From Paul Spencer of Second Nature Solutions, a conversation about the complexities and nuances of building resilient family enterprises, especially in the face of economic and political uncertainties that loom on the horizon. See more at secondnature.solutions.
Paul: Not to be naive and put your head
in the sand, but have some blinders
around the noise so that you can keep
moving forward, building your business,
thinking about how you build resiliency
within yourself and within your family,
but also within the processes and systems
that you're creating within your business.
Welcome to Resilience Talk hosted by
Paul Spencer of Second Nature Solutions.
Let's dive in.
Paul: All right I hope you have
all done your civic duty and voted.
Results are in.
I'm sure you're all excited
one way or the other because
it's good or it's bad, right?
And that is exciting to
you one way or the other.
Um, so yeah, we go through the elections
every two years like clockwork.
We never miss them.
And we're gonna talk today
about the fiscal side.
So I think it's, uh, it's actually fun
that we're in the midterm cycle here,
uh, for this review because we've got
a lot of swirl in the air around who's
right and who's wrong, and affordability,
and war, and taxes, and gasoline,
and diesel, and tariffs, and economy.
And what else can you say?
I don't know.
Lots of stuff.
So anyway, it's all out there.
It's all part of the cycle,
if you wanna call it that.
And so we can look at what's been going
on s- over the last two years and how
does that compare to '23, where we
did our first, um, view of the fiscal
side of things, um, which was during
the Biden administration, right?
And so now we've got two years of
Trump, and like I said before, you
couldn't have two dia- diametricallyâ¦
Is that right?
Is that, is that a word?
Um, opposed views, right?
They have different views about
how to manage the government
and what's going on within it.
So let's look and see, uh, if those
differences in policies, 'cause
they've each had their, their run,
and they've made some changes.
Not a lot of changes.
Most of those changes are executive
orders, not actual legislature
orders or bills or acts.
Um, so they're all temporary, um,
and some of them are not significant,
um, from a financial perspective.
But, uh, let's take a look.
All right, so got some
visuals here for you.
Um, basically just taking the information,
um, out on the government side, and
I think what you've seen before was
I, I just pulled up the websites or
the pages, the reports, um, from the
government sites and showed you those.
So what I did is I took that information
and then just created a little
dashboard using my friend Claude.
Um, so it's a little easier to see.
It's, it's still a lot of
information But, um, I don't know.
Plus it's fun for me, I get
to, I get to mess with Claude.
And, uh, so anyway, we're gonna look
between '23, which again, fiscal
year for the US is, um, October 1st.
That's the beginning of
the next fiscal year.
So we go October 1st to
September 30th, right?
That's the cycle.
So, um, in '23 we looked at it, and we've
done every year, and so this year, '26.
But we're also gonna go back,
'cause we're starting to getâ¦
Again, we're- we wanna think of this as
is if we're running our business, right?
So we're taking our philosophy, the
Deming philosophy, and we understand
that, yes, there is psychology, right?
In the Deming philosophy.
There is, um, there is variation,
natural variation, right?
There is, uh, awareness
of the system, right?
There's theory of knowledge, meaning,
uh, how do we learn, how do we
predict, how do we create theories?
Those are theâ¦
That's SOPK, um, system
of profound knowledge.
So what I just kinda led with, which
is meant to be more funny and making,
um, uh, not making, but just, just
lightening up the atmosphere, the
political atmosphere, is the psychological
aspect of what Da- Deming talks about.
Um, we can't, we're not robots, even
though we have our processes and
our systems, our theories, right?
Biden has a theory.
The Democrats have a theory.
Trump has a theory.
Republicans have a theory.
Does that mean they're right?
No, not until it's proven
one way or the other.
Is it gonna be gray?
Yeah.
A lot of times it's going to be
gray, and it's not gonna be a hard,
uh, fast, solid yes or solid no.
It's gonna be gray.
But inside the gray is where we
learn, and that's where we take our
theory of knowledge, the theories.
We look at what we've learned, and
then we tweak and we adjust, right?
And then we have awareness of the system
about how all the parts relate to the
whole, and that's where we make our
judgments about where the theories are,
where the improvements are made, right?
