Minnesota Law Now is a new podcast from the University of Minnesota Law School that brings together some of today’s most insightful legal scholars in conversation about law, policy, current events, and the ideas that shape our world.
[music]
Welcome to Minnesota Law Now,
the podcast from the University
of Minnesota Law School.
I'm William McGeveran,
Dean and William S. Pattee
Professor of Law.
What does it mean to document harm,
establish the truth,
and pursue accountability
when human rights are at stake?
Those questions can arise
in very different places
and under very
different circumstances,
from a federal government
operation here in Minnesota
to an international conflict
thousands of miles away.
In both settings,
establishing what happened,
listening to people
who experienced harm,
and creating a credible public record
can be essential steps
toward accountability.
Today, I'm joined by my truly
extraordinary colleague,
Professor Fionnuala Ní Aoláin,
a leading international
human rights scholar.
She has spent decades
working at the intersection
of human rights, international law,
and accountability.
Fionnuala Ní Aoláin
is a university Regents Professor,
the Robina Chair in Law,
Public Policy and Society,
and the Faculty Director
of the Human Rights Center here
at the law school.
She is concurrently
a professor of law
at the Queen's University
of Belfast, School of Law.
In just the last two
years, she has added
to her very long list of accolades,
starting with being awarded
a prestigious international
Fulbright scholar.
In Ireland, she was appointed
to the Council of State
by President Catherine Connolly.
In the UK, she was elected
as a Fellow of the British Academy,
and also as a Visiting Fellow
at All Souls College, Oxford,
which is Nirvana for intellectuals.
For the upcoming
Trinity term of Spring 2027,
she'll be spending time there.
At the United Nations,
she was named a Commissioner
to the UN's Independent
Commission of Inquiry
on the Syrian Arab Republic,
where she completed
a fact-finding mission
this past summer.
To top it off, here in Minnesota,
she was appointed
to the Governor's Council
to record the truth
of Operation Metro Surge
and Operation PARRIS on Minnesotans,
known as the Minnesota Truth Council.
The contexts in Damascus
and in Minneapolis could hardly
be more different,
but both involve fundamental
questions about human rights,
evidence, truth-seeking,
public institutions,
and what happens
after harm has occurred.
Today, we're going to explore
those connections
and the differences.
I want to welcome
you here today, Finn.
Thanks.
First, I want you to take
us back to the beginning.
What first kindled
your interest and, frankly,
passion for human rights law?
Well, I grew up in a Gaelic-speaking,
Irish-speaking family
in the west of Ireland.
Irish is my mother tongue,
so I didn't learn
English until I was a teenager.
I grew up in a language
minority household in Ireland.
My father was a language activist.
My family were really aware
of our minority status,
actually, because
at that point in Ireland,
you couldn't get
most basic services in Irish
as a native Irish speaker
on the island of Ireland.
I had a mom who was
from Northern Ireland,
so we grew up with
the conflict in Northern
Ireland as part of the tapestry
of our home life.
We had family members who lived
on both sides of the border.
We lost family
members in the conflict,
so the conflict was very present,
and the rights parts
of the conflict were present.
Maybe the third piece of it is I grew
up in an Ireland in the--
I was born in 1967.
This was an Ireland
where you couldn't get
a divorce, an abortion,
or contraception.
As a young woman growing
up in Ireland, I was really aware
of the limitations
of what it meant to live
in a pretty patriarchal,
but also a society where law
was essentially structured
to ensure that women would have
rights, wouldn't have rights.
I suppose all of those things
together were really formative.
I went to law school
in Belfast as a very young woman
at the height of the conflict,
so I arrived in Belfast
at a time when, yes,
the war was in full
steam, as it were.
Studying law and coming
from my family background, yes,
all of those things
were pivotal to who I am.
Absolutely.
When you began law school,
was it with an eye towards doing
the sort of work that you've
been doing for the last decades?
Yes. I feel like I'm
in a Groundhog Day.
I wake up and I'm
in 1987 all the time.
I had gone to law school.
I had been lucky enough to get
an Irish scholarship
to study in Canada.
I was going to law
school slightly later
than most of my peers,
but I went to Belfast
because Belfast was the place
where the conflict was,
which also had the faculty
that was doing the most obvious
and notable and globally
as well as nationally
recognized human rights work.
Yes, I did go to law school thinking
I would be a human rights lawyer.
Okay, and here you are today.
