The Daily Trend Report

.

Show Notes

Social Media Train Wrecks, the Thursday food and beverage brand crisis post-mortem. Welcome to Social Media Train Wrecks. This is the Thursday episode of The Daily Trend Report feed, where we roll up on a food or beverage brand's worst week online and pick through the wreckage. I'm giovanni gallucci, and Rachel Donovan's riding shotgun. Rachel, what are we rubbernecking at? Gio, this one's a burger chain and a high school football team. The kids shot their team photos at their fa . . . | Strategy and creative are mine. AI helps produce it.

What is The Daily Trend Report?

The Daily Trend Report. Every weekday morning, giovanni gallucci and a rotating cohost (Chloe Dawn on clean label food and beverage, plus Rachel Donovan or Alexis Parker on social media) synthesize the day's cross-LLM trend reports into three operator stories: social media, clean label food and beverage, and content, social, and AI. Tight, specific, no filler. For owners, founders, marketing leads, and operators in clean-label CPG.

.
.
.
| ai-assisted content

[INTRO]
[HOST] Welcome to Social Media Train Wrecks. This is the Thursday episode of The Daily Trend Report feed, where we roll up on a food or beverage brand's worst week online and pick through the wreckage. I'm giovanni gallucci, and Rachel Donovan's riding shotgun. Rachel, what are we rubbernecking at?
[GUEST] Gio, this one's a burger chain and a high school football team. The kids shot their team photos at their favorite In-N-Out, the photos went viral, and then In-N-Out's trademark people made them delete every single one.
[HOST:surprised] In-N-Out sent a legal email to a football team. About free advertising. For In-N-Out.
[GUEST] Three business days to take it down. And they did.
[HOST] I've been waiting a long time for a wreck where the brand runs over its own biggest fans. Pull us up to the crash site.

[STINGER]

[SECTION 1]
[GUEST] So picture Lincoln, California. Placer County, up in the northeast corner of the Sacramento metro. Small town, Friday night lights, and after every home game the Lincoln High Fighting Zebras go to the same In-N-Out.
[HOST] Every team in America has that place. For these kids it's In-N-Out.
[GUEST] And there's a trend going around right now where high school teams do their media day photos at their local fast food spot. One of the team moms, Chelsey Vanderschrier, sees it and thinks, our kids should do this at In-N-Out.
[HOST] Good instinct. That team mom read the feed better than most brand managers I meet.
[GUEST] So the booster club hires a photographer named Glenn Silva. The local manager, a guy the team thanks by name as Andrew, opens the restaurant an hour early for them. Kids in full uniform and helmets, posing at the register, handing bags out the drive-thru window, standing under the menu board.
[HOST:happy] Helmets at the drive-thru window. That's a great photo. I'd have paid for that photo.
[GUEST:excited] And it takes off. One video passes six hundred thousand views and about twenty-six thousand likes. The LA Times says the behind-the-scenes reel got close to a million.
[HOST] For a high school media day. Most food brands I talk to would give a kidney for a reel that does six hundred thousand organically.
[GUEST] The caption said, the history of Fighting Zebras and In n Out runs deep. And they called the players animal style.
[HOST] Animal style players. A booster club wrote that line for free. Strangers loving a brand in public, unprompted, with the kids in the middle of it. You can't buy that.
[GUEST] Then SFGATE calls the photographer to write a feel-good story about the shoot.
[HOST:mischievous] Here comes the train.
[GUEST] Less than thirty minutes after he hangs up with the reporter, an email lands from In-N-Out's trademark team. The subject line, I'm reading it, Unauthorized Filming and Photography at In-N-Out Burger, Immediate Removal Request.
[HOST:sarcastic] Nothing says thanks for the love like the words immediate removal request.
[GUEST] It says In-N-Out takes the protection of its brand, trademarks, and trade dress very seriously. It says using the premises, signs, and logos without permission may violate their intellectual property rights. And it gives them three business days. Respectfully but firmly.
[HOST] So what did the photographer do?
[GUEST] He pushed back, politely. The manager said yes, it was before hours, and nobody's claiming an endorsement. He offered to change the captions or pull the tags. He asked for a one-time exception, for the kids.
[HOST] And corporate said?
[GUEST] Store managers aren't allowed to approve shoots. You need express written consent from corporate, in advance. Then their lawyer writes back and says, we understand this is not the answer you were hoping for, and your request was given careful consideration. Please confirm once the content has been taken down.
[HOST:sarcastic] Careful consideration. Somebody carefully considered deleting a kid's football photo.
[GUEST] Thursday, September twenty-fourth, about four thirty in the afternoon, the posts come down. Silva can't post any of the thirty photos he shot. Anywhere.
[HOST] So, the bonehead move, and I want to be fair here. In-N-Out is famous for guarding that brand. They sued a burger joint in Utah back in 2007. They sued Puma in 2019 over a sneaker. They sent a cease and desist to a San Diego sports bar for selling animal style fries. That discipline is part of why the brand is worth so much. I'm not mad they have a trademark team.
[GUEST:curious] Then what's the bonehead part?
[HOST] They pointed a tool built for copycats at a fan. A burger joint stealing your menu is a business problem, and a lawyer is the right person to handle it. A football team posing at your counter is a community moment, and somebody from social should have been the one to pick up that phone. In-N-Out sent a lawyer to a pep rally.
[GUEST] Was there even a legal case?
[HOST] That's for the lawyers, and I'm not one. Two law professors told the LA Times they doubted it. Mark McKenna at UCLA said a high school team isn't really a commercial user. So the risk they were guarding against was small, and the cost they took on was huge. In my opinion, that's a bad trade.

