio State University with us. And so we're really excited to chat with her today.
Seth:We're going to learn a little bit about Laura and then talk about her research projects that she's got going on. A lot of really cool stuff on soybean, and we're probably going to ignore all the small grains work for today. So Laura, welcome.
Laura:Yeah. Thanks.
Seth:So tell us a little bit about yourself. I know you personally. I've known you for a long time, but we want to introduce you to our audience here. So give us the background. Where did you grow up?
Seth:Where did you go to school? And then how did you find your way to Ohio State?
Laura:Sure. I grew up in Ohio, so I'm still here in Ohio. So I grew up in Northern Ohio in Richland County. I did my bachelor's degree at Ohio State, my master's degree at Ohio State, and then it's always good to go somewhere different. So I went to Michigan State for my PhD, and then that took about three years, and then I came straight back down to Ohio.
Laura:And now I work at at Ohio State. So, not a very diverse trajectory, but I I really like being in Ohio.
Seth:You've only been about 300, 200 miles from home at your maximum. Is that right?
Laura:Yeah. Yeah. Northern Ohio to Michigan State was only about three hours. So, yep.
Seth:That's that's actually really nice. You feel like you're not too far from home, and that's very similar to my story as well. So you started as a soybean and small grain specialist then at Ohio State. That was your initial appointment?
Laura:Yep. Yep. In 2012. Yep. Which was the drought year, so it was a very interesting time.
Laura:I started in July 2012.
Seth:Okay.
Laura:Thrown right into the fire there, literally.
Seth:Well, that... That's good for Extension because we need to show our relevance. And so I'm sure you could get out and talk to folks. So what did you start on when you first started Ohio State? What was your big project that kind of launched your early career and allowed you to get tenure along the way?
Laura:Yeah. So, you know, you know, those first few years were really good times in terms of soybean yield, soybean prices, you know, 2012, 2013 were were good times. So, I was able to get quite a bit of funding from Ohio Soybean Council to start off, which was great. And so one of the big projects actually was doing kind of a survey of Ohio of what's going on. And so, we worked with a lot of extension educators.
Laura:We collected, and it... I paid it, 299 soil samples. I needed, like, one more, but it was 299 soil samples across the state. So, we looked at SCN so we could see how much SCN was across the state, and then we looked at soil fertility values to kinda get an idea of, you know, baseline problems in the state. And then we had farmers fill out surveys about their production practices.
Laura:So initially, it was kinda just getting a feel for for what's going on in Ohio because at Michigan State and at Ohio State, all of my work was on corn. So soybeans were kind of a new thing for me in this position because everything else was corn and nitrogen, which doesn't fit well with soybeans necessarily.
Seth:But that gave you a really nice baseline to kind of It did. And and priority setting in in order to determine what what you thought that the farmers, in Ohio were really looking for.
Laura:Mhmm.
Seth:And so SCN, what did you learn from those SCN samples? There was more SCN out there than farmers knew, or or didn't you find as much?
Laura:Yeah. It was interesting because before I was at Ohio State, don't remember it was ten or fifteen years before the plant pathologist did a survey of SCN and there was a lot more than when when I started compared to their survey, you know, in ten or fifteen years previously. The other thing that was kind of interesting is we had farmers fill out a paper survey, and one of the questions was, do you have soybean cyst nematode? And it was yes, no, or I don't know. And most people put no or I don't know, And when in fact...
Laura:I don't remember the exact percentage, but it was probably close sixty, seventy, 80% of them actually had it. So it was kind of interesting that most people thought they didn't have it, and then they did have it in reality.
Seth:Yep. Take the test. Beat the past days. I think that was always valuable then and it's valuable now. Farmers need to be aware even though they're basically being handed varieties with some sort of resistance So good baseline stuff.
Seth:Tell us more about what you've been doing in recent years. I know you've got some really cool stuff going on very recently, but let's save that for a second. What other projects have really kind of lit the fire there in Ohio and that got you really going and interested in some of the... Some of your best projects you had going?
