AI DTC WTF

How do you hire creative strategists and copywriters when AI writes every work sample?

Stop judging creative strategists on work samples, because you can no longer tell what the candidate wrote and what AI wrote. Make them do the actual job instead: FireTeam's AI interviewer hands candidates a deliberately flawed brief, asks them to find and fix the problems, pushes on why each fix is right, and flags pasted answers. Past that screen, the strongest signal is proof that someone builds and tests with AI while staying skeptical of its output, such as a steady record of GitHub commits. In this episode, Andrew Foxwell and Will Sartorius talk with Jess Bachman, co-founder of FireTeam, about how to hire creative strategists and copywriters when AI writes nearly every work sample. You'll learn how Jess's AI interviewer tests how candidates think, how FireTeam's AI brief writer outperforms a strong human copywriter, and why he would judge a creative strategist by their GitHub commits. Jess runs FireTeam, a performance creative agency that gets paid when ads win. He deployed the AI interviewer to hire a copy engineer and has iterated on it since, and every FireTeam brief now runs through the agency's AI brief writer. We discuss:

  • Why work samples stopped being a useful way to hire creative talent
  • How an AI interviewer uses a deliberately broken brief to show how a candidate thinks
  • Paste detection, dictation false positives, and whether AI screeners turn off good candidates
  • How FireTeam proved its AI brief writer beats a human copywriter, using its own win data
  • Why AI is still terrible at coming up with ad ideas, and what the team does instead
  • Why client learnings, not the prompt, drive 75% of the results
  • Why Jess keeps performance analysis entirely human
  • Why the creative volume game is not coming from Andromeda
  • Why AI raises the floor to a C but cannot turn someone into a builder
  • The hiring signal Jess trusts most for AI-era creative strategists

Get the newsletter: https://www.foxwelldigital.com/email Listen to the full podcast: Apply to Foxwell Founders: https://www.foxwelldigital.com/apply Guest: Jess Bachman, Co-Founder, FireTeam FireTeam: https://fireteam.is Jess on X: https://x.com/HireFireTeam Jess on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jessbachman/ To connect with Andrew Foxwell reach him here Andrew@FoxwellDigital.com To connect with Will Sartorious DM him here https://x.com/will_sartorius To connect with Thomas Moen DM him here https://x.com/thomasmoen To learn more about Foxwell Founders and conversations like this one, go here: www.foxwellfounders.com Learn more about Foxwell Digital and join our newsletter: https://www.foxwelldigital.com/email This Episode is sponsored by Motion's very own Runneth. Runneth is the AI Tool that is quickly becoming the go to decision maker brands turn to when it comes to creative decisions within their ad accounts. From Creative stratigest to hook insporations and creative briefs, runneth can do it all. See the case studies and try runneth yourself https://runneth.com/ Chapters 00:00 How to hire creative strategists when AI writes every sample 02:17 Inside FireTeam's AI interviewer and its deliberately broken brief 04:16 Paste detection, and whether AI screeners scare off good candidates 07:21 How an AI brief writer beat a human copywriter 10:44 From a brainstorm gist to a finished brief in 30 minutes 16:33 Why your data, not your prompt, makes AI copy win 21:29 Does AI only help people who could already write? 22:24 Why the creative volume game was never real 27:50 Can AI turn an average employee into a 100x employee? 31:52 Why GitHub commits are the new creative strategist portfolio

What is AI DTC WTF?

Your Home For Tactical Tips, Strategies and Ideas for Your DTC - AI Workflows

1
If you work in DDC and you use AI
and you're wondering

what the F is going on every week,
this is your podcast.

The AI to see F podcast your home
for tactical tips, strategies, and ideas

that you can implement right now in your
AI workflows to make your brand or agency

more money.

Okay, welcome to another episode of AI D
to see what the.

With Will and I and Jess Bachman from
Fireteam Incredible episode already ahead.

You could.

Right now
I can just tell you it's going to be good.

So if you are thinking about

leaving anywhere
in this, it's on Poly Market.

And if you're thinking about any leaving
during this podcast at all,

you're going to regret it.

It's going to be
the worst mistake of your life.

Like the football coach in high school
that I had,

who told me that quitting football
was the biggest mistake of my life?

It's that it's that level and that still
lives rent free in your head, right?

You think about that?

Yeah. I don't think about that. Ever.

A natural athlete brought to my knees
by the football coach.

