Is Anything Real? is a podcast about questioning the things we've collectively decided are true.
Each week, executive coach and author Adam W. Barney sits down with founders, executives, authors, creators and other interesting humans to get underneath the assumptions, conventional wisdom and occasionally ridiculous rules we use to make sense of work, leadership, success and our lives.
The conversations are prepared but unscripted. No rehearsed talking points. No pretending there's a neat answer when there isn't one. Just curiosity, honest disagreement, lived experience and the occasional detour that turns out to be more interesting than the question Adam planned to ask.
Because sometimes the most useful question is the simplest one: Is any of this actually real?
New episodes every Wednesday.
Here's a myth that needs to be deleted
from the marketing internet immediately.
Words are just words.
I've never seen that as true.
Words are choices,
they're architecture,
they're leverage,
and they can clarify reality
or just simply fog a glass.
And you know,
they can sell us something useful
or manipulate someone who's super vulnerable.
They can also make a leader sound human
or like they were assembled by a LinkedIn prompt,
you know,
from a committee trapped in a beige conference room,
and I think now AI can obviously generate infinite words,
which sounds powerful,
but it's also very dangerous.
Welcome back to "Is Anything Real?",
the reality-first leadership show where we test advice,
publish the receipts,
and ship what actually works under pressure.
I'm Adam W. Barney,
transition leadership coach,
author of "Make Your Own Glass Half Full",
and builder of Energy OS
where I help leaders rebuild their operating system
when the tools that got them here stopped working.
Today's guest is David Deutsch,
founder of Speaking of Writing.
David is a powerhouse in persuasion,
copywriting, direct response,
human communication,
and the kind of writing
that doesn't just sit there looking pretty;
it actually moves people.
And what makes this conversation especially fun
is that David declined the usual prep call.
And I have a lot of respect for that pushback.
He basically said,
"Let's not drain the spontaneity
out of the real conversation
before we record it."
So we're going in with a strong direction today.
And I think there's actually
a much bigger conversation here
than copywriting alone.
It's about leadership.
It's about identity, trust, action,
and the difference between persuasion and manipulation,
and whether originality actually still matters
when the machines can write endlessly
and mediocrity can scale at terrifying speed.
David, welcome to "Is Anything Real?"
Thank you, thank you, Adam.
It's great to be here.
I'm excited to have you here, David.
Let's start in a place, though, here.
When people treat writing as just words,
what are they actually missing?
Well, I think, of course,
writing is composed of words.
You know, you can't deny that,
but you know, it's really so much more, obviously.
You know, the writing can do so much.
You know, you talk about writing,
and leadership, and all those things.
It made me think of Winston Churchill
and how he pretty much,
you know, won World War II with words, right?
And you know, words have a lot of power.
And they can move people to do things.
They can move things to do things in a way that helps them.
They can move people to do things in a way
that's exploitative, as you say.
So, we who use words have a certain responsibility
to use them for, you know,
like Superman, right?
For good and not evil, you know.
But, you know, it's true.
You can do harmful things with them
where it's going to have a harmful effect on people.
Yeah, well
that's the distinction I wanted to hit right away, actually here.
You know, I think most people treat writing like expression,
and of course it is,
but persuasive writing, it's also behavior design,
you know.
I think it's, you know,
what does it make someone notice, feel?
What does it make them believe is possible?
And, you know, I think a lot of times,
and I actually saw this in my marketing background,
which was over 20 years
and $100 million or more in ad spend.
A campaign doesn't fail
only because the media buying was wrong.
It was because the words were
dead on arrival, right?
You can have pretty copy,
but it doesn't have a pulse.
You know, where do you see
smart businesses misunderstanding
what copy is supposed to do?
Well, you know, I think,
to some extent, it gets back to what
your original discussion about words being words.
I think too often businesses see words as just words,
as a commodity.
Like we need some words to go in this space here
to fill this social media post
or to fill this ad copy,
and so they have AI write it
because AI can generate endless words very quickly.
But then the words don't have
that human feeling behind them.
