The Promote Podcast

This week, we slip on our sullied leather jackets and talk about what the entire world is talking about. Because we have to. Because Jensen Huang’s extraordinarily swift fall from grace is also a potential Minsky moment for the future of the AI buildout. And for the entire CRE cottage industry of lenders, developers and advisory firms that’s sprouted up to support it. We then travel to the zombie nation of Downtown LA, where we’re entering a new age for one of the country’s biggest development boondoggles, Oceanwide Plaza. But the buyer’s backstory and vibe don’t inspire confidence that this is the end of the drama. Plus, our Punch List rundown of the newsiest industry happenings: GO/H&R deal dies; Hotel Hayden foreclosure drama; Soundstage pain; the Smekes take on New York.

Sponsors:
1) Bravo Capital, a leading HUD and bridge lender.
2) Pensford, the only interest-rate advisory focused exclusively on CRE
3) H Equities, your mid-market go-to on both sides of the capstack. Hit them up for bridge loans of up to $50M, or if you need a co-GP partner for that last 10-20% of equity.

Partner Content:
"
Inside the Capstack" with Gibson Dunn's Eric Meer. Meer discusses the nuances of taking in preferred equity.

Up your CRE game:  Consider becoming a premium subscriber to The Promote to unlock access to deep dives, bonus content and expert perspectives. Take 10% off annual subscriptions by using this link.

Further Reading/Listening
Jensen Huang is gone. Will the AI industry pay the price?
Notorious Graffiti Towers wiped clean in downtown Los Angeles
KPC Group’s Oceanwide Plaza Bet Started With a Supertall Dream for Manhattan
Brothers Gonna Work it Out
GO’s Multifamily AUM Gobbling ™ 🔒
GO goes after H&R REIT after shareholders reject acquisition
 


What is The Promote Podcast?

Your Commercial Real Estate Insider guide. From profiles of the biggest dealmakers to skyline-shaping transactions, we bring you the deals, breakdowns and war stories that move the market — for insiders, by insiders. From bad-boy guarantees to CMBS tranche warfare to syndicator sins, we cover it all.

Each week, The Promote Podcast explores three of the most interesting and consequential stories in CRE, taking you well beyond the headlines and into the heart of the action. Hosted by the award-winning “Bard of CRE,” Hiten Samtani, along with no-BS institutional insider Will Krasne. Now a top 80 pod on Apple in "Business & Investing." Also check out our 3x/week newsletter for industry insiders at https://www.thepromote.com/

Hiten Samtani (00:10)
There are a few generally accepted forces major. Fires, flood, foreign invasions.

Will Krasne (00:17)
recently had the pandemic, which has been written into every debt doc out there. But one that the data center industry did not and could not have prepared for.

Is excess libido.

Hiten Samtani (00:47)
Welcome back to the Promote Podcast, your insider guide to the money and mania of the CRE markets. I'm Hiten Samtani.

Will Krasne (00:52)
And I'm Will Krasne.

Hiten Samtani (00:58)
This week we slip on our Sullied leather jackets and talk about what the entire world is talking about. Because we have to, because Jensen Huang's extraordinarily swift fall from grace is also a potential Minsky moment for the future of the AI build-out. And for the entire CRE cottage industry of lenders, developers, and advisory firms that sprouted up to support it. Then we travel to the zombie nation of downtown LA, where we're entering a new age for one of the country's biggest development boondoggles, Oceanwide Plaza. But

The buyer's backstory and vibe don't exactly inspire confidence that this is the end of the drama. Let's take a moment to recognize our sponsors who helped make the show happen. Absolutely with

Will Krasne (01:36)
Let's do it.

Hiten Samtani (01:37)
Bravo Capital, the leading HUD and Bridgelender.

Will Krasne (01:40)
Pensford the only interest rate advisory focused exclusively on CRE, they'll make rate caps your problem. No, their problem. I just read JP Singh this morning.

Hiten Samtani (01:51)
You'll also hear during the show from our friends at Gibson Dunn, top attorneys at the firm take us inside the cap stack in a series of conversations.

Will Krasne (02:00)
Before we get into those stories, let's get started with the punch list, our signature rundown of the newsiest news in CRE.

This week's punch list is brought to you by H Equities. Killer mid-market deal? Almost there? Missing that last piece? Elliott Horowitz's team works both sides of the cap stack to get you to closing and get those wires sent and deed recorded.

