Scalability School

How do you build a DTC offer that raises profit without hurting conversion rate? Simplify the offer so a shopper understands it in seconds, then raise MSRP so you can show a bigger discount at a higher final price. The offers scaling DTC brands run today are buy more save more, a discounted first subscription order, or tiered dollar-off bundles. Brian Ng of Digital Ride raised one brand's MSRP to $74.95 behind a 50% discount and saw conversion rate hold steady while the brand moved from a monthly loss to profit. In this episode, Andrew Foxwell, Brad Ploch and Zach Stuck talk DTC offer strategy with Brian Ng of Digital Ride, covering how to raise prices without losing conversions, the three offers scaling brands run right now, and how a $10M a month brand manages creative with outside agencies. You'll learn why raising MSRP behind a bigger discount can lift profit at the same conversion rate, how to test a new offer with a single URL parameter, and why more creative volume often makes performance worse.

We discuss:

  • What a bad DTC offer looks like, and why confusing offer pages lose the sale
  • The three offer structures scaling DTC brands use: buy more save more, subscription-first, and tiered bundles
  • How Brian raised MSRP to $74.95 behind a 50% discount and turned a monthly loss into profit
  • How to test offers with Convert or Intelligems experiments versus sending ads to a new landing page
  • How to forecast ecommerce revenue year over year and why you shouldn't scale before new customer ROAS is there
  • Running a $10M a month brand's creative through three agencies with no in-house strategists
  • Pricing psychology: why $39.99 beats $35.99, and a $30 price change that lifted profit per session 40%

Get the newsletter: https://www.scalabilityschool.com/scalability-newsletter Learn more: https://www.scalabilityschool.com This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It's a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they're offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you! To connect with Brian Ng: https://x.com/briannjho To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck Learn more about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com Learn more about the The Hive Haus Creators Community at http://HiveHausUGC.com

Scalability School is the podcast for media buyers, agency owners and DTC operators who want to grow without guessing, hosted by Andrew Foxwell, Brad Ploch and Zach Stuck.

Chapters

00:00 DTC offer strategy: why $39.99 beats $35.99 02:35 How Digital Ride grows DTC brands as a growth partner 05:27 How to forecast ecommerce revenue year over year 08:56 Can creative agencies replace an in-house creative team? 14:26 How much creative a $10M/month brand launches 22:29 The 3 offers scaling DTC brands run right now 23:55 How to test a new offer: Convert experiments vs new landing pages 25:29 How raising MSRP turned a monthly loss into profit 30:25 Pricing psychology: the $30 price change that lifted profit 40%

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

why have your price at $35.99 when
you can have it at $39.99?

Why have your price at $37, $38.99 when you
can have your price at $39.99, right?

It's something that also, that's how you can
squeeze a couple of dollars of profit

per order whatsoever.

And something like, for example, a lot of people
run the buy one, buy two, get one,

buy three, get two.

And then you run the sub offer
on top of that, right?

And so after 15%, you get your prices
at, let's say you start at 29.

You get your prices to like, I don't know,
$22.99 or something like that.

Why not make that like after the discount,
after the sub discount, $24.99?

It's the same thing.

You're going to make more money off that.

You're going to get the same conversion
rate, a higher rank per user one.

And now let's take a listen to the
Scalability School podcast.

Welcome to another episode
of Scalability School

with a rare appearance of Zach, Brad, and
myself back on the podcast together.

Although I will be leaving early in this

podcast because I'm in Europe
and it's late.

Brian's in Singapore.

It's 4 a.m.

Brian, cheers to you for getting
up our guests.

And Zach and Brad are in a time for them
that's totally normal and makes sense.

But Brian, I'm just going to say Brian.

So Brian is a great guy, member of our

community, has been a member
for three years,

totally an incredible growth expert,
somebody who is an agency owner,

who has recently gotten into
being a brand owner,

somebody who I respect and
who I turn to a lot.

He has always been somebody that doesn't
settle for just the baseline.

He always is pushing.

And I know somebody who's really great when
I introduced Brian to Zach last year

at a Foxville Founders event.

And then Zach texted me after and goes,

you were right, Brian's insane.

And I was like, correct.

He's awesome.

And because every time I talk
to Brian, I'm like,

what do you got going on?

And then you send me these like 35 minute
looms of all the stuff.

I'm like, it's like watching that scene
from Always Sunny in Philadelphia

where the lines of a string are going
between pieces of paper.

That's you.

That's you, man.

So I'm really glad to have
you on the podcast

and I'm glad to get some sauce for
our listeners for you here.

So on to the, since we had the longest
intro of all time.

Sorry about that.

Anyway, so Brian, super glad
to have you here, man.

