Every Friday, join us as we dive into the latest in real estate multifamily with David Moghavem, Head of East Coast Acquisitions at Trion Properties. David invites top experts who know the ins, outs, and trends shaping the real estate multifamily market across the nation!
Whether you’re a seasoned investor or just curious about where the next big opportunity might be, Deal Flow Friday brings you the weekly inside scoop on what’s hot, what’s not, and what to watch for in today’s ever-evolving real estate scene.
David Moghavem (00:02)
All right, welcome to another episode of Deal Flow Friday. I'm your host, Dave Mulgavum. Today we have Mark Kenny, the co-founder and CEO of Think Multifamily. Mark has over 30 plus years of operating experience, including more than 120 multifamily deals, 18,000 units, and more than 1 billion in closed transactions across 15 states. He's exited 20 deals in 2020 alone, and he's been very open about.
how the downturn's been for the market and for him personally. And today Mark coaches and advises operators through deal level problems. And he's written books and advice for operators like ourselves in the industry. So Mark, it's a pleasure to have you on.
Mark Kenney (00:51)
Thanks, Dave. I'm glad to be on.
David Moghavem (00:54)
Great. Mark, maybe give a little more context on who you are, what you do, and kinda how you got into the industry. Go from there.
Mark Kenney (01:03)
Yeah, sure. So I live in North Dallas, but I grew up in in Michigan and I have a dentical twin brother. And we were in we were seniors in college and for whatever reason we were we were like, Hey, we we think real estate's a good good thing, right? We didn't know anybody doing it, we didn't really know anything about it, other than we know you know, people need a place to live. So we started looking at properties actually when I was twenty one and mostly two to four unit properties. And we bought a property when we were still in
College, rehabbed it, and then you we both end up working, you know, corporate jobs. I was a I graduated in county, I was CPA for a while, did manager consulting and got married young too, ⁓ like a year after college. And so my wife and I were buying properties as well together. And it was kind of one of those things where still working full time and buying, you know, small properties. fast forward, you know, I was
I was doing IT consulting. I started IT company 2008 and 2013. you know, I was just working like crazy. Like people say they work a lot. I mean, it was, you know, 80 to 100 hours a week consistently, and it was causing some issues, you know, with with my wife and stuff for never never being home. So we started looking at doing syndications, fancy word, you know, investing with other people to buy bigger deals and pull your capital together.
invested passively on a couple deals with a friend and then another guy I met and then twenty fifteen we started doing our own syndications, raising capital buying deals and that during that period of time, you know, took a took a little while to find our first deal and then we kinda started getting them very quickly. Started closing a lot of deals and that's how we closed, you know, like a hundred and twenty deals.
David Moghavem (02:56)
Yeah, and twenty fifteen really I I think that's when the Jobs Act passed, right? And
That was really the renaissance of crowdfunding and syndication. And you had a lot of companies kind of grow from that. I mean, even try on ourselves. We really took advantage of that syndication platform, crowdfunding, essentially investing with operators that maybe you've never met, but you get to see who they are, what their track record is for the first time, and build trust through ⁓ that. The 50.
one C three, right? Investing and being able to solicit through a bunch of people. So it really grew out of it. But then what we saw now is our first downturn through that kind of renaissance. So maybe talk through what you went through, what the market went through and kind of lessons learned.
Mark Kenney (03:54)
Yeah, so historically we had bought properties that were, you know, value add, and everybody probably has a different opinion what value add is. But we bought some properties that were like zero percent occupied, thirty percent occupied. I'm talking very distressed. You're not gonna go get you're not gonna get Fannie Freddy, you know, loans on those deals. They're not they don't qualify, they're not in a position. Plus, reality is that, you know, you're gonna need a c lot of capital, generally speaking, on those big value add deals and
David Moghavem (04:23)
Right.
Mark Kenney (04:23)
So we were getting a lot of you know bridge loans. ⁓ and they were, you know, they're very from two to five years, generally speaking, as far as loan term. ⁓ rates were good at the time. They were giving us, you know, 70 to 80 percent of our you know purchase price plus all cap X. So all in, I mean, you could, you know, get a a big chunk just from a ⁓ from a lender. And we had
Exited a bunch of those deals, you know, you rehab ⁓ you either refinance or sell them, and you know, in the heyday you're you're doing really, really well on those deals. ⁓ almost no matter where you where you were. It was just a function of that. And in you know, twenty twenty two, we we owned a number of properties, but we bought a lot in twenty twenty two and we bought one in twenty twenty-three. And again, a lot of those were on the floating rate debt and you know, floating rate meaning
It went from, you know, in the fours typically for interest rate up to, you know, ten, eleven, twelve percent interest rate. And you know, a lot of people say, well, you can do what's called a rate cap, not cap rate, but rate cap. It's basically insurance protection, how high your rate can go. That didn't that didn't protect a lot of people either. In reality, is even if you got that, then you have to renew it, you know. So during twenty twenty-three really, still we had some properties that started
David Moghavem (05:26)
Right. Right.
Mark Kenney (05:49)
you know, having issues where ⁓ you know, rents were stagnant and or some cases negative, people had not paid, you know, in a lot of cases as far as tenants, and our interest rate had moved, you know, two, three hundred percent. And that's real money, right? So you quickly you quickly burned through your your reserves in those situations. And and we did. And we were looking at, okay, now what do we do? And there were some properties we were able to refinance.
