Collin Slattery (Taikun Digital) joins Brad and Andrew for a no-fluff breakdown of why Google Ads breaks the brain of most DTC operators who cut their teeth on Meta. The core argument lands early and lands hard: your relationship with Google is structurally adversarial in a way your relationship with Meta isn't, because Google can't manufacture more search inventory the way Meta manufactures more feed inventory. The only lever they have to grow revenue is extracting more from advertisers, which means every default setting, every recommendation, and every "AI enhancement" is built to serve them first.
From that foundation, Collin walks through the operational stack that actually works: ruthlessly segmenting brand from non-brand across both search and shopping, building a real product feed instead of plugging Shopify into Merchant Center and calling it done, structuring shopping into heroes, sidekicks, villains, and zombies, and treating YouTube Shorts as the only YouTube placement worth touching unless you're running holdout tests. Along the way he drops a study Tyken ran across roughly $20M in spend showing that hidden search terms cost advertisers about $0.85 of efficiency per dollar spent, the case for YouTube being the single most incremental channel in digital (87% net-new traffic for one of his nine-figure clients, plus 34 million Americans reachable nowhere else), and a hard truth that Google scaling is brick-by-brick, never one banger creative away.
If you've ever wondered why your Google account "kind of works but never really scales," this is the episode that explains exactly why and exactly what to do about it. Key Takeaways
Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.
We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.
The relationship that you have with
Google is inherently adversarial,
where it is not necessarily
adversarial with Meta.
And the reason it's adversarial with
Google is because Google is a
monopoly, and they don't really have
a direct impact on
search query volume, right?
Like the amount of people who are
going to search for tennis shoes in
any given month is
relatively set, right?
Like they can't really impact that.
And so brand is like this
stereotypical example, and we see it
with brands of all sizes, even from,
you know, seven-figure brands to
ten-figure brands.
You go into their Google Ads
account, and it's very rare that
brand and non-brand is
truly fully segmented apart.
And it has to be.
YouTube today is kind of like Meta
in 2015, where, you know, you do the
1% lookalike audience, right?
Like we on this call all old enough
to remember the old lookalike
audience stacks
and things like that.
So you do have to do
audience targeting there.
But that's kind of like the lowest
form of YouTube advertising.
And now let's take a listen to the
Scalability School podcast.
All right.
Welcome to another episode of
Scalability School.
Incredible guest today.
Longtime friend of the podcast.
Longtime friend of mine and somebody
who I deeply respect and love.
Colin Slattery, the Google Ads
expert of D2C
Twitter, I would say, right?
I mean, can we name you that?
What do we think about that?
I'll take it.
It's a moniker I'll
happily wear for sure.
The person that people are willing
to fight with about
Google Ads on the Internet.
Whether they are
employed by Google or not.
Yeah, exactly.
Who actually is smart and can
respond back to them.
Colin, so glad to have you.
Colin's been an expert in the
Founders community on Google Ads for
a really long time.
And then a couple of years ago,
hired the best in
the game, Phil Kiel.
Previous Scalability School guest.
Now has an absolute empire that is
being built at Tyken Digital.
So we're stoked for you about that.
Good job.
Thanks.
And thanks for having me on.
Excited to check Google.
Excited to hopefully dispel some
myths and share a little bit of
knowledge in the process.
Google is kind of like the ugly
stepchild of DTC Twitter.
People don't want to talk about it.
It seems like you're one of the few
people that want to talk about it.
And I feel like it needs to be
talked about more because I
personally have a ton of questions.
Because I'm curious
how you think through it.
I know you have strong
opinions, which is good.
Because I don't think enough people
have strong enough
opinions that are also thoughtful.
And you have both.
You have both.
So I'm excited to dig in.
I feel like there's a whole other
episode at some point.
We just talk about everything that
you're building agency-wise.
Maybe we've got to get Phil and the
gang back together and
just talk about that.
Get Jake on here too.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Might as well.
Yeah.
Jake the ad nerd.
The OG.
He's in the game now too.
Yeah.
We'll have to get the whole crew on.
But yeah.
Excited to jam Google today.
Yeah.
I think it's going
to be a lot of fun.
And excited to dive in.
Maybe some hot takes.
Or lukewarm takes anyway.
Well, we can kick it off with the
nice original great starting point.
I thought it would
be interesting too.
I know Zach, I was looking back on
this tweet from like almost a year.
It's almost a year ago now.
It was actually June of last year.
It feels like it was just yesterday
that Zach was shitting on
all Google ads agencies.
But I thought this was
a good starting point.
And so Zach's tweet, I'll
probably summarize this.
But Zach kind of started by saying,
if you're a DTC brand, being your
Google ads agency more
than 10K a month, you are very
likely getting robbed.
Zach is known to
take strong positions.
Usually with good reason.
Usually with good reason.
But sometimes he has strong takes.
And so we don't have to spend a
bunch of time dispelling this.
But just curious if you have a kind
of quick take on your
feeling of, I guess, maybe the
average Google ad agency and what
you guys do differently
that helps set you apart.
