Dr. MCB’s Curiosities

Episode 2 of 7 in What makes a high-performance culture? Today's question: Is it safe to speak up?

Show Notes

Episode 2 of 7 in What makes a high-performance culture? Today's question: Is it safe to speak up?
Four people at one club go quiet, and only one of them was ever told to. Through Marta, a composite story about an assistant coach who is shut down once in one staff meeting, Dr. MCB works out how a single sentence can switch off the truth in an entire building, and what it takes to switch it back on. She takes three questions in turn. What switched off: psychological safety, a belief the whole team shares that admitting a mistake, asking a question or disagreeing won't be punished, which isn't comfort, trust or belonging and doesn't remove the consequences of what someone discloses. Why going quiet was the smart move: the status gap, rivals for a place, a public audience, a price that isn't the same for everyone, and the fact that everyone watches what happens to the person who speaks first; and because people go quiet out of fear, resignation or loyalty, those are three different silences with three different fixes. And what switches it back on: finding out whether anyone has tested the room lately (the Sentence Test), separating a decision from the way it's delivered (performance safety), a route for bad news that gets an answer within a day or two, and repairing in public. Two research stories carry the argument: Amy Edmondson's early hospital study, where the best nursing teams turned out to report the most medication errors, and the neonatal intensive care study she did with Ingrid Nembhard, which showed what a leader's invitation does to a status gap. Is it safe to speak up? Dr. MCB's answer is that in too many elite sport environments it isn't yet, because honesty still costs too much; the way to assess your own is to look at what happens when someone speaks. Most of the evidence comes from outside sport, and the tools are practitioner tools, not validated tests.
This series draws on The Psychology of High-Performance Sports Organizations: Culture, Safety, and Leadership by Dr. Marie Claire Bourque and Madeline Antony (Routledge). Find the book.
Read this question on my website: https://www.dr-mcb.com/curiosities/series/the-culture-playbook/is-it-safe-to-speak-up-in-professional-sport
Sources mentioned
Research papers
  • Edmondson, A. C. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. DOI
  • Nembhard, I. M., & Edmondson, A. C. (2006). Making it safe: The effects of leader inclusiveness and professional status on psychological safety and improvement efforts in health care teams. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 27(7), 941–966. DOI
  • Detert, J. R., & Burris, E. R. (2007). Leadership behavior and employee voice: Is the door really open? Academy of Management Journal, 50(4), 869–884. DOI
  • Van Dyne, L., Ang, S., & Botero, I. C. (2003). Conceptualizing employee silence and employee voice as multidimensional constructs. Journal of Management Studies, 40(6), 1359–1392. DOI
  • Rice, S. M., Walton, C. C., Pilkington, V., Gwyther, K., Olive, L. S., Lloyd, M., Kountouris, A., Butterworth, M., Clements, M., & Purcell, R. (2022). Psychological safety in elite sport settings: A psychometric study of the Sport Psychological Safety Inventory. BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Medicine, 8(2), e001251. DOI
  • Taylor, J., Gretton, T. W., & Sweeney, L. (2026). Performance safety: Conceptualising psychological safety when errors have consequences. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 38(1), 1–15. DOI
  • Morrison, E. W. (2011). Employee voice behavior: Integration and directions for future research. The Academy of Management Annals, 5(1), 373–412. DOI
  • Frazier, M. L., Fainshmidt, S., Klinger, R. L., Pezeshkan, A., & Vracheva, V. (2017). Psychological safety: A meta-analytic review and extension. Personnel Psychology, 70(1), 113–165. DOI
  • Fransen, K., McEwan, D., & Sarkar, M. (2020). The impact of identity leadership on team functioning and well-being in team sport: Is psychological safety the missing link? Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 51, Article 101763. DOI
  • Hurst, P., Kavussanu, M., & Stirling, A. (2026). Elite athletes report lower psychological safety and are less likely to report interpersonal violence compared to recreational athletes: A cross-sectional study. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 38(3), 297–312 (published online 2025). DOI
  • Vella, S. A., Mayland, E., Schweickle, M. J., Sutcliffe, J. T., McEwan, D., & Swann, C. (2024). Psychological safety in sport: A systematic review and concept analysis. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 17(1), 516–539. DOI
Books and reports
  • Edmondson, A. C. (2018). The fearless organization: Creating psychological safety in the workplace for learning, innovation, and growth. John Wiley & Sons. Publisher
  • Bandura, A. (1977). Social learning theory. Prentice Hall.
About the host
Dr. Marie Claire Bourque
Dr. MCB’s Curiosities is produced by PIPACO Tech. Dr. MCB is a Clinical Instructor at the University of British Columbia and a Clinical Assistant Professor at the University of Calgary's Cumming School of Medicine. The views expressed are her own and are not endorsed by either university. This podcast is general education, not medical advice, and does not create a doctor–patient relationship.

