Redeeming The Game

THERE IS NO ETERNAL SCOREBOARD

Why Christian Coaches Need to Stop Trying to Prove Their Worth

What if one of the greatest burdens Christian coaches carry is a burden Jesus never asked them to carry?

Many coaches live with the belief that when they stand before Jesus in eternity, they will have to give an account of how many players they led to Christ, how many lives they changed, and how successful they were in using basketball to advance the Gospel.

And while Scripture absolutely calls us to faithfulness, stewardship, and accountability, there is a difference between giving an account to God and believing that our eternal value depends on our spiritual performance.

In this deeply personal episode of Redeeming the Game, Coach Matt Sanders challenges the internal scoreboard that so many coaches carry.

For years, he lived trying to prove himself—to the basketball world, to others, and even to God. He believed his record, accomplishments, and impact were somehow connected to his worth.

But the finished work of Jesus tells a different story.

The blood of Christ is not an invitation to keep score. It is the declaration that the work we could never accomplish has already been accomplished through Him.

We’ll talk about:

  • Why Christian coaches sometimes carry an unhealthy burden of spiritual performance.
  • The difference between biblical accountability and trying to earn God’s approval.
  • Why the number of players you lead to Christ is not your righteousness.
  • How the finished work of Jesus changes the way we approach coaching, leadership, and ministry.
  • Why you can pursue excellence, serve faithfully, and share the Gospel without living under the pressure to prove your worth.

If you’re a head coach, assistant coach, trainer, or basketball missionary who has ever felt like you haven’t done enough for God, this conversation is for you.

You are called to be faithful. You are called to love people. You are called to share the hope of Jesus.

But you are not called to earn what Jesus has already given you.

Your record is not your righteousness. Your impact is not your identity. And there is no eternal scoreboard.

Welcome to Redeeming the Game.

 If could go back and talk to my younger self as a coach, these are the 10 things I’d tell him first.
I put them all into a free guide called “10 Things I Wish I Knew as a Young Coach.”
No fluff. No playbooks. Just real lessons from years of coaching, leading, winning, losing, and learning.
If you’re early in your coaching journey, or you want to coach with more purpose and clarity, grab it for free below.
👇 Free download linked below 👇
www.redeemingthegame.com/10things

matt@redeemingthegame.com

What is Redeeming The Game?

This is a space for coaches, trainers, and leaders who love the game — but don’t want the game to cost them their family, their integrity, or their soul.

Here, we talk about leadership, pressure, culture, identity, and the quiet tensions no one prepares you for when you step into coaching.

This isn’t about chasing wins at all costs.
It’s about restoring what the game was meant to form in us — and in the players we lead.

This podcast is presented by the Beloved Coaches Collective, a community committed to coaching from identity, not insecurity.

I’m Coach Sanders.
Let’s redeem the game — one coach at a time.

That there's no amount of good deeds
that you can do with these kids that

is gonna change the way He feels
a- about you now and in the end.

The account is for how you
lived your life, not for the

amount of souls you got saved.

Welcome back everybody to the podcast.

Sitting here living room style.

If you don't get to see this, I hate
it for you because I'm comfortable

today, not sitting on the stool.

Uh, but if you are only being able
to listen, thank you for tuning in.

Today's podcast is gonna be very unique.

Um, there is, uh, uh, some time as
the podcast creator, um, wherein

we take a lot of time to, uh, build
out what we're gonna talk about.

We go deep into it.

Um, we ChatGPT it or
you, uh, you just AI it.

I know a lot of podcastri- podcast
friends I talk to, and, uh, I use all

kinds of mediums, um, information,
um, uh, mediums to, um, help me

grow in what I'm gonna talk about.

But this week, um, there's no script.

Um, there's no, uh, three
points and a sermon as they say.

This one is from my heart to you.

And I wanted to take a, some time
this week, uh, probably on the short

end of the time, and just say to you
something that is burning in my heart

that I, um, I feel like everybody
from time to time needs to hear.

But especially if you're a leader, and
most importantly, if you're a young head

coach or a coach or an assistant coach.

Um, I think everybody needs to
hear what I'm about to say and,

um, this one's important to me.

So welcome to the podcast
and, uh, the title, which we

need one each and every week.

The title for this podcast this week
is There Is No Eternal Scoreboard.

And I just wanna start by saying that As
a born again, righteous, redeemed believer

in who, uh, God says we are, um, there is
a, an elimination in that of the internal

scoreboard, the external scoreboard.

There is not a, uh, as my, my
shout out to my buddy Greg White

here, God is not a bean counter.