Also background.

One of the reasons I think you're
a killer is because actually

you were a killer in the
Singapore military.

Is this correct?

Oh, that's not true.

I was like the death of us.

I wasn't actually holding the rifles.

Brian, before we hit record,

you were kind of telling us about the
agency journey a little bit.

And you said kind of over the
last three years,

you've onboarded a handful of clients.

And it sounds like you've intentionally been
thoughtful about how many you onboard.

But the thing that was really
interesting,

and I think that what will
set the stage for

kind of what we're going
to talk about today

is just give us, give us
like a little bit.

You're running through examples of like,
client was here, now they're here.

They were here, now they're here.

So just like brag for a
second and kind of

rifle off a couple of the results
that you've seen.

And I think that'll help us like set the
stage for conversation overall.

Yeah, maybe I can get started a little
bit about the company itself.

So DigitalWrite, like Andrew,

as mentioned, we do like Rants and as
well the agency side of things.

We actually started off with Rants,
my business partner.

This company is actually
like 10 years old.

But my business partner was
in like e-commerce

dropshipping for like the first
seven years or so.

And an agency came over
because we've been

working with like an email
marketing agency,

Hustler Marketing.

And they came over and said,

hey, you guys are doing pretty
well on paid ads.

So like, can you help us do this with
some of our clients as well?

And he was like, sure.

And we handpicked some of
like the clients

that we think could work
really well for us.

And that's when I joined in actually
as a junior media buyer,

but like three years of experience
past that.

And so we've only taken on eight clients
over the past three years or so.

We have grown them from like
around 500k to 10 mil,

500k to 2 mil, 500k to 1 mil, whatever
the numbers are.

And we really act as growth
partners to the

kind of the brands that we
work with, right?

So it's like a more of like
a head of growth,

not a CMO, but like the head of growth,

the people that do all the
work in that sense.

And so and we don't bring
on a lot of clients

because we really want the people
to get results, right?

And there's always like so many factors.

It's never just media buying.

So it's me buying creatives, offers, and the
landing page that you send to, right?

Acquisition side, that's what we
focus on predominantly.

And so, yeah, that's kind of where,

how we started and some of like the kind
of results that we've seen.

Cool.

Yeah.

And you mentioned a bunch of different
growth levels.

I know we're going to dig into at
least a handful of those,

particularly interested in
offers personally.

I feel like not enough people spend
time talking about offers

and actually how to craft it.

So we'll come back to that.

But so we have growth levers as options,

but there's like some foundational work
that you can do ahead of time

to help set brands up for success.

And you mentioned forecasting
is one of those things

that you have a unique perspective on

and something that you help clients with.

So can you just kind of walk
us through like,

what is the maybe the 10,000 foot overview
of like how you do forecasting?

And I'm sure we can dig into a bunch of
different questions from there.

Well, I mean, I don't think it's, it's
a, for, for a forecasting piece,

a lot of times for us, it,
when, when you,

when you do things a certain way,

when you like creative test a certain way

and you have a certain amount
of creative volume

for a period of time,

you were able to then kind of see
the seasonality of it.

So like the forecasting that we do gets
better kind of year on year,

just because you, you know,
you, you know,

let's say in February you have
a completely shit month,

you know, in November to January, it's
like a really good period.

And then, you know, kind of
what the trends are

between like maybe certain
July and August

are similar revenue numbers, right?

So you kind of know the, the trend,

trend of revenue that, that,
that the brand is on

and you can kind of forecast just based
off year on year, right?

So we just look at previous
year and this year,

how, what do I forecast in terms
of year and year?

It's like the 80%, a hundred percent
year on year grow, right?

So like double, double grow.

And then from there, a lot of times,

that's where you start thinking of like,

okay, I'm going to be growing like
120% here whatsoever.

I really want to push hard here.

Let me just, let me onboard creative
agencies during this period.

Because that's like the biggest element.

When your offers is kind of doubtful,

you have a decent offer and you
have a good offer page

and all these things.

It's like, okay, I'm going to bring
on new creative partners here.

And that's when you need to
come in and it's like,

going at attention, it's like,

you need to find a good, good, like
good creative partners in.

You need to, you need to make sure
you know how to vet them,

et cetera, and coming in like that.

And so even with that, when
you're forecasting,

you are able to know like, okay,
during this period,

we actually really sucked ass because we,

like we didn't do these certain
things, right?

We didn't plan for, I don't know,
Mother's Day properly

or we didn't do any.

And then that's when you,
you add that in,

you know that you have more
creative coming in.

You know that you can hit your, your
120% year on year grow

or something like that.

Right.