And here I am.
One of the themes
that runs through all your work
is the importance
of documenting what happens
when human rights are violated,
making sure that those harms
are seen, recorded, and preserved.
I want to talk
about that a little bit.
What does it mean
to document those harms,
and why does it matter so much?
Yes, so I think that impulse,
but also the practice of doing
that started in Belfast in 1987.
I was a young law student,
literally in my first couple
of weeks of law school,
when I joined and helped
form a small NGO in Belfast.
I always call
it my longest running job
because I've been on the board
of that NGO since 1987.
We went on to win
the Council of Europe Prize.
Actually, what we were doing
in those early days
was taking statements
from people who had
witnessed violence.
That was often bystanders,
but also family
members who'd lost
a family member to violence.
We were recording
where we could; much less capacity
to do that then than there is now.
We were observing courts.
We would go
to what were Diplock courts,
non-jury courts in Northern Ireland
that were trying people
accused of terrorism.
We were bearing
witness in different ways.
We were monitoring marches.
That's still relevant
in Northern Ireland as it happens.
We've had a very contentious
march this week.
These skills of,
first of all, documenting,
literally taking
down what happens accurately,
doing so in a way that's professional
and actually does justice
to the thing that has
happened to a person.
Learning the skills
of listening and recording.
Then using that information
as a way to initiate
or advance legal process.
That's at the heart
of what it means to document.
Now the skills have got better.
I got trained as a lawyer,
so I learnt a lot of things about
how you take a witness statement,
how you then can use
that kind of evidence
to go into court.
Then over the years as I've worked
in different kinds of settings.
For example, when I worked
at the ICC for a period,
working on cases involving
systematic human rights violations
as the Court was establishing itself,
we were doing things like doing
surveys of communities.
We were using forensic information.
We were able to go out
and gather open-source
and other kinds of data.
The scope of data
and information has augmented
over the years, but the core skill
that what you start with; you start
with recording accurately
and fully what has happened
to a person
or a community or a place,
and you do that in a way that tries
to use all your professional
skills of discernment.
You do that in a way that then
is the basis for what comes next,
but you can't do anything
until you have
that basic set of factual
information at hand.
Sure.
There's lots of different ways
of seeking information.
What does this formal
truth-seeking process accomplish
as compared to, say,
journalism or active litigation
or just individual testimony?
What's special about
that kind of truth-seeking?
I think there are two things.
I think there's truth-seeking,
which is actually a little
bit of what we're doing here
in Minnesota right now
with the Governor's Truth Council.
That's really establishing
a public record.
It's not journalism
because it's telling you something
big and deep, hopefully,
and wide about what's happening.
It's not necessarily with a view
to an immediate legal process.
It's about shaping narrative.
It's about telling
the history of something.
It's also about
validating the victim.
Truth-seeking often, at its heart,
is a victim-centered
process that seeks to inform
and let the victim understand
that what has happened
to them is heard and it's affirmed
by the process of telling
and the process of hearing.
Fact-finding is different.
On the Commission of Inquiry
that I sit on for
the Syrian Arab Republic,
we have a UN resolution
from the Human Rights Council.
It's a political act
to create a mechanism.
That resolution sets
the terms of what we can do.
For example, we can only investigate
alleged violations
of human rights
and humanitarian law that happen
on the territory
of the Syrian Arab Republic.
There's lots of things happening
in the neighborhood around Syria,
and I've been
in that neighborhood a lot,
but that's not what we investigate.
Then, of course,
we have a methodology, which is,
first of all, of course,
it's based on conducting
interviews with victims, witnesses,
or bystanders, but
it also involves a validation.
That kind of fact-finding
requires you
to actually not simply listen
to the victim, but if you're going
to make a finding,
that fact-finding--
we make findings.
We decide if a government
or a non-state group
or a designated terrorist
group has engaged
in a violation,
and we're calling out that act
to a particular
international law standard.
Then you're starting
with the information,
but actually what you're then doing
is, in fact, you have to verify.
You have to make sure that you have
at least two or three sources
that confirm what happened.
That it's not
a criminal law standard,
but it is essentially
a civil law standard,
a balance of probability,
a reasonableness standard,
that more likely than not,
this information
that has been forwarded
to you or that you've
investigated is correct,
and you're making
a legal finding on that.
It's a pretty laborious process.