They don't have
the human persuasiveness behind them.
And more and more, I feel like
people are starting to sense that.
They're starting to recognize AI writing.
They're starting to call it out.
And there's becoming a return,
and people seeking real human voices,
human words.
So it can be a tremendous advantage
to have humanness in your copy and in your marketing,
and it also can be increasingly
a tremendous disadvantage,
especially when you get called out on,
you know, oh, this is AI copy,
and you get comments, right?
Yep.
Well, and you know,
I actually want to go into persuasion,
right?
Because I think that's actually where
this conversation gets morally interesting,
right?
You know, outside of the AI slop that we can report, you know,
now on LinkedIn at the click of a button,
persuasion has a very dirty reputation in some circles.
And, you know, I think people think manipulation,
you know, false urgency, emotional crowbars,
and you know, little dark artsthat
make the internet smell like desperation and protein powder
here in 2026, right?
You know, persuasion itself is not automatically dirty.
But what do you think separates persuasion from manipulation?
I guess where's that line?
I don't know.
I don't know that there's a line so much
as it's just how we define things.
You know, want to define it as manipulation?
Sure.
Like, did I manipulate my wife into marrying me?
Did I manipulate my boss into giving me a raise?
Did I manipulate, you know, you know,
this person to be nice to me
because I smiled at them.
Sure, we could call that, you know,
call all those things manipulation.
You know, we can call them persuasion,
you know, or we could call them just being human.
We're constantly in a state of
persuading people to do things,
right?
Right.
We're trying to persuade the waiter
to come over to our table.
We're trying to persuade our kids
to behave themselves.
We're trying to persuade people
to not kill us, you know.
There's constant persuasion going on.
So, I don't know that it's a matter of it.
It depends on your intent, right?
Depends on intent.
It depends on is the thing I'm trying to get someone to do
useful to that person?
Yep.
Right.
Right.
If I'm trying to persuade someone
to not do heroin.
Yes, I'm being persuasive and manipulative,
and you know, everything I can,
but it's not necessarily a bad thing, right?
Well, you know,
I guess I would kind of ask, you know,
from a leadership lens, David,
how do you teach people to persuade
without becoming creepy little conversion goblins there?
Well, you know.
Mostly, I try to just get people, when I coach them,
to access their natural-born persuasion.
You know,
they've been persuading since they were babies,
and they cried,
and they got what they needed.
They smiled, and they got what they needed.
They learned to talk,
and they got, you know, what they needed.
You know, they became more and more.
And as I say, we're constantly persuading.
So,
I think the trouble with people
when they sit down to write copy
is they get into this writerly head of,
oh, I'm gonna do this and benefits and features
and stories and you know need to remember these rules
and templates and formulas that I've learned
and they hear the echo of stuff that they've read.
You know copy, right?
And then they sort of imitate that,
and then other people imitate them imitating it,
and AI imitates people imitating it,
and before you know it,
everything sounds the same, right?
I like to ask people, okay,
if you were trying to sell this thing to your mother,
like how would you sell her?
Yep, right.
And that right away that takes out all the bullsh-,
the BSing.
It takes out the manipulation
because you're not going to BS your mother,
and you're not going to manipulate your mother.
You're going to really try to find
the genuine connection between
why this is good for her
and how it can help her,
and get her to do it.
You're not going to high-pressure her.
You know, you're not going to try to trick her.
And you're probably not even
going to use copywriting gimmicks because
she'll just say,
"Oh, don't try that copywriting stuff on me, Bonnie.
I know you better than that."
Right?
Well, consumers know us better than that too, right?
Right.
You know, they recognize those tricks.
So, why use them?
Why not talk to the consumer like she's our mother?
And then they feel that we're trying to help them,
and we have their best interests at heart.
That's if we think about salesmen that we like,
right, that we trust.
That car salesman that we would buy anything from, you know.
Or the person at the clothing store
that we always go back to and trust, right?
It's because we think they have
our best interest at heart.
And they do.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Well, well, I want to talk about originality, right?