So anyway, uh, the point of this
is to be able to now, uh, take the
theories and see if they're being
proven true by the measures, right?
A PDSA.
Ba-dum.
There it is.
PDSA.
Boom.
All right.
So starting in '23 to '26, um, you can see
right at the very top there, make this a
little bit bigger, um, maybe There we go.
All right, um, so you can
see that we had a $4.4
trillion receipts in '23.
And this year, um, for, uh, '26,
right, September 30th, it's the
end of the fiscal year, we had 5.4
trillion, right?
So we're up about a trillion.
Um, and then outlays, meaning the
spending side, uh, in '23, we were at $6.1
trillion spending, and this year,
three years later, we're at $7.4
trillion, right?
Another $1.3
trillion more than three years ago.
And you can see that if we get
our, um, economics degree from
eighth grade when we're balancing
checkbooks, it doesn't balance.
Doesn't balance.
So we're off by, you can see the deficit
over there, we're off by $300 billion.
And we'll get into where
that discrepancy is.
Um, but just at face value, if we
were to look at it, this is, again,
we'll go back to the Deming, where
if we're just looking at raw numbers
and spreadsheets, we can already
make a, a conclusion on this, right?
That the theory of this administration is
wrong, and it's, has a deficit, and it's
overspending and, right, all of that.
And we can get that, but we
gotta look at the trends as well.
So let's take a look at the trends.
And I think this is interesting here.
It's not on the sheet, but we are at 1.99
trillion.
That's where we clocked
in at, uh, September 30th.
That is a record.
That's a record.
So let's call it two.
$2 trillion for the year
as a deficit is a record.
Um, and, uh, this is, uh, a cool thing
where we say 27 cents of the dollar spent,
right, are not covered by our revenue.
There you go.
Three years earlier, uh,
it was 28 cents, right?
It's the same.
All right.
So receipts by source.
Um, so th- this is good to-- I think it's
good just to look at because it's so much.
Like, it's just so much.
So, um, so when we have our, our
individual taxes, income tax, right,
um, you can see we went from two to 2.8,
2.2
to 2.9-ish.
Um, payroll, corporate income tax is
actually down less, so more than half a
trillion, a quarter trillion, down by 38
billion on the corporate income taxes.
We can see that the tariffs are going up.
We're about almost to 200 billion.
Um, uh, excise taxes are up.
Um, excise taxes would be all the duties
and federal taxes like gasoline tax.
Um, I don't know if cigarette
taxes are a federal tax or not,
but those kinds of things, right?
They're all the, the taxes on products,
um, or services, um, that we, that
the federal government puts on.
Um, and then you have the state gift
tax, right, which has gone, um, down.
And so, um, I thought this was
interesting here because, so again,
from a theory perspective, um, the
Congress did actually pass a bill.
I'm sure they passed other bills.
I don't know, that would have actually
been a good question I could have
researched before jumping on here.
But, um, we know that they're
not doing a whole lot over there.
So they passed the big,
beautiful bill, right?
And, uh, what that meant was they
extended the, um, the 2017 tax
cuts, um- And they left, right?
They left the, the individual income tax
brackets the same, and then they made
some adjustments in the corporate tax.
And really the, uhâ¦
So I was digging into this.
I was curious on what this was, and
the reason is, is they made a provision
in the, in the tax bill, the new one,
that said that you, uh, that, that,
I don't know if it has a, a time
limit or if it's just a threshold of
amount of dollars, but you can write
off more of a capital expense, right?
Um, if you wanted to, um, buy new
machinery for your factory or, right,
all the, all the, uh, depreciative,
um, big, uh, dollar items that
you're gonna purchase, instead of
depreciating them over time, you
could collect that depreciation all
upfront in one, one time, right?
So that's why this is down most likely.
Um, another reason would
be that profits are down.
So I was also looking at a trend.
I didn't create a chart for this,
but corporate income tax goes up
and down, um, more significantly.
It has more variation than income tax, um,
because there are business cycles, right?
So you may have, um, you may
have a broader recession in the
economy, and that means, uh,
corporate profits are down, right?
