Retail Media Breakfast Club

What should retail media networks share with brand partners, and what should they keep sacred? In this first episode of Arming the Rebels, a four-part series for retail media networks that aren't Amazon or Walmart, I'm joined by Anthony Rotio, co-founder and co-CEO of GrowthLoop, to unpack one of the biggest strategic questions facing retailers today: how do you monetize your customer relationships without compromising what makes your business special?

We get into the tension between audience monetization and customer trust, why unique retailer audiences are so valuable to advertisers, and how data governance, audience activation and lifecycle marketing can unlock new opportunities for retail media networks. We also explore what happens when retailers connect the dots across their entire customer data ecosystem, and why protecting the customer experience isn't just nice to have — it's a clear strategic advantage.

This episode is sponsored by GrowthLoop

Timeline

[00:31] – What's holy about a retailer's audience data, and how much customer access should brands actually get?
[03:45] – Why unique retailer audiences matter to media buyers and how retailers can justify incremental advertising investment.
[04:45] – Speed to first dollar: how quickly retailers can build, activate and monetize audiences.
[06:00] – Connecting retail media and lifecycle marketing to unlock richer customer insights and incremental value.
[09:10] – The surprising audience segments retailers can build using purchase behavior and contextual customer data.
[12:30] – Why retailers need guardrails around self-service audience segmentation and protecting customer privacy.
[14:45] – The Commerce Media Investment Index Report and what advertisers are looking for in retail media networks.

Links & Resources

What is Retail Media Breakfast Club?

10 minutes of expert insights every weekday. Your morning ritual for staying ahead in retail media.

Ep 1 - What's holy?
===

[00:00:00] Kiri: Welcome to Retail Media Breakfast Club. I'm Kiri Masters, and this is the first episode of Arming the Rebels

[00:00:07] A four-part series for every retail media network that isn't Amazon or Walmart, brought to you courtesy of [00:00:15] Growth Loop. My guest for all four episodes is Anthony Rotio, co-founder and co-CEO of Growth Loop. We're starting with the customer relationship and how much of it a retailer should let brands [00:00:30] use

[00:00:30]

[00:00:31] Kiri: All right. So Anthony, we're gonna start off talking about what is what I call holy about a retailer's audience data, and what you're actually selling, and how much of brand, of your customer data do [00:00:45] your brand partners actually get to use? Because this is what I hear from retailers all the time is, "Our customer relationship is the most important strategic asset that we have.

[00:00:57] It's what keeps the whole business running." [00:01:00] Um, brands want access to it. They want access to those audiences. So let's talk about s- uh, you know, a retailer like Costco, who I think what's holy about Costco is that member experience, the treasure hunt, [00:01:15] the hot dog. And I have heard, uh, Mark Williamson, who leads that business, that media business, say that Costco as a business, they'll happily walk away from the free money that they get from retail media to protect that member [00:01:30] experience.

[00:01:31] So I'd love to hear from you how that resonates, that concept, because there is this, like, inherent tension between what a retailer needs to hold onto that keeps them special [00:01:45] as a retailer, uh, while also still metering out that access to brands that wanna, um, get in front of that same customer

[00:01:54] Anthony: Yeah, I think that's a really interesting way to frame this first question, Kiri. [00:02:00] Um, when we think about like what a business brings to the table for their value, right? Like typically we think about products and services, right? And what they're, what they're selling. Um, in retail media, right, we also think [00:02:15] about the customer relationship.

[00:02:16] And so the retailer has these products and services, they sell them to a customer, and what's holy is their relationship with those customers, like you mentioned with Costco. In retail media, those lines begin to blur a little bit, right? Which is interesting, 'cause when [00:02:30] you're selling access to audiences, the, um, the product becomes this audience data, right?

[00:02:36] It becomes this access to these, these great customer relationships that you've built. And there's this fine line of [00:02:45] balancing, um, how do we give access to our brand partners and vendors to be able to address those, those, um, those c-consumers that are coming through the door that we've built these relationships with in a way that's net positive to the customer [00:03:00] relationship and customer experience as well.

[00:03:02] And I think that's kind of one of these lines when we talk about what's holy and what you need to make sure you're doing as a, as a, um, retail media network, is actually ensuring that the value that [00:03:15] the customer's getting is going to increase because of this, right? It's great that they-- It's great that the company gets dollars for selling access to the audiences, but if you do it at the expense of the customer relationship, um, then things can go downhill very quickly.

[00:03:29] So [00:03:30] there's, there's some things you need to do to ensure that you do that. But at a high level, I think that's kind of where, where you draw this line is you need to ask yourself, "Am I doing this in a way that's respecting the customer relationship and going to add value for them as well?"

[00:03:44] Kiri: [00:03:45] Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, and the, there's something that I heard from a, a brand side media buyer, um, on, uh... My, my posts about measurement are always the most popular ones about maths. And, um, one, a comment from a brand [00:04:00] side media buyer was, if the audience is the same one that they can already buy elsewhere, it's hard to justify a separate budget line.