But we are here talking about AI
with Jess.

Jess has built a ton of stuff.

Just as somebody who I love and respect
and has an incredible agency.

Awesome team. Jess,
welcome to the podcast.

Thank you.

Love to be here with you guys.

So let's talk about the thing
that you most recently built,

which is this AI hiring tool
agent situation.

What is this? Let's get into this.

Yeah.

So we are we are hiring a copy engineer.

Or you could say that's
a copywriter or something.

And this is a process
that we've done a lot.

And also I'd lump
in creative strategist hiring that.

And so if you've ever hired
a creative strategist

I'm sure will you know, this
is that like you asked

you ask for work samples
and you read their briefs and stuff

and you cannot distinguish what is written
by them or what it's written by AI.

And even when like, it takes
a lot of time to read samples and stuff.

And so it's a it's
a terrible heuristic to find people.

And then also when we give people
specific briefs to be like,

all right, let's let's do a sample.

Let's see how you work.

Everything comes back as AI.

And so it's
I just did not want to run that

playbook again hiring for this role.

So what I did was I created a
AI interviewer.

And what it does is on the left
hand side of your screen

is a poorly written brief with all sorts
of like errors and things inserted,

and that it prompts you after
it gets like your details of where you're

where you live and whatever it prompts you
to to find where the issues are.

And so that like,
I need to see your thinking

about how you're looking at stuff,

because that's the actual work
that you need to do at

our industry is find
these particular errors and fix them.

And so it will prompt you to find them.

It'll prompt you to to fix them,
but it'll do another thing

where it prompts you to it'll like
push on why you think that's an issue.

Because I don't want to

I don't want someone who's just coming in
based off, you know, vibes or something.

Like if you if you say like, you know,
this is weak and it needs to be this way.

Like what?

What is the truth that you're bringing to
that that makes you feel that way?

Like, is it something you researched
or previous winners or whatever?

And so it'll do a whole bunch of turns
of that probably takes 10 or 15 minutes.

And, and then the last stage
is to be like, all right,

forget
this brief, come up with a brand new idea

for this client,
and it gets a turn at doing that.

So like editing and so like what I found

in reviewing people's responses is like,

there is so much signal in, in this stuff.

I mean, it's
kind of like a real interview,

you know, but except
I don't have to be there at all.

And I can give it
to like 50 people at once.

And there's this,
this is like they the people are.

Let me interrupt like a second.

They're
they're getting the questions on there

and they're speaking their responses
or they're writing their responses.

Yeah, they're typing it.

It's just like typing the clod.

It's the same like that sort of thing.

One thing I had to put in
there was paste detection and timing

on their responses, because I was really
worried that people would

take the
brief and then put that in the cloud,

and then take the question
and put that in the clod,

and then take the answer
and put that back in there.

And so it detects if someone does a paste.

And so I, I deploy this on Tuesday and
I've already iterated a lot, a lot on it.

One, I found it there was a lot of people
that were using paste.

And what I found out is people
that are using like dictation or

like speech to texting
will be detected as a paste.

So I put in a question up front
that's like,

are you using a dictation tool?

And if they say no and then they're still
pasting stuff in there.

Well, it's like I don't know what you're
trying to pull here, but

there was a lot of that going on to.

So it's it's been a
it's been a very interesting battle.

But save me a ton of time
and already found me some great candidate.

Interesting.

I sort of
want to double click on that too.

So like the problem
that you're trying to solve here is like

you were just getting candidates
that were effectively writing

or giving their answers to with Claude.

And counterintuitively,
what you're saying is, like,

you use Claude to sort of solve for that.

Right?

And so I guess what
I'm trying to understand is,

like,
do you think that having sort of like an

AI screener would be like a deterrent
for someone

who thinks like, oh, you know, this person
can't even put in the time to like,

you know,

just to play devil's

advocate, put in the time
to have my initial screening interview.

Yeah.

Well, funny enough,
there was a video that went viral of

like the next day of like this
AI interviewer but it was like faking

a real person and whatever

this, this is, this is different, I think.

I think just being in chat
and not trying to do voice, where you're

talking to some weird avatar
or something is entirely different.

But this is also more than an interview

to get at, like your experience,

like you're doing the work
that you'd be doing here at fireteam.

And so the the response that I've got from
candidates was like,

oh man, this was actually fun to do.

