Nimble Youth

Episode 61: “Just Listen”: How to Hold Space for Your Teen

Summary
Listening to our teenagers can feel like a daunting task, especially when emotions run high. Matthew Butterman and guest Emily Ricks discuss the importance of holding space for our children, encouraging parents to step back from instinctive reactions of fixing or sympathizing, and instead, foster genuine curiosity about their experiences.

The Concept of Holding Space
Emily explains holding space as creating a protective force field around your teenager’s feelings. It’s about temporarily setting aside your judgments and opinions to truly understand what they are going through. Instead of jumping into problem-solving mode, take a moment to ask, “What’s going on?” This straightforward approach can open the door to honest communication.

"Sounds like something rough happened at school today. What's going on?"—Emily Ricks

The Pitfalls of Common Responses  
Many parents respond to their teenager's distress with love-driven instincts like comforting, steering, or even fixing. However, these reactions can sometimes stem from a place of fear, which can shut down connection rather than enhance it. 

Emily breaks down some common responses:
- **Sympathizing:** Agreeing with their feelings without encouraging them to think critically about the situation.
- **Dismissing:** Minimizing their feelings by pointing out positive aspects.
- **Fixing:** Offering immediate solutions instead of letting them process their emotions.
- **Steering:** Pushing your own opinions on how they should handle situations.
- **Coddling:** Overprotecting them, which can disempower their ability to cope.

Embracing Curiosity
Curiosity is a powerful tool in parenting. Instead of reacting with fear when your teen shares something troubling, approach the conversation with an open mind. Ask them about their thoughts and feelings, which helps foster an environment of trust and safety. 

Emily suggests asking questions like,  
"What do you think they were feeling when they said that to you?"  
This encourages them to reflect and process their experiences independently, rather than feeling judged or dismissed.

Conclusion
By choosing to hold space for our teenagers, we create a supportive environment where they can express themselves without fear of judgment. This approach not only deepens our connection with them but also empowers them to navigate their own challenges. 

Links
Think New Thoughts podcast







What is Nimble Youth ?

Welcome to the Nimble Youth podcast, where we provide expert insights and valuable resources for parents navigating the complexities of their children's mental health. We empower parents to nurture healthy minds in children, teens, and young adults through real conversations.

Our team of seasoned professionals, including physicians, therapists and educators, delve into pressing topics, share research-based strategies, and offer practical advice for fostering mental and emotional well-being within your family.

Matt (host):

Today, we're going to talk about something that sounds remarkably easy, listening. But your teenager comes home and tells you something went wrong. A friend excluded them, a teacher embarrassed them, they failed a test, someone broke up with them, they hate soccer, they want to pull out of an activity, they think a rule is unfair and because we love our children, we immediately spring into action. We do things like we reassure them, we give advice, we explain, we correct, we investigate, and we tell them what they should do tomorrow. Or perhaps we let them, we tell them why the situation isn't nearly as bad as they think it is.

Matt (host):

And then we encounter one of the great mysteries of parenting. Our teenager stops talking to us. My guest today, Emily Ricks of the podcast Parenting Teens, suggests another possibility. It's called holding space. Instead of immediately fixing, steering, sympathizing, dismissing, correcting, or coddling, we temporarily put our own opinions on the shelf and become genuinely curious about what our teenager is thinking, feeling, experiencing.

Matt (host):

That doesn't mean parents stop parenting. It doesn't mean we abandon our values. And it certainly doesn't mean we have to agree with everything our teenager says. It means we try to understand before deciding what comes next. Emily Ricks, welcome to Nimble Youth.

Emily Ricks:

Thanks for having me. Happy to be here.

Matt (host):

Great. So Emily, holding space is one of those expressions people may have heard without necessarily knowing what it what it looks like. So let's begin very simply. A teenager walks through the door visibly upset. What does it actually mean for a parent to hold space for that child?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah. So I like to think of it if you ever saw The Incredibles, you know, how Violet can make force fields around herself or her family. I like to think of holding space as a little force field that we temporarily create where we say, Hey, my own judgments, my own opinions, what I think they should do, what I think somebody else shouldn't have done. We're just gonna protect the space from those things for a few minutes So that we can see what's really happening so that our teenager can understand what they're experiencing. So we can get curious and ask questions.