What is Dr. MCB’s Curiosities?

What are you curious about?

I'm Dr. Marie Claire Bourque, Dr. MCB. I'm a psychiatrist, and I ask a lot of questions. My favourite ones are the ones I don't know the answers to.

That's where Dr. MCB’s Curiosities starts. We take a question about neuroscience, human behaviour, clinical medicine, or something else entirely, and build a podcast episode or series to explore the answer.

I read the research and look at different explanations. What do we know? How do we know it? And what haven't we figured out yet?

You get to follow that search with me, without having to work through all the papers yourself. We'll make sense of the science in plain language, including where the evidence is uncertain or the answer is still taking shape.

You might leave with a clearer answer, a different understanding of something you thought you knew, or another question worth asking.

And if you've got a question I can't answer, send it my way. That's the engine.

Dr. MCB’s Curiosities is produced by PIPACO Tech. Dr. MCB is a Clinical Instructor at the University of British Columbia and a Clinical Assistant Professor at the University of Calgary's Cumming School of Medicine. The views expressed are her own and are not endorsed by either university. This podcast is general education, not medical advice, and does not create a doctor–patient relationship.

Four people at one club went quiet, and only one of them was ever told to.

None of them is real, and neither is anyone else in this story. They're composites, built from patterns I've seen many times, with the details changed. But that kind of silence is real, and today I want to work out how one sentence in one meeting can switch off the truth in a whole building, and what it takes to switch it back on.

The one who was told was Marta. She'd been an assistant coach at the club for three seasons, and she had a reputation in the staff room: when the game plan had a hole in it, she was the one who said so. The head coach, Marcus, didn't always enjoy that, but it was how that staff worked.

Then the team lost four in a row. Marcus decided to drop a veteran midfielder, and he didn't tell him. He posted the squad list, and the player found out the way everybody else did. At the next staff meeting, Marta said what she'd normally say: "People deserve to hear it from you before they read it on a list." And Marcus said: "Selection is mine. If you'd rather run your own team, go and find one."

Nobody shouted, and the meeting moved on. Marta stopped raising anything about how people got treated, but she wasn't the only one who heard that sentence. Within a few weeks, the video analyst stopped pointing out when the player-load numbers, the figures on how hard each player was being worked, didn't fit who Marcus was rotating. The goalkeeping coach had a worry about the backup keeper's confidence, and he kept it to himself. A month later, the starting goalkeeper played through a shoulder problem and kept quiet about it, because by then nobody was bringing anything forward.

The analyst and the goalkeeping coach didn't need telling. They had watched what happened to Marta, and each of them drew a conclusion about what saying the hard thing was worth in that building. At the end of the season, the medical review wrote two words next to the goalkeeper's shoulder: delayed disclosure. Nobody drew the line back to a squad list.

This series is about elite sport, and we're answering one big question: what makes a high-performance culture? Each episode takes one smaller question on the way there. This is episode two of seven, and today's question is the one every other answer depends on: is it safe to speak up?

Welcome to Dr. MCB’s Curiosities. I ask a lot of questions, and my favourite ones are the ones I don't know the answers to. So, let's find the answers!