Well, obviously, I
think that's bullshit.
And I said as much around that time
and the engagement was fun.
And I know Zach loves to throw bombs
out there and then
turn around and walk away.
But yeah, no, I mean,
that's clearly not true.
Right.
And I actually would say that Google
in particular is one of the places
where investment in top
quality talent is even more
paramount because of the difficulty
and the number of dark patterns
that exist in the platform.
This gets to a foundational concept
around the differences
between Google and Meta.
And one of those is that the
relationship that you have with
Google is inherently adversarial,
where it is not necessarily
adversarial with Meta.
And the reason it's adversarial with
Google is because
Google is a monopoly.
And they don't really have a direct
impact on search query volume.
Right.
Like the amount of people who are
going to search for tennis shoes in
any given month is
relatively set.
Right.
Like they can't really impact that.
And they already
have the full market.
They can't get any
more market share.
And so the only thing that they can
do and speaking primarily around
search and shopping and
things like that is increase the
amount of money that they get paid
for the queries that
already exist.
That's the only lever that they have
to pull to increase
how much money they make.
They're a publicly traded company.
They're in the
business of making money.
Right.
And when they are increasing the
costs, that is born
by the advertiser.
Meta, on the other hand, has the
ability to impact their inventory in
a way that Google
does not.
Right.
They can increase the frequency of
ads in reels or your feed.
They can make the
product more addictive.
So people scroll deeper so they can
be exposed to more ads.
Right.
And so fundamentally, Google is not
playing nicely with advertisers
because it is in their
best interest to.
Take money from advertisers.
And so if you have someone who
doesn't know what they're doing and
doesn't know Google's
dark patterns, it is very easy for
Google to be an absolute waste of
money because that's
good for them.
Right.
Because they need to make money.
So if you don't have someone who's
excellent, and admittedly, there are
not that many excellent
people out there, it's going to be a
non-incremental waste fest.
And I think that's what most people
run into because they're working
with people who don't
know how to do it or
they're working with people who are
meta first and the rules between
meta and Google are completely
different.
And then they're
like, oh, Google's trash.
Everyone who does Google is trash.
And screw this.
I'm known for taking notes.
And the first thing I wrote down is
Zach equals skill issue.
So that's what I heard
from section number one here.
It is, in fact, a skill issue.
A hundred percent.
Good.
Good.
Well, I'm sure Zach will hear this
and we'll remind him.
But that segues nicely into like,
OK, so then what can brands that are
listening to this do and
take away to actually start to make
Google a channel that
is effective for them?
Because I think a
lot of people will.
I mean, our average, the average
client that we work with has Google
and there's brand set up in
some capacity.
Whether or not it's incremental,
there's a bunch of
questions around that.
And yeah, right.
And you mentioned you mentioned
there's there's probably different
things to consider, certainly
across industries and how you should
consider across industries, but even
account spend and
size.
And so I think if you could just
start to kind of take people through
like what what is the
actual account setup
and structure look like?
How does it change as you scale?
I think that could be a really
interesting starting point to just
kick off, you know, where people
can start to get
some tactical takeaways.
Yeah, and I think this is this gets
back to the size and
complexity of Google, which is
material.
It's a materially more complex
platform than meta is.
There's a lot more stuff going on
and there's a lot of
stuff going on that.
Is beneficial to Google, but
detrimental to the advertiser.
And I think if people are.
Looking to succeed on Google, I
think that is a mindset shift that
needs to happen where
when you are in there, the.
Everything you look at, you need to
think this is set up in order to
benefit Google and
not benefit me.
So you should be very skeptical of
anything that Google recommends.
Right.
And we're kind of that way with meta
when they're like auto apply all of
these AI enhancements
and shit like that.
But those are much more visible in
meta than they are in Google.
And so you absolutely have to be
approaching it with that mindset and
trying to make it
harder for Google to succeed.
And so brand is like this
stereotypical example.
And we see it with brands.
Of all sizes, even from, you know,
seven figure brands to 10 figure
brands, you go into their
Google ads account and it's very
rare that brand and non brand is
truly fully segmented
apart.
And it has to be because if you say
I want a five X right.
And you put brand in there, right,
that's going to generate a 20 X.
And then Google is
like, cool, we got a 20.
We banked the 20 X here.
That means we can waste money on
stuff that doesn't perform.
It'll average out to a five.
And the advertiser is
happy because it says a five.
But they haven't dug that layer
below and seen all those conversions
are happening to brand.
80% of the budget is 10% of the
conversion value and 10% of the
budget is 90% of the
conversion value.
And blended, it looks great.
They run a holdout test on it.
Like, hey, this is
not incremental at all.
Like we chopped our Google and
nothing happened.
It's like, well, yeah, of course.
It's because your brand and non
brand are blended together.
And so if there is one thing that
people take away, get them split
apart completely, right?
And split in search.
So negative it out in
all your non brands.
If you want to run it, put in its
own manual CPC search campaign.
But you have to do it
on shopping too, right?
Like shopping inventory serves
against brand queries.