But every single month we
plan consistently,

like a person, like a percentage of
like year on year growth.

And we usually hit that number.

And usually, and how we control this
is that we can go like,

we actually can go past that, that
kind of year on year growth.

But because we control it with bitcaps,

we just like, we, we make sure
we hit that pace

that we need for, for that number.

And we could go over, but you know,

that guarantees us kind of like hitting
the forecast and in that sense.

So that's how we do forecasting
right now.

Usually when the brands first come in,

they don't have that stability.

So it's more so based off feels.

A lot of the things that we
do is based off feels,

but, but also it's like, I'm,
I'm always pushing,

like you should never scale when you're,

your new customer Royals and your,
your numbers are not,

like are not there.

Right.

Brand owners have like,

or a lot of clients sometimes come to me.

It's like, we need to hit this number.

We need to hit that.

And it was like, yeah,

but it's better to hit a
lower number with,

with a, with a better new
customer Royals,

unless you need to clear
inventory for cash,

cash flow that then pays for your,

for your loan that you took
or whatever it is.

Then, you know, that is a case,

but then you need to be like backed
up by something else as well.

There was a case like that too,

but a lot of times you don't
need to push,

to hit your forecast numbers.

You should only push when
you have something

working in the creative side
with a decent offer.

So, yeah.

More so, I, I, I was going to
say that, you know,

the, the, the most successful partnerships
that we've had with creative agencies

have been getting them when they
initially first start off.

And it's really difficult to find that.

Um, and for example, one of our
home runs was Harry,

when he first started his
creative agency and,

and getting that in and he got like
a lot of wins off that,

a lot of total screenshots of
it, of that as well.

Um, a bunch of clients from that as well.

So, uh, that's been like a
really, really, um,

great, great partnership.

We're really happy with that.

Um, and then we have some other ones.

So we're still exploring when you have
like three creative agencies on the,

in the pipeline right now, but, um, or
like working with us right now,

but it's all long-term relationships.

And, and, and that's kind of what, what,
what we do, do with, with that brand.

Um, less so like with creative
strats, et cetera.

Yeah.

I'm curious.

So do you, you don't have any in-house
creative team for that brand?

It's all agencies that are
feeding creative.

We have like two marketing coordinators
that manage the, the, the brand side,

the agency side of things, whereas
like they're managing the,

the content that's coming in and, and reviewing
and giving feedback, et cetera.

So I think that's, I mean, that's a really
interesting call out though.

So like this brand's doing 10 million a month
and you have three creative agencies

and no in-house creative strats.

Like I think everyone always tries to go,
Hey, we got to build this house,

you know, in-house, it's always
going to be better.

I think it's good to just like say like,

it's possible to build this all with
like external agencies.

Um, we at Marsman have rotated
through a lot.

Like we've probably hired and fired like 10
to 15 creative agencies at this point.

Um, we currently are on with like three.

Um, but we've, I think the one question
that I have for you is like,

how do you dictate a someone, are you or

someone dictating what each
agency is focused on?

Cause I think that's the other part
of it too, is like getting,

at least diverse creative, getting different
types of assets, whatever.

Like how do you think about that?

Um, for a brand that has like
three creative agencies?

So initially I'll say when we bring on
a creative agency at the start,

we usually just say like, Hey, just
do what you think would work.

And that creative agency probably has
access to other ad accounts.

They see what's working in the market.

They're going to try different structures

and, and, and kind of ideas
that are working for

those accounts, um, bringing
them to yours, right?

That, that gives the, the biggest
success in that sense.

Um, once you have that and,
you know, one agency

focuses on mashups, the other
focuses on Yappers,

then I, this is what happened.

We brought on the third creative agency.

They could do everything.

I was like, I want you to
focus on just these

like AI pick sides or just AI
creatives in general.

So can you please just focus,
focus on that?

And, and, you know, of course
they, you need

to see that they might have
the talent for it.

You need to see the other creatives
and what they

have given to you, et cetera, as
a portfolio whatsoever.

Um, so that's kind of how
we have split up.

Uh, say when coming into a
brand and bringing

on a creative agency, I'm just
usually, I usually

know what they are good at.

And also I'm telling them like, do,
do what you think would work.

Of course there's guardrails, right?

Like we will look, we'll,
we'll see, like,

um, we'll, we'll kind of know
what would work

for the account at best.

If they give like some out
of the box idea

that's like really different,
then we'll probably

be like, no, like we're not
going to do that.

Can you like maybe go into this
direction instead?

But it's like, I guess it's more
of, more of like managing.

There's also like just managing
people in general.

You need gifting guardrails and, but let
them kind of do their own thing.

And giving them like a, so we, Zach,
you call it pillars.