David Moghavem (06:05)
Yeah.
Mark Kenney (06:18)
some, you know, and we'll get into a little bit, but you're using kind of information you have at the time and some cases using information you think of what's going to happen in the in the future. Short term is relative and reality is it's it's somewhat a mistake, in my opinion, ⁓ doing that. I'm not saying you can't rely on things in the future because we're all in business, you have to do that. But you know, there was a term, you know, floating around, survive the 2025.
David Moghavem (06:45)
Yeah.
Mark Kenney (06:46)
persist to twenty twenty six. Now our twenty twenty seven is still horrible. Right. So those deals, you know, gave us problems. And, you know, I dumped investors too, right? But I dumped a bunch of money, like w really too much money into deals trying to save them thinking the market was going to turn. And, you know, we were buying a bigger deal. So you're not talking, you know, 10, $20,000 deficits. You know, you're talking tens in some cases, you know,
David Moghavem (06:50)
Yeah.
Mark Kenney (07:13)
across their portfolio hundreds of thousands of dollars of deficits on a monthly basis. And, you know, in some cases you could work with a lender and that's relative what you mean by work with a lender. And maybe they would say, okay, we'll g do like a loan modification. And that's different from every lender. And a lot of people I think have gotten stuck doing that and now are getting caught again because a lot of those things were for short periods of time.
12, 18, 24 months, and a lot of those deals are now having problems that are resurfacing again. So, you know, for us, it was it was hard because we have never been anything, you know, to that level before. You're you're s you want to do the right thing, right? I mean, and you know, we can we can all argue people that probably out there that you've seen out there doing things they shouldn't be doing. Okay, that's that's an obvious thing. You shouldn't be doing stealing money. Let's be
Nobody would say, that's that's a good thing to do. But the right thing means you know meaning like I'm gonna dump all my money I have into these properties trying to save it before I go back to investors and ask for any capital, and then looking at a property and saying, Well, I think, you know, we can get to, you know, another twelve months of runway on this. Well, reality is even that that was not enough time because in a lot of cases you fast forward twelve months from, you know,
mid twenty twenty three to let's say mid twenty twenty four, the the market was no better, right? It was it was getting worse at the time. And what the problem is it wasn't a matter of like, well, hey, why don't you just sell the property? Well, I mean, obviously, if we could sell it, and you know, you have to make those tough decisions. If you could sell a property and even lose all your equity but pay the lender off, that was actually, you know, pretty, pretty common for a lot of deals.
But there were all it was also very common where try to sell the deal, you can't even pay your loan off. There would not be any proceeds to pay the loan off. And not this isn't like a you know sing it digit percentage type stuff. This is a high, high percentage of deals, you know, that would not be able to be sold in 2024 or 2025, pay the
David Moghavem (09:16)
Right.
throughout the nation at this point, especially where Treasuries got to and now starting to pull back a bit. I think you had you brought up a great point. You know, we were only working off the information we had at the time. And the rhymes and reasons, survive tool 25, all sounded great, but the reality is there was no evidence that that was actually going to come to fruition. And as someone when you were buying a deal with bridge debt to do a value add plan, ⁓
Whether you got 80 LTC versus 60, you thought you were being more conservative at 60. The truth is we're so deep in a down cycle that even the people who didn't take as much bridge level leverage are still in the same position. ⁓ so what does this look like in reality? Is kind of what you talked about. At first, you wanted to save the deal because you wanted to do a fiduciary duty as an operator to save each deal. You wanted to be a stewardess of other people's capital.
But then it gets to a point where not only are you potentially throwing good money after bad, but you're starting to deter or starting to deteriorate the the functionality of your own company that needs liquidity to continue doing more deals, continue to operate, continue to manage effectively. And so there's always a push and pull between putting a deal in a vacuum that you have a bunch of investors in and saying, what's best for the deal? Okay, I'll throw money at
Problem to try to give it more time versus, hey, let's look at this holistically. Are we throwing good money after bad money? Are we compromising the opco in trying to save deals one by one? ⁓ and so again, hindsight's 2020, but now that we're four years deep in this down cycle, you start to see how maybe we should have talked to the lenders earlier and asked for that loan mod. Maybe we should have thrown the keys earlier.
and not been shy or bashful about it. ⁓ I think that's one of the biggest lessons, kind of at least for us, ⁓ in this downturn, where it's okay to maybe broach that and see where the puck is going rather than trying to hope and pray for the best.
Mark Kenney (11:45)
No, for sure. And if you you know, you've been through it, it wasn't just rates, right? We had insurance costs that were going up, you know, Florida was two, three hundred percent increases. We had one in in South Texas, went up six hundred percent, you know, one point two to three point six million ⁓ in a matter of one year. Like that's those are real numbers. It's like you you can't make those, you know, you can't make the deal work.
David Moghavem (11:51)
Mm-hmm.
Right. With with higher risk now in insurance and all at the same time lack of capital in the reinsurance markets. That kind of spiked that up too. And then obviously as multifamily supply. I mean, supply arguably, depending on which market you're in, is probably worse than rates in terms of valuations and and devaluing properties.
Mark Kenney (12:20)
Mm-hmm.
