Your Commercial Real Estate Insider guide. From profiles of the biggest dealmakers to skyline-shaping transactions, we bring you the deals, breakdowns and war stories that move the market — for insiders, by insiders. From bad-boy guarantees to CMBS tranche warfare to syndicator sins, we cover it all.
Each week, The Promote Podcast explores three of the most interesting and consequential stories in CRE, taking you well beyond the headlines and into the heart of the action. Hosted by the award-winning “Bard of CRE,” Hiten Samtani, along with no-BS institutional insider Will Krasne. Now a top 80 pod on Apple in "Business & Investing." Also check out our 3x/week newsletter for industry insiders at https://www.thepromote.com/
Will Krasne (00:09)
As well.
What are you talking about?
Ten, we spent sixteen months negotiating this JV. We've traded paper more than half a dozen times since January. We turned down our other LP so we could do this with you.
Hiten Samtani (00:33)
I hear you, but those terms no longer work. Here are the new terms. And by the way, I'm wheels up. Once I'm in international airspace, we get disconnected and this deal's dead. It means more to you than it does to us, so let me know what you decide. oh
Welcome back to the Promote Podcast, your insider guide to the money and mania of the CRE markets. I'm Hiten Samtani Tani.
Will Krasne (01:06)
And I'm Will Krasne.
Hiten Samtani (01:08)
You're Will Krasne and with your first live show under your belt, it was really good to get everyone together in a room and we're gonna do it again and again and it's gonna get bigger and bigger, but felt really good to start with that.
Will Krasne (01:19)
It was a great start. Thank you again to RFR Realty for hosting us. And thank you to, of course, your missus for organizing the vast majority of this.
Hiten Samtani (01:31)
I stayed out of her way and she did a wonderful job. And since we're still on the high from the live show, I thought we should just keep it going. We're bringing you another special episode today. As we promised, we're gonna try and do this every 10 episodes or so. So join us as we go into the belly of one of the most significant beasts in the modern history of CRE. A firm that's no longer around but has left a permanent imprint on the business as we know it. We're talking Whitehall, the famed Goldman Sachs unit that minted so many marquee projects and executives.
15 Central Park West, Hudson Yards, Canary Wharf, the Helmsley Building, hundreds of hotels, the highlight reel is endless.
Will Krasne (02:08)
The names have changed, the people are still the same, the diaspora is everywhere. But really, the model, which is massive fund size, complexity, global reach, it's not dissimilar from what another big private equity firm in Midtown Manhattan does with their real estate group. This model has carried on and really set the stage for a lot of what mega fund real estate private equity looks like today.
Hiten Samtani (02:37)
Before we begin, we want to acknowledge our sponsors who indulge and support all of our wild rides, including this one into international airspace.
Will Krasne (02:46)
Loan Boss, your mission control center for your CRE debt, now supercharged by AI.
Hiten Samtani (02:51)
Bravo Capital, a leading Hodden Bridge lender.
Will Krasne (02:54)
And Harvard AMDP, the leadership program for mid to senior CRE execs. Okay, to White Hall.
So from the early 90s, basically through the GFC, there wasn't a more well-respected franchise in real estate. Honestly, the name just sounds fancy. It sounds like Carrie Russell staying there in the latest season of The Diplomat. Oof, they had everything. Private equity firm, lender, servicer, and investment bank under one roof. And then of course the roof caved in.
Hiten Samtani (03:35)
There's so much to chew on here, I am excited. So let's dive into Whitehall right after this. JP Conklin, welcome back to the promote. There's almost a running gag on the show now where Will can recite the Lone Boss tagline from memory, but the product itself has changed quite dramatically in the last year or so. You've started to incorporate AI in some pretty surprising ways.
JP Conklin (03:59)
I am an AI fanboy and have been from day one. We have just successfully launched all of our AI capabilities. No longer will a vendor and a customer have a discussion around here are the features that you want us to build, let's talk about how we're going to build them. Instead, it is just simply we are structured data with real estate expertise and the rules and governance to go around that. And then you just plug in your imagination and you can make your data do whatever you want.