So I mean, they could be lying

to, to get the job,
but that's what they're saying.

Yeah.

I mean, well,

I mean, somebody
that's going to be doing that

eight hours a day or whatever,
you know, your hours are it's like,

oh no, you said

you guys were 35 hours a week or whatever
because you get half day off on Fridays

or whatever. Yeah. That's right.

Yeah.

So, so whatever,
35 hours a week they're doing this.

You need to make sure
it's like they should find this fun

because like ultimately what what
like a value proposition.

And, you know, in the marketplace

that you guys have had for a long time,
is that the work that you do is different.

And it's fun.

Like, you know, I mean, it's it's
like what sets you apart from going to,

you know,
another place to, to do this kind of work

and people who are good at their job,
they like to be tested.

They like to show off their skills
if they're like nervous

or worried about it.

That's already like a red flag.

That's probably not okay.

So you also in
this said that you have an AI

brief and script writer
that beats human copywriters.

Can you tell us about this?

What are your houses built?

What's you know,

how do you how do you kind of
think of this idea and what sets it apart?

Yeah.

So I've been man ever since like chat
you first came out, I was

I was very much looking for a way
to replace a lot of the work

that I do,
which is copywriting at the same time,

like Fire Team
is, is a quality over quantity shop.

And so like I am looking to explore
like what is the

the quality levers that we can pull on AI
because we just aren't a quantity shop

and we're not going to be that way.

So this is this is probably like
the 50th iteration of where I'm at here.

But all of our briefs are using this

brief writing tool
and I can go into how it works.

But I'll tell you how I know
it's effective is because we do.

We do have a copywriter on staff
who who's very good.

She's a very good copywriter,
but we treat her as a control

and that she does not use
this particular tool.

And then everyone at fire
Team has a, a number.

It's called a Windex or a W index,
which is measures their ability to

affect

winning ads or their ability
to create winning ads.

And it's usually a number.

Hopefully it's over 100.

And it's super complicated
to get into that number in a sense.

But the people that are using this
tool, myself and a few others, have a much

higher Windex number than this other brief
writer who's very good.

She's very good.

And so I have determined

that, like, like we've even brought in,
like, copywriters that aren't that great.

And still using this tool,
they're able to put out

good briefs and the good
I'm trying to be as objective as possible.

The good is not like I love that.

It's like it wins in ad accounts, like
that's the only thing I'm caring about.

And that's the only thing
I'm really measuring here.

So that's how I know it's working.

Or better than copywriters manually.

Makes sense 100%.

Let's let's dissect.

So I tend to agree,

I found that
copywriting has been the hardest unlock

by far in terms of creative strategy.

Like I was very good at like pointing you
in the direction of like iterate on this,

you know, build on this.

Here's a net new persona to test.

But like the copywriting,

you know,

I think I'm 90% of the way there, but
you seem to have sort of cracked the code.

So like, let's talk, you know, what model
are you using?

What is what is like

sort of like the step by step process
that the model is sort of going through.

And then it sounds like you're
almost like training junior strategists

with this tool to write,
to make them write more effective copy.

And is that making them better
copywriters,

or is that just having someone
just, like, better the machine?

Yeah, I don't know if it's making them
better copywriters,

but it's certainly making them better
at producing winning ads.

I'm not

I don't know if those things are linked,
but I'm certainly going for

the latter here.
So I'll tell you how it works.

So like all all of our all of our ads,
they or their ideas,

they start with basically a gist,

which is just a small encapsulation
of what the idea is.

This gist is actually pulled
out of three hours

of brainstorming that we have a week where

we'll just we'll just say into the ether

like project name, rejuvenate,
you know, bedwetting ad

and then it'll it'll make that
into our project

management system
sort of automatically from the transcript.

It will add the gist
about what we talked about, whatever.

That just will then

get served to the copywriter in the tool
when they're ready to write.

So we got that for their.

Yeah.

I just also want to like pause and say
like a three hour brainstorming session.

Like,

I know this isn't about AI,

but are you and your team
just like hopping on a call

for three hours
and just like, mind melding?

Yeah, it's it's one two hour call
and then one one hour call. Wow.

I mean, that's that's the
that's the differentiator, right?

Like immediately right is part of it.

It's the impulse. Yeah. This is
this is an aside.

But the one thing that I found that, like
AI cannot do well is come up with ideas.

It's just like terrible at it.

