Nuclear Investing Podcast

Andrew Meehan joins Brennan for a post-election This Week in Nuclear. They cover why nuclear remains one of the most bipartisan issues, what the market pullback means for public and private nuclear companies, and why a data center slowdown could give nuclear time to catch up. They also break down X-energy's NRC construction permit, the DOE's $5bn conditional loan commitment for Constellation's uprates, the Darlington BWRX-300 delay, and new fuel cycle milestones from Urenco, Centrus and Oklo.

What is Nuclear Investing Podcast?

The Nuclear Investing Podcast features thoughtful, in-depth conversations about one of the most important pieces of the global energy mix: nuclear power.

Through interviews with leading industry leaders, investors, and policymakers, the show explores how nuclear energy is becoming central to the clean energy transition — and how investors are gearing up to support it.

Each episode gets to the root of how companies plan to build, finance, and deploy next-generation nuclear projects — and how they aim to create lasting value for investors and society.

The goal: to advance awareness and informed participation in the future of clean, reliable energy.

Well, Biden wanted to triple it. Trump wants to quadruple it.

So maybe we'll meet somewhere in the middle there with three and a half times, but

it seems like the most bipartisan issue there is.

Is a slowdown in data centers is probably a good thing for nuclear. Why?

Because these guys said, "I need power tomorrow."

If all you need is 25 years and $25 billion and you can solve the nuclear problem,

you're not solving anybody's problem.

Welcome to another episode of This Week in Nuclear on the Nuclear Investing

Podcast. I'm here with Andrew Meehan. Welcome back, man.

Hey, Brennan. Great to be back.

It's been too long. Andrew and I have both been on the road.

It's been a crazy couple of weeks, and we were talking yesterday, and it's like, we

have to get something out. We have to talk about the election.

So this one was actually unscheduled, unplanned, but we're excited to hop on and

get right into it, man. It's been a crazy couple of weeks.

There's plenty of content out there for us to riff on, Brennan. So let's do it.

Well, let's talk about the election.

I've been on the road the past week talking with a lot of investors, and front and

center is, hey, what do you think about data centers?

What do you think about the election?

So, I've been trying to talk to as many smart people as I can in my circle about

it. And you made the comment yesterday, I won't take it from you, I'll let you

relay your comment about the Republican and Democrat alignment on nuclear in

general at the high level, and then we'll talk about what it means for SMRs and

fuel cycle and all that, so.

I think we're in perfect alignment here, Brennan.

You said that you have been saying exactly the same thing.

So, dual credit on this one. But the line is when people are coming to us and

saying, "Oh, what does this election result do to nuclear?" And the canned response

is, well, Biden wanted to triple it. Trump wants to quadruple it.

So maybe we'll meet somewhere in the middle there with three and a half times, but

it seems like the most bipartisan issue there is. So not worried at all.

The memes that came out on Wednesday after the election results a couple weeks ago

were fantastic. And one of my favorite ones was, all the defense tech VCs pivoting

back to climate tech. And so it's nuclear fits in that little Venn diagram

overlapped weeks ago.

Yeah. No, that's what I've been saying for a long time.

It's the one thing they can agree on, right?

We went from tripling it to quadrupling. You say three and a half, I might say 5X.

That's right. Yeah.

You might see another one-upping here because at some point, someone's going to

want a lot of the credit for all this, and it's like, okay, well, right now Trump

really implemented the executive orders under Secretary Wright's leadership, and

then it's like, maybe there's something incremental coming.

I would love to see it happen.

Yeah, exactly. The interesting piece is you've seen in the market, and we talked

last about the pullback in the nuclear guys and really just the volatility in the

space, which was a combination of several variables, would've really set up for the

perfect storm in a way. And I think set up really well for a recovery as well in

the markets. You've seen a little bit of a disconnect in the past few weeks tied to

the chip guys and the neo clouds where uranium prices haven't really traded off,

but the stocks of the uranium miners have pulled back and the fuel companies have

pulled back just alongside the broader market. So I think disconnects there.

Big disclaimer, we always say this, not investment advice, but there do appear to

be some interesting opportunities open up in the markets on really all fronts.

100%. We've said it before, and we'll say it again, that

while the disconnect may start to show, the trade remains correlated.

That the nuclear trade ultimately, especially with the reactor developers out

there, the advanced reactor companies who trade on public markets, you're going to

see high correlation between the hyperscalers and the neo clouds that

trade in public markets, where they're ultimately seen as

ultimate customers to many of these advanced reactor developers.

Brennan, you and I may have different perspectives on whether or not that's how the

transactions will play out. But it's worth reiterating that

those companies correlate. But to your point, it's a big market, and nuclear in

particular is disjointed in a lot of ways.

And so, there is opportunity if it's a publicly traded mining company that

has net asset value that's fundamentally different from the price per pound of

uranium. There may be opportunities out there.

Yeah, certainly. It's crazy. This was in the day of reckoning two days after the

election where things just total panic mode.

But I saw Art Hyde tweet, which I respect him a lot, talking about just looking at

the cash balance of X-energy, the cash balance of Sintris.

And granted, these guys plan on spending that cash on their projects, but looking

at the cash balance versus where they were trading.

And if you look at the value of the business that way, it's like, okay, here's the

market cap net of cash. Basically, there was not a whole lot of cushion of what you

were paying for the underlying technology on the upside of that business.

So I thought that framing was really interesting, and I think a lot of the market

as well was missing that specifically.

Because if you're these guys-

Yeah. Go ahead.

The vocabulary word that everybody should learn here who's interested in nuclear

investing is enterprise value. And the enterprise value is when you net out the

cash, exactly like you're describing.

So, I haven't checked Oklo today, but let's say Oklo is trading at $5 billion, and

they have $3 billion of cash on hand. You can assign an enterprise value.

There are other factors out there, but rough approximation of $2 billion here.

The enterprise itself is worth $2 billion, and then you get an extra 3 because you

have all that cash. But stripping away the cash, what's the company worth?

The market says 2 billion. So, that's a vocab term everybody should know if you're

looking at private and public markets for nuclear investments, is what is the

enterprise value?

Yeah, it's a good opportunity for us to dissect it a little bit.

It is the value you would have to pay for a company.

Yeah.

And so if we zoom out thinking about public companies, okay, what's the price you

would have to pay for, let's say, X-energy?

To your point, enterprise value is the market capitalization of the equity.

So what are the shares outstanding times the price of the equity?

And that's what you typically see when you look at market cap.

And most people think, "Oh, that's the value of the company." So it's a really good

point you brought up, Andrew. The enterprise value is, okay, what is the market cap

of the equity? And then what is the debt?

So let's assume there's 4 billion in market cap and a billion dollars of debt.

Well, to buy that company, you're going to have to buy the equity holders out, and

you're going to be stuck with a billion dollars of debt.

So there's 5 billion in the stack that you really need to buy, but you're also

going to receive their cash.

Yeah. So if you buy the company, you receive the cash, so you subtract out the cash.

So it's a great point because a lot of these guys don't have much of any debt at

this point, especially the reactor guys.

And so the enterprise value is more or less market cap of their equity minus their

cash. So that's a great point.