We were able to ask Lone Boss AI various questions about covenant testing or stress scenarios, create a map of all of my deals, and I wanted bubbles to look a certain way. And then we would pivot to can we do a mortgage statement reconciliation? And it could do all that stuff because we've got this good old-fashioned software company that is being paired with really powerful AI. And then it's just, what do you guys want to do with your data? And they're off to the races.
Hiten Samtani (04:54)
JP Conklin from Pensford and Loan Boss, thank you so much for being with the promote.
Every great real estate experiment begins as a glimmer in one man's eye.
Will Krasne (05:10)
Well it depends 'cause there's another guy who thinks it's two men's eyes.
Hiten Samtani (05:13)
It's true, but I I think it's widely acknowledged that it's this guy.
Will Krasne (05:17)
Dan Neidich
Hiten Samtani (05:19)
Dan Neidich So Neidich joins Goldman Sachs in nineteen seventy-eight and rises to the top of the real estate department.
Will Krasne (05:26)
1990, it's the teeth of the SNL crisis. One of the real foraging grounds that laid the track for the real estate luminaries that we know today.
Hiten Samtani (05:34)
Guys like Barry Sternlicht, Sam Zell. he's dead.
Will Krasne (05:37)
Mm.
Hiten Samtani (05:39)
It's true. Cross him off then.
Will Krasne (05:45)
Goldman sort of had a lot of trading DNA, but they didn't really have a balance sheet or like real estate trading business. And so he saw this opportunity. He forms uh the real estate principal investment area, Arabia, and Whitehall Fund One was launched in the early 90s with a very quaint 146 million dollars.
Hiten Samtani (06:07)
The mandate was pretty simple, right? Acquire loans from the Resolution Trust Corporation.
Will Krasne (06:12)
Exactly. So same exact plan that Starwood launched with money from the Ziff Brothers, et cetera. From those relatively humble origins begat a colossus like the vampire squid.
Hiten Samtani (06:26)
Really was. And Nidic became a Titan in his own right. He had some amazing nicknames here. Equity God, pretty good one.
Will Krasne (06:33)
Goldman Sachs Rottweiler or
Hiten Samtani (06:36)
Whitehall was the be-all end-all of real estate investing. They pioneered so many of the strategies we're gonna talk about. Goldman doesn't have that same luster in this space anymore.
Will Krasne (06:46)
It's not dissimilar to what happened with hedge funds. They're really not known as much for direct, like principal investing as much anymore. It was really an interesting model. And it was like typically Goldman, where they put in a lot of their own money.
Hiten Samtani (06:56)
So it was balance sheet money and partners money. And then they committed what up to twenty five percent of the fund?
Will Krasne (07:02)
Yeah,
and then by the end they're piling in. I think they're about a third of the equity in uh the last couple of fun view.
Hiten Samtani (07:09)
Even the ones that didn't do so well, I'd imagine.
Will Krasne (07:11)
yeah, correct. In typical Goldman fashion, they're not just out there buying single asset, single deal. They are looking really how can we create value and sort of arbitrage every single step of the value chain coming out of, you know, the RTC where so much of the value was buying loans and then taking over asset management or servicing. They ended up buying this company called Archon Group, which no one's ever heard of.
Goldman buys that, and that's really important because it's deal flow, servicing fees, and really creates like an enduring franchise. It's not dissimilar from Star Wars buying L and R. They bought all of that, I think, by 2000. And just to give you a sense of scale, in 2011, Arjun had 1,500 employees. Yeah. All of that staff supports the Repea investment professionals. And so now Goldman is the investor, the GP, LP, servicer, and in some cases the lender. Talking to me.
Well I'm the only one here.
Hiten Samtani (08:09)
And in nineteen ninety six, this is a coup, this is exactly where you wanna be. You want a piece of every little bit of the action. But by two thousand and nine, that same multi front exposure becomes probably their Achilles heel.
Will Krasne (08:23)
It's a make or miss the league, as I say all the time. And when you miss, people start to care about, you know, what color socks you're wearing on the court. It did become part of the undoing of Whitehall.
Hiten Samtani (08:34)
I wanna make one note about just their fundraising prowess. This is where they really leaned hard into their Goldman pedigree, right? It Whitehall to do the deals, but when you wanted to go raise money for it, it was always like, Hey, these are the smartest people in the room. So Goldman Sachs private wealth division would actually assist or in many cases lead the fundraising. They'd raise very, very quick as a result of this. Like in a matter of months, they would put their funds together.