Um, he is not the, the judge holding the
counter, um, in the courtroom weighing

out your good deeds and your bad deeds.

Because of the, the blood sacrifice,
uh, the transfer of the gift from

Jesus to us by his sacrifice,
those things have been eliminated.

The Israelites tried to do it
by sacrificing every single day,

and it didn't, it didn't work.

It didn't, um, get them to
where they needed to be.

Okay?

And so, uh, I was listening to a couple
podcasts this week by coaches and talking

to some other coaching friends and, uh,
my, my basketball missionary friends,

and I just feel like that somebody
needs to hear that good news today.

There is not an eternal scoreboard in
who and what and how you do what you do.

You know, I spent so many years, um,
trying to prove to, number one, to

myself, number two, really to God,
number three, uh, maybe even to my family

and, and not in, um, in a, in a fashion
in which my, my parents made me feel

like I had to prove something to them.

That was never the case.

Shout out, Mom and Dad.

That was never the case.

I never felt like I had to go prove myself
s- to them to, to receive their love.

That was never the case I did feel
like I had to go prove myself to

the world, uh, because a, a coach
told me that I was never gonna be

of the 1% that made it to college.

And so I felt like I had to
go prove to that coach or

coaches that they were wrong.

And I l- I, I…

That in- that internal scoreboard
created this, um, insatiable, um,

uninhibited drive to win really.

To win games, to win championships,
and somehow all of that got coupled

with this, um, performance-based
love that if I got to this place, my

name would get in lights, and people
would recognize me and love me.

Uh, not, not because of the, the lives
that would be changed by the game by

which I was the coach of it, but because
I won, and that my record as a head coach

would say to everybody, "He's made it."

And man, did I set out to do that.

And somewhere in there, there is
intertwined, if you are a believer in

God, and you believe that Jesus died,
and he rose, and your salvation and,

and, i- and your soul is eternally safe
into, into eternity with, with Jesus

Christ and the Lord, there's somewhere in
there as a coach, we have been deceived.

We've been deceived by the culture
that took over sports, and that,

that culture is such that to say
that there is an eternal scoreboard.

I'm not talking about a
here and now scoreboard.

I'm not talking about like, if I win, I…

You know, the people are gonna love me.

I'm talking about way,
way deeper than that.

Almost, if I could be
honest, worse than that.

I think it is utterly, um, horrible, is
the right way to put it for me, that I

somehow thought that winning my players
to Jesus, being a good Christian coach

who didn't cuss, who didn't smoke,
who didn't drink, and all the things

that, that, that stack this thing up.

And don't get tattoos, and, and don't,
um, don't berate your wife, and don't

cheat on your w- all, all these things
would get me this like, in the end, when

I crossed over, there's this, "I'm gonna
stand before the throne, and there's

gonna be this scoreboard account."

And I heard a coach say this
the other day, and it ga- it sh-

it sent shivers down my spine.

Because somehow, I believe this too,
not subcon- not consciously, but

subconsciously, I actually believed
that the, the possibility for me to be

in, uh, good graces with the Father,
Son, and Holy Spirit, the Trinity,

when I crossed over into the heavenly
of heavenlies, that if I did the…

If I did all of those things, there
would be this eternal scoreboard, that

I would have to give an account for
those things that have been counted.

And I want you to know
that I believe with all…

This is me, and so if you wanna push
back on this, that- that's totally fine.

But I want you to know I
don't believe that anymore.

In fact, I w- I hope there's a coach
who hears that, that there is not some

level of good deeds that you will do
to lead kids to Jesus that gets them

to eternity, that there is this tally
system that's going on in the heavens.

I don't believe that's there, and I
want you to know that when I became,

um, a, in my life, when I became aware
of this six years ago, it completely

transformed the way I coached.

Because the here and the now of
leading a player to Jesus now

obviously affects their eternity
later, but it's more important now.

I would rather get the emails, the phone
calls, and the text messages now that

say, "You have no idea that that day,
on that moment, that what you said to

me, God used to transform my life."

Truthfully, that is exactly
what I want to hear.

I, I want to hear that.

I want to hear that, that well done, good
and faithful servant in that statement.

And somehow, as coaches, we have bought
this, that we, we, we, we bought this, uh,

deep, dark, secretive lie that is going…

Especially, let me rephrase that.

This, the, we bought this deceptive
lie that that is what we were designed

to do, and it is going to be a part
of what we do when we cross over.

So therefore, like, the motivation,
and I hope you can hear this in

my voice, the motivation about the
here and now is more about the end.

And I'm like, I did that for so long,
and that is a w- a high-level motivator.