Yeah, and Brennan, it comes back to this conversation we've been having for so long

about, especially in the hype cycle at the end of 2025 when Oklo was trading around

25 billion at one point, all the private market companies were saying, "Hey, those

guys haven't brought a reactor online, and neither have we, and we've got a great

team and great technology, and we're probably pretty comparable to this company

that's worth 25 billion."

There is a stickiness in the private markets of pricing because you're not rerated

on a daily basis. And so,

if you're a founder, it can both boost your valuation and hurt your valuation to

turn around and say, "Oh, well, now Oklo is worth $2 billion in enterprise value."

It might be a tough time to fundraise in private markets.

Yeah, and I think there's going to be some-- I'm going to read a tweet from a

friend, or a text from a friend, whose name I won't mention.

Very sharp guy in the space. I respect his opinion a lot.

And that's why I tried to reach out and talk to as many smart people as I could in

the past few weeks. And we'll get a little bit more into the impacts at the federal

level and at the individual state level.

But the feedback was, I think of nuclear in three buckets. There's three nuclear.

The first one being military, unchanged by the election, and unchanged by pullback

and AI. Full steam ahead for the Antares, the Radiants, the Army, the Janus

program. I think that all is unchanged. But that I agree with. Two, new nuclear.

So largely small modular reactors, and on the bigger end of the micro reactor guys

that aren't really focused on military deployment.

Totally tied to AI, needs to consolidate, many need to die. Many need to go away.

Big nuclear, permit reform, and perhaps power affordability more impactful than AI.

And I thought that was really good insight because we've shown before, and

I'm going to show it again here on the screen, the Gartner hype cycle.

And I respect so much- John Arnold views, and he really opened my eyes to this,

of the Gartner hype cycle and where we sit, very likely on the Gartner hype cycle.

And Andrew, to your point, a year ago, you have a technology trigger, new

technology. This was tied to AI, and the nuclear guys started popping up out of

nowhere, and it really reached this peak of inflated expectations, which is a

little more than a year ago, to your point.

The 25 billion or so market cap of Oklo and the euphoria of, "We have to get public

as soon as we can to take advantage of this peak of inflated expectations." Well,

now we're either on our way down or nearing the bottom of what's called the trough

of disillusionment, and most new technologies follow this chart.

And then I think of that as the reality check.

It's like the reality check of time and cost to actually deploy technology.

And I think you could argue, too, that AI is experiencing the same or similar

position on this chart. And then you go through a recovery, the slope of

enlightenment, and ultimately reach a plateau of productivity where you're truly

manufacturing these things, which was the goal from the beginning.

So, I find this really helpful as framing around, hey, there's nothing new here.

We've seen this time and time again with new technologies in history, whether it's

the railroads or telecom or the internet, and it's just part of the journey.

So I'll pause there. Curious to get your take on all this.

One reaction I have, Brennan, is

how many Gartner hype cycles of nuclear have we already experienced?

That's a good point.

Because in the '50s and the '60s, when we were starting to build all these

different exotic reactors, and it's like basically any company who has a unique

coolant, there has been a reactor design previously operated with that coolant

technology.

The ecclesiastical vision of nuclear, of there is no new thing under the sun since

1950.

Yeah. And so, I think that should be something weighed in.

I will cite friend of the pod, Nick Touran, who gave a fantastic presentation

at the New Nuclear Capital event on Tuesday this week.

And basically, he told exactly that story, and he was like, "Cool new molten salt

reactor, they claim the safety profile, they claim

all of these passive safety capabilities, they claim dissolved fuel, they claim

this, that, and the other." And he's like, "Well, here's the example from 1961

where they ran a reactor of exactly this coolant type, and we didn't commercialize

it." And he basically went through advanced coolant technology by advanced coolant

technology,

pointing the previous reactor designs that had been done before, concluding

ultimately that

water is a wonderful coolant. And actually, I made a meme recently, and

it's the appropriate time to share this meme, and I share it as somebody who has

invested in a thorium-fueled molten salt reactor company, but hear me.

We'll just throw this up here.

A little nuclear investing podcast.

This week's a nuclear meme-

I love it

... for the pod.

Can't wait.

But yeah, point being,

there's a lot of power, no

pun intended, in

what we already know with water-cooled reactors.

Yeah, man, most people don't realize that these technologies date back 50, 60

years. A long time. And that's a big takeaway for me

from the feedback that I was just referencing is,

AI went into this peak of inflated expectations, and then the nuclear guys, you saw

all these companies appear. You've heard about the fatigue from many of the

nuclear industry veterans. It's like, "Oh my gosh, there's a new reactor a day."

And you've heard about the whole paper reactor concept, and this idea that a lot of

companies were formed that probably shouldn't have existed in the first place.

And I think one of my biggest takeaways is with the slowdown in data centers, which

is inevitable, and arguably should have happened anyways, things were moving a

little bit too fast, and communities were loud and clear about their

openness to these massive data center projects.

I think a lot of companies were formed that otherwise wouldn't have existed, and

now therefore there's going to be a filtering out of a lot of those companies

naturally in the next 12 to 18 months or whatever it may be.

And oftentimes that's a healthy exercise for the market, and you're left with the

survivors that in a flat, linear line of progression probably would've been the

only ones to exist in the first place, or there would've been much fewer to exist

in the first place.

Yeah. And Brennan, going back to this Gartner hype cycle, one of the things that

comes to mind

is there is a lot of luck in success, of being at the

right place at the right time. And so if you were out fundraising at the end of

2024, building a new reactor startup,

raising capital, it goes back to this point about Oklo of having $3 billion of cash

on hand. There's a lot you can do and buy with $3 billion to build a business.

Very true.

Right? And so one of the things that I've been reflecting on recently, to your

point about a lot of folks who may or may not

need to continue operations in this environment or may have a tough time doing so,

there's some new kids on the block.

There's some cool new reactor designs that are showing up, and I'm getting pitched

these regularly, and some of them are really exciting, cool novel reactor designs.

And there is a thought process of have they missed the boat at some level?

Has the cycle passed down to the trough of disillusionment and rather than gaining

all this capital by going through the peak of inflated expectations and being able

to fundraise in that environment, they're now going to have to fundraise at the

trough of disillusionment. And that's going to be a lot harder to raise capital,

and they're going to get a lot more expensive capital as they do it.

And so are they going to be able to build a business the same way that the guys two

years ago who were in the right time and place got that wave on the upside?

And it's not to say it'll be impossible.

I'm sure we'll have startups at the end of 2026 who are alive in a few years, and

incredible founders, incredible capability, team building technologies.

There's exciting stuff happening in the space, don't get me wrong, but a lot of

success can come from the luck of being at the right place at the right time.

And you could get cheap capital a couple of years ago by going through this peak of

inflated expectations. And then back to this point about Oklo, there's a lot you

could do with $3 billion on hand.

Totally, man. Right place, right time.

It wasn't obvious when they went public either.

I think there was this lingering period of it just initially was down and then sat

there, and then all of a sudden it hit the wave. It's a great point.

Timing of raising capital and then timing of getting public can go both ways.

You've seen a great example is one of the highest volatility names in the public

markets for nuclear right now is Deep Fission.

Yeah.

What's happened with Deep Fission?

Well, they raced to get public through an alternate public offering, which I've

voiced in the past frustrations around that structure.

I think the best way to get public is through a traditional IPO.

Personally, I'm not a big fan of all the other ways, SPACs, APOs, all the other

ways to get public. I think you're generally signaling that it's too soon.