Emily Ricks:

And then we can say, okay, that force field served its purpose. And now I'm going to bring my own opinions into this, or I'm going to set a boundary or whatever we feel like we need to do. But it's just, it's taking a moment, taking one minute, five minutes, twenty minutes, depending on the situation to just get curious and seek to understand before we seek to correct or, or to do whatever else might come naturally by default without thinking.

Matt (host):

Right. So, there's an interesting paradox here. Most of the responses you're asking parents to resist, they come from love and we fix because we want to help, that we reassure because we don't want our child to be hurt or afraid and we steer because we have more life experience and we protect because we're parents. So why can these very loving impulses sometimes interfere with connection?

Emily Ricks:

Well, so there's a couple of things here. One, I think most of us believe that our responses come from love. If we, if we want to correct or if we want to fix, or if we want to go, oh, that's so hard. And, oh, you shouldn't be experiencing that. And that's the worst.

Emily Ricks:

We want to say that it comes from love. As a life coach, what I help my clients do is really explore their own thoughts and feelings and find out, are you reacting from love or is that actually fear? Because what I often find is what we think is love often has quite a bit of fear. And when fear is, is driving the action of I'm afraid something's bad that's going happen. So I got to correct it now.

Emily Ricks:

That tends to shut off connection. Usually teenagers, they're very smart and they can tell if we're reacting from fear or if it's actually love. And when we react from fear, most of the time they sniff it and they go, you don't really care about me. You're not even listening. So so, yeah, I mean, that's it's like, yes, it comes from love because, of course, we love our kids and we love our kids so fiercely that sometimes we react in strong ways.

Emily Ricks:

Right? And yet if we really get honest, we can go, oh, I see the fear. I see the fear that's reaching for control. And I see that I'm uncomfortable with their strong emotions or I'm uncomfortable with the lack of control that I have over their decisions now that they're 17 years old or whatever. And so what, what I have found and what I believe to be true is that when there's that sneaky fear underneath, that tends to weaken the connection because it's not actually honest.

Emily Ricks:

Oh, I'm just jumping in to protect you because I love you. Are you sure? You might want to take a look at that.

Matt (host):

Yeah. Yeah. So, you've identified several responses we we kind of default to and they are like sympathizing, dismissing, fixing, steering, and coddling. So, I'd like to take those one at a time. So, let's imagine a 15 year old comes home and says, you know, nobody likes me.

Matt (host):

I have no real friends. What does sympathizing then look like?

Emily Ricks:

Okay, so sympathizing would be agreeing with their story, right? The fact might be something that someone said. Their story is, Oh, I have no friends. So sympathizing is, you know, you're right. Or like, Oh, I bet someone did something so, you know, did, did Audrey leave you out again today?

Emily Ricks:

Tell me about that, know, like, and just really, really buying in to their victim, everyone else is wrong, they probably didn't do anything wrong and this is so sad and this is so hard. Or maybe, you know, says, middle school's just the worst. It's awful. Yeah. That would be an example of sympathizing.

Matt (host):

Right, right.

Emily Ricks:

Which again, feels like love.

Matt (host):

Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. Is it? Right.

Matt (host):

Right. Right. So let's talk about dismissing. What would dismissing sound like?

Emily Ricks:

You totally have friends. You just had friends over last week. You just went to a birthday party two days ago. What do you mean you don't have friends? Right.

Emily Ricks:

And again, what we're trying to do is cheer them up. We're trying to help them think positive. It feels loving, but it's also like the, the message underneath is I don't believe you. Your feelings aren't valid.

Matt (host):

Right. You know, this isn't serious. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Matt (host):

So what is, what is fixing look like then?

Emily Ricks:

Well, could be a couple of ways. It depends. Maybe we want to fix their emotion. So we might be like, well, here, let's eat some cookies or let me watch a movie with you. Like, you know, like we're fixing their emotion by trying to distract them from it.