So it is very much a mind meld with like
13 people all yelling on zoom or whatever.

So the the copywriter
will get this gist in the system,

and then they will go back
and forth with buddy,

which is the name we give to our
AI copywriter about this particular idea.

And buddy will reference
previously winning briefs for this

client or whatever,
and it will probe the person be like,

what?

Like what about this is important?

And then they'll like speak into it

or type into it until it gets to a point
where buddy feels like

the copywriter has amplified the idea
in the right ways to do the right thing

that it needs for the generation,
which is the next part.

So it'll be like a sort of a simple idea,
but what the copywriter needs to be like,

what, like what's
really going to get someone to tension or

what's the tension here
and put that in there.

So then it will go into the generation
and I'd probably say

like 75% of what makes it effectively
is that from the generation,

it's pulling all of the learnings

that we have that are both per client
and across clients.

So we have like for each client,
there'll be like 10 to 40 learnings

about what actually has been effective
in previous ads

and things that we've tested.

And it'll pull that into the particular
brief

and write the brief
and make sure a lot of that is in there.

So to generate a brief based off this,
this huge system prompt that we have,

then we'll do a quality control
check on itself based off things

that I have found are generally defective
when AI is trying to do a first pass.

So I'll do its own second pass before the
the human gets a chance to edit it, then

it'll finally give like the full version
in the in the format that we like.

One thing that I found is kind of crazy
is that you have to tell the AI

to show the work on the learnings
that you put in there, and why,

because if you don't, it's
going to get lazy

and it's going to like,
you know, fabricate things like, do you

you really have to work with it
to get it to do exactly what it wants and,

and stress it out, to get it to do
the thing that you want.

And so after it's generated, there's
a whole interface where the copywriter

can go in and like, change
a bunch of lines or do heavy revisions or,

you know, talk back to buddy
to get it to fix everything.

And then at the final stage,
they press the button

and it just goes right
into our project management system.

Should take about a half hour per brief
if you're doing it right.

I mean, incredible process.

One theme that I'm that I hear you
talking about, as far as you know,

you're very clear within
anything that you're using AI for

to make sure that you're putting
guardrails on and definitions around

where you believe it's going to screw up
or like where it could lead people astray.

And, you know,
so can you tell me about the common ones

that you run through that you're like,
okay, you know, I mean, I mean, you know,

well, there's a lot of things
you don't allow of directions,

but what are the
common ones that you utilize?

This episode of

Ada is brought to you by runneth
from motion.

And, you know, there's
so many interesting things about runneth

that I absolutely love.

The best marketers I know right now
are not sitting there going,

how do I get ad answer my questions?

They're thinking in systems.

It's I have taste, I have judgment,
I know my customer better than anyone,

and they're putting that into runoff
and having it work on it

in a really sophisticated way.

It's putting it in there

and runneth is amplifying what they can do
with that particular data.

It's not a chatbot, right?

It's not just Claude, it's
not just ChatGPT.

That's the thing I love about runneth

is that it pushes it further,
and it has your ad data,

your competitor data,

your creative strategy,
it has your product data, and it helps

you understand
all of these things together

so that you can genuinely train it on
how you think.

And it becomes useful
from an operational level,

saving you time, giving you context,
and giving you important information

so that you can make the most absolute
best decisions

as a marketer today, to help
make your business run more efficiently.

Motion can do so much run
if can do so much on top of it.

So I encourage you to give it a shot.

If you haven't run a calm and go
and see what you can build.

Yeah.

So the latest it's very interesting
because the latest iteration is not just

guardrails on the AI but guardrails
on the human, because previously,

like what I did not want it to
be was a skill in how you prompt AI.

I did not want that
because different people

have different interpretations
and how they talk to it.

So the way it works
now is like you have a conversation

with the AI, and from that conversation

it creates the input, which is basically,
you know, half of the prompt

that then goes into the generation.

So it's not like the the writer is,
you know, taking their own spin

on what the input is or becomes like,
they don't know how to.

It's just like anything when you do
when you talk with AI like

or the image generation, like,
I'm not going to write in an image prompt,

I'm going to tell

Claude to write me an image prompt
because it knows how AI talks and thinks

and whatever.
So that's like the way to do it.

So reverse prompting.

So that is sort of built in there.

And that has sort of negated
the skill issue, where

even our account managers
who are not writers

can use this tool very effectively,
but a good writer can certainly plus it.