Right. And you you know, as far as the information, you know, you had available at the time, we were, you know, prior to twenty twenty two, you could go to, you know, three or four brokers, say, Hey, what do think this property is worth? Right. And let's say they they say, okay, they all come in nine and a half, ten million. You pretty much but prior to that, this it's gonna basically trade or sell that that amount. Like that was pretty much almost a given. You fast forward to like twenty twenty three, twenty four, twenty five, ⁓ f five got better, but
David Moghavem (12:52)
Mm-hmm.
Mark Kenney (12:59)
23 and 2024, I mean, lenders were like, I'm sorry, bar brokers were like, this property is worth whatever, $24 million, and offers are coming in at 17. Like those, those are real numbers, right? We another one that was like 15 million offers coming in at 10 and a half. It's not, it's only worth someone's gonna pay for it, right? You know? And so, you know, that was the other thing. We were, this property should be worth X when it's stabilized.
So that would be, you know, a reason you say, hey, may you put money in. You go through it enough times. And I, you know, you mentioned I talked to a lot of people too. And I'm not giving, you know, people legal advice or anything like that, but I can look at the deal and you know, from going through it, we actually I exited 30 deals between 2024 and 2025. And some of those deals ⁓ we exited, we didn't even try to bring capital into them because we're like it it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever to bring capital in. Now
Unfortunately, it took us a number of deals, frankly, to get to that. to meaning we were like, okay, now we're we're smarter now. We've seen this, we've seen this movie before and we see what happens. And it it's amazing in a bad way how fast a property can deteriorate when you run out of money. You can live how how how fast a property's like operations and condition can deteriorate and when you run out of money. So
David Moghavem (14:14)
How fast, sorry, I couldn't hear that.
Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Right.
Mark Kenney (14:24)
You know, it could be 90 some percent occupied, you run out of money and you fast forward, you know, four four to eight weeks and you're you're in the 70s. You know, you can't even turn units, meaning you can't even get them ready for for new tenants to come in and and things like that. So once you run out of money, it's ⁓ it happens very quickly after that, the negative impact that it will have on a
David Moghavem (14:32)
Mm-hmm.
Right. Well, going back to one of your first points of how we were in a time in these past couple of years in twenty four, twenty-five, where bid ask spread was as wide as ever. BOVs coming in ⁓ at one price and then offers coming in minimum ten percent below that, if not more, due to the volatility and ⁓ and the uneasiness in the economy coupled with just market, you know, market of multifamily and supply issues. ⁓
Fast forward to today, I think what you're starting to see is a lot more capitulation on the seller side with some of that ⁓ loan mods that were potentially available, working out with lenders starting to meet its, you know, hit a wall on the road and a fork in the road, and they're trying to actually dispose of the assets and liquidate and move on and recycle that that capital. Are you starting to see some of that? And
As someone who had to play a lot of defense these past two, three years, are you trying to focus now getting back on offense on some of those opportunities? And and how are you doing it if so?
Mark Kenney (16:00)
Yeah, it's probably so d I'm seeing it a lot, like you mentioned, and you know, to put things in perspective, as you as you mentioned, maybe BOV pricing was, you know, ten ten percent off in some cases more than that. But it wasn't even that. It was like when you look at what a property was selling for in, you know, parts of Florida in twenty twenty two and you fast forward to twenty twenty four and cap rates went from, you know, four point four percent to seven and a half percent.
You compl you're completely upside down. Like you keep you cannot sell for your note. It's impossible. It's not an option. So what I'm seeing, I get called on a regular basis. And you know, people think it's bridge, bridge, bridge. I'm getting called on a regular basis of agency debt that's in trouble, like a lot. And ⁓ probably for the first time in quite a while, like probably for the last two years, where I'm like, ⁓ it's hard to look like there's probably some some opportunities.
David Moghavem (16:33)
Right, right.
Mm-hmm.
Mark Kenney (16:58)
out there and you know, maybe pick a number, maybe it's only one in a hundred, but it was, you know, one in a five thousand, you know, a year ago or two years ago. So
David Moghavem (17:08)
Right. It's definitely more now than it was, you know, past other cyc ⁓ years of of this down cycle. And
Mark Kenney (17:13)
Yeah. And we we have a little less ⁓ I don't want to say volatility, but a little less volatility. Meaning when interest rates were going up during, you know, twenty twenty three and tw and two and things like that, you know, they went up drastically. Now, like you mentioned, the ten year, yeah, it's kinda gone up, it's gone down, it's kinda, you know, whatever, r roughly five ish, been a little bit lower, been a little higher. But it's not gonna most likely not gonna go from
you know, five and go up to eight. And it's probably not gonna go five down to two. Well, we saw 300 plus basis point increases in, you know, in short period of time. So I think you have a little bit more of that. the other thing learned a lot is like what what ⁓ it's not just the state, it's actually the county level. What are the counties doing? What did they do even do during COVID, you know, prior to this? How do they react for evictions and things like that? That became very important ⁓ that lesson. And then
What are they doing on property taxes? You know, we have a a deal that's, you know, roughly worth ten million dollars. Our properties, you know, taxes have been assessed for four years, frozen for ten million, and they tried to raise it twenty one million dollars this year. But I mean, and people there's no logic, right? I mean, there's there's nothing to support it.