Emily Ricks:

That's one thing sometimes we do. Or, I mean, we could just jump right in right to a solution. Well, you know, maybe you could sit with somebody tomorrow who needs a friend, or maybe we could have a party this weekend and I'll have you invite all these people over so that you can have friends. Like we, we do the thinking for them and we solve the problem, which as a parent, that might be in the end, something really helpful after you take the time with the force field to see what's really going on and what they're thinking and feeling you might offer at the end of that conversation. You know, maybe we could have a social gathering in our house.

Emily Ricks:

Right? It's not that there's no place for it. It's just if we jump right in, we do the thinking for them and we rob them of the chance to start solving their own problems.

Matt (host):

Right. Right. So what does steering sound like?

Emily Ricks:

So steering and fixing have a lot in common. Right? There's, there's definitely overlap. But yeah, steering is like, oh, well, you tried this? Or maybe you could do this.

Emily Ricks:

Or we can jump in with possible solutions. Or we say things like, well, yeah, you shouldn't be hanging out with that girl anyway. These are the people you should be friends with. Just inserting our own hasty opinions of how they should solve this problem that they're presenting.

Matt (host):

Right. And then so finally, what does what does coddling sound like?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah. Coddling and sympathizing also have some overlap. But I think that the main idea of coddling is like, this is so hard and I feel so sorry for you and you shouldn't have to be going through this and this is just the worst and people are so mean. And again, there's an element of that, that of course you want to comfort somebody who is sad. And as a parent, you know, if your if your baby's crying, you hold them and you you shush them and you help them to calm down.

Emily Ricks:

And we wanna do that with our teenagers too. But this renders them powerless to solve their own problems. If if they're the victim and they feel sad because other people are mean, that's just a disempowering way to approach the world in the end, right? So, it doesn't serve them to sympathize and to coddle and to go, Oh, this is so hard for you, because they're not going to be empowered to be able to respond in a way that helps them, you know, take their own power.

Matt (host):

Right, right. So, you have an alternative, to these responses and you call that holding space. So, what might holding space sound like, in the same conversation?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah, okay. So, I think you said, I have no friends. Nobody likes me. Have no And so holding space, here's just an idea of what that could look like. You'd you say sounds like something rough happened at school today.

Emily Ricks:

What's going on? It's very neutral. It's not like, oh, this is the worst thing ever. Or yes, you do have friends. And it it's the parent staying in a, in a neutral space.

Emily Ricks:

It says whatever you have, I can hold it. You don't need to worry that I'm going to freak out or that I'm going to overreact. I, I can absorb whatever you're going to say. So just like, sounds like something rough happened. Tell me what's going on.

Emily Ricks:

Right. That's an example of a holding space. It's just curious, genuine curiosity without fear or anger or trying to control something or being worried about the future is just in this present moment. I'm genuinely curious. What are you experiencing?

Matt (host):

Right. And you use that word a lot curiosity. And so why is curiosity such a powerful parenting posture?

Emily Ricks:

So what I have noticed in, in the women that I work with, who are parenting teenagers, And this is a normal response. I feel it in myself. I see it all the time. It's very normal as parents of teenagers to react and feel threatened, right? Especially if they're telling us something going on in that their, their peers or they themselves are sexually active, or they've, they've tried alcohol or they, they got offered a vape.

Emily Ricks:

Like there are some serious things that is genuinely understandable as adults, why we would react in a threatened way. It threatens our values. It threatens our sense of control. It threatens the vision that we had for our teenagers and how they would be. But when we react from being threatened, again, this is what tends to shut down connection and the safety and the trust in the relationship that actually most of us really genuinely want to foster with our teenagers.

Emily Ricks:

And so curiosity is the opposite of reacting, being tense and, and scared. Curiosity is we open up to what are you experiencing? How can I help? How can I support? What's your process?

Emily Ricks:

And then we are allowing them to start thinking through so that they can make the best decision that they can.