Will Krasne (08:56)
This is something now that everyone is trying to do. The private wealth channel is the single hottest for commercial real estate fundraising right now.
Hiten Samtani (09:07)
Yeah, especially since the Trump administration kinda relaxed the rules of four one Ks, which we have spent a lot of time discussing and breaking down.
Will Krasne (09:14)
Alright, so that is the rough structure, but when we come back, it's time to get into the good stuff. Let's talk about the deals, and it is a murderer's row.
Hiten Samtani (09:22)
It really is.
Aaron Crowitz from Bravo Capital, welcome back to the promo. What do you
speaker-3 (09:30)
Hi Hiten, good to be here.
Hiten Samtani (09:32)
think about SNFs as a category? Broadly, 101.
speaker-3 (09:35)
They're more similar to hotels than they are to multifamily. Both for an owner and for a lender, what should be top of mind is you're in a life safety category. If a hotel changes hands in a bankruptcy and all the lights go off and people might not get room service on time, that might be slightly unfortunate. In skilled nursing, you're entrusted with the lives of the elderly who are reliant on specialized equipment.
If there's any bump in the road, you really have to make sure these people are prioritized and that it's more than an asset.
Hiten Samtani (10:13)
Stress in a capital stack can actually translate quite directly into distress in a person's life. And that's a pretty big responsibility as both an operator and I'd imagine as a lender.
speaker-3 (10:23)
A hundred percent. That's why reputational risk is so important in general, but especially in the healthcare space where you want to be aligned with people who have been trusted fiduciaries for decades.
Hiten Samtani (10:37)
Aaron Crowitz from Bravo Capital, thanks for being with the promote.
This deal, which is one of the most incredible deals that they did, really uh brings to bear the entire Goldman apparatus. So Goldman Sachs in nineteen eighty-five had underwritten the IPO of Rockefeller Center properties, which was the REIT that held the debt on Rock Center.
Will Krasne (11:05)
It's so funny looking back on this. You could launch a REIT with one mortgage. Just incredible.
Hiten Samtani (11:11)
And it was the largest IPO of its kind at the time in the REIT World.
Will Krasne (11:15)
Truly a coup for Goldman. It went up from there. Something we will see repeatedly is foreign capital coming into New York and the late 80s were one of the high points of this. Uh Mitsubishi estate paid 1.4 billion for 80% of it in 1989.
Hiten Samtani (11:35)
We talked about limit up kamikazis when it came to the Chinese. The Japanese were the OGs here. They came in really hot and everything imploded. By nineteen ninety-five, the center was bankrupt.
Will Krasne (11:46)
Yes. Goldman they have the fun vehicles at this point, but more importantly they have the Goldman Patna. They put together a consortium to buy the center out of the read. This group has quite a few names in it.
Hiten Samtani (12:00)
Yes, one of the names that popped out to me was Rockefeller himself.
Will Krasne (12:04)
It always helps to get the guy whose name's on the building to be in your consortium. They then, of course, I think do what is really, I think, one of their trademarks, which is buy something wholesale and then sell everything off retail. This is the play that Blackstones used.
Hiten Samtani (12:20)
To great effect.
Will Krasne (12:21)
They buy the center, they sell NBC a condo interest in Thirty Rock for four hundred and forty million, and then sell the rest of the center itself to Tishman for one point eight five billion.
Hiten Samtani (12:33)
Two point two five billion. They probably paid a fraction of the initial purchase price to take control of the asset.
Will Krasne (12:40)
There's a great Fortune article from nineteen ninety five about this. They basically said that Goldman's position in the REIT was sort of a backdoor to control everything for about two hundred and twenty five million bucks. I love it. One thing too is that this is actually I think the episode that sort of makes Bill Ackman
Hiten Samtani (12:55)
Bill Ackman,
the guy who goes on rants on Twitter, that guy?
Will Krasne (12:58)
The dating consultant?