Okay.

I mean, all of the organization
and the logic makes sense, but like,

what's the source?

Like, how are you getting this
to write better copy.

Like what is the framework?

I guess I'd push back on what is better
copy because this is not like

in the prompt.

It says you're the ghost of David Ogilvy
or whatever.

Like in the prompt it is, it's pulling

from the highest value signal
that we could possibly get,

which is previous like learnings
that have previously won on this account.

And it's like folding those in there.

Like, like we have some clients
that have like 50 learnings,

even like a great creative
strategist isn't going to have

all of that in their head
and know when to deploy all of those.

Whereas this can absolutely like jam

packet in all the different layers
of what it needs to do.

And so

that's really the source.

It's not like I can't give you

I could, I could like totally open source
the prompt and give it to you.

And it's not going to be the same thing
because you don't have the same data

that we are feeding into
the into the machine.

Got it. Yeah.

I mean did is obviously the wedge
in today's day and age.

So it sounds like you sort of have like
two data sets that you're feeding this

like again, like a time series analysis
of like all of the metadata.

Like I'm sure you like pulling transcripts
from winners and like correlating

that to like sort of CPA row
as thumbs up, Ctrl whatever.

And then on the other piece of the data
set is like the brainstorm.

And so you're sort of combining
those two elements.

And based on that, you know, the,
the tool is seeing like this is, you know,

this is the top performing copy in this,

in this ad account,

like this is the top performing hook
because I put the transcript with Gemini

or, you know,
you know, sonnet or whatever.

And then based on the brainstorming
session we just had about this client,

like, let's translate everything we just
said and reformat it into

that exact or not reformat it.

But just like re contextualize it

based on the winning copy that
we've already written effectively.

Yeah.

Except the the coming up with the winning,
like what are the learnings

is very much a manual process done
entirely by Rachel, our media director.

Like I said, I also do not trust

AI with analysis.

And like I get enough cloud
slop from clients to begin with that.

And I've tried to like,
do a lot of my own, my own analysis.

And it's very, very hard to
to get at a right place

that isn't like you just find one loophole
and then it's like, oh, you're right.

It's totally the reverse of what
you just said or whatever.

So all of our learnings
are are manually sourced by a human.

And I think and like when you, when you
when she puts it

in, she can put whether it's like,
you know, a strong suspicion or

you know the different
there's like levels of learnings.

And then the LM will use that information
as well.

And like lean into the long stuff, the,

you know, the strong stuff
and stuff like that.

So it's a combination of very human and

AI parts.

Funny.

That's that's so interesting
because. Yeah. Wow.

That's very, very cool.

Because I feel like, you know,
we've sort of come down on the other side

where I found the AI is very good
at analysis but sucks a copywriting.

So like I have it sort of
do the first 10% and say, like, here

are all the new personas to test and like,
you know, how are we doing that?

It's just like time series, analysis
app and Reddit cross-referencing the two.

What personas haven't we tested that
people in subreddits are talking about?

And so then it's like

strategist would have that context to go
write the copy, but then it's like,

I don't necessarily feel comfortable
just yet,

you know, giving them like a tool
to write the copy.

So I guess, like when you sort of
think about, you know, fire team

in five years, like,

you know, let's just assume
that you want to keep doing this thing

and definitely like,
how do you sort of think about, like,

training talent and like building people

if they're just like sort of relying
on this to generate better winning ads?

It's it is interesting because I think
we're at a crossroads where

the people that I've who are able to use

AI best are the people
that had those skills beforehand. Yes.

And they know how to edit
or basically not trust the outputs.

You know,

I'm not sure what's going to happen
when we get to a stage

where there is no beforehand and those
people have frigging retired or moved on.

You know, I do worry about that,
but maybe we just keep hiring

older and older copywriters, I guess.

I'm not sure.

Yeah.

Age bias starts
going to other direction, right?

So I mean, like, what do you
so what do you see this

all of these things with the
AI that you're doing changing

in the offerings
that your agency has as time

goes on to because, you know,
you guys do obviously,

this very manual process of research
and iterative ideas and, and, you know,

and then you go in, you know, you're
shooting stuff, you're making great ads.

You know,

as far as I know, you're doing very little
in reference to like creating AI

is actually creating the statics
or anything.

I know there's a little bit of that,

but that's very small percentage
of what you do.