Last episode, I gave names to two things. The silence calculus is the arithmetic people do before they speak: what it costs to say it, weighed against the odds that anything changes. And the speed of truth is how long bad news takes to travel from whoever knows it to whoever needs it. I promised we'd go deeper on silence, so today we watch that arithmetic run through one staff room.

I think of today's question as the foundation. It's the second layer of what I call the High-Performance Culture Operating System, and everything above it, what's broken, how we decide, whether we listen, runs on information. If people can't tell the truth, you're steering on bad data, and nothing tells you so.

So here's what I want to do today. By the end of this episode, I want you to be able to answer three questions about Marta's building, and then about your own. What actually switched off in that staff room? Why was going quiet the smart move in that building? And what would it have taken to switch it back on?

So, first: what switched off in that staff room? The phrase for it is psychological safety, and it has been worn smooth: people hear it and think "nice", or "soft", or "a workshop with a flip chart", so let's be precise.

Here's the definition I work from. It comes from Amy Edmondson, who teaches at Harvard Business School and has spent three decades studying how teams learn, and for her, psychological safety is a belief, shared across a team, that it's okay here to take a risk with other people. That's not a physical risk, it's a risk with people: admitting the mistake was yours, asking the question that reveals you didn't understand the set piece, telling the coach the press isn't working, flagging the hamstring.

Three words in there do the work. Shared means it belongs to the group, not to one brave person. If one defender challenges the defensive setup and the rest of the back line sits there because they've learned not to, you don't have safety, you have one brave defender. Risk with people means it's about what happens between people when you're honest, not whether the standards are high. And belief means people don't check the policy; they check their memory of last time. After that meeting, everybody who had been in that room had the same memory of last time.

And of course the standards matter! Safety isn't permission to skip the hard tackle or lower the bar for selection, and it doesn't remove the consequences of playing badly on Saturday. It means honesty itself isn't punished, even when what you disclose changes a decision about Saturday.

Amy Edmondson draws this as a simple picture. Along the bottom you put how high the standards are, up the side how safe it is to be honest, and that gives you four boxes. Low standards and low safety is the box where nobody cares and nobody talks. High safety with low standards is where everyone gets along and nobody gets pushed; this is the "soft" team competitive coaches fear, and wrongly assume psychological safety will give them. High standards with low safety is the box I think most elite sport lives in; let's call it the anxiety box. The standards are visible, sprint times on the wall, reviews with teeth, but honesty costs so much that everyone protects themselves, not the team. And high standards with high safety is the box you want: selection is still competitive, but speaking up is cheap enough that problems surface while they're still fixable, on Tuesday in the film room instead of in Saturday's post-mortem.

Now notice what's the same in the anxiety box and the box you want: players get dropped in both, and contracts run out in both. The difference isn't whether there are consequences, it's whether being honest is one of them.

One more thing, because it's the commonest mistake here: safety, trust and belonging are not the same, and if you mix them up, you fix the wrong one. Trust is between two people: has this person proven reliable to me? Belonging is inside one person: do I feel part of this? And safety is a rule of the group: what does this room do to people who speak? "We're a tight squad" mistakes closeness for safety, and the closest teams can be the most brutal to anyone who breaks ranks. "I trust Coach" is one relationship, and it says nothing about whether the third-choice keeper can report a sore shoulder. Fix a safety problem with a team-building weekend and you've made some friendships stronger and left the rule of the room where it was.

So that's the first answer. The way I read it, what switched off in Marta's staff room wasn't the friendships or the standards. It was a shared belief about how that room treats whoever speaks, and everyone learned the new rule from one sentence.

High standards and high safety sounds easy, right? So why is it so hard?

Every coach says the door is open, but silence in elite sport isn't a character problem, it's the smart move. The building produces it, even when nobody meant it to.