Summer, I started reading books because I knew my baseball career was sort of no, ending. It was like Money Masters or something, one of the John Train books, maybe. And it talks about Bill Ackman on this, where he meets with someone and the materials come out on Friday, and on Monday, the guy's like, No one could have done as much research in two days as Bill Ackman did. He knew all the leases, all of the cam reconciliations, and basically tried to buy it. He was a nobody. It might have been Lucadia or somebody else, but
They made a bunch of money on the stock as it got bought out. I think they gave him five hundred thousand dollars and like first class plane tickets to Paris.
You see this over and over again now. This is how all of the big megaphones work, where you're buying one public company, which is really complicated and they have the ability to do that. And then two, like selling things off for parts to de-risk. It was hard to raise capital this period, but it was even harder to raise capital for busted public stories. So they had the investment banking shops, they knew the process and they knew all the dark arts and were able to get it done. Most importantly, they got David Rockefeller on board. He's even quoted in this saying.
The fact that the new owners are good friends makes a big difference. No shit.
Hiten Samtani (14:14)
And then they kept going, right? Cadillac Fairview came next.
Will Krasne (14:19)
The Reichmann callback. So around the same time they were doing Rock Center, they did a restructuring because this had gone bankrupt. Huge Canadian landlord owned T D Center, Eaton Center, I don't even know what those are.
Hiten Samtani (14:32)
Center's like the classic downtown mall in in Toronto. Come on, eh?
Will Krasne (14:36)
This is the one where Nightitch, I think, really makes some waves and some of the nicknames are downstream of this. Because there was a a restructuring plan. Whitehall and then Blackstone and Ontario teachers, they injected 800 odd million into Catalog Fairview to take over it. And apparently Nightitch pushed a plan through that so angered Calpers, and who is an unsecured creditor, that Calpers temporarily stopped doing business with Goldman.
Hiten Samtani (15:02)
With Goldman the parent.
Will Krasne (15:04)
With Goldman the parent, yeah.
Hiten Samtani (15:05)
They're used to dealing with a certain type of institutional real estate investor and then these Goldman guys come in with all the Goldman swagger and aggression and they're probably tearing the place apart.
Will Krasne (15:16)
for sure. I was talking about this with someone the other day. Sophisticated people are often easier to deal with because you can sort of predict what they're gonna do. They'll do what makes sense, right? Uh-huh. The problem is that sometimes that sophisticated person, if you misjudge their level of aggression and you show just like your belly a little bit, it's just shiv immediately. I drink
Hiten Samtani (15:37)
Your milk
Will Krasne (15:40)
This is what Goldman would have done. How many times did they, you know, ripp people's faces off in the commodities market or in currencies or with better information?
Hiten Samtani (15:48)
That's
the DNA, that's what you do. Whatever you need to do to gain an edge, you do.
Will Krasne (15:52)
And we are not saying that pejoratively, that is I say it complimentary.
Hiten Samtani (15:56)
They kept going. Trillium Corporation, Westminster Healthcare Across the Pond, Berkshire Realty, Strategic Hotel Capital.
Will Krasne (16:04)
And to give you guys a sense to of how this was working, just the narrative around this was really, really powerful. So fund one was nineteen ninety one, hundred and forty six million as we said. Goldman was seventeen percent of it. Fund two, a year later, eight hundred and five million. And Goldman was twenty-five percent of it. They did fund three, two years later.
Hiten Samtani (16:23)
cross the billion dollar threshold with that one.
Will Krasne (16:26)
And onward and up from there over I think uh Nightish's term, it was twelve billion of equity capital raised, fifty billion of assets bought. That is some leverage, by the way. We used to really be a country, didn't we?
Hiten Samtani (16:40)
And zooming in a little bit, they bankrolled some of the deals of the time, right? The introduction here was a callback to a very famous incident that happened with the Zeckendorfs. And so I was playing the character of Ralph Rosenberg, who was Dan Knightrich's.
But let's talk about that. Even in a business full of great stories, this might be up there.
Will Krasne (17:04)
Five fifteen Park Avenue might have been the first sort of major projects for Arthur and Will Zeckendorf. Yep. It came about because Whitehall had bought the loan from Mitsubishi for some crazy basis. Right. And the brothers had this whole plan. It's laid out tremendously well in New Kings of New York, where they go through and talk about like, here's the floor plans. This is why grand apartments are gonna come back around and demand it.