Now, some people would disagree with that, and that's okay.

What have the SPAC deals done? They have not performed well.

What have the APO deals done? Well, in this case, these guys, they thought they

were going to be able to raise significantly more capital when they listed on

NASDAQ. And then alongside the wave of everyone else, there's been a pullback, but

there's also the short-selling iceberg report that came out, which all of a sudden

you're not only focused on advancing your reactor technology, but then you're

likely engaging a small army of people to go combat this short-selling report and

what the market's doing, and incremental short sellers coming in, the pressure that

puts on your stock. And then in addition to that, Kansas flips from

a Republican state for a really long time to a Democrat state.

And where is Deep Fission's first project? It's in Kansas.

So you saw in the day of reckoning, what I call it, and it's recovered a lot since,

but two days after the election, you see a 50% drawdown in a name.

It's unbelievable. And then where do you go?

To your point, it's like, okay, everyone needs more capital.

No one's sitting around saying, like, "I'm set for the next three years."

Maybe Oklo.

Maybe Oklo, and I think X-energy has a lot of cash as well, but that cash is

accounted for and earmarked towards projects that hopefully get done.

And so then you're left in this position of, where do I go to raise incremental

capital if I'm public too soon? So, we've talked a lot about this before, but

to your point, in the private markets, I would rather take a down round in private

markets and survive than be stuck in public markets where there's

nowhere to hide. It's too early, you know?

It is actually one of the perks of being public is you don't have to take a down

round. You can kind of point your finger at the market and say, "No, they don't

understand us," that, "They're all wrong, and here's your opportunity to buy more,"

right?

Yeah.

Whereas a down round in the private markets is,

there's a hand-in-hand approach of, yeah, we were not worth what we were at that

point, or maybe we were mispriced at that earlier point, and we need capital to

continue operations. So, Brennan, I think an interesting comparative analysis

that's worth digging into with this X-energy comment,

is the X versus Valar conversation, where one has brought a reactor online that's

very much a prototypical reactor, not some sort of commercial fleet, $6

billion headline number. I mean, that's kind of the, we talk about the high-water

mark of Oklo at 25 billion in 2025. The high-water mark of 6 billion for Valar,

in private markets in 2026 seems to be

the number to remember. And so we look at X-energy today, they're trading at

4.3 billion market cap. If they have a billion on hand, let's say, that's a 3.3

enterprise value. So, I think I'll just repeat what you said a couple of weeks ago.

X-energy just got construction permit approval.

They just announced a bunch of new reactors they're going to build, another 12 or

so.

It seems to be a commercial enterprise that's going to go out and build a whole lot

of reactors. Granted, I think there's another news story about a reactor

announcement of

stirring up a lot of market excitement, and actually delivering on that with the

Darlington scenario. There's a wide gulf between announcing projects and delivering

projects. But X-energy just got construction permit approval, so

for folks at home, that's one that may be interesting to dig into a little bit and

do some comparative research on. Is it more meaningful to have a critical

reactor demonstration in the Utah desert, or is it more meaningful to have an

NRC commercial permit to go build reactors in Texas with an offtaker?

And if you conclude one way versus the other, there may be opportunities out there.

Yeah. Well, again, not investment advice.

Exactly.

I'll take daily liquidity in the story of X-energy at four and change of market

cap over 6 billion and being tied in private markets for...

The other question is, what is your investment thesis?

Are you going after micros, or are you going after grid scale?

Because there's a big gap in the size of these reactors and their ultimate use

case. I mean, we'll show on the screen here the announcement, Andrew.

And you're right, this is a big deal. This was a big deal.

It didn't seem like it was going to get done by the end of this year, and the NRC

moved quickly, and congratulations to the X-energy team. This is a big deal.

And there's a couple firsts here that I'll cover.

Monday's construction permit issuance, I'm just reading from the ANS article.

For the 320-megawatt electric reactor project at Dow's UCC Seadrift operations

manufacturing site is historic on multiple fronts.

One, it is the first construction permit issued for a high-temperature gas reactor

in nearly 60 years. To your point, it's not the first high-temp gas reactor,

though, right? We were doing these back in the day.

It is the first-ever US approval for a pebble-bed high-temperature gas reactor

design, and it is the first time the NRC has issued a construction permit for a

nuclear reactor on an industrial site, the Dow site.

Pretty compelling story there, to your point, Andrew.

Pretty compelling story, and it's hard to really put those two names in the same

category. That's not a dig on Valar, and it's just testament to how long have you

been in business, and how close are you to commercialization.

And so people can do their own analysis on

the comparison there. But

there are some stale numbers from raises that were done over the summer that seem a

bit inflated at this point. Near the end of the peak of inflated

expectations, we'll say, at least on the private side.

Yeah. Well, I think Brennan, one of the things that comes to mind, too,

back to this Gartner hype cycle is there's a market-wide Gartner hype cycle, and

there are company-specific hype cycles that may take place in certain scenarios,

right? And so there are big milestone announcements, and I think back to this

earlier comment of time and place.

It does make a lot of sense to raise some capital when you've got this big

milestone announcement, and you need to moderate the capital raise with the

valuation,

because it's tough to take down rounds.

I mean, just in any market, nuclear

included.

Private market down rounds are tough.

Yeah. Big

time. They're really tough. They're tough to underwrite as an investor saying, "You guys

are worth that, now you're worth this, and now you think you're going to be worth a

lot more than what you were worth the first time." It's hard to recruit from an

employee perspective. It can be really tough on employees.

You go join a company, and for startups, yeah, you make good money most of the

time, hopefully. But the opportunity is really in the equity that you

get in participating in these companies.

So it can be really tough on existing employees and recruiting of,

same hesitation investors see with down rounds, the prospective employees see of,

why would I go join this company when potentially I could go join this one that

looks like a rocket ship?

Yeah.

No, it's very true.

Very true. It makes me think a bit about shifting gears here slightly.

I recently had a great conversation with Michael Laufer on a podcast that will soon

to be released about Kairos's 10-year journey and the iterative development

approach, and they are fortunate to have patient private capital to be able to do

that. One of the concerns we talked about was there's a difference in iterating on

pilot or demonstration projects and iterating on commercial projects.

And I think another risk of a market like this is every new dollar of capital that

comes in needs to be put to work in something that's going to produce revenue.

You don't have this patient capital saying, "Okay, guys, go build another pilot

program project." Which we should talk in a minute about what's the new benchmark

for these private guys that are popping up now, because a year ago, it was the DOE

pilot program.

But it's another risk that shouldn't be overlooked in the industry, and what these

companies are really going to have to battle is, am I going to iterate on

commercial reactors? Or am I going to be able to do some sort of demonstration

testing behind the scenes to learn those lessons that I'm inevitably going to have

to learn between now and that first commercial reactor?

Because there's a lot to be learned even to get capacity factors up over time.

I think that iteration's going to happen on the commercial reactors themselves.

But it's also, I don't know if it's a winning formula for all these companies to

say, we're going to be the SpaceX of nuclear.

We're going to iterate, learn, iterate, learn on commercial reactors.

Because ideally, by the time you get to a commercial reactor, you've iterated and

learned, iterated and learned, and then you can just go cookie cutter spit those

things out. But I think it's just the inevitable reality of having to move as fast

as we're having to move, that some of the iteration's going to go from first of a

kind to these nth of a kind projects, and maybe the eighth or the 10th one is

where, okay, now we have the recipe down.