David Moghavem (18:31)
Yeah. And it costs and it costs money to appeal it and it costs time and yeah, it's it's
Mark Kenney (18:35)
That's right. ⁓ And you might have your lender might require you to escrow the full amount anyways. Meaning if you could say, well, hey, we don't we're not you don't think you have to pay that much, you might Well, hey, we don't know if you don't, you're not gonna have to, so we're gonna make you escrow the full amount. So but yeah, I do see that the little bit less volatility and rates, for example. We're, you know, personally smarter on which counties, how they reacted during COVID, how they reacted for property taxes.
David Moghavem (18:41)
Right.
Mark Kenney (19:03)
which areas got hit the hardest with, you know, insurance increases and you you kind of scale it down and say, okay, well, you know, you can never eliminate all your risk. You can eliminate some risk for a period of time, get a fixed rate, you know, for whatever seven, ten years. Okay, it's fixed. We know we know what it is. But and there are other things that you can't necessarily eliminate, but you can reduce your risk by, you know, maybe buying in areas where property taxes
Haven't been going up like, you know, crazy stupid ⁓ historically, right? And maybe where insurance costs have been more stable and not going, you know, up two, three hundred percent or more. So you can kind of mitigate some of your your risk there. But I do believe, like you're saying, that there are definitely some deals out there. ⁓ most deals right now, I mean, if if the deal can essentially get the loan amount even today, that's and you can step in and take over.
At the loan amount, a lot of deals make sense today. Some still don't make sense. Capital. Right.
David Moghavem (20:04)
Right. Without you're saying without putting in the the capital, right? Just going 100 LTV essentially at the loan mount and trying to operate your way into getting, you know, potentially selling outside of it. The the question there is, you know, you have to bank on a sale.
You have to bank on a sale at that point because it is too over levered. ⁓ sometimes the loan amount at 100 LTV, ⁓ even the stabilized debt yield doesn't get you to where you would need to be able to refi and hold long. And so the question then becomes can you come up with some sort of A B structure where you split the loan and it depends on the lender and how they've collateralized it or not, or if it's on the balance sheet and some are willing to work more than others. I think a big
Component of that is are you a good operator? Is that someone because you know at that point it's a partnership? It's not, you're not just selling it to someone, it's a real partnership. so I think there's creative solutions out there and imp very different than what you and I were working on pre-rate hike of buying, you know, maybe a shell or a four cap or three cap, renovating to a six yield on cost or so, new counters, stainless steel appliances.
Mark Kenney (21:21)
Right.
David Moghavem (21:25)
⁓ get a higher rent and sell it for a lower cap rate than your yield on cost. I feel like that business is gonna be over for a long time, to be to be quite honest.
Mark Kenney (21:34)
I do too. I do too. And your point is w I mean, for me personally, he if I could step into a deal and it's gonna be, you know, a a two, three year horizon, that's not a long enough horizon for me. It's I mean, no, I could be hon Right, right, right. I mean it it ⁓ don't get me wrong, ⁓ you could probably do pretty good on those deals, right? I'm not arguing that point.
David Moghavem (21:47)
Right. Which makes those loan balance deals even tougher, right?
Mark Kenney (22:02)
And you know, some cases people might just honestly come in with cash and just say, well, we'll sell it and exit it down the road, and cap rates think we'll go down and we're in it with no equity essentially. ⁓ so yeah, it's not a long enough horizon for me. And to me, right now, if the deal doesn't cash flow day one, it doesn't have to be necessarily cash flow a lot with with adjusted expenses, meaning like what are my expenses that I know are gonna change, like property taxes or insurance and things like that.
David Moghavem (22:06)
Yeah.
Mark Kenney (22:32)
And with, you know, basically more cash base, you know, revenue, not accrual where, you know, you're counting for stuff you never even received. People get make that mistake a lot too. So if it can cash flow with, you know, actual collections today without changing anything and adjusted expenses, then those are deals for one, they're gonna qualify for agency debt more than likely, all things being equal long term, and you can ⁓ you know.
Maybe cash flows, deals, and have a long runway.
David Moghavem (23:05)
What kind of cash on cash going in is getting you or your capital partners excited in this environment? Because risk free, right? Risk free right now, or you put in a CD is five plus. And so what the ro the the issue we're always running into is.
Mark Kenney (23:15)
Five plus. Yeah.
David Moghavem (23:21)
If you're lower going in on that, it's very hard to justify. Obviously, there's tax reason, bad tax benefits with real estate, and there's appreciation. But if you're not getting to a cash on cash that's close to a liquid, risk-free type of an alternative investment like a CD, then it's really hard to get investors excited.
Mark Kenney (23:45)
Yeah, it's hard. And plus if you're not even if you don't even have like a current pay on it or it's partial current pay. So I agree. I mean, you know, the whole a lot of people will jump to it for you mentioned the tax benefits, but I can tell you well over 90% of the investors and syndicators don't really understand the way taxes work. ⁓ they don't. So I'm not saying there aren't any advantages to it, because there are, but if you don't understand, you know, recapture and
The way it comes back and people, you could literally put a hundred grand into a deal, lose all your money and still get taxed. And people are like, Well, how could that be? You know, and if you don't understand the difference, you don't necessarily you're a CPA, that's the other problem. I, you know, if you say, Well, hey, I don't understand that, that's fine, but most CPAs don't either, you know, understanding like they're like, you got a gang. You didn't get a gang. It's just it's recapture, right? And
David Moghavem (24:22)
Yeah.