Matt (host):

Right. So let's give parents some actual language. Instead of, why did you do that? Which can sound very accusatory, what should I ask instead?

Emily Ricks:

So I love to ask questions that facilitate the thinking process so that they understand what they are thinking and feeling. And they can consider, which is a good adult skill to start developing, consider, oh, what do you think they were thinking? What do you think they were feeling when they said that to you? What do you think the teacher was thinking when they responded in that way? Right?

Emily Ricks:

And so depending on the situation, rather than an accusation, why did you do that? Or even why did they do that? It's like a lot of times I notice I use the word interesting. I'll say, oh, that's interesting. Yeah.

Emily Ricks:

Tell me more about that. Or, oh, that's so interesting. I wonder what she was thinking when she said those words. Or, oh, interesting. What have been your thoughts since?

Emily Ricks:

As you've thought about it since that happened, what do you think about the way you reacted? And then it's this, again, it's this neutral space where oftentimes teenagers will come to a conclusion instead of us telling them, well, that was wrong. If you go, oh, you know, what have been your thoughts since that occurred? And since you got in trouble with the teacher, I wanna know, like, what what have you been thinking about it since? And so often they go, oh, yeah.

Emily Ricks:

I regret doing that. I wish I hadn't. Here's what I learned. And then they, they come to the learning you wanted them to have without you needing to lecture and point that out. It's like the curiosity and the openness.

Emily Ricks:

It's this belief that we have, like, right. The message it communicates is I believe in you. I believe in your ability to solve problems and to think through this and to learn the lessons. And I don't have to shove that down your throat.

Matt (host):

Right. Right. So holding space is probably relatively easy when when our teenager says something we find reasonable. But let's make it harder. Your teenager comes home, your 16 year old teenager comes home and says, you know, my teacher hates me, that's why I got a D.

Matt (host):

And you're thinking, well, no, you got a D because you didn't study. So, what do I do with something like that?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah. Great question. So again, this force field, if we think about it, that says, okay, for the moment, to begin this conversation, I'm going to put my own values, opinions, judgments, all that on the shelf. What I think is so empowering to remember as a parent is you do not ever have to agree with something you don't agree with. So you don't have to say, oh, yeah, your teacher is stupid or you're right.

Emily Ricks:

That's the reason. Right? Like, don't have to link something together just because they did, but you can show genuine curiosity. Well, that's interesting. Tell me why you think that.

Emily Ricks:

Tell me more about this. How many hours did you study for that test? Right? You can actually ask these curious questions. And then at the end of the conversation, you might decide to share your opinions.

Emily Ricks:

You might decide to have a consequence in place, even though they're going to complain about it. Right. But, but you're allowing them the space to think about it and to process it before you jump in and do the thinking for them.

Matt (host):

So I think this distinction is important to stay with because parents sometimes hear that or fear that if they listen compassionately to something they disagree with that somehow they're endorsing it or agreeing with it. So, so how do we separate these ideas? Know, I hear you and I understand why you feel that way. I agree with you and I'm gonna let you do what you want. How do you, how do you separate those, those sentiments?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah. So as a life coach, what I believe passionately is that our thoughts create our feelings, not something somebody else said, not anything anyone else is doing. I can choose by the way that I think, how I want to feel about it, how I want to respond to a situation. And so that's something I never let go of. I never ever let go of that, even when I'm holding space and in the, in the work that I teach other moms to do.

Emily Ricks:

Right? When we hold space for a teenager, it is not to say, I agree with everything and you're right. And, you know, it's good to be, it's, it's understandable that you're angry with this person is different than they made you mad. You're right. Does that make sense?

Emily Ricks:

So it's like to honor another person's feelings is a beautiful gift.

Matt (host):

I can

Emily Ricks:

see that you're really upset right now. And so you felt lonely when you were sitting alone at lunch. Yeah. That makes sense. I get it.

Emily Ricks:

And also in my own mind, I'm thinking, okay, well, that emotion is being created by their thoughts. I can have compassion that they're feeling whatever they're feeling. And I can also know and believe that they have the power to choose a different response when they're ready to. Right? It's this empowering thing.