Hiten Samtani (02:28)
They do bridge loans of up to 50 million or a 10 to 20% code GP check on the equity side to get you to that closing table.

Will Krasne (02:35)
Find them at hequities.com dot com. That's hequities dot com.

Hiten Samtani (02:39)
First one, do not pass go.

Will Krasne (02:41)
Do not collect $200. In fact, try to collect $72 million because that is what the Go Partners is looking for as a breakup fee after shareholders voted down their take private of HR Read.

Hiten Samtani (02:55)
Yes, this is a big blow. This was a transaction that was gonna add more than ten thousand Sunbelt units to Goat Partners nascent multifamily empire.

Will Krasne (03:04)
I might even say inchoate

Hiten Samtani (03:07)
inchoate is the way you would say.

Will Krasne (03:09)
Seriously? Have I been saying inchot for years?

Hiten Samtani (03:12)
No. But that's okay. I forgive you. You still did well on your SAT

Will Krasne (03:17)
that sucks.

Hiten Samtani (03:20)
Yours sounds like a little sexual.

Will Krasne (03:23)
I always thought that But anyway

Hiten Samtani (03:27)
Yeah, this was gonna add ten thousand plus Sunbelt units to the portfolio, two point eight billion dollar deal where Go was gonna take the multifamily and then Blackstone was gonna step in and take the industrial portfolio from HR. But this has been mired in a lot of drama since the very beginning.

Will Krasne (03:42)
Well,

you forgot one piece of it, the problematic piece really, which is that the Hostetter family, the largest shareholder individually, they were gonna get some side snacks at correct indeterminate value that I think the other shareholders were a little bit upset with. You could feel this coming right when the deal got announced, a lot of people were upset about it. There were various substacks.

Hiten Samtani (04:03)
I love the angry Canadian analysts on Fintwit just going after this one. Don't wreck our show you

Will Krasne (04:09)
So not a surprise that this happened. I do think what's ironic about it is that look at the tenure when the deal got announced and look at the tenure today, and you might say to yourself if your go partner is what are you trying to tell me that I can dodge?

Hiten Samtani (04:23)
All right, next one.

speaker-2 (04:25)
Yeah.

Hiten Samtani (04:29)
Lest people accuse us of just focusing on the mega deals, we're gonna take you into the heart of a very tiny deal, but what it lacks in size and makes up for in spiciness?

Will Krasne (04:43)
We're including this mostly because it's got the best one-liner, this side of if the glove don't fit, you must acquit. And this is a forty-four million dollar foreclosure lawsuit against Morris Moinian's Hotel Hayden.

Hiten Samtani (04:56)
The buyer of the NPL, which is Bastion Broda's 109 companies, you might know the name Bastion Broda as one half of 60 Gilders with Chisholm back in the day. He snapped up the NPL on the Hotel Hayden, boutique is hotel in Manhattan controlled by Morris, and he was moving a foreclose. However

Will Krasne (05:16)
When Morgan Stanley was the lender on this, they refinanced it in 2018 and they filed the note and the mortgage separately. Okay. They were put together with a paper clip, which technically to the letter of the law is not allowed. The two need to be, quote, so firmly affixed thereto as to become a part thereof, courts have ruled. So this foreclosure isn't happening because the ruling here denies summary judgment, and so the case has to go to trial.

Hiten Samtani (05:42)
Which means that Morris obviously has more leverage to try to work out a deal.

Will Krasne (05:46)
Exactly.

Hiten Samtani (05:47)
I love this because real estate is mired in these little technicalities and Will will say, Ask me how I know. I'm sure you've had your share of these, but these little, tiny little things that can derail a deal, and this is one of the greatest examples.

Will Krasne (06:00)
I've never heard of anything like this. Truly fantastic. It's one of those things where I guess you gotta read the docs. I guess you gotta read the rules about paper organization. This is like in that episode of The Office when Michael Scott changes the slogan of Dundan Mifflin to limitless.

Hiten Samtani (06:20)
I will say that the attorney who successfully argued this on Morris Moinian's behalf is becoming really a character in his own right in the promote cinematic universe. It's Leo Jacobs. He's been representing the Shatreet brothers in their whole bankruptcy saga. And he recently had a bit of an altercation at the Amman. Oh god. A very prominent Syrian retail investor called Alex Hadjbi. Apparently he went over to Leo Jacobs, who's who's a big lad and slapped him.

And then went in for another punch and then for the the third punch, Leo Jacobs landed one blow that apparently ended things.