So their income tax goes down.
Or you may have pockets where you have
maybe, uh, a lighter, um, side on, say,
new buildings, new construction, or, um,
maybe in a, in a, in the factory, uh, in
the manufacturing space might be lower,
and it's just that one segment or one
industry in the economy, and that could
affect it, the corporate inte- income tax.
Um, but it has lots of variation, whereas
income tax tends to have less variation.
But if you do have a big, broader
recession and lots of layoffs and
those kinds of things, then you'll
have a dip in, in income tax.
So anyway, the, the broad story of that is
at face value, we would say, well, um Uh,
the big beautiful bill reduced corporate
income tax, and that's a bad thing, right?
'Cause we should pay more
taxes or we need the money.
Um, but it's basically a wash because,
um, they're not gonna be able to
depreciate it over a long period
of time, so they end up payingâ¦
It, it ends up working out the same.
Um, the, the intention of it
is to encourage a lot of, um,
investment right up front, right?
Because that's part of
the, the Trump philosophy.
Part of his theory is that, uh, if
we can grow the economy, if we can
grow the manufacturing side, uh, then
we can grow out of the debt, right?
That's his philosophy.
So anyway, that one's interesting.
The other thing I, I looked at was,
um, and kind of noodling on with Claude
about if he didn't pass the big beautiful
bill and he didn't extend those 27
tax cuts and basically did nothing and
let them revert back to 20th- prior to
218, so 217 tax brackets and everything
else, those tax brackets would've gone
up, um, for every individual, right?
Um, those brackets would've been higher.
Um, and it said that you would probably
get between $300 and $400 billion more
Uh, say just as hypothetical in '26,
um, if you were to let those expire.
So I thought that was interesting.
Um, so that would put that,
um, that range instead of $600
billion, it'd be up to a trillion.
Um, but there's some
caveats to that, right?
Which is, um, at least recently we've
been talking about inflation and
affordability and can't buy anything,
and the housing is expensive, the food's
expensive, gas and diesel is expensive.
That's creating more inflation, right?
All those things are true.
Um, but if the government was gonna
bring in another $300 billion because
they raised your income taxes, right,
that's less money you would have
in your pocket, which would make
affordability, right, even harder.
So y- y- it's a give and take, right?
All right, so then down on the, the
outlays for the, for the year, right?
We're at $1.3
trillion, um, difference between
2023 and 2026 on the outlays.
So, um, in the end, I think what we
talked about last year, which you
would've heard if you listened to the,
the episode, we played it over again,
um, was that it was a wash, right?
The policies differences, the tax
policy differences, the economic
philosophies and differences, um,
from a deficit standpoint is the same.
We're getting the same results.
So the economy, if you wanna
say the economy, I don't-
I'm not even gonna say that.
The inlays, right, the receipts
are increasing for sure.
Um, but also the outlays are increasing.
So e- even if we're, even though
we're bringing in almost a trillion
more than three years ago, um,
we're actually spending $1.3
trillion more than we
were, um, three years ago.
And, uh, the big part of that is net
interest is now a trillion dollars.
So it's- It's, um, it's actually s-
uh, this is actually sort of incorrect.
So Medicare is just, should be
second, and net interest is just
below that at, at a bil- a trillion
52, and Medicare is a trillion 73.
Um, but I mean, you cut the net interest
by half and say, we'll just call it
what it was in '23, 700 billion, right?
Uh, you make up that 300 billion
difference, which is at the top, right?
That's the 300 billion difference.
So all things being equal, interest
payments are going up, right?
You don't pay down the principal.
Your interest payments
continue to rise, especially as
interest rates start to rise.
So that's the, that's the, that's
the main difference between '23 and
'26 as far as outcomes and results.
And so what are we learning?
We're learning that we can grow
the economy, um, but we're also
learning that, um, Congress, and
I would say this is Congress, not
really Trump or, um, Biden, right?
It's not really the executive
branch that does the spending.
Congress is not in session.
They've been out of session, in
my opinion, for 20 years, right?