Brennan, it brings to mind an exciting private market announcement.

Neutron Power Ventures was part of this.

Project Omega announced a series A. They raised $80 million.

First of all, massive congratulations to Staff Sheehan and the whole Project Omega

team. Super impressive what they're working on.

Definitely some bias over here. But to the point of this conversation

You got to find ways to monetize a business outside of just, let's iterate on our

singular commercial reactor design and hope we can improve it over time.

And so I bring them up because they've got such a cool approach to fuel recycling,

where they're going to harvest isotopes and sell the isotopes and have a separate

line of business that can then reinvest in fuel recycling programs.

And if their whole value prop was, "No, we're just going to figure out fuel

recycling, and over time we'll get better and better and better at it, and

ultimately that'll make money." We've had this joke before, if all you need is 25

years and $25 billion and you can solve the nuclear problem, you're not solving

anybody's problem. Right?

So you got to find ways to monetize the business as you go and to produce

revenue, exactly to your point. And so I got to give them a shout-out.

It's really exciting, I think, especially to this point about where we are in the

market cycle at this point. The ability to raise money in the current environment

will speak at some level to the quality of the company and the team they've built.

Another company, I'll just shout them out, who announced a big round recently is

Seth Cohen and the Mavria team, Nick Poradek, and Adam Blake.

Shout out to those guys. They just raised $100 million.

Seth's been such an important individual in the nuclear conversation,

in where we are today in nuclear.

Yeah.

I'm hesitant to call it the renaissance, right, but we would not be where we are

today in nuclear without Seth Cohen's contribution.

And so shout out to him. Super cool to see what he's working on.

Yeah. But to the point of high-quality companies are still able to go out and raise

capital despite market conditions.

Yeah. Cool business, too.

Yeah.

And by the way, our friend Brett Rampal has an excellent episode with Seth Cohen

on his "Gener8" podcast that everyone should go listen to.

And it was pretty recent. It was within the last month or two.

Go listen to that because you hear about Seth Cohen went in and broke a bunch of

things, starting in the DOGE effort, but then also in the DOE.

And really high caliber, former Kirkland & Ellis attorney, which those of you

familiar with K&E, it's not easy to get a job there.

Some of the highest caliber lawyers in the world.

And also a little bit of an interesting genesis of how he got there.

He had this interest in UFOs, and so go listen to it. It's worth listening to.

What a cool concept, though. They're doing basically shipping container-sized data

centers, right? Like they're making micro data centers that are presumably

transportable, huh?

Yeah, the data center equivalent of an SMR, yeah.

That's awesome. And I wonder, I'm sure eventually they're going to try to use a

micro reactor for power as well, huh?

I think they'll take whatever electrons they can get-

Yeah

... at some level. But I think that given the interest and desire to catalyze

nuclear, that they'd be happy to offday some electrons at the right price-

Yeah

... from a nuclear reactor.

I saw those guys highlighted in a Wall Street Journal episode the other day.

Congrats to both.

Yeah.

And I totally agree with you, staff and what they're doing at Project Omega,

congrats to you also for the deal there.

Again, guys, not investment advice here, but congrats to you and the team on the

deal there and congrats to Seth. That's exciting.

It's cool to see these guys that went in and broke things and were impactful, and

whether it was in DOGE or in the whole push for nuclear inside the DOE, and what

are they doing now? What are they excited about now?

You mentioned Nick Touran earlier.

He's also a part of a maritime-focused endeavor, which is really interesting, and I

think it'd be hard to get that guy excited about something.

Yeah. Because he knows a lot about a lot of things in nuclear.

He's been a teacher to many of us, and the fact that that got him excited

makes me really want to pay attention as well.

It's like these smart guys, what got them excited is certainly worth paying

attention to.

Yeah. Brennan, it's worth taking a moment to mention maritime nuclear.

There are certain moments in life where something happens, and you realize that

the tides are changing or that there's a new cool kid on the block.

And so I'll tell the story without naming any names, but

had a few cold outreaches and a few warm referrals and a few meetings set up that I

went into about three weeks ago, and back to back over the course of the afternoon,

I had three pitches for maritime nuclear companies.

And I went into that day not thinking much about maritime nuclear, right?

Yeah. It was on my radar. I knew about Nick and Ocean Atomics.

But walked away from that Wednesday afternoon of like, maritime nuclear is in vogue

right now. So opening up the curtain a little bit of what we're seeing from a deal

flow perspective. There's a lot of maritime nuclear deals that are being pitched,

and it's an interesting space. It's kind of a new area to underwrite at some level.

When you think about, hey man, the regulatory perspective's hard enough for

terrestrial-based reactors. What happens when you're talking about shipping cargo

to oversee ports, and who's regulating in the open oceans, and

the waters are a bit muddy there, no pun intended.

I guess part of the technology pitch there is that you have this abundance of water

that you can just use, cycle as coolant, right?

So you're not having to-- The water thing is much more solvable.

The thing that I go to there, it's a massive, massive industry, right?

Yeah.

Like the amount of goods that gets transported in these

massive vessels, whether it's commodities or goods get moved around the world.

I don't know the percentage of fuel consumption that is diesel powering these

ships, but it's a lot. It's a significant amount.

And so, yeah, it's certainly an exciting space.

Brennan, to the line I'll use there is the further you get from Texas, the more you

pay for energy, right?

This is true. Yeah.

And so,

it's one thing to have a terrestrial-sited reactor, somewhere in the US or

somewhere on planet Earth. As you get out in the oceans, you're probably paying

more per megawatt than what you would pay for a land-based system.

And then as you get into outer space, you're paying a lot more than what you would

pay on either of those two primary locations.

So you kind of extrapolate it out from there.

Yeah. Which is why the

space area

of all this is so interesting as well, what the Antares guys are doing, and there's

others chasing that too, is you're going to need a lot of power in space, reliable,

high-density power in space, not just to get there and to move around, but also to

power the things that we want to do there.

Yeah.

Interesting stuff, man. Well, look, let's close the loop on the election.

Fair to say neutral to positive at the federal level and state dependent, depending

on where you're at. I think my home state of Texas, it's going to be an interesting

dynamic related to data centers, and there's no hiding the fact that a lot of these

newer SMR companies were born on renderings of parking a co-located reactor next

to a data center. And so I think the macro there, depending on the state, could be

challenged, but I don't think the macro for the power we need for the grid in

general has changed. I saw a great tweet the other day talking about, hey, did you

guys forget the ADVANCE Act? That was before this AI craze, and that was under

Biden, and that was pre-underwriting any need from AI.

And at that point, we were, you said earlier, Andrew, wanting to triple nuclear by

2050, right?

And so the base case for base load grid scale

nuclear neutral to positive, and that's my framing, is state dependent on

penetration of data centers. A positive to that, which another friend of ours,

a very smart guy, gave me this insight, and I thought it was spot on, is a slowdown

in data centers is probably a good thing for nuclear. Why?

Because these guys said, "I need power tomorrow. What power can I get tomorrow?

I can get nat-gas. Give me a nat-gas turbine." Well, those are back ordered through

the early 2030s now, too. And okay, the menu, I'll rewind.