Will Krasne (06:57)
That's what I really want in my attorney is, you know, one punch knockout power. uh

Hiten Samtani (07:02)
But he had a pretty iconic line here.

Will Krasne (07:05)
No staple, no case.

Hiten Samtani (07:07)
Nothing to add. All right, next one. Poster child of just how bad the soundstage real estate can get. Hackman's Radford Studio Center in Studio City. It's heading to foreclosure. Netflix was in talks to buy it for what, 400 million? What was the original purchase price?

Will Krasne (07:27)
One point nine billion dollars. That is

Hiten Samtani (07:29)
Correct. Goldman had loaned about one point three billion dollars on this thing. So underwater by a factor of three.

Will Krasne (07:37)
A bunch of things at play here. The you know, studio business has been consolidating. We've seen Warner Paramount merge, and there's a lot of questions around how much the studio business in LA is going to be utilized. There's tax credits going through that John Voigt of all people is pushing.

Hiten Samtani (07:55)
Jon Voight of Anaconda?

Will Krasne (07:58)
yeah. Yeah, Jon Voight of Anaconda. The thing though that I wanna flag here, the lower market multifamily market has been hit really hard by LA's measure ULA tax.

Hiten Samtani (08:08)
Also known as the mansion taxi, yeah, for

Will Krasne (08:10)
For

properties over five million dollars, basically it's extra transfer tax essentially. That applies to everything. And so Netflix's purchase here of $400 million is gonna have twenty something million of ULA tax going in there as well. So is there some weird like city incentive to actually get this done here versus like a deed in lieu or something? And I'm sure that the clever lawyers at whatever firm Netflix is hired will figure out some way to avoid that tax.

Hiten Samtani (08:38)
Next one. Every new cycle, there's a new crop of mad lads who come around with big dreams and have the daring to do something different. And I feel like this is my most favorite recent example, the Smekes Not

Will Krasne (08:52)
Yeah, we added this in

Hiten Samtani (08:54)
not the smecks.

Will Krasne (08:55)
The extra syllable it's it's cleaner. Yeah. Really great segment in the promote newsletter uh this past week about the these guys who have been buying up a storm. They've got love of the game, they do, which really comes across and it's just something we wanna celebrate.

Hiten Samtani (09:10)
They're in contracted by the Episcopal Church headquarters on 2nd Avenue. They bought 300 East 42nd Street. They did a very complicated ground lease collapse at 136 East 57th Street. They made an unsuccessful but still glorious run at the Hudson Hotel. What binds these deals together is typically massive discounts to original basis and incredibly complex, messy transactions where there's typically some distress involved or

decent amount of finagling between the seller groups and all that. And the Smeckies, this is very early days. We'll see which deals work out, but the Smeckies have shown an impressive ability to kind of wade into the messy stuff, which we love. And I caught up with Alberto on Friday, who is the younger Smecky brother, very piercing eyes, handsome man. He had the love of the game that you just discussed.

Will Krasne (10:01)
Excited to see how these things go for these guys. You love to see somebody new on the scene doing cool deals. Cause that's what again this is about. Anyone can kind of say the biggest number, but to really do a complex transaction with different stakeholders like this does take a different type of juice. And it's impressive to get these things done.

Hiten Samtani (10:17)
That is it for the punch list. When we come back, we dive into what do we call this? The end of the affair?

I should get away with that.

Aaron Krawitz from Bravo Capital, thanks for being with the promote. Do you think

Aaron Krawitz (10:40)
Great being here.

Hiten Samtani (10:41)
in general HUD is understood well enough by the sponsors out there?

Aaron Krawitz (10:45)
Definitely not. People call us every day with very outdated misconceptions and ask, is HUD only for affordable properties? The majority of what we finance is market rate. People don't understand how some of the rules work, how MIP works, how stat limit works. So our belief has always been if you're not pure play at HUD and bridge to HUD, you're not going to be good at navigating that particular process.

Hiten Samtani (11:11)
There's a HUD Healthcare Lane Express deal that you've been talking about quite a bit.

Aaron Krawitz (11:15)
My mortal enemy is combating timing to close. Anything I could do to shave off hours or days without jeopardizing quality or diligence, we will do. And in this case, HUD made it easy for us. HUD rolled out an express lane on the healthcare side where if you meet certain underwriting criteria, you're eligible to submit within the express lane. Bravo seized the opportunity.

and submitted an application that in only four days was approved.