They haven't balanced a budget
since Bush's first term, maybe
like '23 or '24, maybe even '22.
Um, so we've gone 25 years
without Congress doing its job.
Um, and I shouldn't call
it balancing a budget.
They haven't passed a budget.
So normal, normal, uh,
what do they call it?
I forget what they call it.
Basically, uh, normal practice,
they have a term for it.
Normal practice in Congress, right,
is they create appropriation bills.
There's, I forget how many of those
are, five or six, depending, uh, and
they're all specific to different
areas of spending in the government.
They debate those things in the House.
The House is meant to debate
those, refine those, sending
it up to the, to the Senate.
The Senate will debate them
and refine it if they want.
If they refine it, it
goes back to the House.
The House will debate it again, and then
they pass it, goes up to the Senate.
The Senate passes it, it goes to the
president, the president signs it, right?
That is, that is normal.
Uh, we haven't done that in 25 years.
So we've only been doing continuing
resolutions, which is we just take
what we had before, and we'll say,
"We'll add $2 trillion to that.
We'll add 300 million.
We're not really debating it.
We're not really kicking
it back and forth.
We're not compromising, right?
We're able, uh, with, uh, actually the
Affordable Care Act, with the, um, both
the tax, um, should, at least this most
recent tax, the big, bea- beautiful bill.
Um, I don't know if the 2017 was one.
I would bet it was.
Were all continuing resolutions, right?
They w- they didn't go
through normal order.
That's what it was, normal order.
They don't go through normal order.
They have one party gets what it
wants and is able to do a continuing
resolution through a backdoor process,
and it's not properly debated.
So anyway, to me, that's a
big, that's a Congress problem.
All right.
I just wanna show you one
other thing, um, in here.
I've got a couple more slides that I
think are, are just fun to look at.
So it's always good to go back and look
at 2000, only because that's the last
time we had a surplus for the year.
So we had a 236 billion
surplus, um, in 2000.
And, uh, and then as you know, the
following year, we had 9/11, and then
we had the Iraq War, and on and on
and on and on and on and on and on.
Right?
So we spent a lot of money since then.
So we went from a $236 billion
surplus, and in 26 years, we're
now at a record of 3 trillion, and
that's per year, per year, right?
We're not talking about the, the
41 trillion we're at right now.
Um, let's see what else is on here.
Anything exciting?
So I think, uh, that's just, uh, this is
all nominal, so I bet if I went through
and I, uh, did this in real dollars to,
to account for inflation, everything,
probably wouldn't seem so drastic.
Um- But this one's also interesting too.
I thought this was, um, fun to see,
um, because it's, um, really what
I'm, what I'm looking f- trying to
understand is, is this normal, right?
And I would say it's not normal.
Um, but how do we, how do we look at it?
And so here you can see that,
um, it's just a different way of
looking at tho- at those numbers
that we were looking at before.
So if you look at the receipts
and you show from two thousand
to twenty six and how they stack,
you can see it sloping upward.
Which makes sense, right?
The, the-- What we've already
seen is the US economy grows.
We ex- we expect it to grow.
We'll have downturns like in two
thousand and eight and two thousand.
Um, we actually had one in,
uh, twenty-three as well.
Excuse me.
And, um, and so that's normal, right?
But it's trajecturing up.
And then if you look at the
outlays, it's doing the same thing.
So then it's more of, well, how does this
compare if we do like a share of GDP?
And this is interesting.
So if you-- If I click on
this, um, it flattens it out.
So you can see that in two
thousand, total inlays was just
under twenty percent of GDP.
So it made up twenty
percent of GDP, right?
So it was about nineteen percent.
And then you look at today, all income
is, uh, just under eighteen percent.
So you'd say it's about
a one percent difference.
If we were talking in Deming
terms, we would say we were
completely in control, right?
That would be natural variation.
Um, and then when you look at the
outlays side, in two thousand, we
were about maybe in that seventeen
range, um, seventeen percent of GDP.
And now when you look at, at the totals,
we're just under twenty-five percent.
And, um, and so that is
much larger variation.
Could still be in control,
but just bigger variation.