Like pillars is like the core message
that's being communicated in the ad.

So it's like, um, hollow,
the example we've

used 8,000 times on this is
like hunters versus

compression or whatever.

Are you telling the agency, are you at least
giving them like the parameters?

So it sounds like in some cases you kind

of know, Hey, make yappers
or make mashups.

Are you also helping guide them with the

direction for like what they should
be talking about?

Are you giving them the freedom
to say, Hey, we

see that this pillar angle
message or whatever

is working and we're going to
create within that.

The idea is at the start,
we give them the

direction, like more so
where it's needed.

Give them the creators that they need.

There's what best in our account.

Give them kind of the winning
videos that we

have and the messaging that
we have and what

we say in the ad and all this
that makes it work.

And after we guide them and give them in.

But then like over time, after that three

months, after that period of
time, like I don't

want to be managing the creative agency.

I don't want to be guiding them
into the right direction.

They need to know what's working and they

need to iterate on that and
then get new stuff

that's working without my time.

Right.

Because then it becomes very like
I'm doing a job basically.

So it's like they need to be able
to do it themselves.

Maybe guardrails at the start.

And even if they're not like they
don't follow it as well.

Right.

I mean, that's usually a
sign that it's not

going to work out for a
creative chat or a

creative agency.

But if they don't, you know,
we still give

that three months and we test
them fully because

we onboarded them in the
first place, which

is then we know we trust
that they're going

to produce good creative and their kind
of portfolio and all that.

But, you know, sometimes there's kind
of deceiving in that sense.

But after three months, then
you can fully judge.

And it's not really for a bigger brand.

It's not really a cost.

It is a cost, but like the cost of not
doing it is more expensive.

So, yeah.

Yeah.

And you mentioned this has been the topic
of the Twitter discussion.

This is not going to come out for
a couple of weeks at least.

But literally in the last like 48 hours,

it's been is creative volume
important, which we

can if you want to share an opinion on that,
you're more than welcome to do that.

But for the brand that's
doing 10 million a

month, like what's what is
what kind of creative

volume are they pumping out?

I think it's like launch like maybe
60 to 75 concepts a month.

It's not that and not that how many how

many variants like of that
is it like concept

is okay.

You should have a variance or whatsoever.

So a couple hundred couple
hundred and like

when you say concepts like
pretty distinctly

different concepts probably across
messaging as well as formats.

Yeah, exactly.

So so basically like, you know, I mean,

Harry has done I think probably
has talked a lot

about it on Twitter and probably
on podcast.

But he is one of our main creative
partners right now.

And he really like just changes
the front end

story of it and maybe changes
the mechanism,

like the unique mechanism a little
bit like and and and so.

But yeah, it's it's pretty diverse in that
sense, like really different stories.

Got it.

Got it.

I can give a comment on.

Yeah.

On the volume and create the volume.

Yeah, please.

Volume.

I think it's it is such a like common

problem, I would say, like volume
as of itself is not

really that helpful.

I've seen like newer like we just onboarded
a new brand maybe two months ago.

The founder was doing really well last

year, August, and he was making
his own content,

et cetera, blah, blah, blah.

And then after that, he
started going into

this like if you guys know
Tribe, Tribe is like

TikTok shop for Meta, he
went to that tribe

where a bunch of creators
coming in producing

like hundreds of assets
every single week.

And I'm like, dude, you produce
more than this brand.

But but his results have gotten
worse and worse.

And so I see in this way,
it's, you know, you

need to have like thought
out like concepts,

right?

And you need somebody to do it.

So you need like if you have a creative

shred, they need to be thinking
out their concepts

and then producing it with
with intention.

And and then you can do like maybe
10 to 15 iterations.

You do five is completely net you.

Right.

And the same goes for, let's
say, Tribe creators.

I would say or at least the creators that

they're coming in, they need
to have that have

a like thought behind it.

You know, if not, I test them
a different way.

I'm not testing them in a ABO creative

testing where I really spend
budget on putting them

in a CBO and I'm throwing it in.

Because TikTok shop for Meta,
like the tribe

thing, the thing is, like,
I've only seen that

work with and this is my inexperience.

I've only got on the platform for like a
few months, like three months or so.

And, you know, I don't have that much

experience in this, but I'm starting
to get way more

because we have brands that
are pushing this.

Um, but it's like the those brands
are like TikTok shop.

They have creators that are producing
stuff that's winning.

Then they pull that over
to tribe and then

they start posting that or
they then pull them

over into their own.

Um, they have their own
system of of doing

things and and and and and that works for

them.

Right.

But those are like top creators and
they're putting spend behind them.

Right.