Hiten Samtani (11:48)
Aaron Krawitz from Bravo Capital, thanks for being with promote.

speaker-3 (11:55)
Breaking news and video

Scandal the New York Times reported Jensen Huang was

Hiten Samtani (12:03)
An alleged Chinese spy and Huang then admitted affair. This was just stacking up. And frankly, you know, there's more just hard

speaker-3 (12:11)
So it's just

Hiten Samtani (12:13)
to overstate what a earthquake this is for the AI industry.

There has to be a better process for these guys to get laid. That was the takeaway from my guy's group chat, and I'm sure there's been echoes of this on group chats across the world. Jensen Huang is out at NVIDIA. This is not just a normal sex scandal, and this is not just a normal CEO. I would argue that Jensen is probably, I think it's inarguable actually, that Jensen is probably the most important man in AI.

Will Krasne (12:43)
Smarter

people than me can dis debate that. He's certainly one of them. But I think what's lesser known is that he actually may be the most important man in real estate. Because not just the whole data center industry is sort of dependent on this, but the real estate industry writ large is being propped up by the capital flowing into this. If it stops or those returns aren't there, it will be beyond devastating.

Hiten Samtani (13:12)
What we're gonna get into just now is the implications for the data center build out. It has been the be all end all of the real estate world. Look at CBRE's profits. It's all been driven by data centers. Look at what the Newmark guys are doing on the debt side. It's all data centers. Look at the quantum of dollars that has been raised by the Brookfields and the relateds and the Blackstones for the strategies. Jensen sits at the the center of all that action.

Will Krasne (13:36)
It's not often that we get topics that are aped on Saturday Night Live. Just to put some numbers on this, they're almost made up. It's just like gobbledygook. Yeah. Yeah. NVIDIA is one of the data center industry's biggest tenants. Yes. Biggest lease guarantors and biggest financiers. Yes. Nvidia's made a hundred and five billion dollars in guarantees just for one company in Open AI. You still have a cap rate on that. We're talking about real money.

Hiten Samtani (14:04)
They've also used their balance sheet to gin up over half a trillion dollars, trillion with a T dollars of outside capital for chip financing.

Will Krasne (14:12)
All of

these other sort of the neo cloud industry is like basically being backstop these guys. So Core Weaves IPO. The IPO was muted. Nvidia sort of was seen as a backer of last resort. And so they anchored the IPO for Core Weave, also put in a massive order to backstop the stock. We talk about Wild Gotcha all and you're like, my God, what's the jam building? It's so much rent. Yeah. It's not just what are they paying to all of these other landlords? It's just

What is everyone else paying to all of these landlords and where is that money coming from or being guaranteed?

Hiten Samtani (14:43)
Nvidia has been a five trillion dollar plus company. It's not going away. It is very much the center. In fact, as we are talking, Jensen Huang is in conversations to potentially make a make a return.

Will Krasne (14:55)
Wait, is is this breaking news? Wait.

Hiten Samtani (14:57)
This

is this is happening right now where Jensen is mulling, as they say in journalistic circles, a return to NVIDIA. FT's reporting that today.

Will Krasne (15:07)
I wouldn't know 'cause I don't get my paper.

Hiten Samtani (15:10)
I put in a good word for you with the right people. But but by the time this airs, we might have Jensen back in the seat. Who knows? But the reason this is essential is that Nvidia, unlike pretty much any company of its size and importance, is a Jensen Huang operation. Jensen makes a lot of the deals almost in a Trumpian style where he steps in, talks one on one with the right person, makes it happen. There's very little infrastructure around Jensen. He has all the power. I think he has 60 direct reports.

Which just makes my stomach turn.

Will Krasne (15:40)
Seems like a lot.

Hiten Samtani (15:41)
His family is in other positions of power at the company. So tremendous amount resting on one guy. And a lot of these deals that we're talking about, the backstopping, the financing, the commitments, that's all Jensen just stepping up to the plate and saying, We got this. So if there is a changing of the guard there, a lot of these assurances that he's given the other people that are part of this AI ecosystem.

That could be a question mark.

Will Krasne (16:09)
That's great point because the whole economy just rests on confidence. Yeah. The whole thing is a scam. We don't have enough gold backing the dollars in our economy.

Hiten Samtani (16:19)
I

mean the stock market in general is just a sentiment business.