And how do you see this evolving in
in your agency as time goes on?

I think the North Star is that

we're a performance based agency.

We get paid when things work and
when they don't, we don't get paid more.

If we deliver more, like we get paid more
if things work better.

And so with that framing, we're constantly
looking for ways to work better.

And like we like
we have two designers on staff

and we have two video editors,
and they both use AI all the time,

but not for the purpose of like
pumping out, you know, 800 statics.

That's that's not something
that we've seen be effective.

And so I think we're going to constantly,
you know, like we track our win rate

across clients and our hit rate
and like our people on

staff are looking to improve their own
Windex scores and stuff like that.

And so I think if you build the incentives
internally to do this

and it ladders up to the incentives
of the agency, which is to,

you know, win more,
you don't have to, you know,

there's a simplicity and a complexity
that's like wrapped up into that.

And I don't have to,
you know, people will find their stride

at their agency, at this agency
and do what they need to do.

I don't know, I'm kind of just rambling,

but let me know if this is making
any kind of sense whatsoever.

I mean, it's
yeah, I mean, I think it's your

what I hear you saying is you're providing
the framework of this is what we do.

These are the outputs we need,
and this is how we're tracking it.

And the way that you get there

is, you
know, sort of up to you to a degree.

And if you're using AI, there needs to be
certain guardrails on it.

And here's a way that we think about that.

But you're giving them the freedom
to be creative and be productive to

to try to, you know, increase their own
Windex or whatever else.

And I think if our offer was a set

volume of creative, we'd
be a very different type of agency and,

you know, different that looks different
on a margins perspective.

And we just operate entirely different

in a way that I would literally
probably hate my job trying to do.

So I very much like what we're where

we're at and feel
very confident in our offer, I guess.

Yeah, absolutely.

I mean, it's always been as the volume
game is always going to be there, right?

And it's like as a hedge, you guys are
like, look, this is a manual process.

It's different.

Is it is it,
is it always going to be there

I think well I think I think if you look
in any marketplace like there's always

there's always going to be room for people
that want the volume style

and want like, yes,
let's make a bunch of this or,

you know, let's give this and maybe,
maybe they're not going to pay

as much for it
and it'll continue to decrease in value.

But I think there's always this idea
that more is better from a lot of folks.

Right.

Like, you know, like I think over time
it maybe isn't going to perform,

you know, as well.

And people are like
it turns into a negative thing, I guess.

I think I think the pendulum
will swing back if it hasn't already.

The volume game is not coming
from I'm telling you,

it's not coming
from Andromeda or a need for

you know what meta wants.

It's coming from the ability
to create this stuff at scale,

which agencies absolutely freaking love
because it's so cheap,

and then that gets wrapped and then
that gets twisted into what like rep say.

And then all of a sudden
it's like attached to Andromeda,

but like you go back historically,
it has always been a quality game.

Like it is never been a volume game.

That's true.

And so I think you're right.

I guess
what I'm saying is, I think there's always

this idea that people are like,
yeah, I really like that.

It can do 50, I can get 500 of these,
you know what I mean?

Like, I mean, it's like it's a
there's a novel concept to it.

But in terms of actual quality,
I think you're right.

And and I think you raise a good point
about what

how it gets twisted
in terms of how it gets talked about.

Yes. You need to have more creative and,
you know, whatever.

And I think a lot of people are listening
to this.

Would totally agree
about the creative and quality piece.

I guess to me the question is is always,
you know, how do we turn it into,

you know, how do we research brands better
and make sure that we understand

angles that haven't been explored
and make quality ads

to speak to those people
that have not been addressed previously?

That's like the challenge of any creative
creative shop creative strategist today.

And how do you present them in a way
that's going to make that company

more money, and you don't really know
in terms unless you start sort of testing

and digging into that, what do you think
creative strategy will look like?

I mean, the role of a creative strategist

has already changed
in the last 365 days, dramatically.

So like, what's the what's this?

It's like a Rorschach inkblot,
whatever that term means. Yes.

Yeah. Right. Yeah.

Yeah. It's interesting.

Like, I just wonder what it's
I just wonder how it's

how the how it's going to evolve
creative strategy overall.

I mean, I think it's obviously AI enabled,
but I,

I wonder sometimes
there's certainly a lot of talk about

100 X employee right now
to like the person can do a lot more.

Do you feel that the volume

of tasks that a person can accomplish

equate to better quality
for the end user, for the client volume?