Emily Ricks:

It's not... Yeah, we're not judging them, but we also don't have to agree with their interpretation order to feel compassion and to be helpful.

Matt (host):

Right, right. And I like your expression that sometimes we temporarily have to sort of put our opinions on the shelf and the important word there seems to be temporarily because you're not telling parents they shouldn't have opinions. So, when do we take the opinion back off the shelf? What's the appropriate time for that?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah, that's a great question. Obviously, depends on the situation. It depends on the teenager. It depends on your relationship. However, I will say that the goal of everything I teach is rather than seeking for control, which comes from a place of fear.

Emily Ricks:

Right? So rather than feeling threatened and afraid and reaching for control, the the goal actually is to feel at peace and centered and open and curious so that instead of control, which is an illusion, you don't really have it anyway, even if you want it. Instead of control, what we're reaching for is influence. That is ultimately what we want and what is possible in our teenagers' lives. We don't get to have control.

Emily Ricks:

The older they get, less control we're gonna have, and that the more we can come to grips with that, the better. And so when we reach for influence, that's where getting our own opinions back into the conversation can really happen. So again, we've got this force field, right? We keep the protected space and we say for a minute, I'm gonna stay neutral and I'm not gonna say all the things that I think they should do and all that. But oftentimes after a teenager comes to you, if they feel heard, if they feel understood, which is different than being agreed with, understood, right?

Emily Ricks:

Once they feel those things, it can be very seamless to say, can I tell you my perspective on this? Or can I share with you an experience that dad had with something similar and what he chose to do? And if we ask that permission many, many times, they'll say, well, yeah, like, want to know, I do want help with this. Like, I'm really struggling here. And that's very different than the second they present with something uncomfortable.

Emily Ricks:

We jump in and share that exact same thing. Probably they're not gonna be open to it. Yeah. So in fact, holding space as contrary as that sounds, choosing to hold space actually generally opens the possibility of us being able to share our perspective and have it be received with so much more acceptance.

Matt (host):

Yeah. Yeah. That is sounds counterintuitive, but but also it makes a lot of sense at the same time. So there's there's a related question I've heard suggested, that is you asked a teenager, do you want comfort or solutions? How do you feel about that question?

Emily Ricks:

That's interesting. I... I'll be perfectly honest. It's not my favorite because sometimes, especially when we're upset, we don't really know what we want. I so like, right, I can see it like in a healthy marriage, right?

Emily Ricks:

If somebody, if I come to my husband with something and he were to ask me like, well, do you just want comfort or do you want solutions? It's still a little bit of an accusation to

Matt (host):

me. Yeah.

Emily Ricks:

To me personally. So it could work. It could be really helpful. Like I'm not, I don't think it's a bad idea.

Matt (host):

Right.

Emily Ricks:

But for me and my teenagers and my relationships, it feels a little bit still kind of like, you're complaining. So do you want this or this? Rather than just genuinely being curious? And I

Matt (host):

think it

Emily Ricks:

also, it kind of puts on the other person, like they need to tell you what they want and what they need. They don't know yet. Yeah. They're grappling. They're, they're, they're drowning.

Emily Ricks:

They're flailing their arms around in the pool. You're like, oh, well, do you want a pool neuter or a life jacket? And they're like, I don't know. I just am wet and I'm scared I'm gonna drown.

Matt (host):

Yeah. Yeah. Right. You know? So,

Emily Ricks:

so I think maybe it could be helpful, but maybe that's a question you could ask without asking.

Matt (host):

Right.

Emily Ricks:

To assess by, by getting more information, what you think they need. And then I think you can answer the question for yourself after a few minutes of genuine curiosity.

Matt (host):

Yeah. Yeah. That certainly makes a lot of sense. So, let's dial this up a little bit. Let's make this a little more difficult.

Matt (host):

Your teenager tells you something that immediately activates you. We all have these triggers, right? Things that might irritate us. They failed a class, they got drunk at a party, they want to drop out of an activity you've invested thousands of dollars in, and they want to say something cruel about the other parents, and suddenly you're not you're not, calmly holding space anymore. Your heart rate is up and you're angry, you're frightened.