Um, and you can see that, uh,
it's going up at a higher share.
The inlays are more flat, tighter
variation, more flat, hovering
around twenty percent GDP.
When you look at the outlays,
uh, it is trending up, and it's
grown by seven percent, roughly.
Um, and so you can see why
we're compounding debt over
the last, uh, twenty-six years.
Um, anyway, it's just a different
way of looking at the data.
And then the last one I
wanted to show you, um-
So, uh, I actually had to
think about, again, from Deming
perspective, and you can seeâ¦
So this is showing basically
the same chart, different look.
So it's showing, uh, the green line, um,
is revenue from tw- 2000 to '26, and it's,
it's up and down, natural variation, which
we would normally expect, again, between,
say, 15-ish percent to 20% up and down, up
and down, up and down, up and down, right?
Um, and you can see the red line, which
is the spending line, and that one has
lots of special cause in it, right?
Um, and that's, that's kinda spreading
between, say, 16% and 32%, right?
Huge variation, but I wouldn't
even say that's in control, right?
Um, lots of tampering that's inside there.
Um, so I'm just gonna read this.
This is what Claude wrote on this.
Um, the one thing to
see, revenue is stable.
It's a stable process.
It stayed inside its normal 16 to
20 band the entire time, and that's
over the 26 years since 2000.
Ordinary va- variation
around a steady center.
That's what it said.
Spending is not.
It shifted to a permanently
higher level and held there.
The deficit is a spending signal, not a
revenue one, meaning the, the debt that
we have, right, the deficit that we have,
the 42 million or trillion, and the $1.992
trillion a year, the de- that
signal is, um, is a spending
signal, not a revenue one, right?
Um, and it says the three, the
about 3% point dip in revenue, um,
and it's showing the last, the last
bottom, um, between 2001 and '26.
There's about a 3% difference, dip,
it would- it's calling it, and it's
calling it just common cause, um,
and instead of, uh, tampering, right?
It's saying it's common cause,
where the spending is tampering.
Um, anyway, very
interesting to think about.
Um, uh, another thing that, uh, I'll
just kinda wrap it up here We have,
we have the political situation,
and, uh, it's like what we've talked
about before with, with Brandon a lot
was we're in this age of turbulence.
And there's lots of theories, as
if we've talked about already, that
we're kinda in this cultural shift
and just demographic shift in the US
and in different parts of the world
as well, which is very turbulent.
It's just disruptive.
And so if you're looking for some
peace into why we're experiencing
these, these huge pendulum swings, um,
since basically since 2016, uh, to now
politically, both in the presidency
and in Congress, it's just like
whipsaw, and policies are whipsaw.
I mean, we're not, we're not just
tweaking the prior, uh, party's ideas.
We're ripping the guts out
and replacing it, right?
Ripping the guts out and doing
something completely different.
Um, that is to be expected as where
we are, and that's where we've, we've
talked about being resilient in our
businesses is about, um Being aware of
these things, but also understanding
the noise, right, from the signal.
Common cause from special cause.
And it's not to keep your-- not to be
naive and put your head in the sand,
but have some blinders around the noise
so that you can keep moving forward,
building your business, thinking about
how you build resiliency within yourself
and within your family, um, but also
within the processes and systems that
you're creating within your business.
That is what gives you resiliency
when we hit these crazy events, right?
This whipsaw in policy, right,
the tariffs are a whipsaw.
Um, the, uh, healthcare regulations
were whipsaw at one point, right?
We've been whipping
around all over the place.
Uh, it's just part of
the, part of the deal.
The theory is that in five, six years,
that'll start to settle down, um,
but potentially it could take more.
Maybe it's ten years before it settles.
Um, and I'm not talking politically,
I'm talking about just the whipsaw where
we all can come to an agreement, and
then we can start to get more common
s- common cause, stable, um, policies
within our government, but also in
how we feel how things are going.
So anyway, uh, you guys got it.
You're getting it.
And, uh, not only is it fun to
look at the numbers, but always
be thinking about your theories.
Are they proving correct?
Are they not?
And just try to take a objective
view in it, uh, so that you can
continually improve your business.