Hiten Samtani (17:31)
very,
very significant project, not only because it was their first development project that they did solo, it was also the prototype for what is widely considered the most successful condo project of all time in fifteen Central Park West. But the five fifteen Park Avenue deal almost died in midair.
Will Krasne (17:57)
Ralph Rosenberg was flying I want to say to Paris, calls them, you know, from the phone. In my head, it's just the one like in the back of the
Hiten Samtani (18:06)
You poured a little snitcher of brandy and then you get it.
Will Krasne (18:08)
And you swipe your credit card. He calls them This as well. And basically tells the brothers, Hey, new deal terms, take it or leave it. I'm about to hit international airspace and lose reception. And if I do, it's going to the dead deal pile.
Hiten Samtani (18:21)
He just said straight up to them, he's like, it means more to you than it does to us.
Will Krasne (18:27)
He was correct.
Hiten Samtani (18:28)
Fishes.
Will Krasne (18:31)
But it does lead to 15 Central Park West. We all know the details. May 2004, the Zekendorfs, Whitehall, plus uh yeah, ALO for pockets
Hiten Samtani (18:39)
Yeah. One of our quintessential men with Deep.
Will Krasne (18:43)
and energy pockets. They made four hundred one million dollars, which was an astronomical sum at the time. They got a nine hundred million dollar construction loan, and the result was a two billion dollar sellout in a year and a half. That is how you do it.
Hiten Samtani (18:57)
They also went back and this is one of the glorious things about doing some of these episodes, um, Canary Wharf.
The deal that brought down the Reichmans, they actually came in on the 2003 recaps. What a cast of characters here. The Khataris, my guy Shimi Glick, the Diamond Mogul, Prince Al Walid bin Talal of Saudi Arabia, and Morgan Stanley and Whitehall. All of them came in in 2003 at Canary Wharf.
Will Krasne (19:27)
So this was a glorious run. Whitehall is on top of the world in terms of the biggest deals, the sexiest deals, the brand. The juice. But even as they continued up the ante, the team started to get restless and more on that right after this.
If you're a mid to senior CRE striver, we have news for you. School's back in session in the best possible way.
Hiten Samtani (19:54)
Registration for Harvard's AMDP, their advanced management development program in real estate, is now open with the class kicking off in July 2027.
Will Krasne (20:03)
As a GP running his own shop, I get it. I spend all day in my own deal flow, my own markets, my own cap stack. It's hard to see around the corner when the corner is the only thing that I ever look at.
Hiten Samtani (20:13)
And AMDP is a few weeks of being inspired to look elsewhere. Faculty-led cases pulled from every asset class, and a cohort of operators who are seeing cycles that you aren't, different geographies, different product types, different capital.
Will Krasne (20:25)
You merge with a map of the whole board, not just your own square. Plus, let's be real, it's Harvard. The network compounds faster than default interest.
Hiten Samtani (20:34)
See if Harvard AMDP is for you at their website. We'll drop it in the show notes. And tell our friends there that the promotes enter.
Equity God.
Will Krasne (20:48)
Equity God gets restless.
Hiten Samtani (20:50)
He leaves in two thousand three to go and found a company called Dune with Steve Minuchin of all people.
Will Krasne (20:57)
Totals for Nightish as he leaves to form Dune, 12 billion of equity raised, bought fifty billion, absolutely crushed it. Dune. They still have a series of real estate funds.
Hiten Samtani (21:05)
Special sits distress stuff. You'll see them pop up in cap stacks here and there.
Will Krasne (21:09)
What was the bank that Steve Newkin bought post GFC? One West. Yeah, One West, yeah. So Dune is still around, does big deals, very successful, but a lot of guys left. Pat Riley calls it the disease of mole
Hiten Samtani (21:20)
This is another real PayPal mafia of the business.
Will Krasne (21:23)
Ralph Rosenberg. Ralph left in two thousand six. He was at Eden Hall, uh, which is Eric Mendish's, one of the largest hedge fund launchers of all time at that point. Uh went on to become head of real estate at KKR. Ed Siskin, who founded Cale Street.