Will Krasne (16:21)
Right. And the whole thing here in real estate, that one of the underpinnings of this podcast is narrative drives flows. And we've seen flows like we've never seen into the data center space because of this narrative. And a lot of that is driven by NVIDIA and by Jensen Huang.

Hiten Samtani (16:39)
You know who else reiterated what you just said? Lowell Barron of Brookfield. I saw him last week and he basically said the same thing. He he would know.

Will Krasne (16:46)
A good company. Yeah. That's the thing is the stories are not about the guy himself. It's what does he represent? Jensen represents this indomitable spirit. The whole story about his wife hocked her wedding ring. It's incredible. Make them make payroll. The stock has moved so spectacularly. There's some number of people at NVIDIA worth $100 million. And all of the fundraising that goes around this, if you're raising for a data center business that has nothing to do with NVIDIA directly, if you were

Raising for a company that was servicing data centers, if you were lending to data centers, the whole thing felt inevitable because you had a guy at the center of it who felt inevitable. Hear that, Pastor Anderson? That is the sound of inevitable. If that guy is gone, whoever steps up is going to be incredibly competent, incredibly capable. But that doesn't matter. Because what matters is the guy at the top. You have these magic guys and

Jensen Huang is one of them, and there's only a handful at any one time.

Hiten Samtani (17:48)
Steve Jobs and the Turtleneck, Jensen Huang and his leather jacket. It's the same mythical element that he brings with him.

Will Krasne (17:56)
The difference though, the economy has grown in such a way that it's almost hard to believe. Apple wasn't the largest tenant in America. Apple wasn't backstopping every hardware company that drove all of office leasing in San Francisco.

Hiten Samtani (18:13)
Apple wasn't also the most important venture capitalist in its space.

Will Krasne (18:17)
We've talked about San Francisco and how the office market is on fire. We've talked about New York and how the office market is as strong as it's ever been. What is driving that? It's AI and AI adjacent stuff. And all of that goes back to him. The downstream impacts of this scandal are massive for real estate. It's totally crazy.

Hiten Samtani (18:37)
When this broke, I was actually chatting with the very big deal maker at Newmark. He just sends me a text. He's like, not good for several reasons. That's it. It this comes back to that energy and forward momentum, which is so important in any aspect of real estate, but especially in an asset class where projects are multi-billion dollar multi-year build-outs like AI, data science.

Will Krasne (19:00)
One of my favorite lines I think you've ever had is that a condo sale is like an IPO and you have to like organize the deck shares and timing is everything. These projects are taking so long that it's just the longer you're in the market, there's only bad things that can happen for the most part. It's worth considering like all of the other things outside of data center directly or AI directly that are impacted by this. What's it going to mean for real estate fundraising? What's going to mean for real estate liquidity writ large? Because all of these different

Big firms have raised capital around data. Like Starwood Capital was a quarter hotel three funds ago. And now it's like a quarter data.

Hiten Samtani (19:36)
Center. Related Brookfield Blackstone's entire thesis. Yeah. Yeah.

Will Krasne (19:40)
If capital shies away from real estate, it's gotta go up.

Hiten Samtani (19:42)
elsewhere.

Yeah. The other part of this is NVIDIA might navigate the scandal just fine. But if this creates any sort of extra backstop, for example, there's a whole storm brewing about Howard Lutnick, who is our commerce secretary, and whether he did enough of a job to make sure that the chips were not going to China. And again, some of this is beyond our expertise. So we're just going to say what we know. But Howard Lutnick is under fire for that. What if it turns out that in the shakeout from all of this, there's greater attention paid to where

These chipmakers are sending their stuff. Is there any delay to any of that? Does that delay then create any further delay in the build outs the funding of these data center projects as well? Real estate doesn't love checks and balances.

Will Krasne (20:24)
It does not just think of the fantastic New Yorker article about Taiwan semiconductor. Literally a grain of sand can just like it's use the whole thing is useless. And that's really what we're looking at. It's all made up and relies on confidence. If you take anything away from this, it's just if that bowl gets pierced, you can't duct tape it back together.

Hiten Samtani (20:56)
Okay, let's go inside the cap stack with Gibson Dunn. Eric Mir from Gibson Dunn, welcome back to the promote. We're

Eric Meer (21:02)
Thanks for having me again.

Hiten Samtani (21:04)
talking pref today, which has become ubiquitous in cap stacks across the city. There are certain considerations that both sponsors and anyone who wants to get into the pref space as a provider should be keeping top of mind. So what are they?