The menu is nat-gas and nuclear for incremental base load at scale, nat-gas and

nuclear. So what does this do? I think it really gives the nuclear guys the ability

to catch up. A lot of these projects, if they're not going to break ground tomorrow

like they thought they were going to, it gives nuclear a lot of time to catch up

with the technology. And maybe by the time we get there, on the menu, they say I

will build an SMR on site here instead of a gas turbine. Because gas is great.

We have an abundance of gas. We need to use a lot of gas. We've talked about this.

It is very exposed to changes in fuel prices.

You are continuously refueling this thing. It's like filling up your car.

You always got to be putting more fuel in.

The big benefit of nuclear is you have to use new fuel every couple of years,

every five years, depending on the design.

But the benefits of that, of not having that exposure day to day to day, week to

week on the fluctuations in prices and what that does to the economics of the

project if prices change fundamentally is a big part of what makes nuclear

stand apart as well, so.

It's the catch-22 of nuclear of if you already have the CapEx spent, if you already

have a reactor in place, the OpEx is fairly negligible relative to the amount

invested to build the thing. Whereas with the nat gas plant, that's quite the

opposite, right? It's fairly cheap to build a nat gas plant, relative to a

nuclear plant. But it can become very expensive depending on the price of gas,

wherever you may be.

Yeah.

And to your point, you're subject to volatility in those fuel prices in a much more

meaningful way.

Yeah, it's a good comparison of understanding overnight capital costs, which is

if I were to build this thing tomorrow, overnight, what would it cost to build the

thing, versus the LCOE calculations.

Now, neither one of these are perfect, but the LCOE estimates the cost over the

life of the project. Now, an LCOE assumption, to your point, is going to bake in

current gas prices. What are gas prices today?

$3 an MCF, something like that, more or less. What have they been before?

Well, they ran up to north of $10 an MCF in the

early 2000s, like 2006, 2007. And what broke that?

Well, the shale revolution in oil & gas broke that, which also was part of the

big pullback in interest for nuclear, because suddenly gas got really cheap.

And then Fukushima happened. You had this perfect wave.

But comparing the two, what is the LCOE sensitivity to natural gas prices

versus what is an LCOE sensitivity to the price of uranium?

And the LCOE is much more sensitive, I imagine, to changes in gas prices because

you're continuously fueling the thing over the life. So that's a great point.

Yeah. Brennan, that does bring to mind a point that's worth making

about ceilings and about kind of moderating expectations.

We had talked previously about the price of diesel going up and that being positive

for nuclear, right? The price of alternative fuels to nuclear going up simply makes

those LCOEs go up, exactly this conversation.

That said, I read this really interesting analysis about $200 oil, and it was

basically saying,

$200 oil is never going to happen. And if you look back at March when the Iran war

started and the Strait of Hormuz was suddenly closed,

and all of these sets of conditions that suddenly showed up, the shocks to the oil

market, and we still didn't hit $200 oil.

Yeah.

And it's like, okay, provide me some set of conditions where you could reach $200

oil, and you would have to make a lot of pretty crazy assumptions to get there, if

the shock previously couldn't do it.

And so I think that leads to one other key piece of this hydrocarbon

conversation that's I think just a good knowledge base.

I think to this point of

sensitivity between the two fuels of oil, gas, and nuclear, is

understanding the relationship between oil & gas.

And that in the Permian Basin and in many of the productive,

oil-producing regions in the world, oil & gas are co-produced.

And so when the Strait of Hormuz was closed in March, a bunch of people bet that,

hey, the price of oil's going up, the price of nat gas is going up.

And what we saw was the price of oil did go up, but the price of natural gas

actually moderated down slightly over the course of that trade.

And people were really confused about this.

And the response, Doomberg wrote a great article on this, I think in May or so, we

can

confirm that. But he basically just talked about co-production, and that when you

drill a well, you're going to get out some oil, and you're going to get out some

gas. And in certain areas, you'll get out a little more oil, and in some areas,

you'll get a little more gas. But these are co-produced chemicals.

They're coming out of the same wellbore.

And so you go out and you drill a well, and

I think it's important to understand that there is ultimately an ultra long-term

macroeconomics theoretical perspective.

You're going to find clearing prices that have pretty comparable fuel costs across

the board, but there will still be some

interrelation caused by co-production, right?

So I just think that's an important piece to answer why did nat gas prices go out,

because all these mining rigs got stood up in March and April saying, "Hey, there's

not oil coming out of the Middle East.

We need to drill new wells in existing locations." We drilled those new wells with

a desire to produce oil, and what do you get?

You get a whole lot of natural gas coming out of those wells as well.

Yeah. And so that drives down the price of gas as a co-produced item.

And I go through this long diatribe just to make the point of, yeah, gas may go up

over time, but I wouldn't count on

going past $10 gas ever in our lifetimes, right?

That we will find inventory, and new ways to produce this stuff.

New shale frack.

Yeah. So you've got to bring the cost of nuclear down as the solution to this.

You can't count on the other guys getting worse.

It's great framing and great education as well.

With my oil & gas background, my brain tends to try to draw parallels there

because it's true. I spent a lot of time in the Permian Basin.

I was just in Midland most of this week, actually. And it's crazy.

If you conceptually think about negative gas prices,

just what does that even mean? Negative gas prices.

Imagine you go to fill your car up, and I'm talking about natural gas, but just

conceptually, you go to fill your car up, and instead of paying for the gas, they

pay you to take the gas. This happens in the Permian Basin, to your point.

Negative gas prices or close to zero gas, what does that mean?

It means I'm producing this thing that I can't get rid of, and therefore I'm going

to pay someone to take it off of my hands.

And so it's really good framing, Andrew, because what happens out there, and this

is why a lot of data center projects have gotten stood up out there, and they're

using behind the meter gas generation, because right now, gas is cheap.

Why is gas cheap? Because they're producing it to produce oil.

It comes out, they have to do something with it.

Gas is really hard to transport without a pipeline. You can't move it.

So if there's not pipeline capacity to move it around the country, then there's

nothing to do with it. What do they do historically? They flared it.

Well, that's not great for the environment either, so there's a lot of restrictions

and rules around flaring the gas. Flaring it means you're just burning it into the

atmosphere, wasting it, essentially.

And so there's a big push to get even more pipeline capacity out of the Permian for

this reason, because there's so much gas there.

With the extra gas, you can either build something right on site that uses it, or

you can build a pipeline to move it.

And it's also why gas gets really expensive in certain parts of the country in the

winter when there's a big storm and a big freeze, and then it stays cheap in Texas,

to your point. So we could probably talk an hour.

Maybe we should do an episode someday on natural gas and how it functions.

Yeah. But it's a really good point you made about to produce the oil, you got to produce

the gas. They come out together. Oil comes with a bunch of gas typically, and a

bunch of water, and that mix changes depending on the basin.

But great framing, man. I love it.

Let's move on now. You ready to talk? So we covered the X-energy deal.

You want to give another shout-out to Julie and team, the EDF, the Constellation loan,

the conditional financing, $5 billion? It's so great to see these announcements.

The Energy Department announces a $5 billion loan to boost nuclear power and help

lower costs in Illinois, Maryland, and Pennsylvania.

A lot of good work being done there on uprates and extensions, huh?

It's awesome to see another announcement here.

It seems like they've been coming out every couple of weeks these days.