Think about who's being challenged: the person you'd have to disagree with usually controls your minutes, your contract, your next job. The best study I know on that gap comes from a hospital, not a stadium. Ingrid Nembhard, who studies how health care teams learn and improve, worked with Edmondson on a 2006 study of neonatal intensive care units, the wards where the sickest newborns are cared for. On those wards a doctor outranks a nurse the way a head coach outranks a rookie. Every unit was trying to improve its care, and the researchers wanted to know who would actually join in. So they asked the doctors, nurses and therapists on each unit how safe they felt speaking up, and how far the unit's leaders went out of their way to invite people in and thank them for what they said. The status gap showed up exactly as you'd expect: the doctors felt safest, and the people further down the ladder felt least safe. But that gap shrank on the units where the leader actively invited the lower-status people in, and the invitation did the most for the people with the least power. Those were also the units where people threw themselves into the improvement work.

That's a tendency, not a law, but sport's status gaps are wide, and the lesson travels: the rookie doesn't need a door that's open, the rookie needs to be asked, by name, and thanked for answering. Marcus did the opposite of inviting. When Marta pushed back, she was told that if she'd rather run her own team, she could go and find one, and everyone else in that staff meeting heard it.

Then add the rest of what raises the price. The people beside you are rivals for your place, there's a full stadium with cameras on every decision, and nobody's job is secure, coaches and staff included; "hired to get fired" is the saying. When losing face costs that much, silence is the logical choice.

And the price isn't the same for everyone. In a leadership group that's all one race, the same concern can be heard as "difficult" or "an attitude problem" depending on who raises it. Gender, sexuality, a visa and a mental health problem can each add to what speaking costs, and they stack. So when you're assessing this kind of pressure, watch how the same concern is treated when a ten-year veteran raises it, versus when a first-season player on a visa raises it: who gets cut off, and whose worry turns into action. If the same people keep paying the price for candor, that isn't safety, that's a participation gap.

Now here's how one sentence spreads. Albert Bandura, the Stanford psychologist whose social learning theory came out in the 1970s, showed that people learn consequences by watching them land on someone else: you don't have to be punished, you just have to see it. And two management researchers who study why employees speak up to their bosses asked, in a 2007 study, whether the open door is really open. They found that people speak up to a boss they see as open to it, and hold back from one they don't, because that's how they judge whether it's safe. Put those together and you get Marta's building.

Marcus never told the analyst to stop, and he didn't have to, because the analyst was in the room. One defensive reaction from the top can reset the silence calculus for everybody below it.

But they didn't all go quiet for the same reason, and the reason decides the fix. Last episode I named three kinds of silence by where the information gets stuck: fear, the people who were never in the room, and the back channels. Today I want to stay with the people who are in the room and could speak, and sort their silence by motive, because even there it isn't one thing. Linn Van Dyne and colleagues, organizational behaviour researchers, set out three silences sorted by motive in a 2003 paper, and Marta's staff room had all three.

Marta's silence was the fear kind: she spoke, she got hurt, and now she was protecting herself. The analyst's was different, because he never got burned. He watched Marta get burned and concluded that flagging the numbers was pointless, so his silence was resignation: he'd given up. And the goalkeeping coach was silent out of loyalty, protecting a working relationship and keeping the peace. That kind is everywhere in sport, because sport raises people to protect the group.

Three silences means three different fixes. Fear needs the consequences changed: what actually happens to the person who speaks. Resignation needs proof, so you show that speaking changes something, visibly and quickly. And loyalty needs the loyalty redefined, because staying quiet about a problem isn't protecting the team, it's leaving the team to find out the hard way. Run a "speak up" campaign on a room whose silence is resignation, and you've reassured people who were never afraid.

So that's the second answer. Going quiet was the smart move for Marta, the analyst and the goalkeeping coach, each for their own reason, and none of them was a coward. They had read the room correctly. Which leaves the third question: what would it have taken to switch the truth back on? It starts with finding out whether it's off.

Here's the trap: unsafe rooms often sound great, loud, funny, everybody finishing each other's sentences. I call that false cohesion, a room that sounds sure of itself, where nobody says what they think. The tell is what comes out loud and what doesn't: agreement, enthusiasm and toughness arrive at full volume, while uncertainty, disagreement and "I need help" arrive as silence.