In Syria, people sometimes wonder,
where there's an atrocity,
why we don't come out
and say the next day,
"Oh, so-and-so, this is a war crime."
It often takes us months
to make that determination.
Yes, there's a team
of highly skilled investigators,
forensic lawyers.
We have a military advisor.
We have a political advisor.
Of course, we have lawyers
and commissioners
who are advisors themselves.
That's a really
different kind of process
than, let's say,
the one that we're doing here
in the Twin Cities.
I want to dig
more into the comparisons,
both similarities and differences
between the Minnesota
experience you're having
and the Syria experience
you're having,
which are just two examples
of the kinds of things
you've done all around the world.
Let's turn to Minnesota.
What is the council
being asked to do,
and how are you going about
doing it here in the state?
Anyone who's been in the state
in the last year knows
what a really challenging year
the state of Minnesota,
Greater Minnesota,
and the Twin Cities, has had.
We had an unprecedented presence
of federal agents in the state.
They were charged
to engage in immigration actions
that resulted
in the detention of hundreds,
up to thousands of Minnesotans,
or persons here
on the territory of Minnesota.
Of course, they were associated
with pretty significant human
rights violations.
We had two deaths,
which are currently
the subject of investigation.
The council is not making
determinations
on those deaths, but we had hundreds
of people on our streets.
As Physicians
for Human Rights reported
in their report on the use
of non-lethal weapons
in the United States in the last
couple of months,
we had the use of the kinds
of weapons, actually,
I often see in war zones.
I don't expect to see them
on the streets of the city I live in.
Of course, we've had significant
and mass detention,
and that detention has raised
a whole set of concerns
about arbitrariness.
Was there a legal basis
for people to be detained?
Then once they were detained--
and of course, the Whipple Building
close to the airport that many people
in the state would know,
has been a source
of particular attention.
I've spent my life visiting
places of detention,
and of course,
as we'll talk about more,
some of the things we're learning
about what has happened
in places in detention in Minnesota
bring to mind places of detention
in other parts of the world.
It's not the kind
of discourse or reality
that we would want to be living
with in an advanced democracy
with a constitution
that has long sought to protect
the rights of persons
here in the United States.
The Governor responding, I think,
to the deep and profound
concerns about violations
of both state and constitutional law.
Also, what's interesting
about the executive
order that establishes us
is that it acknowledges human rights,
a global set of human
rights as the standard
that we should be attuned
to establish this council.
The council's goal is to set
a record of what happened.
We're not a fact-finding body.
We're not an investigatory mechanism.
We're not offering redress.
What we are doing is taking testimony
from those who were affected;
those who observed,
but also those who helped;
those who engaged in acts
of communal care, of resistance,
but also of lawyering.
There were lots and lots of lawyers
in our state responding
to the challenges
of the federal
government's operation here.
The council is super varied.
There are two law
professors on the council,
but there's also others.
There's a doctor.
There's the head
of the Minnesota Farmers Union.
There's a former police officer.
We are a varied bunch.
Remarkable.
It's great because I've gotten
to know a bunch of people
that we all work, I would say,
in different areas
where we have deep
concern for our community,
and we are deeply committed
to the state of Minnesota,
but we all do different
things slightly.
We've had several obligations.
We're supported by The Advocates
for Human Rights,
which is one of our premier
human rights organization.
It's an organization
that here at the law school,
we partner with all the time.
Our Robina Clinic has done
so for years.
We've had the New Americans
Clinic has done so for a year.
As has the Human Rights Center.
We've long partnered with this
organization in different ways,
but the Governor charged
the organization to be the one
that gathers the testimony.
A lot of the work
is gathering testimony.
The second part of the work
is we've had these public hearings,
four of them, three at the Capitol,
one in Rochester to go
to the greater Minnesotans
and hear what happened to them,
and we're going to write a report.
That report will be issued
on the 1st of December,
in just a couple of weeks' time.
Coming up soon.
One of the things
that strikes me about this work
is this is a public
institution trying
to create a record
of events that people
may have experienced
very differently.
How is the council
approaching ambiguity
or different viewpoints
of the same types
of events when you're trying
to synthesize
it into a report like that?
Yes.
One thing I will say,
and this is true of my experience
in multiple places
when I was Special Rapporteur
on counterterrorism and human rights,
and I was visiting so many countries
and investigating incidents,
it's a little bit
like when you see a car crash.
If you're a tort lawyer, you know
there's like five different
versions of what happened.