Eric Meer (21:18)
Oftentimes preferred equity is a stand-in for an additional tranche of debt in the capital stack. And so it's helpful to think of a preferred equity provider as effectively just another lender. And that dynamic will color a lot of the negotiations.

Hiten Samtani (21:34)
How should Pref be thinking about their position in case of a default?

Eric Meer (21:38)
But it depends on when in the origination of the transaction the preferred is coming into the capital stack. If the preferred equity provider is coming in simultaneously with the closing of the mortgage loan and the mezzanine loan, then they're very much a junior lender in the capital stack and they should be treated as such. Just like a mortgage lender or mezzanine lender, a preferred equity provider should be entitled to assert its remedies upon a default. Now, a sponsor is going to be cognizant of the fact that.

Unlike a mortgage lender or mes lender, a preferred equity provider could take over control instantaneously.

Hiten Samtani (22:13)
The sponsor has always had at the back of their mind that they have a little time to figure things out, but when it comes to pref, that may not be the case.

Eric Meer (22:21)
Exactly. And so if we're representing the sponsor, we would oftentimes want, for instance, a lengthy period before the preferred equity provider has the ability to trigger a for sale, replicating the period of time that a mezzanine lender would have to take title through a UCC foreclosure. So the name of the game, if you're the sponsor, is to uh try to delay the point in time in which the preferred equity can take over the control of the property.

Hiten Samtani (22:48)
These cap stack dynamics are so fascinating. Eric, thank you so much for sharing them with us.

JP Conklin. Welcome back to the promote. Tell me about the conversations you've been having post-rate hike. I would imagine there's been a deluge of inquiry, concern, existential doubt since then. The most pressing question is: how many more hikes will there be? A lot of the discussion is around, I can probably live with two or three. Anything above that starts becoming pretty painful. And so a lot of the discussion that we're having with customers is how likely is it that we'll see more than 75 basis points of total tightening?

And I've been punting on things like selling or refinancing or even hedging decisions because I kept expecting rates to come back down and now I don't know what to do. But Pensford, you've been a hand on the shoulder for these investors for about 20 years now. What are some of the evergreen reflections you could apply? Because a lot of these people, this is their first dance. This is their first brush with this kind of pressure. The lender requirement shouldn't be their hedging strategy.

decide what is best for them and their business independent of what the lender is requiring. From there, let's have a discussion around what are your disposition plans and what is your risk tolerance. If something might cause you to not be able to sleep at night, let's try to that risk. JP Conklin, thank you so much for being with the promote.

This is the end of the medieval period and the beginning of the Renaissance.

Will Krasne (24:30)
Lorenzo Medici.

Hiten Samtani (24:33)
This is in fact KPC's John Petty. He is the chief lieutenant for a guy called Dr. Cali Chowdhury, one of the most interesting figures in the Los Angeles real estate game right now.

Will Krasne (24:43)
And that's really saying something giving what's going on in in Los Angeles. What we're talking about, of course, is Oceanwide Plaza in downtown LA. If you don't know the building and you're from LA, but you've ever noticed a gigantic, unfinished, graffiti-strewn hellscape.

Hiten Samtani (24:59)
Great story for us because it hits on so many of our threads. Foreign capital, foreign capital being gelded very suddenly and violently. And then the the Thank

Will Krasne (25:09)
By the way.

Hiten Samtani (25:10)
you. And the after-effect of all of that. So in 2014, as the Chinese did, this Chinese group came in really hot. They were called China Oceanwide Holdings, and they went on a buying spree across the West Coast. They bought

This site in Los Angeles and another giant site in San Francisco. They weren't just buying properties. They were looking to go full on ground up development, 11 out of 10 complexity. This was supposed to be a two million square foot, three tower mixed use complex, 500 condos and apartments, a five star hotel, and LA's answer to Times Square in terms of this monster signage everywhere. So they there they were going really big.

Will Krasne (25:52)
Let's put some numbers around other stuff that they bought. So Oceanwide Center and SF, they had a thing they liked, which was really gritty neighborhoods, incredibly complicated development. So they're buying in downtown LA, they're buying in the mission, and they're buying in the C

Hiten Samtani (26:04)
Technically great locations in terms of proximity.

Will Krasne (26:08)
If you've never set foot in any.