We sometimes brands just use
tribe specifically

to use for like the payment processing
of creators,

paying the retainers, paying
the percentage

of ad spend or revenue that
that you're doing.

And that is worth the fee that it comes
with, the 1.5% fee that it comes with.

Right.

So, yeah.

But going back to that creative
piece is more

so like you need you need
people of intention

to produce that.

If not, you need to find a different
testing structure for them.

So if like creative agencies, they need
to be producing that with intention.

And and that's the most important thing.

And the way that you scale
volume is to have

more creative agencies and more
creative strategies

and that have the intention
and push that through.

Yeah, that makes sense.

Um, cool.

I want to jump into offers
because I think

you it sounds like you have
some strong opinions

about offers.

And so I'd be very curious.

Maybe where we start is,
um, it sounds like

maybe even recently you've
pulled up and you've

started to look in some ad accounts.

And like one of the first things you're

looking at and trying to diagnose
is just like offers

in general.

Um, what does it what does a
bad offer look like?

Is maybe a good start.

All right, friends, quick break.

This episode is brought to you by North

beam, the marketing attribution
platform that we

love over here at scalability school.

If you're a marketer, I mean, you
probably agree, right?

Incrementality testing is broken.

They were these tests require
tons of labor,

spreadsheets, statistical
reference, and the

designing of a test is slow
and error prone.

How are you supposed to know what
to test in the first place?

Right.

There's a million factors that can make
incrementality testing difficult.

But the good news is North beam has completely
changed the game and they fix this.

Only North beam incrementality
automates your

incrementality test design
and monitoring while

protecting you from the major mistakes
that plague incrementality testing.

North beam builds tests
using your own MTA

data, launches them directly
in ad platforms

and automatically monitors
them throughout.

If something threatens validity, you're
alerted before it ruins the result.

With North beam, you can launch tests in

platform with a single click,
saving you tons of time

and reducing any chance for errors.

And when the test concludes,
your results flow

straight into your MTA, meaning
you can easily

see results alongside the
rest of your data.

Incrementality was broken.

North beam fixed it.

No discount.

It's like 20% discount here.

It's really not really incentivizing any

action on like the middle
or bigger bundle.

It's really difficult.

I think the visual of it
is very important.

When you land on the site or the PDP or
offer page, now it's the same thing.

You need to understand what's going on.

A lot of brands, they have
it designed so badly.

Like in a way where it's like things
are so messy, right?

The paragraphs that they have is like four
paragraphs under the image carousel.

Like that whole like, and
it looks super bad.

The four paragraphs in.

And then you have like another
offer, which

is like four blocks long,
you know, or like

five blocks long of like the different
tiered discounts, for example.

And that just does like extremely
horribly.

Why?

Because when customers land, they
don't know what's going on.

They don't know what you stand for.

It takes too much time to read
what you're saying.

It takes too much time to understand
the offer.

So one of the things is like
simplify the offer.

Try and put that higher kind of discount
threshold as well.

Like raise your MSRP, bigger
discount, you know?

So like that.

And they're like standard offers that you

can run nowadays with like
supplements is like

buy one, buy two, get one,
buy three, get two.

For any type of multi-skew
or single product

multi-skew, like different
color brand, you

can run like more of the javvy
style offer pages.

Those are like our go-tos right now.

Yeah.

So bad offers.

It's confusing.

There's like way too many things like the

customer has to do math to
try to understand

the economics.

Like that's a good example of that.

And then like the low percentage.

Yeah.

It's too confusing.

It doesn't look like a good deal.

It just needs to feel like a good deal.

They land on it.

Your ad needs to do all that persuasion
makes them like really want to perk.

And then they land and see what you have,

maybe some reinforcement,
but then you see

your offer is like, okay,
this makes sense.

You know, do I want to fork?

Then the question in your
head is like, do I

want to fork out this dollar
amount for what

I just, you know, heard through an ad?

Yeah.

And so you mentioned a couple of things
in there that was interesting.

So like the idea of like stacking and you

can kind of do that with
buy more, save more

while also like playing with
the MSRP value.

And I think particularly
in the supplement

space, like there's a couple
of outs that people

are going right now.

It's buy more, save more or subscription

only or some kind of like blended
version of the

two.

I think like that's, that's
pretty common.

But when people are doing
the BOGO, I guess

this is actually true of the
subscription offer

as well.

They're kind of like, it's like, okay, what
is all in that first, that first order?

It's like, okay, we're going to throw in, you
get, you get, you're going to get the

base products.

You're probably going to get
a couple of free gifts.

Then you're going to throw
in free shipping

or you're going to throw in
shipping, which has

a value assigned with it.