I think we understand; the thing
about truth is always complex.
I actually prefer the word
truths because generally,
there are often multiple
understandings of what happened.
The second thing
I would say is that actually
it's pretty hard to do this work
because this operation
is still ongoing in the state
of Minnesota as it is
across the country.
I think I'd say, Dean,
that many of the people
who have been the most affected
are the most frightened to give
testimony, right?
Of course.
Because their immigration
status may be uncertain.
They fear reprisal.
That's a hard thing
to say in a country where--
I've worried about reprisals
in countries like Egypt.
I've worried about reprisals
in really authoritarian
spaces when I've traveled
to the Russian Federation
or other places.
I would never have assumed
I would worry about reprisals
for people giving witness
in the United States.
I would say it's been a lot of work
to bring even those most affected
to talk about what happened to them.
We know from other
truth-telling processes
that actually, sometimes
people take a long time.
When something really
traumatic has happened to you,
it may be a year or years
before you can talk about it.
You're too busy feeding your family,
getting up in the morning,
trying to get back lost wages.
To the fundamental question
about how do we bring
a diversity of voices,
I think we've tried really hard.
Because what I would say
is it doesn't really help
the Truth Council
or the state of Minnesota
if all of the people
who already agree
that this was a not appropriate
use of governmental power,
that there might have been excessive
use of force,
that the detention regime
was in itself not lawful;
it doesn't really help us
if the people who already agree
that those things
are in that box agree.
The point is to build
a shared understanding.
Some of that is reflected
in the diversity
of folks on our council.
We have a former police chief.
We have a former judge.
We've got people who are used
to hearing different
versions of things,
but also who's given evidence to us.
I'm not going to say--
I think if you went
to post-war Germany
and if you'd ask Germans,
"Was there a consensus
on what happened?"
The answer is there probably
wasn't a consensus for several
decades about what happened.
I'm not comparing those two things,
but simply saying,
actually, it takes a long time
for people to agree.
We're just one little
part of that, I think.
Yes.
The process of forming
that shared narrative
can be, I think,
helped by the kind of work
that the council is doing.
Yes, I think that's right.
I want to talk a little bit
more about evidence.
You've mentioned
testimony a number of times,
but you've done
this kind of investigative
and truth-seeking
work around the world.
What makes evidence,
be it from witnesses
or other kinds of evidence
like documents or photos
or something; what makes
evidence persuasive
and credible when you're doing
a human rights
investigation of this kind?
Yes, it's a really good question.
It reminds me of the question
that sometimes my students
will ask me, Dean,
like, "How can I be
a human rights lawyer?"
My answer is, "You just have to be
a really good lawyer first."
That we start from the question
of how do we do human
rights well, is how
do we do law well?
How do we do evidence
well in domestic law?
If we were presenting evidence
at a courtyard
down at Hennepin County,
or if I'm presenting
at the International Criminal
Court or at the ICJ,
the answer is the same.
First of all, we have to be sure
that the evidence isn't tainted
by prejudice, by mistruths,
by inconsistencies.
The same kinds of things,
the same kinds of tests.
We have to make sure
it's not hearsay evidence.
"Oh, I'm saying something,
but it's not because I saw it.
It's because the guy
down the street told his neighbor,
who told me, and I'm telling you,"
but that's not what you saw.
The kind of rigor we apply
to standards of evidence:
can you verify that evidence?
Are there other sources,
whether it's open-source material,
whether it's witness evidence,
whether it's forensic evidence?
We have protesters who say
they were subject to battery.
Oh, but then we're going to go look
at the hospital or medical records
that tell us that somebody
was subject to that kind of harm.
The same kind of triangulation
we do in our parsing
of facts and evidence
for any criminal proceeding
or any legal proceeding, we do here.
Now I will say,
there are some differences.
I would say, here
are the differences.
Generally, when you deal
with, I would call,
regular law enforcement,
you have a set of assumptions
that people feel safe,
that they feel secure,
that they are not going
to be subject to reprisal
if they give information
to public authority.
When people don't feel those things,
then actually it's much harder to get
the evidence or to do
this triangulation work.
When I've worked in conflict zones,
and this is not true of Minnesota,
but it's certainly true in Syria;
if we want to go do a forensic
examination somewhere,
well, first of all, you might
be negotiating with the state,
but you might be negotiating
with other actors who control
territory, men with guns
who you have to convince
are going to let you in.