Laura:Yeah. Yeah. So I work a lot with the the plant pathologist, Horacio Lopez Nacora, and you'll probably talk to him at some point. And so we've done some work with fungicides. So we did some fungicide work to look at our three applications versus our our five applications, tank mixing with insecticides just to see if it pays.
Laura:Because we hear a lot from farmers, depends on the price of soybeans, but if they apply a fungicide, they throw in an insecticide just to see what happens and it's cheap insurance, so things like that. So a lot on the input side. Biological seed treatments, I know you were involved in that one as well. So a lot of product evaluations that are relevant to farmers.
Seth:Yeah. The biologicals work that was conducted around The US by the Science for Success team was led by Laura and a graduate student in her lab. And they did a really fantastic job with that. We learned a ton about biologicals. And I think it was a little frustrating to a lot of farmers and advisors how little response we got.
Seth:It was kind of confounding to a lot of us and frustrating for the folks in the industry. But I think it gave us a good baseline to start with. And we were able to get that going kind of at the early side of all this biological craze. So what do you hear from the industry about biologicals after you published a lot of work that said that there's not a lot of value in these? You get some pushback?
Seth:And where have you taken your thought process since that work got out?
Laura:Yeah. Yeah. So not a lot of response to these biological treatments, even though I kind of wanted to see something, it's more fun to see something, but no no response. You know, from an industry standpoint, I've heard a lot of companies trying to maybe package the microbes differently or deliver them differently, to maybe, cause once they're on the seed, they have to be there in large enough numbers and they need to be alive and they need to... I hate to use the word infect, but they need to infect the seed.
Laura:And so, maybe some technology down the road could could help help in that area. But, I mean, they're still out there. They're still being sold to farmers. There's new products all the time. So I'm sure the products we looked at, you know, two years ago are probably not even on the market anymore.
Seth:Yeah, that's true. So another, I want to hit on one more project before we get to some of your latest stuff. But I was also involved with a project that actually has become really timely, I think, for this year, is you had a student leading a project on harvest timing and the effects of getting out in the field and harvesting either really on the early side of maturity at higher moistures or waiting and letting those lay in the field for a while. So any early results from that you'd like to share? Any very high level stuff that you you and your student learn?
Laura:Yeah. I mean, 2024... We did the project in 2024 and 2025. 2024 was really, really hard for us in terms of where our our research was at in Western Ohio. It was the first time we were ever in a d four drought in Ohio since the drought monitor was existed.
Laura:And so we had our harvest date project that year in Western Ohio. Things dried down just so fast because of the drought. The problem is our harvest was delayed because we had rainfall from hurricane Helene that came through, and so we had these really, really dry beans, and then it got really wet and warm and humid, and the losses were astounding. Even in in farmer's fields, again, I was driving with our plant pathologist out to the field, and he made me pull over the car because he wanted to know what cover crop was planted, and it was soybeans. The cover crop was soybeans because the shatter was just astounding.
Laura:It looked like a blanket of a cover crop. So timely harvest is really, really, really important, especially if you're in those drought years and then get rainfall. Just the soybeans turn black overnight, and the shatter was just off the charts.
Seth:I think some of those findings are probably relevant for this year in the Western Corn Belt. We've had really kind of a similar environment in that we were really, really dry over here. Minnesota and the Dakotas down into Nebraska and Kansas have been... And part of Iowa had been really, really dry. And then now we've got a really extended wet weather here as We're of a little bit on the cooler side, so we've been able to withstand some of these harvest problems in the North just because of our cool conditions.
Seth:And maybe some of that work will come out within your research project as well in some of that summary. But I think you're going to generate some really good stuff that's applicable for a year like this. So tell us about, since we're talking about wet weather, what's it like right now in in Ohio, and how are the farmers faring in in Ohio here the first day of October as we record this?
Laura:Yeah. So it's kind of hard because I always tell people we need rainfall. You need rainfall rainfall at grain fill. Right? That's where we see our highest yields.
Laura:And so we've had really good rainfall in July, in August, in September, but in some areas, it's almost to the point of too much. And I hate to say too much rainfall because after having some dry years, but we've had some some fields, probably mostly in Central Ohio, South Of Columbus as well, that have had really, really heavy rainfall, and I think there's some issues, that are gonna result from that.