No, I my general lens of of AI

is is like more and better.

Like you can certainly do more,
but you also have to do better as well.

And and whenever we talk to employees,
it's always like

where where in your process
can we insert AI to

allow you to do more, but also,
you know, better at the same time

in terms of like the 100 X employees,

this is something
that I've really struggled with

because I love building
AI and I want my employees to do it.

But I've really found that, like you,
you cannot

turn someone into a builder.

Like you can identify the drive to like,

improve things,
but like, you can't take like a frigging,

you know, even like a B+ employee
and throw them in a freaking cloud code

harness and and be like,
look at all the things you can do.

And you can't spark that desire

to improve something,
you know, on the one sense,

because they're an employee and you know
you're the owner, that's one thing.

But also in general, like you kind of need
the hunger in the fire to like push

this stuff,
which is very opaque and hard to work

with and confusing at times
to get what you want.

And you might you might need to like, hire
those people or look

for those those people in the signal

when you're hiring,
because it is very difficult,

if not impossible to motivate
those people, just giving them a tool

that can now ten x,
you know what they can do.

Yeah,

they're the way that they think.

And the way a person thinks
is still a massive competitive advantage.

Like the way that they're going to reason
through something

and sort of look at the why of it, etc..

You know, I agree,
and I've seen that definitely happening of

like I've given them all the access,

I've given them all the tools
and they're still not doing what I need.

It's like I also to me, that's also

like a lack of strategy,
that there isn't the will.

And I've talked about this in the podcast

like there's there's this
there's no strategy.

It's just like come up with ideas
like do more and you're like, well,

they don't see it the way that you see it.

Like it's not,
you know, you have to sort of

lay out like,
this is why this is important.

Here's the idea.

Come up with iterative ideas on that
and like that or, you know, whatever.

Like making it more narrow
so the person can sort of

start to understand,
like what they're trying to accomplish.

But yeah, it's interesting.

Yeah. You can also

instead of just
ten axing, you can almost like negative

ten x some employees
because it allows them to create

so much like downstream work
or you know, there's error.

Like they just allows them to create
so much more stuff that if they were a

C plus to begin with.

Now there's like they're just generating
all types of like work.

And it can really
it can really like gum up your team.

Yeah. I mean I completely agree with that.

It's like definitely can create a race
to the bottom very quickly.

And that's like one,

you know, downside of saying like,
oh, we're AI enabled or like we use AI.

You get these people

like, oh, I can just like fucking phone
it in and just like, you know,

not have to think so.

I mean, yeah.

Anyway, it is it is sort of crazy.

Yeah.

I think, I think if, if I'm a listener
and I'm maybe like looking for a job

right now, you know, at a brand or
an agency, you know, something you said is

like you can't force people to sort of
like ten, like who has this like sort of.

And you briefly sort of touched on this,

but I really want to
sort of drill down on it like,

like what sort of person

has this really worked for, and who's
a person that this hasn't worked for?

And like, what is a gap and the difference
between the two of them?

Is it like their copywriting skills,
or is it something like more inane

that they sort of innately have?
What do you mean work for?

Like what type of person?

Yeah.

So is it like
and I don't want to just like,

you know, lead the horse water here,
but like, is it someone who is like

intellectually curious about, like,
you know, getting better or like,

yeah, sort of that idea like,
is this going to take like

D plus person to an A

or you know, or,
or like a plus person to a B or is it,

you know, only going to really work
if you're a B, you know, to an A and like

if you are like a D plus now like,

how can you get yourself up to be a
B like using AI?

I'm not sure. I'm not sure you can.

I think, you know, the
the floor is probably

AI is just raising the floor to a C,

and if you're a deep person,
maybe you can get up there.

But it's hard to get higher.

And like if I was
if I was evaluating a creative strategist,

like if I really want to pay
a very good creative

strategist to change my business,

unfortunately,
I would be looking at their GitHub commits

and seeing how much,
how much stuff they are like pushing,

because that is the signal
that that they're looking

to like improve and change and actually
be on the forefront of using this AI,

like AI is like anything, it's it's

the people who are well, there's like

there's there's two levels to that
to a, there's like being so bought in

that you kind of like
don't know what you're doing

and you can't evaluate it
and you're just like,

you just like so and you know,
we have a lot of clients that are even,

you know, like this as well.