Because I think it actually gets into that.
I think one of the one of the,
honestly funniest but saddest things
about this AI era
that we've just entered into really,
Is that everybody suddenly has access to infinite words,
and somehow everything just ends up sounding more the same,
right?
It's more perfectly formatted nothing.
It's, you know,
like the internet discovered, you know,
maybe a beige fog machine.
What do you think makes writing original?
Not cute, not quirky.
You know, and how do writers
find the non-obvious idea there
on the other side of originality?
Yeah, well, you know,
originality may be a little bit overrated.
You know, what is original?
Probably all combinations of words have appeared
at some form or another.
The thing I think that's important is
does the writing sound fresh, right?
Does the writing sound, is it unexpected?
Is it unpredictable?
You know, can I cover up the first?
Can I cover up the second half of the sentence?
And if I just read the first half,
do I know what the second half is going to be?
Right.
With AI writing, you pretty much know,
or you know the structure,
you know the rhythm, right?
If it gives you one thing,
it's going to give you two more things
to make three, right?
If it tells you what something isn't,
it's going to tell you what it is, right?
And that freshness is what we have
when we talk to people,
when we naturally try to persuade people.
Like if you ran what I'm saying through an AI detector,
it wouldn't come out as being AI, right?
Yep.
Yep.
Because it's being generated from a real human,
and that's,
why not just write what you would say to someone?
Right.
It's really fairly simple in a certain way, right?
True.
Like you would talk to someone
and how you persuade someone.
You just have to know how to put it
into a certain structure,
and you have to know how to kind of
keep your mindset there,
not let it drift into, you know,
marketing pabulum that you've heard
and we've all heard countless times.
Well, that's where originality gets real
when I think the writing contains evidence
that a human being actually
risked a thought there, right?
And I think that's interesting to talk about
in a sense of direct response also because,
you know, it's so useful,
but it's so misunderstood.
I think a lot of brand people
look down on direct response
like it's the roadside diner of marketing.
And, of course, you and I both know
direct response has receipts.
It either works, or it doesn't.
People respond, or they don't.
You know, the market votes.
The copy pulls.
The offer.
Right, right.
And that's something beautiful,
brutally, rather, clarifying about that.
And I think the business world
actually needs more of that clarity.
I mean, for a long time
people have confused polish with performance,
and they love to say something feels elevated.
But did anyone do anything?
What did direct response teach you
that brand marketing often forgets, though?
Well, yeah, I mean, brand marketing
often forgets that the ultimate goal is to sell something,
right, or to get someone
to sign up, or donate, or, you know,
whatever the ultimate goal is, right?
Right.
It's a response, and response can be measured.
So the best brand marketing
and the best direct response marketing
measures that response.
But, you know,
it's easy to feel like I've been in advertising.
I've worked on Madison Avenue.
I know how easy it is to forget.
Like you just want to do a fun television commercial, right?
Let's put palm trees in
because then we'll have to go to the tropics to shoot this,
you know?
Yep, yep.
And, oh, let's do something clever
and maybe we'll win an award,
right?
Because, you know,
to some extent you're judged by that.
I mean not so much where I worked at Ogilvy,
but, you know, in the advertising world, right?
You know.
Awards are are your calling card and your capital.
So yeah, I mean,
it's something that I love and hate about direct response
is everything is measured.
If I send an email, I know what the response is.
If I create a sales page,
I know how many people it's converting,
and I can play the game of
oh okay, oh, what if I change this?
Does that increase it or decrease it?
What if I took this out?
What if I added this?
Right, right, right.
That's why I love performance pressure, right?
When it's used honestly,
I think the response is a receipt,
and also not every important thing
can be measured perfectly,
of course, right?
But, you know, it connects to leadership.
Leaders love to judge communication by intention,
by saying, you know, I told them,
I sent the email, I put it in the deck.
That's great, but you have to ask, did it land?
Did they understand it?
Do they trust it?
Do they act?
What do you think leaders
at an executive level
should learn from direct response, David?