It looks like this is

uprates at eight plants in Illinois, Maryland, and Pennsylvania.

The plants being Braidwood, Byron, Clinton, Dresden, LaSalle, and Quad Cities in

Illinois, Calvert Cliffs in Maryland, and Limerick in Pennsylvania.

Some of these plants where the uprates were announced earlier.

We had the week of uprates, I think at

middle of October, beginning of October.

And so some of these plants now are getting

energy dominance financing as part of the uprate project.

So, if the investment alone or the offtake alone wasn't

good enough, now you get an even sweeter package on it.

So, I think moreover to the comment we've shared, and I don't know if I've publicly

called it, but the

Google announcement of $4.7 billion

against 890 megawatts of uprates, it's probably going to be the best rough

gigawatt dollar spent of the 2020s.

Yeah, you've made that framing before, what is the dollar per gigawatt?

Yeah.

Yeah, and to your point too, this was really part of other hyperscaler

announcements that have already been announced, have taken this capacity away.

And so what do those agreements allow Constellation to do?

They said, "Okay, we're going to get a market premium rate by hyperscalers for

these volumes, and therefore we can go underwrite spending that capital to bring

these volumes online." What does the EDF financing do?

Well, it's just additional tailwinds to get those volumes online with lower cost

financing. So instead of using equity dollars to go deploy these projects or higher

cost project finance, they're going to be able to use low-cost debt financing.

So great for all parties here. Great for the plants, uprates, extensions.

Great for the hyperscalers. They get firm volumes with 20-plus year commitments.

And great for Constellation. They get low-cost financing.

So win-win-win on this front.

I think the simplest model to understand this is it brings down the interest rate,

right?

Yeah.

You're going to loan some money to do an uprate project and

think of it as taking a loan to do a renovation on your house, and

renovate the kitchen, and the EDF steps in and says like, "Hey, we'll give you a

sweeter interest rate on your loan." I think that's the right mental model for

folks.

Yeah, and I'm just looking here. I just briefly looked up the hyperscale agreements

tied to this. As Google, five of the eight plants were in an October 6 announcement

of a 20-year PPA between Google and Constellation.

Amazon on September 30th, Constellation finalized the PPA with Amazon, supporting

190 megawatt uprate at Calvert Cliffs. Meta.

Clinton was already in line for a 30 megawatt uprate under a 2025 deal with Meta.

Walmart became the first retailer to sign a nuclear PPA for power from Dresden.

It's awesome to see Walmart jumping in there.

So yeah, these are deals we've already discussed previously, but again, they're now

going to get done with lower cost financing from the EDF, which is good for all

parties.

Should we talk about Darlington?

Let's do it, man. I saw this.

I really like and follow Steffan Szumowski, I apologize if I pronounce it wrong, he

has some great insights on X, and brought this up. You want to start, Andrew or me?

Darlington

has a BWRX-300 project that announced a

delay that it will no longer be on time, nor will it be on budget.

Uh-oh.

Uh-oh. This came from Nick Touran as well, huh, initially posted this, who's

another great one to follow. Go ahead, Andrew.

They didn't provide too much more than that, frankly.

They didn't give revised costs. They didn't give a revised deadline.

They just said, "Hey, we're not going to be there on time."

Let's read. So Nick Touran's tweet, I'm going to read it here.

"OPG update on the BWRX-300. The DNNP Unit 1 is no longer expected to achieve the

previously disclosed commercial operation date target of October 2030, or be

completed within the previously disclosed estimated cost of $7.7 billion."

And that's where a lot of the skeptics here have been around this specific

technology being deployed in Canada.

So you have that pushback from the Canadians, like, "Why did

we not pick a sovereign design? Why did we not pick a domestic design?" I saw Chris

Keefer was quite vocal about this, so the support for the CANDU reactors and why

they went this way. And then separately, just if we're going to do an SMR project,

why are we picking older technology that is very high on a dollar per kilowatt

basis? So that's been the pushback I've seen.

The proponents of it I've seen is more like, look, well, the here and the now

technologies that are licensed and deployable and understood is basically the

AP1000 from Westinghouse, the BWRX-300 from GE.

So if you want to build something today and get to work on coming down the cost

curve, those are your options. Well, you've seen the Oppenheimer guys, you've seen

the nuclear company really go more targeted towards the AP1000 design.

You've seen Elementl go towards the BWRX-300 design their project in Ohio with

Google. By the way, David Faherty was on the Catalyst podcast with Shayle Kann

yesterday. That's also worth a listen.

That's a must-listen. That's a fantastic episode.

And those men, those guys are inspiring.

I really like them a lot, what they're trying to do and just really focused on

execution. So the question is like, okay, hey look, we're going to go execute on

multiple projects, and we're going to learn from that, and then we're going to

execute on multiple more projects in a technology agnostic way.

Well, their view is that this is a smaller sized build, so we can build more of

them quicker. Therefore, we're going to try to go deploy half a dozen of these

things in Ohio, and we're going to learn a lot along the way.

So the other positive or defense I heard of this was, look, there's a lot

of civil infrastructure costs being spent in Darlington that will be spread out

across future units. It's that fixed cost that has to be deployed either way.

And so, at the end of the day, I think you and I both agree, we want this to get

built. We want it to get built on time. We want it to get built on budget.

And we're also not immune to the realities of building these things for the first

time.

Brennan,

it's always important to normalize our numbers.

So the original estimate, 7.7 billion against 300

megawatts, is a $25.6 billion

gigawatt, if you're going to put in a few of these units.

That's expensive as hell.

Say that number again. Say that number again.

25.6.

Woof.

Yeah. It's an expensive gigawatt.

Yeah.

The solution to building new nuclear is bringing down the cost to be--

It goes back to this whole thing we've been talking about of overnight cost of gas

plants, about $2 billion, $3 billion, and then you're subject to the price of the

fuel. And the market has declaratively announced they'd

much rather take fuel risk. And I think that's why we harped on about

understanding ceilings around hydrocarbon markets, because we got to get more

competitive there. If we can build a nuclear plant for $5 billion, we'll have

announcements all over the country.

But if we're saying, hey, it's 25 billion for a gigawatt of this

technology,

it's going to be really tough to keep doing these, especially when the first one

sees a delay, and we don't even know what the cost is going to be and what the due

date is going to be.

Markets are highly influenced by expectations.

Anybody who's done enough economics, there's always an expectation term, and when

you create volatility in that expectation term, you have to underwrite to a

downside case. And so it becomes

really tough to get excited about some of these projects when you don't have a good

expectation and your base case is a $25 billion gigawatt.

Yeah.

One of the lines that has been discussed is,

there may be a valley of death with some of these 300 megawatt SMR

water-cooled reactors. And it's not that I'm inherently bearish, and I think a lot

of what I'm commenting sounds like, oh, I'm super against these.

I'm not against these. MPV's an investor in Flue Energy.

They're taking the BWRX-300 design and planning to build it in Port of Victoria in

Texas. Novel build approaches, but realistic expectations about what can be done

there. But the line is, with some of these valley of death reactors as they've been

dubbed, is how about 75% of the civil infrastructure for a third of the power

output? And it's like, well, wait a second, we're already talking about something

that's super expensive to begin with.

So

we need to find a way to lower the cost.

Yeah.

And that's why I think with some of these EDF announcements, the operating projects

are great, but they have a cap.