[00:04:09] And that's what we're, you know, that's something that Growth Loop does. Uh, you help to [00:04:15] activate those unique audiences that a retailer has access to and allow, uh, them to be activated and bought by, uh, media buyers. So talk us through when you w- start [00:04:30] working with a new retailer, what are some of the early use cases and wins that you look for w- when sort of assessing their audience data landscape?

[00:04:42] Anthony: Yeah, I think one of the, one of the things that's [00:04:45] clear is there's demand from the, uh, buy side on speed and time, like time and, and responsiveness. There's also a need on the, on the sell side, right, for time to first dollar. Um, [00:05:00] so the first value that typically folks will get with someone like a GrowthLoop coming in is just being able to build audiences quickly and make them available quickly, right?

[00:05:09] Um, so that's one piece. And an example is, um, Gopuff built, I think, 600 audiences in the first [00:05:15] hour after they were live with GrowthLoop. And this is one of the things that becomes enabled via APIs and MCP and like a- agents building some of these audiences as well programmatically versus by hand-managed services responding to briefs.

[00:05:28] So it's a-- [00:05:30] it can be a different paradigm for different customers at different phases of the likes- life cycle. But once you kind of settle in and get the foundation built of, hey, we need some audience library available, um, is you start to really get into the interesting pieces of [00:05:45] being able to predict what type of value you could bring to the customer, like I was saying before.

[00:05:50] And We have a few customers now that have come in and said, "We don't just wanna use GrowthLoop for retail media, but we a- actually wanna use them on the [00:06:00] lifecycle marketing side too." And when you do that, you can gain learnings from all the marketing you're doing as a brand in terms of, um, what these folks might be interested in next, right?

[00:06:12] And then if you can do, um, do the [00:06:15] following, right? If a, if a brand-- I used to work at AB InBev, comes in, and I remember, um, I used to manage some of our partnerships there on the marketing side, and NASCAR was one of the partner, partners that I managed. Um, and we were begging for [00:06:30] access to some of the NASCAR audience data back 10, 12 years ago, and the tooling and infrastructure just wasn't there to be able to say who might be interested in buying a Budweiser versus what they're buying today, or who might be interested in buying a Budweiser because they're buying [00:06:45] food and, and certain food items have high propensity to buy a Budweiser.

[00:06:49] So that's where I think when you align kind of both and, um, if you can, if you can, if you can think about it more of a, an audience operating layer across [00:07:00] the, across the retail experience, both for your own brand and for the, um, CPG companies and vendors that you're serving, then suddenly you can start to connect dots that maybe other retail media networks can't connect.

[00:07:14] And this is [00:07:15] where you can tie it back to the incremental value that you can provide over, you know, um, a media network that maybe is doing things more simply. They may be they're bigger, maybe they have a, a big audience, uh, catalog and a huge consumer base, [00:07:30] but they're not able to tie those insights together where if I as a brand come in and say, "Hey, I wanna target folks who, um, may be ready to buy, uh, a beer at the next NASCAR race because of their purchase history or, or fan history with [00:07:45] NASCAR," then suddenly you have an edge.

[00:07:46] And then it is something you can go justify to a CFO, and you see in all the maths and the incrementality measurement that you're talking about, Kiri, that these are actually having more impact. But it takes-- You know, you have to kind of be across [00:08:00] the, across the organization and across the enterprise to be able to tie a lot of this together.

[00:08:05] We're talking about the insights gained from brand marketing, um, the needs and briefs coming in from the buyers, and the, like, [00:08:15] position in the stack to be able to do full incrementality measurement on both the lifecycle side and the, the media side. So it's not a simple thing to just get started today, um, when we talk about, you know, is this something I can build [00:08:30] myself?

[00:08:30] Is this something I go to an all-in-one suite for? There's the, it, there's kind of a sweet spot that you need to, you need to be in when you're thinking about how to tool this the right way to be able to provide that type of value end-to-end.

[00:08:41] Kiri: Yeah, and this is something obviously that GrowthLoop, before your [00:08:45] foray into the commerce media game, you've been doing lifecycle marketing for a long time. That's your bread and butter. Um, I wanna point out, I know that we- we- we're... this is a, um, an audio experience for most people listening to this, but there were some segments [00:09:00] that your marketing team actually pulled out, 'cause I was, I was really curious myself about, like, what kind of audiences can you target, and what kind of surprising audiences can you target?

[00:09:10] And there's things in here like, um, Super Bowl fans with an [00:09:15] elderly parent, and late night urgency shoppers, and, uh, cats moving from adult to senior. So these are, these are all the things that retailers have access to. You know, [00:09:30] our, um, they have a, have a saying at Kroger Precision Marketing, "If you know the cart, you know the heart."