I mean, that's a really interesting question,
and I want to answer something first, which is,
you know, that the idea that,
which you touched on,
the idea that the communication
is how the person takes the message.
It's not the intent, right?
Right.
So many times we're like,
well, but I said this.
Well, maybe you did.
But what is received is the communication, right?
That's what was received.
And gosh, you know,
the whole topic of how that relates to leadership.
You know,
leaders can't lead by intention, right?
Leaders lead by results.
Leaders lead by the effect
that they have on people.
So, doesn't matter if their words are beautiful.
Doesn't matter if their words are well put together.
What matters is what someone comes away with
having heard those words,
whether that's the employee that
they just reprimanded or tried to inspire,
or whether that's addressing the whole team,
whether that's addressing stockholders,
whether that's addressing, you know,
the whole market in some ad or speech,
or, you know, post, that they make, right?
They need to realize that
the effect that they have is what counts.
And that's, you know,
if they're leading, they have to lead in that way.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Well, you know, communication gets real, I think,
when the response matters more
than the sender's intention there.
I wanna, you know, also
widen this just for a minute
a little more beyond marketing.
I think language is one of those
most underrated leadership operating systems
in that sense.
You know, I want to ask, though, you know,
because I think if you can't name reality,
you can't lead inside of it.
What language should leaders retire immediately, David?
What language should they retire?
Well, I this is in the inspiration of, you know,
I feel allergic to corporate vanilla, right?
It it doesn't just sound bad,
it protects power,
it hides truth.
You know, I think it's
if you think about what language works for leadership,
right?
Specific language, stories, inspiring.
You know, what do leaders do?
Leaders give credit to others, right?
So, of course, any kind of complaining language then,
like, but you just
look at the opposite of all those things, right?
So any kind of complaining language
and also just vague language, right.
You know, Churchill was never vague, right.
He didn't say we're going to fight them
all over the place and we're going to do.
He said, we will fight them on the beaches,
we will fight them in the streets,
we will fight them in the highway,
you know,
he was very specific
and he painted pictures,
and I think that's certain.
So leaders want to retire vague language
and, you know, and you also use active language.
Right.
So the flip side of that is not using
passive, nominalized language.
Yep.
But you know verbs,
powerful verbs.
So, you know,
you could do a very interesting study
of how great leaders speak, right?
If you took, I don't know who we consider great leaders,
but Steve Jobs and Jack Welsh,
and, you know, people like that,
and did an analysis of their writing, you know,
I bet you would find a high use of verbs,
a high use of action verbs,
low use of generalities,
high use of story,
high use of specifics.
You know, maybe you would find
not a lot of use of I, but more we.
You know, you could.
You know, I'm a really big advocate
of mathematical approach to writing in a certain way.
Ooh.
Right?
Yeah.
Like, I can't understand,
if you want to learn to write better,
you want to learn to write like Hemingway.
Well, look at what Hemingway does.
Count the number of words in his paragraphs.
Count the number of syllables in his words, right?
Yeah, yeah.
Count the number of adjectives
compared to the number of nouns.
Count the number of verbs
compared to the, you know,
it's identifiable what writers do,
and you can identify your own weaknesses or strengths.
Even just to do a reading index,
what grade level are you writing at?
Yeah, that's fascinating.
I would love to partner on doing some of that research, David,
I would not have thought
that the mathematics side would come into this,
but I love that idea because you can find those trends
and it connects back to what you were saying earlier about, you know,
when I was a kid,
I remember hearing time and time again
growing up in the 80s, you know,
practice makes perfect.
I say to my own kids these days,
practice makes better, right?
Practice is just.
You never get to perfect.
Nothing is perfect.
So, you know, I think that's a perspective here
in leadership that we could dig into.
Well, you know, I want to take this, David, though,
and move it into one EnergyOS system move
that our listeners could run this week.
And inspired by our conversation today,
I want to call this one
The Human Signal Edit.
And I would say it's for founders, executives, coaches, writers,
or anyone of the many people out there that's letting AI produce
perfectly acceptable communications
that no living person
can or wants to remember.