Hiten Samtani (21:36)
Which is becoming a bigger and bigger player to watch. The promote had them in our Quiet Kings of Capital series. Yeah. They're one of the main lenders on uh the Zekendorf Project, A.D. Clarkson.
Will Krasne (21:47)
Mm-hmm. Richard Georgie uh worked for Soros. Brahm Kramer, who was the co-head of Alliance Bernstein Real Estate, Marty Berger, who ran Silverstein, now out on his own. Those are a lot of senior, serious dudes. As those guys are leaving though, and the cycle is heating up, Whitehall goes so hard. Like right at the absolute top. Between May 2007 and August 2008, they invest 3.7 billion dollars.
Hiten Samtani (22:17)
That's absolutely incredible. And Whitehall's head at the time, who was on his way out, he goes to the Rebni Gala, and this is known as the Liar's Ball. Been there many times. You're at the dais, and everyone just keeps talking. No one actually shuts up. This guy, his name Stuart Rothenberg, and he said the following. He said, The firm was, for all intents and purposes, almost an enlarged hedge fund for the past couple of years. Where the more investing that we could do on balance sheet and the less we could do in the funds, the more we did.
Will Krasne (22:51)
These are like real blasts from the past. Tharaldson Hotels, March 2006. So this is 130 hotels. Gary Theraldson, who's the richest guy in North Dakota. I like works on trying to buy these things from Whitehall when I was a server, I think. Uh-huh. Bought 130 hotels for 1.2 billion dollars. They bought, I can't pronounce this, car stack.
Hiten Samtani (23:08)
Karstad Quell High Street J V.
Will Krasne (23:11)
German department store bought the store and the real estate for 4.5 billion euro. Equity Inns, another big hotel portfolio, uh 2.2 billion, including debt, 137 hotels, third largest hotel rate. Helmsley Building 2007. Uh Whitehall backed Monday properties to buy it for 1.15 billion. Icons Nevada Casinos, they bought for 1.3 billion for the Stratosphere, two Arizona Charlies and the Aquarius.
Hiten Samtani (23:38)
They went pretty hard and they as as we said, they invested three point seven billion dollars, out of which two point one billion dollars was written down.
Will Krasne (23:47)
Equity ins, 262 million of equity. And by the way, they paid, what are the paper equity ins? They paid 2.2 billion and they put in 262 million of cash, just phenomenal. That 262 million of equity was marked to six million um according to the Wall Street Journal. And in two thousand nine, the fund had to call another billion dollars from LPs to fund a plan to recover equity. And
To their credit, they did. They scratched and clawed. People ended up getting back like 75 cents on a dollar, which is pretty
Hiten Samtani (24:18)
Yeah.
Will Krasne (24:19)
good. So we talk a lot about real estate. You play with live ammo. And I really want to drill down on this point. There's that famous Sequoia fund we've mentioned on the pod where they scraped post tech bubble bursting to like make a one, like no fees, no nothing. If you haven't lost money in real estate, you're leaving return on the table because you aren't taking enough risk.
This was obviously way too much risk, but this is like the true character of the man, the entity, the culture of Goldman Sachs, because they fought their ass off to get that money back for people.
Hiten Samtani (24:52)
What I'm trying to say is like returning 75 cents on the dollar in this environment was a fucking miracle.
Will Krasne (24:58)
That's as good a return as anything they did in the beginning on a relative basis.
Hiten Samtani (25:03)
didn't really say anything about their fee structures based on some reporting in Perry. Whitehall was considered to have pretty steep fees for the time. They would, you know, again, bring up the Goldman Sachs name, so they could pad the fees quite generously to give you that assurance that you were investing with the the best and the brightest.
Will Krasne (25:20)
While these funds are getting written down, you know, the fees which came out, the journal had an article, eighty-eight million in financing fees, thirty million in advisory fees, nineteen million in property management fees, plus a zero point five percent management fee, which okay, fair enough, not too bad on gross cost of seventeen point two billion of assets.
Hiten Samtani (25:42)
Quite wonderful. We've talked about how they were leveraging the mothership for fundraising. Now in the triage mode, they're again tapping into the mothership, right? So Whitehall on the Nevada recap, they borrowed what, a billion one, from Goldman's mortgage unit. And in the recap, the Goldman Mortgage forgave close to six hundred million dollars of that.