Matt (host):

So what do you do in those situations?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah, that's that's real and generally as parents of teenagers there are going to be things that hit that button that we didn't know we have that really triggered that fight or flight response where we feel very threatened. So I have a couple of thoughts. I mean, I will say, so first, the long game is if we overreact and if we show up in a way that we don't want to, part of what I teach is self coaching, which is looking back on events and saying, I'm not happy with how I showed up. What was going on for me? What was I so threatened about?

Emily Ricks:

To identify those thoughts, right? So the long game is we open up to after the fact when we're in a safe space and when we're not trying to have a conversation to really honestly look at that because otherwise those things are going to get triggered every time something like that comes up, then we're going to feel threatened, right? So that's the long game. I think in the short term, it is okay to honestly notice that in oneself. My gosh, my heart is starting to beat fast.

Emily Ricks:

I feel angry. I want to yell. I want to get upset. And the more practice you get at holding space, the more you can notice, oh, this is different. I'm, I'm wanting to insert my own thing here.

Emily Ricks:

And I don't think that's going to create the trust that I want. Honestly, some of some as parents, I think almost all of us have to experience that a few times where we respond from that place of pressure. And then we go, oh, that isn't what I wanted. Right. But, but let's say that we've done that.

Emily Ricks:

And we know, because we've looked at it a few times, that's not how I want to be showing up. I'm shutting down the connection. This isn't what I want to create. Then in the moment, you can say, you know, this is a big thing. And I noticed I'm having a really strong reaction to it.

Emily Ricks:

And I want to be able to show up in a way where we can have a great conversation and I'm going to need a few minutes.

Matt (host):

Right. And that's what you call, I guess you would call that holding space for ourselves, right? Yes. For the parents, right? Yes.

Matt (host):

Yeah. So, here's another very familiar situation, anyone who's had a teenager, the parent will ask, you know, what's wrong? A teenager's like, nothing, which means the exact opposite. So, you know, are you sure there's nothing wrong? Yes.

Matt (host):

You seem upset. I'm fine. What happened at school? Nothing. So, at what point does our attempt to connect become pressure?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah, about then. About that point, right? They made it clear that they don't want to talk about it right So I think if we expand this concept of holding space, how we've been talking about it so far is within a conversation, right? That we hold space for them to think and feel what they're feeling. If we expand that out a little bit, I think the way that you would practice this skill of holding space is I respect that they don't want to talk about that right now.

Emily Ricks:

So, okay, that's fine. Right? I can be genuinely curious over the long term, over the next two days or three days. Maybe I still, I want them to know I'm available. Right?

Emily Ricks:

Maybe I go into their room at 09:30 at night and sit on the bed and ask an open question about something and see if they want to. But, but yes, it's this very, we're always, we, we don't want to force ourselves into their lives because generally that's when we're met with them digging their heels in and saying, I said I don't want to talk about it. Like, and then it's like, are we are we trying to get them to talk for them, for their sake? Or is it something we need for us? We need to feel like a good parent or we need to feel like we can fix it.

Emily Ricks:

Right? So I think it's very respectful to literally give them space. Maybe on a walk, maybe over dinner, maybe in the morning, maybe tomorrow afternoon, we could circle back to it and see if maybe they're ready to talk. It's really respectful to allow them that time.

Matt (host):

Right, right. And so another thing that I think is, I think it's a really interesting idea is the idea of silence in a conversation with your child. You know a teenager tells us something difficult and they, you know, pause for five seconds so we immediately go in and feel the silence, know, well you should do this, should do that, whatever. Should we do that or do we just need to be comfortable that silence and let the situation stay silent for a while? What's your response to that?

Emily Ricks:

Well yeah, any decision you make as a parent, it just depends on what you want to create. Should you? It depends. It depends on what the dynamic is that you're wanting to create between you and your teenager. But personally, I think silence can be golden.