Seth:Okay. So, Dave is talking to me here while we're trying to have a conversation with you. He's showing me some soybeans from right here. So we've got real problems of some seed quality issues this year for And I think understanding the impact of kind of this long trajectory of wet weather during the later part of seed fill through maturity versus what you saw in that kind of those hurricane years where things dry out and then we get a deluge later. I think we're gonna see some different stuff this year.
Seth:And I know, you know, the purple seed stain is really starting to show up in some states like in Wisconsin, Indiana. And frankly, you probably just haven't had enough harvest there to know what kind of problems you have in Ohio. It could be a real headache this year in terms of seed quality issues. And certainly, we're gonna have problems here even in Minnesota because we're wet, and now we're we're on the warm side as well. Mhmm.
Seth:So I guess the last thing I wanted to talk about is the battle for the belt. A lot of folks have been talking about this project that you've got. But give us a little bit of the background why Battle for the Belt and why you chose to kind of embrace this kind of idea and and what you were trying to research and and and the kind of information you're trying to provide for farmers in terms of an educational moment for them as well.
Laura:Yeah. So, you know, one thing we know about soybeans is timely planting is really, really, really important. Right? Because we see yield reductions if if planting is delayed. So I talk about that all the time in Extension, to farmers.
Laura:And then after I give my little spiel about it's important to plant soybeans timely, the next person to speak is our corn agronomist, Osler Ortiz. And so he tells farmers the exact same thing. Planting corn timely is really, really important to maximize yield. You see declines if you delay planting in corn. And then without fail, there's always a farmer or two that says, well, what should I do?
Laura:If I have one planter or, you know, I don't have a lot of time, what crop should I plant first? And so battle for the belt is the corn belt versus the soybean belt, and which crop should have planting priority in the spring. And I did buy a wrestling belt, which is super awesome. And Ohio State has no restrictions on buying wrestling belts for whatever reason. It's very hard to buy a lot of things, but wrestling belts came in, like, two weeks, which was phenomenal.
Laura:But that's the idea of battle for the belt. Corn versus soybean, which crop should have planting priority in the spring? Just because we know our planting window is really, really, really narrow in Ohio. Kansas State keeps a track of suitable field work days. And between the middle of April and the middle of May, we only have half of those days suitable for field work on average.
Laura:So there are a lot of years where we have very, very limited field work days, And so some farmers, you know, want to plant earlier than what's ideal because if they wait, it may be the middle of June, and we know that's bad as well.
Seth:So it sounds like you and your corn agronomist have set up a series of of of trials that have corn and soybean plantings at the same location across a series of dates. Is that correct?
Laura:That is correct. Yeah. We have three locations in Ohio, and we plea early as the end of March. And then five... Go ahead.
Seth:I'm gonna have you back up just a little bit. I had a glitch in my
Dave:You you froze a little bit. Are you on
Seth:It's... I... Who knows where it was. It was us or them. But let me let me just start back, and I'll go back a couple minutes, and I'll I'll start the little bit that I gave with the the bit about the kind of setup.
Seth:So if that's okay.
Laura:Sure. Yep. Go ahead.
Seth:So it sounds like you and Osler have put out research trials where you plant corn and soybeans on the same day or at the same relative time at the same locations. Is that right? So you can look at the yield decline over time for each of those crops at the same location. Does that kind of summarize what you've been doing?
Laura:Yep. Absolutely. We have three locations in Ohio, Northwest, Northeast, and then West Central. And then we plant corn and soybean on the same day for five different time periods. So we go as early as the end of March all the way to about the third week of June.
Laura:And we've done that three locations over three years, so quite a bit of data.
Dave:Well, Laura, this, this is Dave again. I wanted to visit with you a little bit about that because we are going to invite you and have invited you already to be a speaker in Minnesota. Every December we have our crop pest management short course which is a partnership with the University of Minnesota and the Minnesota Crop Production Retailers. And it's held in Minneapolis and this year it will be held on December 8 through the tenth. And you're gonna be on our program on December 9 which is the middle day and talking a little bit more about battle for the belt but particularly what you've learned and some of the yield results.