So it's important to actually calculate
that entire MSRP.

And then you do your markdown
on top of that.

Is that kind of in the right direction?

Yeah.

I mean, I can talk about the offers
that work right now.

Because technically there's
only like three

different offers that brands
that are really

scaling hard are doing.

Right.

It's that buy more, save
more, which is you,

you, you buy one or you buy
two, get one and

you buy three, get one or get two.

The other one is more of
like what Marsman

does, which is like you do
the, the, the, like

a subscription only at the front end.

We're actually going back to the
buy more, save more.

That is like the one-time version
that you can run.

And then you can run that 15, 20% discount
as well on top of that for subscription.

And usually you see like a 60%
tick rate on that.

Right.

Best app to use that for
is Keqing Bundles.

It's the easiest to do it.

That's why the dropshipping demons do it.

Use, but the, and then you have the, the,
the, the one that Marsman runs more.

So it's, it's like that, like a bigger
discount up front, $39.

I think you get a higher tick
rate from that for sure.

And then the subsequent orders
are like $59, $59.

And then the last one, which is more of

like what Better Body Co-runs
and like Rejuvene

that like those two companies,
they're like,

last I saw it was like a buy
one and then you

buy two and then you buy three.

And then it's like $10 off,
something off,

and then like $30 off, something
like that.

But also not sure how well that is doing

for them, but it doesn't
seem to have, they

haven't seemed to have grown that much
from, from the past couple of years.

But probably has, I don't know, it's
looking at traffic wise.

How are you testing this?

Like, how are you testing
in the ad account?

Is it like in the ad account, you're doing
separate ad sets and doing ABO?

Are you doing IntelliGems on the backend?

Like, I think there's, there's so many

ways to be able to try to
test and I feel like

offers is like a really complicated
thing to test.

It is, well, there's two ways, right?

You either throw it in, like
you, you add like

a UTM parameter that triggers
this experiment,

like in a convert or IntelliGems, or you

can shoot it to like your
best ads to the new

kind of offer page or landing
page itself, right?

I still fall into the lines of
like convert experiments.

I'm a bit old fashioned that way.

My business partner does all of the tests

now through, through the,
through new ads,

new ad, best ads to that landing page.

What we found is that different
ads perform

to that landing, if it's
a different landing

page, let's say.

But offers wise, usually same ads.

I think, I'll presume the same ads would
perform, but that's two ways.

That's the two ways.

I honestly just like, like do a convert

experiment because it's like
just way easier.

Like I just throw it in, put
the URL parameters.

I launch it and then it just tells
me like 20% up, right?

For user.

And I'm like, cool.

That makes sense.

And then I throw into cloud, profit,
profit analysis.

Does that make sense?

Okay.

It makes sense.

Great.

You know, it's a winning thing.

Like that's how, how we do things.

But my business partner now has gone into
the route of more so like, um, ad set.

And then after that to new,
new landing page.

But yeah.

How much are you thinking
about like offers?

If you are like on the, on the,
the, the rebuild side.

So like from a subscription
perspective, like,

are you charging, like thinking
about charging,

shipping on, on a rebuild?

Is the price going up?

Is it going down?

Are you throwing in free gifts?

Like, are you, are you thinking about the

retention piece and the offer
for rebuilds?

So many of the clients that
we have scaled

right now, uh, just like
more so one time.

So like a 10 mil per month client is a
one time purchase kind of thing.

Very small subscription after, um,
we also have skincare.

Um, but you know, like we're starting to

push this like piece a bit
more in terms of the

retention side.

One great piece of advice
that, um, Zach did

give me was to like, you
know, free shipping

up front.

But after that you charge them $8.795
or something like that.

And that, um, we have implemented.

So this new brand that we just onboarded

is the one that I've stopped
off like this.

It's like, they were losing money
for a lot of months now.

Um, went from like negative 24k.

And then like the next month
was 10k net profit.

Then the next month, this
month, um, should

be like 50k in that profit
based off what we've

seen.

Um, and that, that was just all based
off like an offer change, right?

We modeled that Javi framework, multi skew,
um, different, different flavors.

And then the MSRP were just too low.

The co-founder told me like, um, oh,
I think the price is too high.

Or like, I don't even think
we can charge it much.

I'm like, fuck it.

Just run.

Let's see.

Let's, let's run it and see.

And, and, you know, this, this is literally
what your competitors charge.

You're charging way less than them.

Why don't you, you increase
your prices and,

and, you know, so they went
from a one-time

offer, which was buy one,
buy two, save like X

percent, buy three, save X
percent, buy four,

save X percent, which in and for itself
is like so big and long on screen.

We moved it to that Javi offer page style,
you know, and, and that is sub first.