Yeah.

Right? You can only get so much juice out of a reactor.

Yeah.

And so at some point you got to build new infrastructure and,

yeah, the subsidizing them is not going to be the path to

building.

Yeah. In reality, there's only so much capacity, to your point, of operating

extensions, and it's the lowest hanging fruit.

Yeah.

Yeah. That's what's so tough about the financing piece of this is like, if you're

an investor, you want to underwrite the project, the widget, whatever it is.

And maybe you say, "I want to see how the first one goes before I make a decision

on the second one. And then I want to see how the second one goes before I make

a decision on the third one." But to your point, the civil infrastructure build needs

to happen either way. So do you bill all that to the first investor, or are you

able to allocate that over multiple projects?

And that's the hard thing is it's like, okay, well, we need you to commit to three

of these or four of these for the math to work, and we're going to average out the

dollar per kilowatt across those three or four facilities. Where are we at?

We're at a gigawatt.

Okay, what does the math look like? What does the civil infrastructure look like?

Should I just go build an AP1000? And I don't know. I haven't seen that math.

But I think that's what these guys are wrestling, and I can see both sides.

I can see that if I'm going to do three or four of these, I might as well do one of

those. And I can see, well, the third and the fourth version of this thing's going

to be a lot more efficient than doing one of those things.

Yeah.

And so-

And Brennan, I should point out, when I say $25 billion gigawatt, there are

many people who would correctly argue with me and say, "You're going to do better

on the second, and you're going to do better on the third than you did on the

second. You're going to do better on the fourth than you did on the third." And at

that point, you're at 1,200 megawatts and you're able to kind of

compound down, and you're not at $25 billion all in, you're at

$14 billion all in. And then you look a little bit more like an AP1000.

You have more flexibility, and you can go out and build these as one-offs.

Hopefully, the way you build the fourth unit, not the first unit,

in other locations and other places, and now you have more flexible power resource

to give to a community who may only need 300 megawatts and doesn't need an AP1000.

Yeah. That's a good point. It's a good point.

At some point we have to talk about this with John Arnold as well.

At some point, we have to innovate our way up the size curve.

Because-

That's been what I've been saying for-

Yeah

... for months now is, when people talk about a gigawatt reactor, they can't help

themselves, they use the term AP1000.

Yeah.

Nobody calls it a gigawatt. They call it AP1000.

And it's like the default vocabulary in the industry is-

Yeah

... if you want a big reactor, it's an AP1000, and it's Westinghouse.

And there's not competition in that market.

Yeah.

And we've said it here before, and we'll say it again, American greatness comes

from competition. And if we want to have greatness at this scale, we need

competition at this scale.

Yeah. Totally true. It's become the Google or the Uber word of, I'm going to search

for something, I'm going to Google it.

Yeah.

I'm going to order a car, I'm going to order an Uber.

I'm going to build a gigawatt, I'm going to build an AP1000. It's a good point.

It's a very good point.

Yeah.

I think it's worth kind of closing the loop too on this New Nuclear Capital summit

from Tuesday. The line in the room was,

the question was, "Can we end on a positive note?" And they went down the panel and

everybody

being funny. "I'm positive we need more government subsidies and government

support- ... in building nuclear." And

it was a harmonious announcement coming from the stage

and maybe I'm a bit subversive here, but I don't think so.

I think that American markets are great when they're competitive and

properly advantaged. And so government's role, my reaction to this is, I

don't think these EDF loans are going to solve any problems, frankly.

Who's the beneficiary when EDF announces these uprate projects?

It's the person who's going to have to take a higher interest loan, which was

either the utility or the offtaker, right?

Fisher or Constellation, basically.

Yeah. So the utility, if it's Fisher or Constellation, then that means ultimately

the ratepayers are paying a little bit less, which is a good thing for society.

If it's Google, then it's taxpayer dollars going to subsidize a loan for a

hyperscaler, right? And we can have

a conversation about whether or not that's how taxpayer dollars should be spent.

Yeah.

But if it's, hey, we're going to go out and build greenfield projects, and what we

need is the EDF to provide cost overrun insurance, I think that is a

horrible model for building these things because it adds a

disincentive to on time, under budget performance.

And it says, "Hey, if things do go sideways, you'll get bailed out." And the

investment community at large is not going to show up and underwrite these things

without that backstop.

Yeah. And that backstop is not how we're going to solve the problem here.

And there is a time and a place, right?

I have a bit of a crass analogy that I've developed of the nuclear methadone

clinic. Right? The EDF office in some ways can be the methadone clinic of like,

you got to get off the hard stuff and there's a transition period, and there's a

time and a place, and we're going to provide you the materials to help you out and

get better. But if you keep going back to the methadone clinic and you don't

actually heal, and you can't go off and live a life-

Yeah

... you just switch your juice, right?

And so I want to see competition solve big scale reactors.

I want to see competition bring down the price of a gigawatt such

that the private markets are saying, "Hey, we don't need a subsidized loan.

I'll build this thing. I'll throw my infrastructure finance dollars into this, and

we'll go build a bunch of these and be competitive.

And if the EDF wants to show up and make it cheaper for us, great.

But we don't need their cash to make it work."

Yeah.

And that's my positive vision of a nuclear abundant future and my belief of

how we need to solve that to get there.

Yeah, you've been pretty vocal about it.

It's like, let the private markets figure it out.

Well, the alternative is no one-- I won't say no one, most people don't want the

government overly involved in anything, right?

They want the government to stay out of healthcare.

They want the government to stay out of education.

But in this case, it's almost like if you were to say, what was the dollar per

kilowatt of the reactors built in France

by the other EDF, the utility, the state-owned, state-backed utility in France.

I don't think it mattered.

And there's criticism on the cost as well of Hinkley Point C, for example.

But when the governments get involved in backstopping these things and providing

all the financing for these things, I mean, France is not a low labor cost country.

Yeah.

That was the framing John Arnold laid out is, hey, large scale nuclear works really

well in countries with low labor costs and high electricity costs.

So you can use cheap labor to compete with prices that are really high.

And so you look at the US and you say, okay, we have relatively high labor costs,

and we have very cheap electricity costs versus the rest of the world.

Granted, we use a lot more and we need a lot more because we're leading the AI

race. But for countries like France, it doesn't really matter.

The facilities in the UAE, those were done respectably well, but it probably

didn't matter so much. Why? Because they're state-owned, state-controlled,

state-financed. And I don't think the nuclear industry in the US wants to be

state-owned, state-controlled, and state-financed.

But we want the benefits of that, right?

Yeah.

We want the benefits on the front end of the financing.

And so, yeah, I largely agree. I think we need a lot of oxygen on the front end,

and then we need there to be a weaning off plan

of subsidized financing.

So two things come to mind. One is I would add an additional piece to John Arnold's

framework of you need scientific and engineering institutional

capability as a third piece to build this stuff.

Because if it's low labor

costs and expensive electricity costs, then sub-Saharan Africa would be full of

nuclear plants.

Yeah, that's true.

So there's more to the model than those two things.

And the other piece on the EDF front that I'll call out, and I may be

misattributing this, but I believe it's Peter Drucker who said, "Show me the

incentive, and I'll show you the outcome, and I'll tell you the outcome." Right?