And then there's like the really effective
layer is one layer below that where

you have
a very healthy sense of skepticism,

but you're still building
and you're still testing.

And that is like the true, productive,
productive layer.

And so I've seen people like,

you know, I built an AI and it's like it's
based on consciousness and love.

And it's like, that's not the

that's like the wrong level, but like,
show me what you've built.

Whether you are an AI or a strategist
or a video editor or whatever.

And if it's like a real tool or something

like that, that's
probably the highest signal for employees.

I think that's I mean,
I think that's always been the case of,

you know, going back thinking about
when we were in the early days of meta

ads and Facebook ads, like I was always
and still to this day, of the most curious

with about people that are doing crazy
shit like that

are trying really strange stuff
that are doing, you know, and it's like,

and I think if you know, the technical,
if it's a person

that's competent on writing
and can think through things

and then has this capability
of almost technical AI curiosity,

then it's like a winning combo
because it's

the tools are obviously going to continue
to change, you know, and it's like

they're going to continue to to evolve
and you have to to go for that.

So I think looking at GitHub
commits is like super interesting idea

and one that I was,

you know, voiced to another person
the other day about, you know,

trying to get their employees to be more
bought into this.

Like,
hey, can we look at that as a metric?

Because I think that's
and for the creative strategist,

like for copywriting,
it might be one thing, but for a creative

strategist, which is a role that spans
multiple departments and disciplines,

like that is absolutely a place
where AI enablement can can like force

multiply all sorts of outcomes versus
purely like copywriting or I know we're

sort of nearing time here, but sorry,
I do want to sort of drill down into this

because I think it's fascinating
sort of the GitHub

commit sort of hypothesis.

And I again, just playing the devil's
advocate, I don't agree or disagree, but

like, you know, obviously tech companies
for a while were gauging their employees

success by the amount of tokens
they were using internally.

And obviously like that
caused the employee that costs

the company's a fortune.

So they stopped doing that in this case.

Like, how do you know that the GitHub

repo that they're creating
are actually accretive?

And they're not just like in this
AI psychosis state where they just like

are building because it's like fun
or just like for the sake of building.

Yeah.

That's a great question.

I think it's it's probably a lot
easier to like, run up a huge token bill

than, you know, do commits for days
and days and months and months.

But I think you I think probably,
probably what I would do,

I would create an AI interviewer
that interviewed them

specifically on their
their thoughts around

AI and probably put some like, like,
here's a problem.

How would you solve that with AI?

And if they're like, oh,

you need Jack into the matrix,
then they're like the wrong person.

But that's probably what I would do.

Yeah, so much of it.

And hiring is always thinking like
figuring out how somebody thinks anyway,

you know, so just doing that
a little bit different speed.

So just one more question
on the GitHub thing.

What is the Willy Wonka golden ticket?

If you opened a GitHub
and you saw X, you know, would you say

like this person has got the jobs
to be a great credit strategist?

I would say,
I would say because a lot of this

vibe coding is still pretty new.

I just want to see activity to start.

I would, I might say that
like too much activity or if you're like,

you know, contributing
to open source or something,

it's like you might be too far
in the dev side of things, but like,

I really just want to see the fire
and the determination,

even the determination to fricking
for a quote unquote creative strategist

or someone who feels like their creator,
or if they're a UGC creator

and they want to become
a creative strategist,

even to freaking get set up on GitHub
and start like pushing

stuff requires you
to push through some uncomfortableness

about what your new identity is, or what
I'm doing, or what this future is,

and like seeing their ability
to do that on a on a consistent basis,

regardless of what the, you know, the work
product is, is, is a very good start.

Well, I'd like to introduce you
to interviewer by Fire team.

The world of the the world of interviewing
is never going to be the same.

Or I'm trying to think about all the exact
the scripts from the exact same video.

So we've lost.

Well, I'm more than happy to share the
like I posted in the channel, like the the

the prompt of how to sort of

put this together in a huge EMD file
on what I've learned in doing it.

And you can just throw it in your car
and say, build it.

So I'm happy to share that too. Nice.
Well thank you.

We'll put that in the in the notes.

Jess, appreciate your time
and appreciate you being here.

If anybody has questions or whatever
they can reach you on X,

we'll put that in the show notes as well.

And as always, thank you to our listeners.

Always my pleasure guys.