Hiten Samtani (26:10)
That's exactly right. It's one of those, oh, it's right next to X. Yeah. Should be great. But my God. They pumped in reportedly about a billion dollars into this project. And unfortunately for them, Beijing had other ideas, as we've talked about with Anbang and H A and all those other groups. Sometime in twenty eighteen or so, Beijing started cracking down on these gray rhinos. They started

really restricting capital outflows. Formerly flush companies were no longer so flush and oceanwide, it really impacted this project.

Will Krasne (26:44)
These things take decades, right? And they start in 2013 and 2019 work has already stalled. So this is pre-pandemic. And of course, I think L of all the like sort of major US cities, LA probably pretty bad has taken the longest to recover. Yeah. A tricky project and a tricky area with a pandemic. And then not really a recovery, and then a fire. And it's just been sitting there for years at this point. And Len Lease, who's the GC, one of a handful of GCs that do this super complicated.

high end stuff. This might be the biggest like mechanics lien I've ever seen.

Hiten Samtani (27:19)
Lenlease claims that they are owed over four hundred million dollars, which is astonishing on one project. It's it's absolutely crazy. Unfortunately a bunch of E B five investors got fucked here as well. Yeah.

Will Krasne (27:31)
That's tough. There is some upside though, which is that if you had a YouTube channel and were into bass jumping, this was a great place. uh

Hiten Samtani (27:44)
No buyer in their right mind, at least out of LA, typically would have gone for something like this. The lenders had hired Colliers and Hillco to market this project.

Will Krasne (27:53)
So that's the real signal here. Hillco's not selling super easy down the fairway projects. They're selling the craziest.

Hiten Samtani (28:03)
Imagine going to Bayern saying, hey, so we've got this giant mixed-to-use development in the heart of downtown LA. The good news is there's already been a billion dollars supposedly injected in the project. The bad news is there's another 800 million or so you need to pump in to finish this thing.

Will Krasne (28:20)
This is one of those projects too where you could spend a billion dollars and be like, Where did it go? What did you actually do?

Hiten Samtani (28:26)
Exactly.

Will Krasne (28:27)
This is also not a market where the market has been strong. There's been a spate of foreclosures or give backs on office deals.

Hiten Samtani (28:36)
We just saw that Brookfield walked away from a six hundred million dollar rental out there.

Will Krasne (28:40)
So it's not as if people are racing to, you know, put more money back into this. But with a project with a lot of visibility, you attract a certain kind of investor, more caution. Like after Frank McCourt, where he's sort of like attached to all of these projects, but like none of them ever seem to happen, but he always seems to make a lot of money. So

Hiten Samtani (29:00)
So KPC

One of those Los Angeles nebulous firms that just kind of exists and does real estate, founded by Dr. Callie Chowdry, who was an orthopedic surgeon who's since transitioned to more lucrative real estate ventures. And he made a play for 80 South Street, which was the oceanwide property in the Seaport. He was apparently in contract to buy it. However, it was next door to the leaning tower of Seaport. This leaning tower was encroaching in the site and

Kali Chowdhury was warned that hey, if you get into this project, any shenanigans from that one might impact you, so you're probably better off backing out, which he did. So Kali Chowdhury had to give up on his development dreams in Manhattan. So the next best thing he thought was this.

Will Krasne (29:52)
Hooray.

speaker-2 (29:53)
Well

Will Krasne (29:55)
The deal in a bankruptcy bid. It's five hundred million in cash and credit. I would love to know the split between cash and credit.

Hiten Samtani (30:03)
Petty, who's his lieutenant who's been speaking to the press, probably ill-advised interviews, because there's just like one after the other zinger, but he said, we're getting a little bit of Manhattan without having to go to Manhattan.

Will Krasne (30:17)
What does that even mean?

Hiten Samtani (30:21)
What do we know about Cali Chowdhury? If you had to describe him, what's his personality like?

According to his lieutenant again, he was described as a type A of a type A guy.

Will Krasne (30:35)
Type A squared. These deals attract a certain type of guy where like you wanna not just be a successful developer, you wanna be like a capital R, capital E, capital D real estate developer. And it's also too like what's the story of the capital?

Hiten Samtani (30:53)
We don't know the provenance of this guy's wealth. Uh I will say that he's apparently he's not in the money making business with this project, which is probably a good thing. According to Petty, his boss is in quote legacy mode. He is willing to sacrifice economics for something that he can be proud to have been a part of in creating. Essentially a trophy type property in downtown Los Angeles. Not the best signs to go into a project, not the best signal to send an LP or a lender, I would think.