Will Krasne (26:01)
They took a write down, got rid of the guarantee, and then took a big equity stake. So it's debt for equity swap. Going back to, you know, Knightch doing a deal so tough that Calpers stopped doing business with Goldman. I don't know if it was that level of bare knuckle brawling. On equity ends, same sort of thing happened. Goldman Sachs mortgage had given a loan to Whitehall. They forgave more than half a billion dollars of debt.
In exchange for getting an option to buy 80% of the hotels. In the dark of night in 2012, they sold that option back to Whitehall for $175 million. No
Hiten Samtani (26:37)
No third party involved whatsoever.
Will Krasne (26:39)
third party involved. All the equity and prep holders did not get to participate in this. Their dividends were suspended under the new debt covenants as part of that exchange. And they sued. However, it was disclosed.
The two thousand six P PM for the deal warned that there was quote no assurance that Goldman Sachs will be able to resolve conflicts favorably.
Hiten Samtani (27:01)
That's legalese for
Will Krasne (27:03)
What are you gonna do? It's in the docs. And again, RTFD. Read the fucking docs.
Hiten Samtani (27:09)
This did bring up broader questions about how we could get to this place. Partners group Snori Lietz spoke to this. She said, The investment banking model is broken in real estate private equity. You don't say.
Will Krasne (27:23)
Everything ends badly. Otherwise it wouldn't end.
Hiten Samtani (27:27)
From January 2010 onward, Whitehall restructured about eighteen billion dollars of debt.
Will Krasne (27:32)
After a decade of workouts, the 2007 fund returned about 75 cents on the dollar, like not zero. That is heroic. I can't stress that enough.
We talk about cowboys and suits. The banks had cowboys and suits clothing. Dodd Frank changed all that. So we talked about how they were putting up a quarter or even a third of these funds, both in terms of Goldman balance sheet and then Goldman Partners Capital itself. That no moss.
Hiten Samtani (28:03)
You could almost argue that if if that hadn't happened, we wouldn't have the debt fund system that we have today, right? The whole shadow banking system and everything that we see that defines our CRE capital markets today wouldn't really exist in that form.
Will Krasne (28:17)
You're exactly right. Like it really restricts the ability of a firm to invest their own balance sheet capital. because it it's now like low single digits that you can put in rather than thirty three percent. Going back to Stuart Rothenberg's line where the more we could put in balance sheet capital and less fund capital we do it, that's that's not allowed under the current regime. Goldman has really pivoted. They don't really do equity in the same way as more. They've got credit funds.
Hiten Samtani (28:42)
One of the things you do when you want to leave the past behind is you often re-christian and you come back with a new name. They came back with the name Broad Street. Fund one was raised in 2008 and it was Broad Street Real Estate Credit.
Will Krasne (28:55)
And that series continues to go on.
Hiten Samtani (28:57)
And there was a comeback of of sorts a little while ago, twenty twenty two.
Will Krasne (29:03)
The name Ugh just Whitehall's such a good name. Broad Street's like not as not nearly as good. But this is even worse. This is real estate investment partners. It was branded as Goldman's fourteenth fund and the first real estate private equity close in fourteen years. But this one was really sort of more down the middle. Core plus value add.
Hiten Samtani (29:22)
No romance in this one, huh?
Will Krasne (29:24)
It's very sad. We talk about seventy five cents on the dollar on that last big fund, but the ones before it in this in the real salad days, pre tech bubble bursting weren't really anything to write home about as well. Net IRRs and the high single digits, which is sort of meh.
Hiten Samtani (29:41)
So wait, all those swashbuckling deals for what, eight percent, six percent?
Will Krasne (29:45)
Think of it this way, like look at the branding of someone like Andreessen Horowitz. Whenever the data comes out, you'll see the information or whomever put out one of their fundraising decks and you look at the DPI and you're like, you would have been better off kind of just going into the Nasdaq. But it doesn't matter because there's just this like feeling that you're in a safe pair of hands that is ensconced in mink gloves.