You may not have literal
access to territory.
If it's a mass grave,
then actually if the state
won't let you in,
and if you don't have
the medical and forensic
resources to open up
that grave appropriately,
then you don't have evidence,
even though you'll have people
who told you, my son,
my daughter, my father,
my brother is buried
in that mass grave.
I start with the premise; we use
the same standards
we teach in evidence
in this law school
to make good human rights law
and good human rights investigations.
They're not different.
They may be subject--
You're still making the distinction,
is this going to a criminal process?
Is it going to a civil process?
Is it just going
into a public record?
But even the public
record standard has to have
a degree of certainty
and triangulation for you to say-
ultimately, for this council
to say with a degree of certainty
and using our reputations to say,
"We believe this to be the truth
of what happened."
The complexities
in places of conflict are real,
and they're different.
It makes that exercise way harder
than it is in a functional
democracy with a rule of law.
I think what we here
and in the country
as a whole have to hold on to
is that actually,
we need people to be able to say
what happened because
we actually need to uphold
that premise that
we are a functional democracy,
that we have a rule of law,
that people can say
what happened to them without fear.
It does seem like some of the things
you're talking about,
the consciousness
of the diversity of viewpoints,
the rigor of examining the evidence
and having corroboration,
those are especially
important in a time of polarization.
A time when some groups in society
can't agree with other groups
about what facts
even are on the ground.
That's true.
I think the challenge we have,
I think it's a real challenge
in this society, is, again,
we're not a criminal body,
so we're not ascertaining.
We're putting things
into the public record based
on a process of making sure
that we are being deliberative
and thoughtful about
the evidence that's gathered
and how it's gathered,
and all of the evidence
gatherers are trained
by The Advocates for Human Rights.
Also, I would just say,
it's definitely my own experience
of taking evidence
from people who've suffered trauma.
People who are traumatized
often give evidence
that's challenging to understand.
They have refracted memory.
Sometimes the harm
that they've suffered is so profound
that they can't even speak about it.
Sometimes people have gaps
in their memory about what happened.
When someone's been
in arbitrary detention,
hasn't had a phone,
has been sleeping under bright lights
and white noise for days on end,
as many of the people
we know who've been
in the Whipple Building
have been subject
to that kind of regime of treatment,
then that makes it hard for people
to give the kind of classic,
what we teach in a law school class,
"Oh, here's a good testimony."
One of our challenges
as lawyers is how do we deal
with people who
are imperfect witnesses?
This is maybe one of the things
we know about any kind of lawyering,
but definitely human
rights lawyering,
is that people are often
imperfect witnesses.
For all the reasons
that the traumas, the harms,
the violations
they've suffered have meant
that their capacity
to perform linear speech,
linear memory recall, it's always
that can be super compromised.
You've referred to your work
in Syria a couple of times.
I know that the commission,
yourself included,
was there this past summer
on a mission.
The commission
has made some statements,
raised some serious concerns
about reported abuses.
Maybe you can say a little
bit more about that experience
for you, because
I know that you've done
that kind of work all around
the world, and yet what happened
in Syria presented
some special challenges, didn't it?
Yes.
I'm a newcomer to the Syrian
Commission of Inquiry.
It's a political appointment,
so you get appointed
by states as a commissioner.
I was appointed in December.
I've been to Syria before.
I was there during the war,
so I know the region really well.
I know Syria really well,
but I hadn't been back
since the fall of the regime.
I went in March and got
stranded by a war.
Instead of spending five days
in Damascus; spent almost
three weeks in Damascus.
We were there in July.
That was a much more normal visit
because we weren't hunkered
down avoiding missile fires,
so we were able to do a fair amount
of travel across the country.
That kind of mission has different
parts for a commissioner.
We will meet with ministers.
My counterpart would be
the Minister of Foreign Affairs.
Generally, we will meet
with the minister.
The commissioners
will meet with the minister,
and then meet with other ministries.
The Minister of Interior,
Minister of Justice
in particular is a really
important interlocutor for us.
This is a transitional government.
This government, of course,
in its prior iteration,
was a non-state armed
group and was fighting
a war against a highly
oppressive regime.
When I visited Syria during
the conflict, one of the things
that struck me is as soon
as you cross the border,
pictures of Assad
everywhere, everywhere.