So if you incentivize and you create some incentive of, oh, hey, we're going to use

government dollars to provide cost overrun insurance and make that premium cheaper,

well, guess what? You're going to get cost overruns.

And if you do some sort of performance-based bonus or tax credit, and I

don't have the answer, I wish I did, but I think we need to scheme up on the carrot

on the front end,

not the cushion on the back end. Right?

If you say, "Hey, we've got all these cushions, and you guys can spend as much as

you need to," you're going to end up with cost plus nuclear, and if we have cost

plus nuclear, we're not going to build this stuff.

Yeah.

Cost plus scares me. I don't like that phrase.

I don't like it.

Other than Mark Cuban's company. Yeah.

Yeah.

Okay, I know we're running short on time here. Let's finish this up.

Lots of other things we could talk about. Let's talk Urenco real quick.

What happened? Urenco USA produced its first cylinder of UF6, enriched to 5 to

10% U-235, which is considered LEU+, in Eunice, New Mexico, which

it calls the first commercial LEU+ production in the Western world.

This was announced on November 2nd.

The NRC authorized enrichment up to 10% in September 2025.

The customer and fabricator aren't named here, but the cylinder ships with others

in late spring 2027. Good news here, huh?

We're finally getting there on domestic enrichment capacity for LEU+ and

eventually to HALEU.

I'm not counting my cylinders before they hatch, but

yeah, it's fantastic news, man. We need the capability.

We need to be able to

have a domestic,

robust front-end fuel cycle.

Yeah, Brennan,

sometimes we'll do small digressions for a little educational material.

One of the small digressions for educational material, and a question I have around

this announcement, Urenco USA produced this.

Basically, the point is, if you're going to have unobligated supplies, that applies

not only to the material itself, the physical material.

So yeah, you've got to mine it in the US, and you convert it in the US, and you've

got to enrich it in the US, and you've got to fuel fabricate it in the US.

And there, your uranium for unobligated material is US-based.

Not only does the physical material have to be unobligated through that supply

chain, but the technologies along the way used to process it

also have to be domestically supplied.

And so, I'm curious on Urenco, granted, they're not the primary suppliers

for unobligated materials, but could they be is kind of the

question. Are the centrifuge designs and the parts used in these centrifuges,

would they qualify as unobligated?

And so, a tidbit I learned recently and figured the world should know, that the

technology itself must also be unobligated, and the materials and the equipment

used for the processing. So, the term unobligated when it comes to uranium has

wide and reaching implications.

That's interesting, man. Good perspective.

Yeah.

On the fuel front, also talking HALEU.

Oklo announced a deal with Centrus, and a really interesting takeaway here I saw.

Again, a shout-out to Steffan Szumowski. I think he has some great perspectives on X.

Centrus is making about 600 kilograms of HALEU per year.

And who is getting that HALEU is the question.

You've seen four deals announced with Centrus, Oklo, X-energy, Antares, Radiant

by 2030. Who's actually getting the delivery was the question.

I thought this was a good question, and clearly not something that was disclosed.

So, we talked about the cash on Centrus' balance sheet, I'm sure is

earmarked to try to help solve this problem. But it is a good question.

Who's getting the allocation by 2030?

And if not, where is the incremental capacity coming from?

Will Centrus become the kingmaker of nuclear?

Yeah. So yeah, interesting take there, but congratulations for those guys to

continue to announce deals. Anything else on that front, Andrew?

Nothing here.

Okay. Oklo Groves 1 cleared project in Lockhart, Texas.

The DOE cleared the final operations for the Groves Isotope Test Reactor, Groves 1.

This was the reactor used for their criticality, allowing it to move into research,

testing, and the training phase. So congratulations to the Oklo Isotopes team,

and another win following up their criticality win earlier this year.

Who's going to go critical next, Andrew? Do we know? Something's coming.

Yeah.

Something's coming out of Radiant or Last Energy or someone else.

There's got to be something else coming soon.

We need another win on the pilot program.

I'll predict Radiant goes critical by the end of the year.

Yeah, and I guess dissecting that a little bit,

they're taking it a step further, right, which is part of the delay there.

Radiant is taking it a step beyond just cold criticality, is my understanding.

Is that correct?

That's correct.

Yeah.

They're working on balance plant.

Yeah, and I think, too, Last Energy's doing similar.

They're trying to ultimately convert it into a power-producing facility.

So,

last real point here. I meant to pose this earlier and didn't come back to it.

What is the new benchmark for a company starting right now?

We talked about earlier this wave of companies that were formed around the peak of

inflated expectations, and they were able to point to the pilot program.

They were able to roll up their sleeves and say, "Hey, we got selected into this

thing, and there's this deadline, and whoever gets there is a winner, will be

deemed a winner by the investment community." And we've seen some companies get

there, some not, for various reasons.

What's the new benchmark? Is it the Launchpad program?

Because I've talked to another startup company here recently, and they were like,

"Yeah, we're not doing Launchpad because we feel like you had to do the pilot

program

to reach the criticality date because the press and everyone was focused on that.

And now Launchpad, we're not sure it creates the same level of hype around

potential fundraising." Which is an interesting perspective, because my response

was, "You should absolutely do the Launchpad program."

Yeah.

The ease, the access to the DOE facilities and everything that that provides, you

should absolutely do the Launchpad program.

So it left me thinking, what is the benchmark between

startup today and commercialization now that the pilot program's gone?

And does there need to be some second round or some second deadline set by the DOE,

or are these guys going to be able to create their own benchmarks, more or less, in

fundraising?

I would think the latter. I would think that individual companies will have

different priorities, and that's probably a good thing.

And the two benchmarks that come to mind are going to be power gen, balance plant,

in a more meaningful way, and manufacturing capabilities,

right? Starting to stand up real manufacturing operations

for some of these reactors, and beginning serial production.

Because the hard part, the Musk quote is, "The hard part's not designing electric

cars, it's making a million of them," right?

The hard part's not actually designing

... It is hard, but the harder part is not designing the reactor, it's going to be

making a million of them. And so, fortunately, here in the US, we have some

really impressive talent and deep tech expertise in manufacturing.

As much as kind of maybe less sophisticated manufacturing has gone overseas in many

ways, we do have some great, smart talent for deep tech manufacturing

here to help build these projects out.

But, yeah, I'll be looking for announcements around standing up manufacturing

sites.

Yeah.

Good stuff, man. Well, this has been a lot of fun. Anything else?

I know we're almost out of time here.

No. Thanks, Brennan. This has been fantastic.

We're recording Friday, November 13th.

I'll see you Monday in Phoenix. Hopefully, we can get this out by then.

The ANS Winter Conference. Man, we're almost at the end of the conference circuit.

See you in Phoenix, Brennan.

Thank you for joining another episode of the "Nuclear Investing Podcast." Be sure

to like, subscribe, and follow, and stay tuned to continue learning about how to

invest in nuclear energy. See you next time.

Brennan Moore is the founder and managing partner of Nuclear Capital Partners.

All opinions expressed by Brennan and podcast guests are solely their own opinions

and do not reflect the opinion of Nuclear Capital Partners.

This podcast is for informational purposes only, and should not be relied upon as a

basis for investment decisions. Nothing in this podcast is an offer to sell or a

solicitation of an offer to buy any security.

Nuclear Capital Partners, its affiliates and investors may hold positions in

companies discussed on this podcast.