Emily Ricks:

And especially if we message to our teenagers, this is a safe space, which means it's okay if it's quiet. It's also okay if you have strong feelings, I can handle that. It's also okay if you don't want to talk about it right now. Write any of those responses on a multiple choice for them. It's like if you choose A, B, C, or D, I'm still here.

Emily Ricks:

I'm still okay. I don't... I'm not... I don't have to be uncomfortable with whatever it is you choose, including silence. And that's a beautiful gift.

Emily Ricks:

It's a type of unconditional love that we can give to our teenagers.

Matt (host):

Right, right. So, teenagers, they have this very remarkably sensitive radar for conversation that isn't really a conversation. The parent will say, I'm just curious, which to them sounds like a, you know, a prosecutor moving in, right? It sounds accusatory in a way. So, you know, how important is that genuine curiosity and why is it that they can so easily detect an agenda?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah, I think one of the greatest gifts that teenagers give to their parents is seeing through hypocrisy and Yeah. They're very, very smart and they notice immediately. And in some ways that can be discouraging as parents but I like to think of it as an invitation for us to get a little bit more honest with ourselves. Right? We can thank our teenagers for calling our bluff because they're right when they're like, you don't even care about me.

Emily Ricks:

You're just trying X, Y, Z. You just want to look good in front of your friends. And it's like, well, if we really look at that, there's a little, there's usually a little truth. Now there's also usually love and other motives that they're maybe not understanding, right. That we have as well.

Emily Ricks:

So, I think again, what, what I teach as a coach is understanding your own thoughts and feelings and responses and owning those, not blaming those on your teenager. Then like, if you're going to have a conversation and you want to show up with curiosity, I recommend doing some self coaching before the conversation and, and finding out, am I actually curious or am I coming from a place of fear that wants to control? And if you're not curious yet, maybe don't talk about it quite yet. Maybe get yourself to the place where you genuinely want to know and you're not getting information so you can punish, getting information so that you can correct, getting information. You're just, you genuinely want to understand so that you can support.

Matt (host):

Now turning to another difficult topic, there are some circumstances where, I think we'd all agree that simply listening isn't quite enough. If a teenager is talking about suicide or self harm, if they're being abused, if they're in danger, if someone is exploiting them, if their substance use has become dangerous, if they're threatening another person. So when does holding space and parental intervention begin?

Emily Ricks:

That's a great question. The truth is I can't say for any situation specifically, right, because they're all different. But I think the principle to apply is holding space is both within a conversation and within entire context of their life, that we understand that their thoughts and feelings and responses are not gonna be the same as ours, and we allow that to be true. Right? Now with that, there are absolutely times where we need to step in or intervene or take action.

Emily Ricks:

Right? But even even with something that is very extreme, like what you're describing, what I would what I would offer is sometimes things feel incredibly urgent and they are very important, but sometimes the urgency factor is actually false. Right? Like if if they're in a situation where they're being mistreated by another person, but we're in our kitchen talking to them about it, they're safe right this minute. They may not be safe with what's going on with this other person.

Emily Ricks:

Right? But but just to take a few minutes to understand the situation, like, and and calm down that urgency doesn't mean that we're not going to take action. It doesn't mean that we might, maybe we need to get professionals involved. Maybe we need to get law enforcement involved. Right?

Emily Ricks:

Like there are things that might need to happen. But I, what I would offer is that our own sense of panic and urgency and fear is almost never useful. It doesn't actually help us to show up in a way that's most helpful because we get blinded by our own fear.

Matt (host):

Absolutely. So, I think every parent has experienced this. Their best conversation with their teenagers, they don't happen sitting face to face at the kitchen table or dining room table, they happen in the car or, you know, walking the dog, cooking dinner or late at night, these sort of informal settings. So, why is it that these lower pressure environments make it easier for teenagers to talk?

Emily Ricks:

Well, yeah, I love what you said, lower pressure, Yeah, mean, if you come in with guns blazing and you're like, I need an answer from you right now and this is the time we're having this conversation, there's a lot of reasons why they may not want to open up. I probably wouldn't want to open up either in that situation. Right?