[00:09:35] And, uh, what we buy is a reflection of, you know, who we are and what we value and our, um, our, you know, ex- experiences day to day. So of [00:09:45] course you're going to have all these surprising and insightful data points about what customers are doing and what they're consuming and what they're interested in. Um, I'll just, I'll pause there just to see if anything [00:10:00] else is coming to mind

[00:10:01] Anthony: oh, I think that's spot on, and the, uh, you know, we're, we're living in this world of, um, rapidly increasing amounts of data, right? And that context, if you can use it the right way, um, can be incredibly valuable. Uh, [00:10:15] if, if you're not building your media network on top of this governed data layer in one of these data warehouses or data lakes where your organization's already investing in getting all this contextual data there, right?

[00:10:28] You may not, you may not [00:10:30] know if you're, if you're buying on like a, you know, a, a tool or an on, you know, an onboarding tool or an all-in-one suite where only some of the data is loaded into it, that, uh, this cat, you know, owner is moving from, uh, elderly, you know, the, the example that you gave [00:10:45] there or the, um, the, the Super Bowl fan that's taking another action, right?

[00:10:50] It's like there's all this contextual data that you may be missing, uh, in one of those platforms. So that was our bet early was that, hey, when we started on the life cycle side, uh, almost a [00:11:00] decade ago on the, on the brand marketing side, was there's all this rich data that folks are investing in bringing centrally, internally into their data warehouse.

[00:11:09] What if we built a system that just plugged directly into there and had access to all that data for the marketing use [00:11:15] cases? And that just happened to be, a few years later, also a great place to be able to serve the, the media networks as well, um, because this, for the same reason, right? It's like it's speed, it's speed to value.

[00:11:28] You have all the data, so you can really [00:11:30] quickly build audiences and see and get feedback on the size of them, the makeup of them, the revenue touched across the business, the types of things that are in the cart. Um, and, and two is you get this rich contextual data about things that, you know, may not even be as valuable to the [00:11:45] brand itself, uh, for marketing, but it may be really valuable to the, to the suppliers and to the, to the, um, consumer goods companies that are actually buying, uh, buying audience access through the network.

[00:11:58] Kiri: Well, we've got, uh, very [00:12:00] lucky because we have you for, for a whole series of discussions over the next couple of weeks, so we're gonna get into speed, um, a little bit later on why that's so important. But to wrap things up today where we're talking about what's holy [00:12:15] and what a retailer, you know, keeping what's really special and unique about that retailer while also, um, providing access to brand partners so that, you know, ultimately looking for some win-win scenarios here where the category is [00:12:30] growing.

[00:12:30] What is, what's something that retailers, you've seen retailers walk away from because it would, um, it would impact the member or customer experience? Is there some form of [00:12:45] data that a retailer has refused to use because it would damage that trust or that relationship with the customer?

[00:12:53] Anthony: I think it's more of a, a pattern, um, that they want to make sure that is, is being [00:13:00] stopped. And I know that sounds a little abstract, so I'll give an example. Um, with one of our customers, they're really big on self-serve, right? Is they have managed services, but they also embed GrowthLoop in, you know, their, their, um, buyer-facing platform, [00:13:15] and they really want to govern the data that's accessible to that, you know, self-serve segmentation tool.

[00:13:23] And that's just more of a-- There's a lot of, a lot of data that's holy in there, and a lot of the customer experience that's [00:13:30] represented in there that you don't wanna let folks get down to an audience of size 100 or size 10, 'cause then you start to, you start to be able to infer who's in that audience, right?

[00:13:39] And more specifics and things, and you may not wanna show the granularity of detail that [00:13:45] you look at internally, um, when you're, when you're marketing to folks and, and preserving that relationship in a, in a self-governed way when you're exposing things externally. So it's, um, you know, it's funny, we use the word composable for a lot of things, but it, it [00:14:00] r- it applies here too.

[00:14:01] It's like you kind of wanna be able to compose the experience for your buyers to make sure that your own understanding of what's holy within your organization is preserved in, um, in this use of the data, right? And in this, [00:14:15] in this use of the customer relationship, right? You don't want, you don't want to just give the full access externally that you might have internally.

[00:14:22] Um, so that's more of what we've seen is each organization has a different understanding of what's holy to them, and we wanna [00:14:30] enable the, the, um, the organization to be able to keep those rules in place, uh, as they're actually activating, um, retail media, uh, opportunities with their, with their buyers.

[00:14:42] Kiri: Great. Well, we're gonna wrap it up here for today. [00:14:45] One thing that you might be interested in if you're listening to this and you wanna learn more about what media buyers are looking for with their commerce media investments, GroupM put together an amazing set of research called the Commerce Media Investment [00:15:00] Index Report, which gets into what advertisers are looking for, what kind of, um, factors they are ranking in terms of what a retailer's customer base needs to be able to target, what's important to them.[00:15:15]

[00:15:15] Definitely recommend checking that out. We'll link up to it in the show notes. And Anthony, I'll catch you in the next episode talking about MarTech before media

[00:15:24] Anthony: Thanks so much, Kerry. I'm looking forward to it

[00:15:26]