Mark Kenney (24:39)
All those things and it's split up and you can actually be taxed. You know, people say at twenty five percent. You can actually be taxed on all the the recapture, you know, back to your capital account going set back to zero. You can be taxed at 37.5%. People are like, well, that's not true. Well, no, it is. Go look at it. You have twelve thirty-one, twelve fifty, twelve forty-five. So people are very unpleasantly surprised on some of these deals that didn't perform and then getting hit with you know, tax impact. As a GP, you're getting
Literally crucified if you run out of net operating losses, which I did, and then you're trying to, you know, you're selling deals with no profit and you're getting recaptured on all all those capital counts.
David Moghavem (25:19)
Because because you cost because you did an accelerated cost segregation, right? And you accelerated the depreciation. And so if you're selling a property that you've already accelerated all the depreciation.
And you have nothing to necessarily offset that recapture if you're going for to buy something else, you're gonna get stuck with the back. Yeah. And your CPA, you said to your CPA?
Mark Kenney (25:38)
Right. Yeah. ⁓ yeah, I mean not practicing, but I I went for accounting, became a CPA, worked for the big four, but yeah, not not I I don't practice anything, but I I definitely understand the tax side better than it probably
David Moghavem (25:49)
It it helps. I mean it
Yeah, I I think what's interesting too is coming out of this downturn. ⁓ and we just talked about before of how we were buying properties, flipping them, three to five year holds, renovating them. I think there's so many better ways at this point in time of making money shorter term in that horizon. And real estate really the beauty of it is the tax benefits.
And kind of the long-term appreciation of it. And so, at least for myself, if I had to build a company today, I'd probably stray away from some of the three to five year shorter term fix and flip and bank on an exit to hit my IRR and think more about cash flow and tax benefits and being able to hurt long term. Yeah.
Mark Kenney (26:45)
Hundred percent. I mean cash flow would be yep. And you know, the issue you run into a little bit is that most people didn't want to hold properties or claim they don't want to hold properties that long, right? Then through a a syndication. I mean, it used to always be five years, then it was like people, you know, we had like one that was like fourteen months we doubled our money, right? I mean
David Moghavem (27:02)
Yeah. But the incentive structure incentivizes to sell, right? With a promote and carried interest. And so I think operators in general in our industry might need to just take a harder look on what incentive structure should look like in order to incentivize the true benefits of real estate multifamily, which is tax benefits and cash flow. whether that's participation in some of the cash flow as an operator or
Mark Kenney (27:07)
Dusk. Yeah.
David Moghavem (27:31)
being able to have ⁓ exchanges. ⁓ because I think a lot of syndicators and investors who invested with syndicators got burned through this, through this rate hike. And so I think a lot of operators just need to take a harder look on how do we restructure or pivot? Because if you continue trying to do this, this business plan, I don't know if you'll be able to A, raise enough capital and B, be able to see a promote.
Mark Kenney (27:58)
Yeah, and it it's starting all over again. I mean, I talk to people that are back in it, right? Trying to trying to do the same things or and or rescue capital for their own deals. And I think a lot of those guys probably get caught, you know, through a portfolio type thing. But ⁓ yeah, I think the long term for me, the older I've gotten, I'm like, dude, yeah, like I like the idea of holding stuff for a long, long time. But you have to be capitalized to do that too, because you know, you're gonna have repairs, you're gonna have certain things.
you know, HVAC goes out, maybe the you know, you have to replace your roofs. Let's say maybe they have ten years left on them and in ten years fast forward replacing roofs. You know, you're talking, you know, most cases hundreds of thousands of dollars to to do those things. So you have to be a lot smarter about it, or buying better assets and putting money away and not distributing everything. But, you know, like you mentioned exchanges, if you get smart about that and and wait till, you know, frankly you die, and then you still have the properties and you're in better position.
that way too. Not to mention just the sheer fees associated with it. I mean, it is insane how much money goes in just from a closing cost standpoint. When you buy a property and you sell a property and you add that up, you're like, holy cow, man, like just between the buy and sale side, it's it's crazy. You know how much you're putting how much you're spending just on that. Now a lot of those deals there's fine, right? Because you're still selling and making huge profits.
David Moghavem (29:16)
Yeah
Mark Kenney (29:24)
and then you have other things too, like, you know, people think all long term fixed rate debt. Well, if you did want to exit for some reason and you don't get the proper, you know, debt, even if it's banny, things like that, and you have like yield maintenance or some of the other ones or defeasance and things like that. That's just a prepayment penalty. That's all it is. But you know, we had one deal, I think in probably I'm trying to think when we did sell it. We sold it, I think, in twenty twenty two. And it was ⁓
eight point three million dollar loan. So pretty small overall. And our prepayment penalty is like two point four million. Yeah. Two point four yeah. And now if we had that same loan on a bridge, prepayment penalty basically zero or maybe one percent. I mean on the exit. There's not, you know, after you hold it usually isn't even a prepayment penalty. Paying exit.