It was a reminder that you lived
in a place where somebody
had control over your life
and could actually upend
your life arbitrarily at any point.
This set of meetings
are really about engaging,
what we call in UN parlance,
constructive engagement
with the government,
which is where you're telling
them some things they don't want
to hear, like,
"We're concerned about this.
We're concerned about
this massacre that happened.
We made these recommendations.
We're concerned about
this pattern of violence."
You have to build trust.
One of the reasons we go
a lot is if you just speak
in one voice, if you're
always complaining
or you're always telling
a government what they've done wrong,
then you're not really
always helping them.
Sometimes you have to tell
them what they're doing wrong,
but what you're really trying
to do is move
the needle on these things
as well as point out
what's happening.
You have to build
relationship or connection
to have some basis
for them to listen to, right?
Yes, exactly.
That's been a hallmark of the work
that I've done always,
which is that my view
when I was in my last role
in this UN role is I talk to anybody.
I talk to governments
that are blacklisted
by the United States.
We talk to people who are sanctioned
by the US and other governments
because my fundamental--
I learned this in Belfast in 1987,
is that if you didn't talk
to people outside
of the circle you were in,
you don't fix the problem.
You have to talk to the other,
and the other can be varied,
but that's a fundamental rule for me.
In Syria, we went to several places.
We went to Quneitra,
which is southern Syria.
Israel has extended its occupation.
There was an occupation
of the Golan Heights
and a demarcation line
that was established in 1974.
It was really complex.
When we do these kinds of trips,
we're traveling in armored cars.
Obviously, there
are very strict protocols
about even just getting
out of your armored car.
Your security team
gets out before you,
and the one rule
is you don't step out
of the car until it's cleared,
so you're safe.
A lot of these places-
you're doing work in places
that are complex to get to,
where you're taking some risk.
Don't tell my Dean I'm taking risks.
[laughter]
You always register
the foreign travel appropriately-
I do. [chuckles]
-with the university authorities.
I know you do.
[chuckles] I do.
I tell you where I'm going.
There we were talking
to people on the ground.
Farmers walking the fields
that have been pesticided,
looking at the trees
that have been felled.
Talking to families
whose children and young men
and older men have been
taken into custody.
That's an example there.
Then we went to a city called Homs.
Homs had one of the longest sieges
in modern history
recorded during the conflict.
I have pictures in my office
of just the scale of destruction,
not a building left standing.
People living in tents.
It's not just that the buildings--
the former regime,
with the assistance
of the Russian Federation,
barrel-bombed
many of these buildings,
so they're unusable.
Then there was a really
organized system
of pillage where actually
the state went
in and took everything out,
so there isn't a pipe.
There isn't wood.
There's no glass.
It's like a bone
after it's picked clean.
It speaks to the scale of harm.
How do you rebuild
a country like that?
Then we talked to communities.
We talked to the Alawite community,
and these are the folks--
President Assad was an Alawite.
This community now feels
a burden of stigma,
a burden of responsibility,
a burden of fear
because we had some massacres
of Alawites in the first year.
Right, you've seen
some vigilantism [?]
We have, yes.
It's pretty hard work.
I'm always glad when I come
home because part
of the thing is you go
and you do this work
and you're witnessing.
We are an investigative mechanism,
so we're traveling
with lawyers who are assessing.
Then our teams of investigators
are either there
or coming out or going in.
There's an intersection
between the political
and investigatory work
of the commissioners,
but also this team.
We have a team of 27 who support us.
Yes, it's pretty intensive
work, but I will say,
Syria is one of the places
where I feel right now,
the international community
is prepared to invest.
It's prepared to invest
in accountability.
We have a Commission
of Inquiry that can do its work.
There are lots of places in the world
that no one is investing in.
This seems like a good place
to be putting a little effort.
Still on Syria, you've spoken
in the media about
women and children,
several thousand of them
who are still in detention.
Your colleagues in the human
rights community have described
it as just an open-ended detention.
What are the special concerns
about that kind of situation
and that caused you to speak
out about it in particular?
Yes.
This issue of mass
arbitrary detention
in northeast Syria has been
a longstanding concern of mine,
but it's organically
connected to something else,
and something else is the detention
at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
Because I actually think
that that practice
of rendering people across borders,
and holding people
without trial indefinitely
in conditions that met
the standard for torture,
inhumane and degrading
treatment, actually set
the precedent for what we see
in northeast Syria today.