But just take one important piece of communication.
It could be a sales deck.
It could be a landing page,
a team announcement pitch.
Whatever it is, you know,
ask four simple questions though.
First, what response do I actually want?
You know, and that shouldn't be sounds good.
It's what the reader should actually think, feel, or decide.
Second, what human truth is this avoiding?
Could be fear, a desire, objection, tension.
The third, then, what sentence could only I write?
You know, and that's where that scar tissue comes in,
that lived point of view,
that detail that proves you
were actually someone standing in that spot at that time.
And then the fourth, where am I persuading
and where am I manipulating?
And then, you know, clarify that choice there,
don't steal the agency.
But David, what would you
add for our listeners to that list,
or what would you adjust there
based on your expertise there?
I think intent is really important.
People don't think enough about what do they want.
Not only what do they want the person to feel,
what do they want the person to believe,
and then what do they want the person to do
after they've read the thing.
Which kind of gets into direct response in a certain way,
cause that's the response.
I think they need to think about who this person is.
What do they care about?
What do they believe?
What do they think?
What do they feel?
What do they want?
What keeps them up at night?
You know, what do they dream about
when they do get to sleep?
Right.
They need to think about how what I have to offer,
or what I want them to do
will bring them closer
to the thing that they want,
and/or help them avoid the thing that they don't want.
And then I think they need to think about
what's the best way into this discussion with this person.
Right?
How do I, you know,
so many people just attack things head-on.
I got this thing to sell you,
and it's the greatest thing in the world.
Yeah.
Rather than, you know, if you watch infomercials, right?
A lot of times it's much more like,
hey, have you ever had to, you know,
how it is when you try to clean you floor
and you can't push the mop
and you know, you know,
and then it brings in the
so, so just to think about, right?
How do I broach this?
And then to think about,
well, what do I need for them to believe
in order for them to think, do, whatever,
what I want them to do.
Right.
Right.
I may want you to buy something,
and I may need you to believe that it works.
Yep.
But I also may need you to believe
that not only that it works,
but it could work for you specifically.
Right.
Because everybody's like,
yeah, it worked for him,
but he's, you know,
six feet tall or she's this,
and I'm older, younger.
Yeah.
You know, I'm a soccer mom.
You know, I don't know if it'll work.
So you got to convince it'll work for them.
Right.
And maybe you have to convince them
they won't look stupid for buying it, you know.
It's just all sorts of things to think about with that.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Because to me,
writing anything and writing copy
is more about,
copy especially,
it's more about thinking
than it is the actual writing.
I think people don't like to cold copywriting,
copy thinking.
Right.
And it should be thinking writing, basically.
It's because words get real when they, I think,
stop trying to sound impressive
and start doing that real, honest work.
Yeah, yeah.
Can I loop around to something?
Please, yes, go for it.
Yeah, you could always edit this back to where it belongs,
or people could do that in their minds.
But when we were talking about math
and you were saying how interesting it is
that copywriting or writing
can be looked at mathematically.
You know, to me,
if AI proves anything,
it proves that.
Right.
Right.
It proves that this amazing machine
was able to take human writing
and break it down mathematically.
Because that's all it is, right?
It's all algorithms.
It's all probabilities.
It's all mathematical weights.
Was able to break it down mathematically
and reproduce it to the extent
that it passed the Turing Test, right?
To the extent that it's difficult for people to tell,
for the most part, that it's not a human behind it.
You know,
it could break it down enough to startle us, right?
You know?
Why don't we look at writing mathematically too, right?
Why don't we take advantage of that
because that can get us to a little bit of a higher level.
Yep.
Yeah.
Ooh, I love that.
And I'm going to keep that actually right where you parked it,
David.
Okay.
I think you know how we end here,
after all of this,
and this actually ties to that,
and the myth that those words are just words,
is anything real?
Is anything real?
You know, again,
depends on what one's definition of real is,
right?
Is anything real?
I mean, we're looking at the world, right?