[STINGER]

[SECTION 2]
[GUEST] Okay, so the posts come down. The booster club does something I didn't expect.
[HOST] They apologize.
[GUEST] They apologize. To In-N-Out. A team mom group says sorry to a burger chain for loving it too much on camera.
[HOST:appalled] The parents apologized to the burger chain. That one stops me cold.
[GUEST] And In-N-Out writes back, and Gio, the tone flips. Thank you for your prompt response, we are happy to consider this matter resolved. We appreciate the positive relationship your organization has with INO, and we hope the Fighting Zebras continue to enjoy many more post-game visits. Best of luck with the rest of the season, exclamation point.
[HOST:sarcastic] The exclamation point. Somebody in that building thought the exclamation point fixed it.
[GUEST] Grade it for me. Start with that email.
[HOST] The email gets a D. It reads friendly, and it's the meanest note in the whole chain, because it treats the kids losing their photos as a closed ticket. If you're going to be warm, be warm before you take something away from somebody. After reads like a receipt.
[GUEST] And then the story gets out.
[HOST] SFGATE breaks it. Then it runs everywhere. New York Post, the LA Times, USA Today, KTLA, the Sacramento Bee. Techdirt called it breathtaking, and they didn't mean the photos.
[GUEST] So what did In-N-Out say to all of them?
[HOST:annoyed] Nothing. They didn't respond to SFGATE. They didn't respond to the LA Times. KTLA asked, no answer. The Sac Bee asked, no answer.
[GUEST:curious] Is silence always wrong, though? You've said before sometimes the right move is to say nothing.
[HOST] Silence works when the story has no face. A pricing complaint, a menu fight, a rumor that dies in a day. Silence here is a whole different animal. This story has a face, and it's a teenager in a helmet holding a bag of fries. When the other side of the story is a kid, your silence doesn't look calm. It looks cold.
[GUEST] So the response grade overall?
[HOST] The decision to protect the trademark, I'll give them a C, because I understand why a brand like that holds the line. Everything after, an F. They had about a week where one phone call could have turned this into the best story of their year, and they let a trademark email be the last thing anybody heard from them.
[GUEST] One phone call saying what?
[HOST] Something like, we got this wrong, the kids can keep their photos, and the team eats on us after the next home game. That's it. Nobody's arguing with that. That's the In-N-Out story people would be sharing right now instead of this one.
[GUEST:thoughtful] And it would've cost them, what, a few dozen Double-Doubles?
[HOST] A few dozen Double-Doubles and one email from someone who isn't a lawyer. The photos reached maybe a million people. The takedown story ran all the way to USA Today, and every person who read it now knows In-N-Out as the place that made a football team delete its pictures. They got the reach. They just got it for the wrong story.
[GUEST] And the photographer?
[HOST] Glenn Silva told SFGATE it hurt, because that shoot could have been the start of something for him. Every creator who read that story learned one lesson. Don't make content about In-N-Out. Fan content is the cheapest marketing a food brand will ever get, and they scared it off.