And then after that one-time purchase

option, it's like, if you click
on it and go to the

site, no free gifts.

We raised MS, MSRP to like $74.95 and
then we gave it a 50% discount.

And then the sub, the, the,
the interesting

thing is, is that the conversion
rate has stayed

roughly the same.

Like, like, um, the conversion
rate has stayed

the same as it was a 4% increase
in conversion

rate and like a 18 or 15% increase
in revenue per user.

And we're getting subscriptions
like every single day.

They like, we're going to
get more, like in

two months time, we're going
to get the entire

subscription thing that they
have been doing

for like the past year plus
year to two years.

And it's a script.

And usually with subscription, you see like
a negative 10, 15% gram per user.

So it's like this, that was
like an insane win.

And it was also predominantly
by increasing price.

Now we're going to get free gifts.

It's, and the gifts are going
to be related

to kind of the, the product
that they sell.

And it's going to like convert
even better.

And so then there are a
lot, a lot of spit

tests that you can do, especially
on the Javi

style page.

We can talk about that if you want.

But yeah.

Yeah.

The MSRP thing is so interesting because

at the same event that like
whatever a year

ago where we were all in the same room, but
we didn't meet when you talked to Zach.

Zach, I'm pretty sure we
sat down with like

a handful of brand owners
and like I watched

you talk to them about their offer.

And they were like, they were really hung
up on like MSRP and changing it.

And you just, I don't know if you even

remember this conversation,
but you were basically

like, you just need to change it until
like the offer makes sense.

And like the offer looks
compelling enough.

Like you sat with them and
it was just like,

you just have to continue
to like manipulate

some baby, an aggressive
word, but like you

have to continue to manipulate
and like, don't

be afraid to change the MSRP.

That really stuck with me
because like people

don't, like they don't, they
don't change the

base price.

Because Brian, to your point,
like they're

worried that it seems too high,
maybe by comparison

to like what the market is saying, or like
they don't think that they can, they can

justify that.

Zach, I don't know if there's
anything else

that you remember from that
conversation or offer.

Yeah.

I mean, I just, I gave them
the example of

hollow, which is like, dude,
like we shouldn't

be charging 50, $60 for a single pair of

socks, but to hit the, to hit
the discount and offer

that we want to, to make it compelling

enough to buy, to hit the AOV
versus the NCOC that

I have to have to back out
to the math works.

Like you sometimes have to increase prices
that you can play with offers.

And yeah, their performance wasn't hitting
where they needed it to be.

I'm like, it's not going
to fix by you, by

you not messing with this,
like this offer

dynamic.

You just have to try.

Yeah.

So yeah, I mean, that's,
that's usually the

brands candidly that are
stuck at that like

sub few hundred K a month in revenue.

And they're like, I just like
can't break through

or like, we're just not profitable
and just can't

get it to work.

Almost always it's like an offer problem.

And then obviously like,
you know, creative

is a huge piece of this,
but almost always

I think it's like an offer issue.

Yeah.

So yeah, Brian's, Brian's right.

Exactly how, I mean, I think more brands

need to be aggressive when
it comes to pricing

and stuff like that.

Cause yeah, if you're torching cash, it's

not working like an offer
change can literally

turn the business around.

Yeah.

Yeah.

We ran a pricing test recently.

Yeah.

It was a quick kind of quicker
pricing test that we ran.

It's a high AOV call it in
like the $400 range.

The MSRP kind of like close to $500.

And it was just like an awkward
in between number.

Like I'll pick a random number.

Like for example, it was 297 or 279.

It's like 279, like the 79
feels super random.

It's like not quite 299, but
it's also not 249.

It's just like this awkward spot.

And so we push them to drop it to just
like get it below the next threshold.

Like they were running a
$50 discount to get

it to 229, but 229 still feels
kind of random.

So like, okay, try pushing into 199.

And we saw like a 40% lift in profit per

session while also being able
to scale substantially

further.

And then just like a couple of times

throughout the month for various
reasons, which we don't

need to get into.

It's like they go to full
MSRP and it's like

MER gets shittier and they
lose 50% of their

spend volume for the course of that week.

Unless we try to hold it to like continue
to like maintain whatever funnel.

Um, and it's just like, it's insane what
just those, those small changes can do.

Even if it's like the change
is not that meaningful.

It was a, it was a $30 change on
a really expensive product.

And, uh, it, yeah, 40% increase
in profit per session.

Insane.

The, it's just pricing psychology.

It's like, why have your price at 35.99
when you can have it at 39.99?

Like, or 30, why you have
your price at 37,

38.99 when you can have your
price at 39.99,

right?