David Moghavem (30:11)
Yeah, there's a there's a fine line of of security of a fixed rate perm loan versus getting a bridge with flexibility. I think one of the strategies kind of coming out of this that I like is just paying up for a flex prepay adder on some of the agency stuff and just having a little bit of a higher rate in exchange for flexibility because you can't time the market, but if you have a longer window of having a
smaller prepayment penalty, it allows you to be a little more flexible in navigating through the environment. That said, you know, even if like we we got a few fixed rate loans ⁓ during the ZERP era in 2020, 2021, we did even seven year debt. And with how impacted the market is today, we, you know, you we did everything right. We got fixed rate debt, we got a low loan and we did f flex prepay.
Mark Kenney (30:46)
Yeah.
yeah.
David Moghavem (31:09)
And we're still, you know, running into some issues. And I think it speaks to what you were just saying, whether you were buying ADLTC or somewhere in the middle or even agency, everything is now impaired in some way, shape, or form.
Mark Kenney (31:24)
Right. And I think you brought up a good point too around basically knowing anytime you have unknown, right? The more unknowns you can make known. So you could say, what does that mean? Well, with a yield maintenance or defeasance, you have no idea what your prepay is going to be. ⁓ in like zero. You have no idea. Now it'll calculate it today based what they think it's going to be, but that that's meaningless. That's not reality. Versus getting one, let's say a Freddie step down where it's maybe.
five five, four, four, three, three, or whatever it might be, right? But you know, meaning like they're it's it's a known prepay. Yeah, it could be high, but it's known, but it goes down also over time. And there are there are a lot of private credit type ⁓ loans right now that are they're five years, so not super long, but they have ⁓ you know, yield maintenance for like the first maybe twenty four to thirty six months. So it's really high, right? If you get out within the first two or three years and then it goes down to like maybe two percent, one percent, like type thing. So
It's it's a knowing. ⁓ it's it's when you're getting in these situations and you're like, I need a rate cap, for example. And you know, rate caps went up at one point in time, went up thirty four hundred percent. I mean a hundred million yeah, a hundred million dollar loan was like ninety eight thousand dollars for a rate cap and it went to like three point four two million, you know, two years ago.
David Moghavem (32:32)
Right.
If you have a Freddy floater that they're impounding and then they, you know, during rate caps were so cheap and then rates rates rose and you look at your bill and you say, Wow, my impound has 10X. How did this happen? It's crazy. Yeah.
Mark Kenney (32:52)
That's legit. That that is that it's legit. And that's the thing about it too. You mentioned you mentioned, you know, Freddie or whatever. And the reality is everyone's like, Fannie, Freddie, good. Bridge, bad. No, there are a lot of people on floaters on the agency loans too. And, you know, so and like you mentioned, you do everything, you know, on paper and even reality, do everything right, as much as possible, like fixed rate, long term, et cetera. And you're like still like, well, man, we're
With this downturn lasting so long, we're still, you know, potentially, you know, screwed on some of these these things, right? And so the longer term you can get, I I like the idea of holding. I mean, there's some HUD loans that are, you know, 35 years and there's some you know, there's some advantages and disadvantages to those. We've done it a couple times. ⁓ but you know, at least you know what your prepay is, you know that it's 35 year fixed, you know, there's no interest only, so it's all amortized and they're harder to sell and things like that. But
If your plan is, hey, I'm gonna hold this property for like just long, long time and I'll put money aside for cap capital improvements, things like that, and hold it till I die and give it to my kids, ⁓ probably pretty good investment.
David Moghavem (34:03)
Right. So, Mark, you're advising clients as well, your coaching operators, it sounds like you've written a few books.
⁓ my question to you is in this moment in time, what are the biggest struggles that your clients are kind of reaching out to you and getting your input for and how are you advising them?
Mark Kenney (34:24)
Yeah. I'll make one comment about the book. The book's definitely the main one is around, you know, lessons learned. And it is not like a rah-rah, look at me. It's like, hey, I got my butt handed to me and here's some lessons, right? And the biggest thing I run into, I mean, it's common, like getting called all the time. We're like, hey, we can't we can't make our mortgage payment. What do I do? And am I gonna sit, you know, def I would ask a slew of questions, right? But, you know.
Are you better off paying your mortgage? Are you better off paying a vendor that has a lien in the property? Are you better off, you know, what is your exposure, right? Understanding your exposure. But there are a lot of deals right now that people are like, hey, should I put money into it or not? And I'm ever I'm never gonna tell anyone, hey, yes or no. I'll tell you what I would do if was in your shoes. And looking at it, and a lot of these people, I mean, there's some big, big syndicators I'm talking to.
But a lot of them really haven't been through it navigating it. And it's you you do learn a lot. Like you're like, hey, you need to take the emotion out of this. You need to take out the whole idea of like pie in the sky, la la land. It's like this is a reality. And a lot of people don't even know their current reality. Meaning, one guy reached out to me at a deal in Nashville. It was a $29 million purchase price, $23 million alone. The property's worth about $12.5 million. Like legit, no joke.
David Moghavem (35:47)
⁓ my god.
Mark Kenney (35:50)
And ⁓ his 17 months left on a family loan because he had bought it and took over the loan and wondering whether you should put money into the deal and things like that, right? You know, without telling with you know, you have to have a bunch of other questions. But reality is, I said, hey, send me your mortgage statement, your rent roll T12. But I said I want cash and accrual base basis both. So for July of 2026, if you look at the cash base.