There are still 15 men
at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba,
and several of them
have never been charged.
They've been held for over 20 years.
What I hear when I go out is,
"Oh, but if a democracy
can hold people without trial,
then why should anybody
charge anyone with an offense?"
Here we have this large
group of women
and children who are deemed
to be associated with ISIL.
They were rounded up at the end
of the conflict, so around 2017.
They were taken into custody
by a non-state armed group
supported by the US,
the Syrian Democratic Forces.
This is a Kurdish militia,
which is now being
integrated into the Syrian army.
I visited those camps
in 2023 and saw firsthand--
I can't even describe it.
The scale of violence
against these people.
No one had ever been charged
with any crime
or had any legal process.
My fear is this place
in northeast Syria,
which our teams have been back to,
is the largest single place
of detention on security
grounds for women and children
anywhere in the world.
It's abhorrent and it's unnecessary,
and unless we fix it,
someone else is going to do
the same thing somewhere else.
Sure.
We've talked about the Minnesota
and the Syria examples,
and so many similarities
and differences have emerged,
but I wonder--
Let's talk about
the commonalities for a moment.
Can you kind of surface more some
of the common principles that apply
across those extremely
different contexts?
You've noted that there's
different situations
on the ground, there's
different legal infrastructure,
there's different mandate
of the entity
that you're working with,
but what's common to them?
The commonality is that people
who have had violations
of their dignity,
of their most basic rights:
the right to life,
the right to be free from torture,
the right not to be
arbitrarily detained,
the right to family life.
We all profoundly care
about our right to family.
When individuals and families
and communities
experience those violations,
they feel a deep
wrong is done to them.
That doesn't matter
whether it's Syria,
or Ukraine, or Minnesota.
That fundamentally human sense
that some wrong has been done
to me and I have the right
to be treated
with dignity is the same.
That's the thing for me that--
it's the thread that runs
through all of these places.
I've never gone to a place
where someone says,
"I don't want human rights.
I don't want human rights."
What's common about the mechanisms
then is that in each place,
the striving to do better.
That was our post-World
War II compact.
Not that the world is perfect,
not that we can prevent
human rights violations,
not that we live
in perfect democracies
or that we have perfect transitions,
but actually the striving
to do better.
Those take different
institutional forms.
In the best-case scenario,
as we should have here,
we have a functional
rule of law system.
We have functional criminal courts.
We have functional federal courts.
We have fair process for people
and people are equally
entitled to it.
In other places like Syria,
which is a transitional context,
that's what people want.
They want to get to that.
I think the work we do--
I'm a great believer in boomerangs.
You do a little bit of work
here; it reflects out there.
You do some work out
there; it reflects back here.
Last spring, the law school,
as you know, Dean,
we took a group
of Minnesotans to Geneva.
We took our students,
we took friends of the law school,
we took longtime advocates.
What we were doing,
as we've done at the Human
Rights Center for decades,
is to bring Minnesota to the world.
Mostly, we've been
bringing our expertise out
to fix other places.
We've been a world
leader in setting standards,
from the Minnesota Protocol
on Investigation of Unlawful Deaths,
to the work of my predecessor,
David Weissbrodt,
and so many issues
from torture to fair trial.
We've gone out and done that work.
We've taken all of the knowledge,
the legal skills,
the things our students
and our faculty
and our community knows about rights,
and we've taken them out,
but now we're taking ourselves out
because we need
help from other places.
What's really interesting
to me, even in Syria--
and because it's Arabic-speaking,
my Arabic is an improving language.
I understand some Arabic.
People will say to me,
"Oh, Minnesota. Oh, Minnesota."
It's because they've seen
the coverage of what happened here.
Not just, of course,
the harms, but they've seen
the extraordinary response
of this community to that harm,
and that's gone viral
in the best possible way.
Yes, and far, far away.
You've mentioned
a few times accountability.
I do want to talk about
that shift from truth
and establishing
it into accountability.
Once an investigation like this,
that you've been involved in,
establishes some kind
of factual record,
what does accountability require?
Can the acknowledgement
and transparency themselves
be a form of accountability,
or is more required?
How do you think about that?
Yes.
I think about it in several ways.
One is, I think, as we started,
I think that basic
establishment of facts
and shared understanding
of what happened
is what gets you to the next thing.