[STINGER]

[SECTION 3]
[GUEST] So how does this not happen? Prevention.
[HOST:excited] It starts with that manager. Andrew said yes. He opened the store early, he made the kids feel like the place was theirs. That's the best brand ambassador In-N-Out has in Placer County, and corporate's answer was to tell everyone he wasn't allowed to say yes.
[GUEST] So give the manager the power?
[HOST] Give the manager a path. A one-page permission form, two questions, sent to corporate, answered in a day. Is this a business selling something, or is this our community celebrating us? If it's community, the answer's yes and here's how to tag us. Most brands don't have that path, so the only path left is a lawyer.
[GUEST:mischievous] So the team mom needed a form.
[HOST] The team mom needed a form and a thank you. And second, before any takedown goes to a fan, somebody from social or comms has to sign off. Legal can say we have the right. Social has to answer the next question. If this email shows up as a screenshot with our logo on it, who wins?
[GUEST] And if the lawyers still say they have to protect the mark?
[HOST] Then protect it with a yes. I'm not giving legal advice, but ask your trademark lawyer about a simple written permission. Permission you grant is still you controlling your mark. You keep the photos up, you stay in charge, and the kids keep their memories.
[GUEST] Okay, storm-proofing. Make it work for a brand that's never heard of the Fighting Zebras.
[HOST] Five pieces. One, sort the mail. Every piece of content with your logo in it goes in one of two bins. Somebody trying to make money off you, or somebody who loves you. Lawyers handle the first bin. Your social team handles the second, and the second bin is a lot bigger than you think.
[GUEST] Two.
[HOST] Two, nobody sends a scary email to a fan without a second signature. Name the person. Who holds that button. If you can't name them today, you have the same hole In-N-Out has.
[GUEST:excited] Three.
[HOST] Three, build the yes before you need it. Give your store managers something they can approve on the spot, with rules attached. Tag us, don't sell anything, have fun. Fans don't read your trademark policy. They read whether the people behind the counter were glad to see them.
[GUEST] Four.
[HOST] Four, when kids are in the story, your clock runs at double speed. Teams, schools, anybody the public instinctively roots for. You get one day, maybe two, to say something human before the internet decides who you are. Silence past that point gets read as a choice.
[GUEST] Five.
[HOST] Five, keep a fan budget. A standing line item for exactly this. Free meals for the team that shot the photos, a repost, a gift card for the photographer, a handwritten note. It's the cheapest crisis plan you'll ever buy, and most of the time it turns the crisis into the campaign.
[GUEST:thoughtful] So if In-N-Out had done all five?
[HOST:happy] Then we're not doing this episode. Somebody at In-N-Out reposts the reel, the team eats free after the next win, the photographer gets credited, and every high school in California wants its media day at In-N-Out next fall. Same photos. Different decision.
[GUEST] Give me the line people screenshot.
[HOST] Your fans make your best content for free. The least you can do is buy them lunch.

[STINGER]

[OUTRO]
[HOST] That's the wreck. If you run a food or beverage brand, your customers are already posting about you, and somebody on your side needs to meet them there. That's my job. Fifteen-plus years running organic social media for food and beverage brands, and community management and fan content are the work. If your fans are posting and nobody's answering, let's fix that. Find me at gallucci dot net, or DM at gallucciNET on Instagram or LinkedIn.
[GUEST] Thanks for riding along, everybody.
[HOST] For Rachel Donovan, I'm giovanni gallucci. Send your fans lunch, and catch The Weekend Trend Report on Saturday.