Here's the form I meet it in most often. Ask a team to rate their chemistry and they'll give you a ten out of ten. Then I ask: when did somebody junior last tell somebody senior they'd got something wrong, and it went fine? And the room goes quiet, not because nobody can think of an example, but because everybody knows the honest answer is embarrassing. So I've stopped asking whether a room feels safe, and I ask instead who has tested it lately, and what happened to them.

That question is the heart of a tool I call the Sentence Test, and if you take one tool home from today, take this one. Take the five most powerful people in your building, and for each one, look back thirty days: did anyone with less power disagree with them in public, bring them bad news, or admit they were confused? If you can't find a single instance, or you can and it went badly, safety hasn't been tested, and a team that calls itself close hasn't earned the word yet. Run it on Marcus, and you find one instance, and you know how it went. I'll say plainly what this is: a practitioner's tool, built out of the research, not a validated test. It won't give you a score, but it tells you where to look.

Then you look, rather than ask. In meetings, watch for whether it's always the same few voices, or whether the bench players and the junior staff speak too, and after an error, notice whether people move toward the person who made it, or away. There are proper surveys too, including one built for elite sport, but in an unsafe building people don't believe anonymous means anonymous, so look first, and survey second.

So think about your own building for a moment. Who was the last person to test it, and what happened to them?

Now, the objection, and it usually comes in these words: "This is coddling, and elite sport needs thick skin." Here's my answer: comfort means "don't push me", but safety means I can tell you what's true without being humiliated or punished for saying it. A fear-based culture doesn't get rid of injuries, doubt or mistakes, it gets rid of the reporting.

Edmondson found that out by accident, and it's the story of how this whole field began. As a doctoral student, she went into hospitals to study medication errors on nursing teams, with a simple hypothesis: the better-run teams would make fewer mistakes. She measured how well each team worked together, collected the error reports, and the result came back upside down. The teams that scored highest as teams reported the most errors. For a while she assumed she'd got something wrong, and then she sent a research assistant to spend time on each unit, without saying which units had the high numbers, and the assistant came back describing two different worlds. On the strong units, nurses talked openly about mistakes, and the nurse managers treated an error as something to learn from. On the others, nurses described a place where a slip was held against you, so the smart move was not to write it down.

The better teams weren't making more mistakes; they were admitting them. That reversal is the finding this whole episode rests on.

It's the same in sport. The athletes still get hurt; they just stop saying so, and the coach picks the team on incomplete information. As a doctor, I read "delayed disclosure" as a symptom, and Marta's club wrote down the symptom without ever asking what produced it. The problem was never hard coaching, it's what happens to the person who carries the bad news.

So how do you switch the truth back on without pretending consequences don't exist? Selection, contracts, careers: no coach can promise that mistakes won't count, and no coach should. The resolution is what's sometimes called performance safety, which means you separate the decision from the way it's delivered. Three researchers writing in a sport psychology journal in 2026 formalized that idea for settings where errors carry real consequences, which is exactly what elite sport is. You can take a player out of the team, but you don't get to humiliate him on the way out. Think back to Marcus and that midfielder: in two different buildings, the decision is identical, he's dropped, and what differs is whether he learns it from a list, or from a conversation where someone gives him the reason. And the rest of the squad is watching how it was done, and updating their own arithmetic. If that's how a veteran gets treated, what happens to me if I report a sore groin in a contract year? Think of the last person who was dropped in your building: did they find out from a list, or from a conversation?

The same split runs through injuries. An injury gets hidden, because disclosing it risks your place, or reported early, because the medical pathway doesn't run through the selection meeting. A rugby forward doesn't need comfort; he needs to know that a head knock he reports goes to the doctors, and the doctors decide when he plays again, not the coaches.

So what do you do on a Tuesday morning? That's the standard I hold every idea to: if it doesn't change something on an ordinary weekday, it's decoration.