The reality is in most societies,
whether it's Minnesota last year,
or whether it's Syria
in the aftermath
of 50 years of repressive
rule and then almost
a 15-year civil war,
not everybody gets a remedy.
Not everybody will have
a criminal proceeding
for the loss of a loved
one for torture in custody.
That doesn't mean
we shouldn't have some of that.
I think the importance
of criminal accountability
for serious violations of domestic
or international law
remains absolutely prescient.
We had trials in Syria recently.
We had trials of some
of the most serious violators,
a case called Atef Najib and others,
and the others included
an in-absentia trial
for the former president
of Syria, Bashar al-Assad.
We're starting to see
this link being made
between the evidence
that commissions of inquiry
but also local actors
have gathered into criminal trial.
We also have seen
international proceedings.
One of the things
the Commission of Inquiry
does is we have
memoranda of agreement
with courts all across the world
who are able to prosecute people
under a doctrine called
Universal Jurisdiction.
If you commit
a certain kind of crime,
then you don't have to be tried
in your own country.
We have a version of that here,
the Alien Tort Statute, but--
It's much more robust
in international [crosstalk] --
It's much more robust
in other places.
Here in Minnesota,
I think this is one
of the points that Pete Cahill,
our chair of the Truth Council,
has made is that these other
processes continue,
criminal investigation,
civil proceedings,
some of which have been
issued in the deaths
of the two individuals,
Alex Pretti and Renee Good.
These things sit together.
I really, fundamentally,
don't believe--
It's not an either/or.
Is justice perfect?
Justice is never perfect.
We tell our students that.
The arc leans towards justice,
but not every person gets a remedy,
and sometimes not enough
people get a remedy.
What we're always leaning towards
is more justice for more people.
I think at the heart
of a public university,
a public law school,
is that fundamental
commitment to more justice
for more people.
Is that what gives you hope
when you do this work?
Yes, I'm always hopeful.
I don't--
I think you probably have to be,
to be able to do this work.
Yes.
I think there are several things
that enable me to do this work.
One, I work in a great law school
that's forced me to do this work.
I think that's essential.
I don't think you can do this work--
you can, but I think people burn out.
I've been lucky.
I haven't burned out.
The second thing that gives me--
actually, listening
to the Truth Council
is a really good example,
and I would encourage folks--
There's a YouTube channel.
You can listen
in on the Governor's website.
What you hear
are ordinary Minnesotans
affirming both what happened
to them, absolutely,
but affirming
their fundamental belief
in the goodness of other people
because they saw it firsthand.
They saw it when people
ran their kids to school,
picked up their groceries,
paid their rent,
offered comfort,
stood with them in solidarity.
These things are so powerful.
Legal remedies are powerful.
Solidarity is powerful.
These things go together.
Listening to people reaffirm--
Ordinary people, not lawyers.
Ordinary people say
they believe in law--
See, we sometimes get cynical.
We're like, "Oh, we know
the inside and outside
of every rule."
We're always very able
to tell students
how to think critically
about almost everything.
Actually, at the heart of it,
we're also really committed
to the enterprise of law.
I love the law.
I think the law
as an organizing principle
in society is what saves us.
It is at the backbone
of every open society.
That's where my hope is.
I think the tools
that I have as a lawyer enable me
to do things and to be a changemaker.
I think that's true of, we hope,
everyone who walks
in the door of this law school.
That in whatever they do--
You can be a human rights
lawyer in a corporate law firm.
You can be a human rights
lawyer being an in-house counsel.
You can be a human rights
lawyer doing several different jobs.
What matters is that
you define yourself
as someone who's animated
and motivated by rights.
Yes, we have lots
of people who think that way.
Yes, and who understand the structure
of law as something
that can contribute
to that sense
of justice for everyone.
Yes, exactly.
Fionnuala, I was delighted
to have this conversation with you.
It's taken us
from Minnesota to Syria.
I really just want
to thank you for the work
that you're doing
and for the opportunity
to share it with you here
this afternoon.
As Professor Ní
Aoláin has described,
documenting harm
is not simply about creating
some kind of historical record.
It can be a foundation
for understanding,
for acknowledgement, for reform,
and for accountability, and for hope.
My thanks to you for joining us
and for sharing your wide-ranging
and global expertise and experience.
Thank you for listening
to Minnesota Law Now.
I'm William McGeveran.
If you enjoyed today's conversation,
please be sure to subscribe
wherever you get your podcasts.
We'll see you next time.
[music]