Matt (host):

Right.

Emily Ricks:

But, you know, on a car ride or on a walk or something, it's like, okay, we can go here if you want to. Right. We sort of inch our toes into the water. And instead of you have to come swimming with me, it's like, we could go into our ankles. Does this feel okay?

Emily Ricks:

Okay. Do you want to go into our knees? Okay. You want to be done swimming? Okay.

Emily Ricks:

We can be done. It's and I don't mean to, it's not pandering. It's not people pleasing. That's not what I'm saying. It's just honestly, genuinely allowing them the agency to decide if they trust you and if they feel comfortable talking to you.

Emily Ricks:

If they don't meeting that with, okay, I get it. I understand. I understand why you might not feel comfortable. And maybe I haven't been a safe space in the past for you to talk about this. Or maybe the last time you brought something like this up, I freaked out.

Emily Ricks:

Yeah, I get it that maybe you're not ready. That's okay.

Matt (host):

Right. And that leads into my next question. So, sometimes a parent will say, you know, my teenager isn't telling me anything anymore. So, when that situation comes about, when the teenager seems to just clam up, just be communicative at all, what questions should that parent ask themselves before concluding that the teenager is simply being secretive?

Emily Ricks:

Well, again curiosity is magic and I wonder why. Wonder why they don't want to open up. I wonder what's going on for them. I wonder what they're perceiving from me. Yeah.

Emily Ricks:

Like, right. To really go inside and honestly say, what am I bringing into the relationship non verbally or verbally that maybe would make them not want to talk to me? Like, oh, yeah, I tend to jump in and fix. Or a lot of times when they don't open up, what they're feeling is judged. Maybe they have shame about something that they're choosing to do that they know you disagree with and they know you wouldn't be proud of.

Emily Ricks:

Like, that's understandable. Right? It's understandable that they don't wanna come to us if they feel ashamed. Maybe they feel upset. Maybe they feel embarrassed.

Emily Ricks:

Like, there's so many emotions. Right? So I think when we can get curious of, I wonder what they're thinking and feeling that is creating this response in them where they don't want to talk to me. And instead of making it about me, it's like, can, I can look inside and see my own part, but also want to understand where they're coming from?

Matt (host):

So, for the parent listening who recognizes themselves in this conversation we're having and realizes, well, okay, I fix, I lecture, I steer, I interrupt, what's one thing, one simple thing they can do tonight to change things, to help things?

Emily Ricks:

Yeah. If you want just a very, very simple thing, it's like the next time you're in a conversation, just pause and take a breath and ask a question before you jump in, before you, you know, before you agree with or disagree with their story, before you react, before anything, just take a breath and get curious. It's it's not that hard to do, actually. It is. It takes intention, and it takes presence.

Emily Ricks:

It's a type of discipline, actually, as a parent.

Matt (host):

Sure.

Emily Ricks:

And yet also, we are we are made to be curious beings. When we can tap into that, it's a little bit easier than it might sound.

Matt (host):

Exactly. Yeah. Yeah. So, guest today has been Emily Ricks of the podcasting... Of the podcast Parenting Teens and we've been talking about holding space, temporarily setting aside our judgments, solutions and opinions so that we can become genuinely curious about what our teenagers are thinking, feeling and experiencing.

Matt (host):

And an important reminder, holding space doesn't mean ignoring genuine safety concerns. If a young person talks about things like suicide, self harm, abuse, exploitation, dangerous substance use or other serious threat to their safety, listening compassionately and getting appropriate professional help is the next appropriate step. So, we'll include information about Emily and parenting teens in our episode notes and if today's conversation made you think of another parent who is trying to be... Just trying hard to get their teenager to open up, please do share this episode with them and if you enjoy Nimble Youth, follow the podcast and leave us a rating or review. It helps more families find these conversations.

Matt (host):

Until next time, perhaps the greatest question isn't always, what should I say to my teenager? Sometimes it's, can I create enough space for my teenager to say something to me? I'm Matthew Butterman. This is Nimble Youth. We'll see you next time.