T12 profit loss versus the accrual, there was $127,000 difference in NOI between cash versus accrual. Dude, you don't even, I don't think he, I'm not exaggerating, I might be critical. I don't think he even knew what the difference between cash and accrual was. So I'm not being critical of him and saying, like, dude, you don't even know where you're at in this property. Like you have no clue your current position. And then people look at, my NOI is this, my mortgage is that. What about all the stuff below the line?
David Moghavem (36:32)
Right, yeah, yeah.
Mark Kenney (36:45)
Meaning like CapEx and you know attorney fees might be a little there and other fees, right? So yeah no I NOI could even be, you know, meeting one point two five that the agencies want, and you're still in trouble. So ⁓ the biggest thing is, I mean, it's not like, hey, I need help improving my property a little bit. It's like, hey, you know, one guy called me a six properties, put three million of his dollars of his own money in the properties, told him a year ago, stop put stop putting money into it when he's at about a million.
And all six properties are defaulting. And so it's those, you know, you there's a number of questions, you know, you can ask to first get a current understanding of the current operations, which a lot of operatives don't really have. Then it's taking a step back and saying, you know, there are there are some deals here and there where like, man, this kind of makes sense. You could do a refile, you put some money into it and things like that. But it's all it's not like, you know.
I need little help. It's like this property's falling apart. And you know, the one guy, his his occupancy average was seventy two percent, you know, across his deals. I know a guy right now too that, you know, he he bought a bunch of deals and it's a it's eight deals and he's running negative six hundred and sixty one thousand dollars a month right now in negative. And ⁓ no yeah, well after after yeah, after debt payment, after everything.
David Moghavem (38:08)
On NOI. After that. Okay. After that. Yeah. Well, I think I think the the important lesson ⁓ is being able to have control of management and self-managing. We self-manage on our portfolio. And when even though
Mark Kenney (38:13)
So
David Moghavem (38:27)
You have a deal that maybe the cap stack is flipped upside down and maybe loan is impaired. There's you get credit implicitly for having a property that's performing better than the comps. And I think that's a great barometer when a lender wants to see how the property's doing, when your equity partner wants to see how a property's doing. ⁓ they understand the state in the market we're in, but there shouldn't be an excuse as an operator if you're underperforming relative to your comps.
So if you're at or overperforming relative to comps, you'll get credit for that. And that can come in the form of agreeing on to a loan mod because the lender might feel that you can operate it better than they can. Or you'll get credit from your equity partner that says, hey, they know how to operate. And this might have just been bad timing. So I think being able to manage effectively self-managing.
Is it great because you care more than maybe a third party manager, but you also need to have competence too. It can't just be about care. So being able to manage effectively and caring for it, I think really goes a long way in this cycle. So that you don't get stuck in this decision of what do I do with the property when it's you know 70% occupied.
Mark Kenney (39:45)
Right. And and you know, planning and you know, first getting, like I said, kind of the current situation, state of the land, what's going on. You run through it and I mean I've seen deals, I'm not kidding, you have to be, you know, a hundred and eight percent occupied in order to pay a mortgage. Okay. Well, I mean, then what? Right? You there's no there's no ⁓ way to do that, obviously, without putting money into the property, raising rents and you know, all those things take time and not gonna materialize in time. So
David Moghavem (40:01)
Yeah. Yeah.
Mark Kenney (40:15)
Taking the emotion out of it, figuring out where you are, putting a plan together. Yes, you have to use some things from the future. I get that, because just reality, it's a business. And then making the real tough decisions, like, man, does it make sense to even put money into the deal? You know, it's the really the first one, first time you make a decision where you're like, man, this is this property's gonna fail. Like you feel you as an operator, well, most likely you sh you do, you feel like a complete failure, you know, as an operator.
David Moghavem (40:28)
All right.
Mark Kenney (40:44)
And yeah, the property did fail. I would just say, like, there are a lot of big guys out there too. I mean, you can pick some little trillion dollar, you know, company has been around 150 years giving keys back to to lenders because they can't make the properties work. Now they're in a different situation than the average syndicator because they nothing's gonna happen to them, right? It's like they just keep going on. ⁓ but it's ⁓ it's tough to come to that realization and I would just say think really, really hard.
before you just start throwing money into a property. ⁓ you know, you you can do that at the risk of your own, you know, family, frankly, and your own health. And end of the day, don't get me wrong, I mean it was you know, I still I'm still going through stuff, right? But dude, it was to say it was rough is is quite the understatement. And I'm not trying to over dramatize the what I went through, but it was it was horrific for me as a as a person. And you know, end of the day.
The number one thing that gets me through and it's got me through stuff is ⁓ just being grateful to God with the stuff that I I do have. And end of the day, I don't really care about stuff that much more. I never really cared about a bunch of stuff, to be honest with you. I liked cars and I like some nice things here and there. But ⁓ end of the day I'm like, man, I have a wife for thirty one year years. I have two kids. We're all healthy. I have a I've my first grandchild a month old now. And I'm like, dude, you know what?
Yeah, I mean end of the day, don't get me wrong. I think it's good to have goals. I don't think there's anything wrong with that. I think even, you know, materialistic things are okay if you have a goal of that, as long as that doesn't really have you or own you or define your identity, totally fine. You want this, okay, go ahead and work for it and get it. But when you boil it all down to the end, you're like, none of that stuff really matters. It doesn't. I'm not saying be lazy and don't do anything. I'm not saying all those things, but you really need to put your life and per priorities in perspective.