It's, it's something that
also, that's how

you can squeeze a couple of
dollars of profit,

um, per, like for order whatsoever.

And, and something like,
for example, a lot

of people run the, the buy
one, buy two, get

one, buy three, get two.

And then you run the, the sub
offer on top of that.

Right.

And so your, your sub fifth
after 15%, you

get your prices at, let's
say you start at 29,

you get your prices to like, I don't know,
20, 22.99 or something like that.

Why not make that like the, after the discount,
after the sub discount, 24.99.

It's the same thing.

You're going to make more money off that.

You're going to get the same conversion
rate, a higher revenue per user.

Why?

Just because like people
view it the same.

That's why all the stores,
they put it like,

and at 9.99 or 9.97 or some
bullshit like that.

So it's like, yeah, it's like the pricing
part is so important.

I see so many people, they put
like their price at $85.

I'm like, why not $89?

It's like, why put it at 85?

So like, that's how you squeeze.

Like, this is where we like
squeeze so much

of the profit, all these little
small changes

that we've made onto the site.

And if like so many more
like CRO wins that

can go through, they're like
super obvious,

but like have really made a substantial
difference to our business.

Even though we don't run CRO, it's
just like common sense.

You know, like we're not a CRO agency,
but we technically run it like that.

The Amazon thing is super interesting

because the one I just, the
one that I was talking

about, they did the, they intentionally
did it.

Well, they intentionally left
the MSRP higher.

They didn't like go raise
the price, but like

Amazon, and I'm sure there's
like some Amazon

pricing things you have to consider for

this, but their Amazon is
listed at the MSRP.

And then they have a nice
little, you know,

it's not an always on offer
on the website,

but same thing.

Like it launched on Amazon and the
website stayed the same.

Pricing was better on the website by a small
amount, even though MSRP was listed.

So there was a discount
and they saw like,

okay, yeah, Amazon went from
zero to a couple

thousand dollars a day.

But the website went from, you know,

whatever, 50K a day to 60, 70K
a day, because to your

point, like the pricing psychology and like,
oh, now it feels like a better offer.

They saw the exact same thing.

Since we're going, since
we're going bar for

bar on tests right now, let
me tell you about

a loser.

It's pissing me off.

We launched a, we have a test
rolling right now.

It's just a, it's a PDP test.

Well, the original version,
when they redid

the PDP, they relaunched
it with like an AI

summary of the reviews.

And to me, I'm like, okay,
that's interesting.

Like Amazon's got the AI summary,
but like, I

just feel like customers are
kind of like averse

to AI things.

Maybe not with reviews because it's on

Amazon, there's that summary,
but there was no, you

couldn't read actual reviews.

And to me, I was just like,
felt like, ah,

it feels weird, especially
because there's

tons of glowing, like they have great reviews,
4.7 stars, tons of awesome photos.

Everything is great.

So the test we're running
right now is the

summarize version against the full review

widget.

The summarize version is winning
by 10% profit per session.

And it's pissing me off.

It's like, it makes no sense to me.

Because like, to me, it's
like, you'd want,

you would assume customers
on a high AOV product

would want to read real authentic
reviews from other humans.

Um, but apparently they like the, the

summarize version and it literally
says AI summary.

No, no, but that's a really good idea.

That's interesting.

Um, that'd be super interesting.

That, um, what's front row, front row
MD just came out with that.

A bunch of people are testing this
like clinicians AI thing.

I don't know if you guys have seen that.

IMAID's doing it.

And I know a couple other
brands are doing

it where you land on a PDP
and you can ask

clinician AI about the product.

Um, super interesting.

We tried to, I tried to
break it yesterday

for IMA by asking it like,
will this heal,

cure my whatever disease?

And it was, it was, it was pretty
good about response.

Yeah, I'm sure.

I go follow Brian on X.

Brian, B-R-I-N-N-J-H-O on X.

Brian, thanks for being here, man.

This is great.

Thanks, man.

The only way that we grow this podcast is
by you sharing it with your friends.

Honestly, like reviews kind of don't really
mean anything too much anymore.

They're really meaningful, but they don't
do a lot for the growth of the podcast.

Um, and so sharing YouTube links, sharing Spotify
links, sharing Apple, whatever we

call it under the podcast app.

Now, anything you can share the
better we're going to be.

Um, guys, anything else you
want to say on this?

Yeah.

Please go check us out on YouTube,
rack up those views for us.

We'd love to see it.

And then subscribe, make sure to
subscribe on YouTube as well.

And I relentlessly refresh the YouTube

comments because it dictates my
mental health for the

day.

So please say something nice
about all of us.

Thank you, everyone.

Thanks for listening.

Honestly.