Dave:Now you're a little bit earlier than sometimes we start here in the cold North here in Minnesota in terms of getting into the field. But nonetheless, I think there's a lot of important lessons that you can translate back and forth. We have your information in terms of what you're gonna be talking about. I was just glancing on it. You're gonna be covering some of the things about delays in terms of the effect on soybean yield for every day that goes past some of those critical time periods.
Dave:Anything else that you can give us as a hint of what you would like to be... Have the time to cover for our Minnesota audience?
Laura:Yeah. I think for me the most interesting thing as an agronomist was seeing corn and soybeans side by side, the same planting dates. So they're exposed to the exact same weather. Exact same weather. And the way corn reacts and the way soybean reacts to the exact same weather is very very different.
Laura:And I think we know that, but to see it firsthand was really kind of amazing for me because they react completely different to weather conditions, especially early in the growing season.
Dave:And some of your research, obviously, the unique thing is that you were able to start, as you mentioned a little bit earlier, in March. Mhmm. Which we consistently are not really able to do that much in Minnesota. So I think that's some of the unique things. We have crop insurance deadlines and things that come into play for growers.
Dave:But I think from an agronomic standpoint, it should be fascinating information. And again, for anybody listening to this podcast is welcome to join us at the CPM Short Course as yourself and then there'll be a number of other speakers. And really in this case, we like to and love to bring in folks from other states at least a third of the time because then the audience can hear what goes on, you know, in the other parts of our quote corn soybean belt as you say as well. So you're gonna appear twice. So that's really great.
Dave:Thank you.
Seth:Yeah. And as part of as part of our shameless advertisement here, we're not going to tell our podcast audience the, who won the belt each of those years. So we'll let you share that with the audience there so they can they can make sure and show up. So if I think about your study, what you're probably looking at is you're looking at pure yields over this delayed planting window for both corn and soybeans. So there's a pure economic question here in terms of yield loss versus the price of that crop.
Seth:And then you've got a kind of a risk management side to this. Right? So you've got the the kind of conditions that you have in any of these planting windows and whether corn or soybean may actually come through that better. Mhmm. And maybe even a little bit about the cost of planting and replanting if you had to.
Seth:So I could see that's an important aspect of this. And then you talked about working days too. So farmers have to kind of figure out when they're going to utilize those scarce spring planting days and what crop they're going to put in. So I think there's a lot going on, and I really, really appreciate what you're doing over there in Ohio. I think the folks here at the CPM Short Course are going to learn a ton about how to manage that early season risk management and try to produce the highest yields.
Seth:Awesome. So do we have a closing, Dave? Do you want anything else?
Dave:Not at this point in time. Again, famously inviting people to come to the short course, an opportunity here at firsthand. So that's really the end of it. But like we were talked about a little bit earlier, we're just getting into our harvest here a little bit and been delayed weather and so forth. So we've have some concerns about quality going in there but it does look like the next week.
Dave:So I think Laura you're bringing us good luck. It looks like it's going to have dry weather. So growers should be able to get back out in the field and and start on some things. So it'll be a busy October, which I imagine it is gonna be in Ohio as well.
Laura:Yeah. Yes. It is.
Seth:Alright, Laura. Well, we've we've kept you long enough. We really appreciate you joining us here today and being able to put out, again, a shameless advertisement for our CPM Short Course coming up on December eighth through tenth in Minneapolis. So thank you again, Laura, and we're looking forward to seeing you here in the Twin Cities. I'm...
Seth:I hope I'm able to take you out for dinner so I can learn a little bit more about your harvest season this year.
Laura:Yeah. I appreciate the opportunity.
Dave:Well, thank you. Well, this has been another edition of the University of Minnesota Extension and CFANS College University of Minnesota podcast, Minnesota CropCast. Their hosts have been doctor Seth Nave, University of Minnesota Extension soybean specialist. I'm Dave Nicolai, University of Minnesota CropCast educator. Thanks for your time and we'll talk to you next time.