And you know, if you're Christian or or not, but I mean, if you don't put God first, okay, that that's that's your prerogative for sure. But ⁓ the relationships that you build and you cultivate and being grateful for I mean, we're sitting on here, right? We can see, I can hear, I can walk, I can talk. And all you have to do is have some little thing happen to you. You know, like at a canker store like two weeks ago. I'm like, man, can't I'm like, really? Like I'm complaining about it. I mean, yeah, don't get me wrong, rather than I have it.
But it really puts things in perspective where you're like you get a little hangnail and you're like, that really hurts, you know. What? I mean, you have hands, you have all these things. So I'm not trying to be there's so many things I took for granted, like thank you for a place to live and blankets and people like, well, that's kind of being whatever. No, I mean, there are people literally, you're one decision away from making, you know, a very bad ⁓ lifelong ⁓ decision or the or reverse. And you know, it's not necessarily always one decision, it can be a multiple.
you know, gradual, multiple decisions that get you there. But I know a lot of guys in the industry dude and a lot of people have had some really, really hard times and and some frankly, some pe people haven't made it.
David Moghavem (43:53)
Yeah, I mean I've I've heard some really tough stories, people I personally know, and it's been very tough, but you said it best, you got to take your emotion out of these decisions because that emotion can really put you in a bind. It could put you in a pickle, it can make you make decisions that can cost your
livelihood, your family. So being able to take the emotion out. You have your stewardess of capital, you have a fiduciary duty, but your investors have taken on this risk. And this is this is part of the business. ⁓ And being able to just ethically and be transparent about the decisions made and taking the emotion out is gonna allow you to come out of this alive with experience.
And thrive when things get better. ⁓ I truly believe that when multifamily is back to being the bell of the ball, they will the the equity will flow towards the ones who have survived through and can now thrive in this upcycle. ⁓ and being able to outlast the cycles and being able to navigate through it, you will get rewarded for that. So
Mark Kenney (45:06)
Yeah. And you brought up and now ⁓ to piggyback a little bit on what you said too, the as a general partner operator, right? There's ⁓ a lot of people, not all, a lot of people are like, hey, this is like it's it's all on me. I have to do everything, right? I have to put all my money in the property. In some cases, there are expectations from LPs that okay, you it's it's your deal. Well, okay, let's reverse. If the property makes four hundred percent return, do I get all the profits? No, I don't. So
I don't own own the whole thing. Now I was guilty in in a bad way of like, hey, I'm just gonna, you know, sell my stuff, I'm gonna do this, I'm gonna put money into it, get a line of credit, just dump, dump, dump money. And all I would say is before you do that, you need to talk to somebody who's been through it for one, but two, as much as people might pressure you or try to pressure you, whether it's a lender, whether it's LP, making it basically your sole responsibility to fund all.
deficiencies and and things like that with a deal. I would just say think really, really har long and hard about that. I consulted people on a regular basis, just another one two weeks ago. I said, dude, it's on you. I said, I can tell you the conversation we had six months ago, told you not to get your line of credit. You did. 400 grand, now you're, you know, you're whining about it basically, right? Don't he want to do the right thing. I get that. But you're you can really hurt your yourself and don't like I said, don't
David Moghavem (46:16)
⁓ Some really good advice. I'm I'm I hope that there's
Mark Kenney (46:30)
Yeah, if you have it and you're able to do it and you're comfortable, yeah, honestly, do that. But don't make people, you know, let them guilt you into doing things where you're you're putting yourself and your family in jeopardy.
David Moghavem (46:46)
some listeners that, you know, are listening and probably having a hard, hard day or a hard week and can hear this and say, hey, you know, there's light at the end of the tunnel, even if it's pretty bleak right now as a, as a multifamily operator. ⁓ I'd love to end on a positive note, ⁓ Mark, for think multifamily, what do you what's next for for it? And how are you kind of growing up from here?
Mark Kenney (47:10)
Yeah. You know, so we've done a lot of, you know, more damage control. We have, right? And trying to get things, you know, ⁓ the problem deals and things like that. I think in the last, you know, even sixty-ish days or so, I do think they're starting some opportunities popping up, you know, some of these deals that are distressed that make sense and actually qualify for for agency debt. So and then, you know, ⁓ haven't totally thought through every aspect of it, but there's there's a big need for
people that are, you know, in different businesses. I consult people in a lot of different businesses, not because I'm an expert in those, but I'm able to consult on certain things I've learned. So I do like the idea of this advising, you know, type role. And not that I have all the answers, but I've been through quite a bit. ⁓ contract side, negotiating and and just things like that and how to navigate ⁓ problems. So I'm gonna probably start doing more of that and maybe put together kind of a a group or team related to
That piece of it.
David Moghavem (48:12)
Awesome. Well, Mark, it was amazing having you on DealFlow Friday. ⁓ you're definitely very personable and being able to be open with and vulnerable with ⁓ at a time like this in multifamily where it's not the prettiest. ⁓ but appreciate having you on and sharing your wisdom and looking forward to staying in touch.
Mark Kenney (48:32)
Thanks, Dave. I appreciate it.
David Moghavem (48:34)
Awesome.