Will Krasne (31:18)
Correct. Legacy mode, particularly when there's not really a lot of other projects. The legacy of what?

Hiten Samtani (31:26)
He has been sniffing around this property for a while. In twenty twenty three, he had made a trip to China to try to bid directly with Oceanwide at the time to get this property, but they were asking apparently too much. So he waited around. He bought a piece of the EB5 debt, which was clever. He's like, I I'll get into the mix that way. And then this auction happened and he was probably the only serious

Will Krasne (31:47)
Doing these types of projects, they've sort of become the realm of solely, you know, the related, the Brookfields, the those types of firms that have super long capital base outside of a fund structure. Obviously, Brookfield has a lot of funds, but like the SMA capital dudes would be outside of it. The way for someone private to get in there is to step into something like this. Super hairy, tons of complexity. And it's also gotta be I think this is the most important part.

A market that people don't want to be in right now for whatever reason. But you could sort of see through the trees and say 10 years from now, this thing will have completely flipped and there's a right tail outcome here that's extraordinary. Those elements are here. I'm obviously not saying that a massive, complicated mixed-use development in downtown Los Angeles will be successful. But if you are an individual guy, this is the only way you can ever get your hands on one of them. For a certain type of folk, maybe that's worth the risk.

Hiten Samtani (32:42)
I like the city element here when we talk about real estate being so interesting because it's not a linear business. There's like a thing that matters so much to one party, which is inconsequential to the other. In this case, the city of Los Angeles, the most important thing for them when it came to approving a buyer here was that whoever it is agrees to clean up the graffiti. Because Karen Bass and the mayor could go back to her constituents and say, We're cleaning up the city. And that was the condition of the sale here. Pretty amazing.

Will Krasne (33:10)
It's just wild sometimes what these pressure points or bugaboos are 'cause it's just inconsequential to the deal, but optics are everything.

Hiten Samtani (33:20)
They are. I am very skeptical that this guy is going to close and I'm very skeptical that he's going to make anything out of it. But I I wish him the best because I love pirates like this. They really get my juices flowing. But what I loved about this is it shows that penis envy is still very much a thing. Development is not a rational enterprise. You're not doing it because you're putting in X and getting, you know, 1.8. You're doing this because you want to build a dream and you want to have a name and be somebody if you're not somebody. And I love that this is.

How it plays out sometimes.

Will Krasne (33:51)
It's true. Every building you see in whatever city you're in was built by some crazy guy who

Hiten Samtani (33:57)
Who fought

Will Krasne (33:59)
The entropy of the world to create something. So you have to tip your cap to that and you love the romance of it. You don't get a chance to get your hands on this big a chunk of a major city. So you can see why in the boardrooms of Oceanwide in Beijing it made sense. But you gotta remember, you know, if you're not from a city to go do a major project and you don't have super boots on the ground, you are just looking to get your face ripped off in a lot of cases.

Hiten Samtani (34:27)
In projects like these, it is often the third buyer who makes the money, who brings it home. Motion White was the first. Doctor Chowdry, if he closes, will be the second. So dot dot dot.

That's it for the promote pod this week. Carnal Excess has taken down many a man. Will it this time take down an entire industry? And one of America's biggest development mysteries is beginning its next act under a Maverick Conductor.

Will Krasne (34:58)
Thank you again to our sponsors. Without which we would just be two guys talking into mics in the ether. Bravo Capital, who you can find at BravoCapital.com.

Hiten Samtani (35:07)
Pensford, who you can find at pensford.com.

Will Krasne (35:10)
And HEquities at agequities dot com.

Hiten Samtani (35:13)
Thanks again also to our friends at Gibson Dunn. oh

Will Krasne (35:16)
I'd just

like to say too that the Gibson Dunn conversations, you can only find them on this podcast. They're actually incredibly valuable, incredibly meaningful for GPs. This is not a why is this the often the best? It's very specific examples of things that can trip you up if you're trying to build your own business. I find it very useful. So thanks, Gibson Dunn.

Hiten Samtani (35:35)
A little bit of inside baseball in the pod. One of the things we're working towards. I hate using the word in insights for minutes because it makes us sound like VC douchebags, but I love the idea that anything we put on this podcast is both entertaining and valuable and that includes our partner content. So thank you for noticing. Of course. I will see you next week. Thanks, man.

Will Krasne (35:54)
Thank you.

Hiten Samtani (35:55)
Ciao.