Start small and visible: at your next staff meeting, or in the post-match review, ask for one worry about the game plan. Ask the quiet end of the room first, the bench players and the junior staff, before the veterans speak. Thank whoever speaks first, and then change one thing, visibly, because of it. Everyone else is watching what that first person gets for it, and that's the whole mechanism.

Then build a route for bad news, because "my door is always open" is not a system. A 2011 review of the research on why people speak up at work found three things that predict whether they actually do it: will anything change, will I be punished, and is there an obvious route? You need a route for concerns that doesn't run through the person who picks the team, with someone outside the coaching line to receive them, a welfare officer, say. You need a reply within a day or two: here's what we did, or here's why we didn't. And you need to be clear from day one about what stays private and what, by law or safeguarding policy, has to go further. Nothing coming back after someone speaks teaches everyone else to stay quiet.

And when it breaks, because it will, repair in public and repair fast. Imagine Marcus, the next week, standing in front of the same staff and saying: "Marta told me something true last week, and I shut her down. That's mine to fix. So what else have you been holding back?" That correction does more than any invitation, because it proves the room can survive the coach being wrong.

The room isn't watching the mistake. It's watching what you do next.

So let's go back to Marta's building and answer all three questions. What switched off was a shared belief that the truth wouldn't be punished. Going quiet was the smart move for Marta, the analyst and the goalkeeping coach, out of fear, resignation and loyalty, because one sentence from the top showed everybody in that room what speaking cost. And switching it back on takes proof, in public: a decision delivered without the humiliation, a route for bad news that gets an answer, and a coach who repairs it out loud when he gets it wrong.

Where does the research stop? Most of the evidence is from outside sport. In 2017 a team of management researchers pooled a hundred and seventeen studies and found a moderate-to-strong link between psychological safety and sharing information, learning, and getting the job done. But that pooled link doesn't tell us how safety works in an elite dressing room, where your body is the work, the judging is public, and deselection is a constant threat. Sport research is catching up. A team of sport psychology researchers surveyed handball players in 2020 and linked safety to team resilience and to how satisfied players were with the team's performance. A study in 2025 compared elite athletes with recreational ones, and found that the elite athletes feel less safe and say they'd be less likely to come forward if someone was violent toward them. But there's a caution, too: a 2024 review of the sport studies found that the field hasn't agreed what "safety" even means in sport. So the evidence points a direction; it isn't yet a detailed map. And the tools I've given you, the Sentence Test, sorting silence by motive, separating the decision from its delivery, are practitioner tools built from that research: a lens, not a score.

Madeline Antony and I wrote the full framework up in a book, The Psychology of High-Performance Sports Organizations: Culture, Safety, and Leadership. The link is in the episode notes.

So, is it safe to speak up? Here's the answer: my judgement is that in too many elite sport environments, it isn't yet, because honesty still costs too much. You find out about your own by looking at what happens when someone speaks, rather than assuming an open door means it's safe.

Safety is the shared belief that admitting a mistake, asking a question or disagreeing won't be punished, and it's made or broken by what everyone watches happen to the person who speaks first. You don't survey your way to it: you test it, you separate the decision from the humiliation, you build a real route for bad news and answer it fast, and when you break it, you repair it in public.

So here's what that adds to our big question: a high-performance culture is one where the truth travels fast, because everyone, not just the people with the most influence, can raise a problem, admit a mistake or disagree, and what they say gets a real response rather than a cost.

Next time, question three: what makes a sport culture toxic? It starts with a new head coach, Tomás, standing in front of his whole staff in his first week and asking them what isn't working, and a room that just sits there.

That's Dr. MCB’s Curiosities. I hope you learned something. I sure did. Can't wait to ask more questions with you. See you next time! Dr. MCB’s Curiosities is produced by PIPACO Tech. I'm a Clinical Instructor at the University of British Columbia and a Clinical Assistant Professor at the University of Calgary's Cumming School of Medicine. The views here are my own and aren't endorsed by either university, and this podcast is general education, not medical advice.