It works.

You can be cr- I mean,
unbelievably motivated.

But here's what happens.

When a coach, and I'm using myself
as an example, when a coach runs

across a kid who completely goes, "I
want nothing to do with that Jesus.

You're a fraud.

He's a fraud.

All of the things that you say are
not real," m- mostly because I'm so

motivated by the end that I miss the
here and now, and I miss what they need.

And they need the God of the universe
through the game by the, by the coach who

is in front of them to say, "I love you
just as you are, not as you ought to be."

And I didn't do that.

I did not do that.

That I didn't portray the love
of God for the first 25 years

of my, my coaching career.

And I'm not saying, and I, I tend to
get these from time to time with my

former players, "You did do that."

But I know, I know there was
a deeper level to it because

I've now experienced it.

That the players now that I coach
don't see the Jekyll and Hyde.

The guy who is different in, when the
lights come on and the game happens

than the guy who is hanging out with
them in the van or the bus or the

classroom, who loves them unconditionally.

See, the two things can coexist.

You can love them unconditionally in the
game, in the midst of the competition,

be a fiery competitor, and be after
their hearts and be the same person

in the classroom, in the bus, in the
cafeteria, at dinner, whatever it is.

And we, we have, we have, we have
totally, in athletics especially,

but most importantly with basketball,
we have bought the lie that

those two things are separate.

There is the sacred and the secular.

That basketball itself is meant to be
a scoreboard-keeping, life-changing

game that's only meant for the gym,
the court, the time that you're there.

And that's not the case at all And
so when I heard this coach say that,

I found myself remembering that I
was ultimately motivated by this.

I was ultimately motivated on the deepest
parts of me to try to thrust out all

of the non-Christian parts so that they
would want to be like the Christ in me,

and I was actually faking it because
when I got to the game, I completely…

That guy, that, that, that person
that was, you know, not cursing,

not screaming, not all the n- the
non-Christian value things, the non-moral

value things, they went away when
the lights came on, and I became this

raging idiot because we weren't winning

I threw one of these.

I broke one of these.

I, many, many pens got thrown.

I broke watches because I clapped so
hard because of the rage on the inside of

me that these young men and young women
were not more than just cogs in a wheel

to me, th- 'cause that's what they were.

It was subconscious, and I wasn't
using them sub- consciously, but

subconsciously it was a means to get
me to the win so that I could say, and

people would say, and then I can say,
"Well, I'm a good Christian coach,"

and they can say, "We love you."

And they learned a lot because I
hear it from them, and I'm, again,

I'm not saying that they don't.

So shout out to all you guys and girls
who reach out and say thank you so much.

That, this, this isn't that.

I'm just saying that there's not an
eternal scoreboard, that the account

that we will give is for our whole
lives, and our whole lives are right now.

But there's no tally mark to go,
"Well, you didn't speak to that

kid, and you didn't lead that kid to
Jesus, therefore you don't get in."

I can't imagine being
motivated by that now.

I can't because it always is going,
what do you do with the kid who says no?

What do you do with the kid who says
no because you acted a crazy way?

What do you do with that?

I don't know what you do with that.

Because now I know that the thing that
I want, wanted to do, I never did it

until God came in and ambushed me with
His love and said, "I love you just

as you are, not as you ought to be."

And how in the world can
I not coach that way?

And you can ask the players, man, I just
wish I have them all on here, how there

was an about face in how I did everything,
and there wasn't this raging up and

down the sidelines and throwing things.

That doesn't mean I
re- r- raised my voice.

Don't hear that.

That, that's for sure.

That definitely happened because they're,
you know, it's loud, and sometimes to

raise your voice in a, in a game is,
is helpful to get people's attention.

I'm just talking about the, the
undressing, the de- the degrading,

the demonstrative statements that were
gonna m- make that player feel singled

out, spotlighted, and not good enough.

When my life should say, and the way
I coach them should say, "You're,

y- well, I love you just as you
are, not as you ought to be."

Do we want you to do better
in certain situations?

Absolutely.

But when that scoreboard, that
eternal scoreboard went away, I

want you to hear this, when it went
away, it changed everything for me.

And to be frank with you, because
of the origin story of basketball

and its ability to tell me that God
loves basketball as much as I do, and

there is a, an, uh, an eternal use
for it, that God was working in it.

As my dad says, uh, "He was working,
He works in us both the willing and

the doing of His good pleasure."

Same for basketball And good
gracious, I wish I knew that.

I mean, my goodness, I wish
I knew that in my career.

What…

I would have been a incredible coach.