Hiten Samtani (30:07)
Whitehall really had that aura in those 15 or so years from inception to the GFC. The smartest guys in the room doing the biggest, most creative deals, and then figuring out how to expand their tentacles into everything from asset management to credit to being the LP. It was exciting. And you want to be part of something exciting.
Will Krasne (30:27)
Yes, they were taking a lot of fees, but at the same time, syndicators are in deals with no money after the AC fee. These guys were a third of the capital. You like to say that the at breakfast the chicken is involved, but the pig is committed. And these guys were really committed. So for all of the issues around returns or big deals that went sideways, it was their money. It's a lot harder to criticize people when it's their money because they believed in it. There is romance in that, right? Because this is
the suitiest place that ever suited. And there still is just a little bit of romance and cowboys in there.
These guys put a ton of partner capital in and it really hurt a lot of the employees. They ran a white call buyback offer for employees in two thousand nine, basically saying, Well, buy back your stake because, you know, not only did our stock price get halved, but
Hiten Samtani (31:24)
You're getting shellaced on these too. Yeah.
Will Krasne (31:27)
Slacked
here too and that's that's not a great look and peel are really hurting. So they they bought it back from Ern Boys. That's a moral ethical thing to do.
Hiten Samtani (31:35)
Where we want to end is what the the the L-word, right? The legacy of this firm. Not only did it bankroll really so much of the modern skyline in New York City and other major markets in the country, how many hotels and condo projects would not exist were it not for Whitehall? Not only is there that element, but what seeped into the water because of Whitehall is another big reason we're doing this episode.
Will Krasne (32:00)
Right, the style is basically megapund private equity before such a thing existed. This was the playbook that all of these firms are using, public company transactions, going global, credit, debt, lending to yourself, which a lot of these firms now do, like with their infinite money machines.
Hiten Samtani (32:20)
Dan Knightich walked so that Todd Boley could run.
Will Krasne (32:23)
There
you go. It's important to note, like, the Goldman Special Sits group is considered sort of this incredible cradle of investment talent, you know, with Dan Ock.
Hiten Samtani (32:34)
Goldfinger McKittrick.
Will Krasne (32:36)
Yeah, McKittrick, Bob Rubin, um, all of these like incredible investors. This was sort of that for real estate, except it blew up. It's sort of like how uh Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger talk about they're like, there was this third guy, his name is Rick Guerin, and they're like, he was just as smart as us, he was just as good as us, but he took on leverage. And in the early 70s, he had to sell back all of his Berkshire stock to Buffett because he got margin called.
And Rick Guerin, you can look it up, he made a lot of money, he did very well. But he wasn't Warren Buffett or Charlie Munger. Whitehall is sort of the Rick Guerin to the special sits groups, Charlie Munger and Warren Buffett.
Hiten Samtani (33:17)
I absolutely love that. So instead of being on the front page, they're a footnote in history, but a very, very important footnote.
Will Krasne (33:24)
It's one of the ultimate if you know you knows.
Hiten Samtani (33:52)
That's it for the promote podcast this week. Thank you so much again to our sponsors for indulging us on this wild ride. Bravo Capital, a leading HUD and Bridge lender.
Will Krasne (34:01)
Lone Boss, your mission control center for your CRE debt now supercharged with AI.
Hiten Samtani (34:05)
Harvard AMDP, the leadership program for mid to senior CRE professionals. If you are a Whitehall alum or you've done a deal with Whitehall or you have some fond memories that you'd like to share with us, confidentially, of course, please hit us up at podcasthepromote.com. I'm sure there's so many war stories that we just never have heard of, and we'd love to hear them from you.
Will Krasne (34:25)
And I live literally almost in between two hundred west and eighty five Broad. So, you know, happy to meet anyone, either place.
Hiten Samtani (34:35)
As always, if you're interested in advertising with us, we're at partnerships at thepromote.com. This audience keeps getting richer and better and bigger.
Will Krasne (34:43)
And you know, based on the live event we just did handsomer.
Hiten Samtani (34:49)
True. It was wonderful to see you in person. I really enjoyed it and I will see you next week.
Will Krasne (34:56)
See you later.
Hiten Samtani (34:58)
Thank you. Thank you. Ciao.