You know,
we're looking at this little bitty bandwidth of sound.
We're looking at this little bitty bandwidth
of the whole spectrum of light.
Something that is real to me
may not be real to you.
A chair is composed of atoms,
which are like miles apart, if you blew it up,
there's actually mostly space.
We're looking at the world as our perception.
It's just, you know,
if we ever saw the raw data coming into our brains,
we would freak out
because it's just like millions of lights and sounds and,
you know,
but we've kind of narrowed it down, right?
We've narrowed it down to this thing we call reality.
Right, right.
It's almost like the aperture, right?
Yeah.
Rather than the color, so much, I guess.
So, to just bear that in mind,
kind of frees us up a little bit to see,
well, maybe I'm not seeing everything.
Maybe there's a reality.
Maybe there's a level of reality I'm not seeing.
Right?
If we look at a chair,
we see, oh, that's a chair.
That's the reality.
But the reality also is
all the people that went into making that chair,
the people that constructed it,
the people that chopped the wood in the forest,
the people that, you know,
designed the chair,
you know,
where this chair has been, you know,
that's part of the reality
that we don't we don't see.
So, to me, the whole question of reality
is a very interesting one.
Yeah.
So I'm not sure what your question was,
I was more.
Well, I think what feels real to me
is the response.
Right, it's not the applause, the polish,
it's the actual response.
Did your words reach a human being?
Did they clarify something?
Or did they
move the person you intended toward a better decision?
Well yes, that is that is more real than anything else.
Certainly is, you know, not my intention,
not the words I used, but what it caused.
Right?
Just like if I strike this glass
and it makes a tink, right?
It's like, that's the reality.
It made that sound when I struck it, right?
You're getting to, like, almost
first principles kind of thinking, right?
Yeah, like,
how simple can we make something,
and the simplest thing is,
I sent a message,
and this response was received.
Everything else is just sort of theory.
And it's about, you know, especially with that teacup,
did that carry a real signal through the noise?
And it did, and that's what's real there.
Right.
Awesome.
You know, David, where can folks find you,
speaking of writing, your Substack, and, you know,
I'll of course,
link to that lead magnet course
that's below your name there,
but to everything else you're building here?
Yeah, sure.
I mean, people can find me
on LinkedIn or on Substack.
Speaking of writing
Is what I go with
the name of the publication is there.
They can find me at
speakingofwriting.com,
but if they want to sign up,
and they can get a couple of free reports,
but I'm kind of excited about this five-day writing challenge
where I send out a series of emails.
They're kind of like little mini lessons
over the course of five days,
and they help people do what we've been talking about,
which is, how do you take writing
that maybe from AI or maybe is my first draft?
How do I take it from ordinary to extraordinary
or extraordinarily effective, right?
Right.
Because I think, you know,
there's a saying, right?
Great writing is great revising.
Yeah.
But how do you do that?
How do you look at it?
What things do you look for?
So the course is about that, and it's
speakingofwriting.com/5day
No hyphen, just 5day.
Perfect, and we'll link to those
in the show notes below,
but David, I'd say, you know,
for our listeners today,
stop treating those words like filler.
You know,
the words are shaping decisions, shaping trust,
and you know, shaping what people believe
might be true, possible, urgent,
safe, desirable, or worth doing next,
and, you know,
in the AI era, I think especially
producing more words isn't the win.
It's clearer thinking,
sharper judgment,
and maybe a human signal there too.
So, I would challenge our listeners:
if this hits,
send it to a founder, marketer, writer, executive,
or AI happy content machine who needs to remember
that sounding good is not the same
as saying something real.
And, you know, also,
if you're navigating a leadership transition,
there's a 20-minute foundational call with me
linked in the show notes below.
But David,
thank you for skipping that qualifier,
protecting the spark,
and also bringing the receipts on
why words are never just words.
Oh, you're very welcome.
It's been a pleasure exploring that with you.
Likewise.
Well, until next time,
stay grounded,
stay human,
and keep questioning the noise.
Okay, bye bye.