I would incred- Sorry, an
incredibly different coach.

And, uh, again, this
isn't shame of my past.

I'm not ashamed of it.

I'm so grateful for what it has taught
me, and now I get the opportunity

to tell young coaches and to tell,
and even older coaches, there is

a better way to do this, and that
there's not an eternal scoreboard.

And so I wanna take a breath, and I
know I've been on one for the last

five or 10 minutes or however long this
has gone, but I wanna say this to you.

If you've been following this for
any length of time, and you have,

you have already subscribed and
you've liked, I just need you to

jump in with me and share this.

Share it.

More coaches, post this on your
Facebook, post this on your

Instagram, uh, post a link.

I would greatly appreciate it.

The … Again, I'm not, I'm not
out here stacking the paper and

getting a, a mansion out of this.

God is blessing it, and he is
providing resources for sure.

I'm not saying that.

I'm saying thank you for listening,
subscribing, but I w- I just…

All of you guys who
listen, copy, paste, share.

Someone needs to hear that message
that there is not, there's not

this tally mark at the end.

So thank you for that.

And f- uh, most importantly, too, for
you guys who are, uh, weekly, monthly,

uh, prayerfully supporting, financially
supporting, um, it's why I'm sitting here.

It's the only reason that I go to
work at a golf course, and then I

come home and I make podcasts and I
make content, and you're doing that.

And God is working in you through this,
and it is affecting people's lives.

And I make you this promise that
on the next podcast, uh, where just

me individually, I'm gonna tell
you some stories, specifically I'm

gonna read you some emails, because
I need you to hear what coaches are

saying and what people are saying.

land the plane.

So as I have began to tell the origins
story, the 1891, the peach basket, the,

the 10 foot high, the, the, the, the gym,
the gym floor is greater than the pulpit.

Here's what I'm recognizing and that's
being brought to my attention, is w-

if you have heard that story and it has
resonated in your heart, you need to

become a world-class storyteller on it.

And as a coach, this is super important
because if you believe that God sent

His Son and He died for you, and you've
been righteous, redeemed, and now you're

a beloved child of the King, and you've
been hearing this every single week on

the podcast, and you know and you're
starting to hear this, you need to hear

this message more than anything else.

That there's no amount of good deeds
that you can do with these kids that

is gonna change the way He feels
a- about you now and in the end.

The account is for how you
lived your life, not for the

amount of souls you got saved.

That is…

He will leave the 99 and go
after the one every time.

And so I just want you to hear that
today, that this is so important to

me that you hear that message today.

There's no way around that, that
He is happy with what you've

done, and He loves you just as
you are, not as you ought to be.

And I don't want you to think that
you should be something else, 'cause

I did that for so long, and it is a
terrible l- motivator, and it leaves

you, um, it leaves you guilty, it
leaves you shameful, and it leaves

you full of doubt, the Unholy Trinity.

And guess what else it does?

It leaves you empty.

Totally empty.

And I just want you to hear from me as
a coach and, and somebody who's spent

the sidelines for 30 years, high school
and college, that there is a better way

to do this, that knowing the origins
story of the game, and most importantly,

that there is not a tally mark system
gonna come to you when you cross over,

that you stand before the Lord and
you have to say, "Well, there is…

You should have," and that person, and
you missed that, and you should'a…

No.

It is the account of your whole
life, and you recognizing that

Jesus Christ is the Son of God and
died for you is enough for today.

Let eternity handle itself
when that time comes.

These kids need you now.

If you're a business owner,
you are, you're leading people,

the, your people need you now.

They don't need you tomorrow.

They don't need what you
did and do yesterday.

They need you today.

They need you to be present today.

Remember, the present is a gift.

Don't give it away

And so I wanted to come on today and
be a little bit shorter and brief and

just say to you that that mantra, that
narrative of, "I haven't done enough.

I'm not doing enough," because
of eternity and also because

I don't feel like I'm enough.

God loves you at just as you are and
not as you ought to be, and He is giving

you everything that you need as a coach
that pertains to life and godliness.

And if you lean into Him every
single day, He will meet you right

where you are, just like He did me.

So if any of this has resonated with you,
I need you to jump in the show notes.

I need you to download the 10 Things
I Wish I Knew as a Young Head Coach.

I need you to download it, read it,
and then if any of it resonates deeply

with you, I need you to reach out
to me, matt@redeemingthegame.com.

As I say every week,
I appreciate you guys.

I love what i- that God is doing with
the game and through Redeeming the Game.

I appreciate you so much, and we're
redeeming this game one coach,

one family, one player at a time.

See you next week.