And so if you're not segmenting out
branded queries and shopping,
if you don't have a
branded shopping campaign,
all that's going to roll into your
Pmax is going to roll into your
regular shopping.
And it's going to be the same
problem that you would have with
search as Justin Shopping.
That is, I think, the biggest
problem and also the
easiest problem to fix.
Is that a one-time thing?
Or do you have to
check it regularly?
Because Google is trying to jam
brand back into things
or brand adjacent things.
So if you do a good job with your
negative keyword list,
you're going to get 99% of it out.
It's not going to
cover all misspellings.
And so it does make sense so much in
a while go through and negative out
the misspellings.
When you launch new campaigns,
you do need to apply the negative
keyword list to the campaign.
But it's mostly a one-time, 30
minutes max sort of activity.
So there's a lot of brands.
Brad was saying there's a lot of
small brands or smaller brands that
listen to this podcast.
And I think, you know, have always
wanted to test Google.
And I think people
get excited about brand.
They get excited about launching
Google and they get excited about
launching YouTube ads as well.
So when you're looking at those
brands that you've
worked with in the last,
let's just say 12 months, because I
know it changes over time.
What are they doing?
What's the mix of brand, non-brand?
Are they doing shopping?
Are they doing YouTube?
What does that mix look like?
And what are the things that you've
seen be truly incremental to their
results and their growth?
I'm going to say something, and
maybe this is my first hot take,
even though it's not a hot take
because it's driven by data.
Google and YouTube done well are the
most incremental advertising that
any brand will ever have,
period, full stop, done.
We've done this with nine-figure
brands where 87% of the traffic
coming from YouTube is
net new to the brands,
whereas Meta is
sitting around like 60, 62%.
Google and YouTube are so
incremental and expose so many
people to traffic
that is nowhere else.
There are 34 million Americans that
are not on Meta properties,
are not on TikTok,
are not in any other
digital properties,
but YouTube.
Literally, the only place you can
reach these 34 million
people are on YouTube.
Totally net new,
do not exist anywhere else.
They're only on YouTube.
And you can reach them there, right?
And so,
and that's just the people that
aren't anywhere else, right?
It's not even counting the people
that you don't reach
because they're not in a
conversion-focused audience
in Meta or anything like that.
So,
massively, massively, massively,
massively incremental.
It's just set up
poorly most of the time.
Now,
to kind of like loop
back and it's like,
okay, well, how do you
make Google incremental?
Well,
one is,
it's get brand and non-brand
separated, right?
And then what you're doing is
different based on the scale
of the brand and where
your budget allocation is.
The first thing I'd say is like,
don't run brand at all.
Like negative it out and
then don't have it running,
period.
And I think Zach will probably agree
with me on that, right?
It's generally a waste of money.
And it's one of the very first
holdout tests that we run
with any client that comes on,
whether it's Meta in
Google or just Google only,
is like,
let's test brand,
like see if it's incremental
because it's usually not.
And it's something
you can just turn off,
which is great, right?
If you can allocate
that budget to things,
put it as a YouTube shorts instead.
Like what a better way to do it.
So if you can get away
with not running brand,
don't run brand.
And then the structure is like,
it's going to be pretty consistent,
but the budget
allocations will be different.
So non-brand shopping or like a
non-brand shopping Pmax,
right?
Non-brand search.
And then if you are running brand,
brand search,
brand shopping,
and then some degree
of demand gen shorts
as kind of like the
third component of that.
So,
you know,
we're looking at
three to five campaigns
as kind of like the
default structure.
When do you,
so then,
okay,
so that's for everybody.
So what is scaling it out look like?
Is it horizontally
adding more campaign
by product,
product category?
Is it just scaling it
up by cranking budgets
and sending it to the moon?
Obviously,
YouTube is probably
handled fairly differently
because there's a
creative component to it,
whether that's shorts
or just,
you know,
general YouTube placements.
So you can pick either side,
maybe Google is the place to start
and then work over to YouTube.
But like,
what is actually,
what does it look
like to start scaling up
the Google side?
Yeah.
So I think
the easiest scale to
unlock is shopping,
right?
It's the shopping inventory.
And it's easy,
but it's not simple
because what
dictates how shopping works
is really the structured data
that you're giving Google,
right?
So it's the quality
of your product feed.
It's the descriptions.
It's the images.
It's the secondary images.
The color data,
the size data.
It's how optimized your titles are,
right?
It's making sure that
there aren't price mismatches
or any other issues
that are impacting
the quality of the data
that is being fed to Google
because that's how Google decides,
oh,
this is,
this is,
you know,
a blue sneaker,
right?
It's,
well,
you have to give them all that data.
And so if someone
searches for blue sneaker,
right,
you want to show up for that.
And so the only way
you're going to show up
is if you have good,
clean data.
And reviews are another huge
component of that.
People are going to go,
they're going to
search for blue sneakers.
What's going to get surfaced
and what's going to get clicked on.
Stuff that has good data
so that Google knows
that's what you're selling.
And then things that
have a lot of reviews
because that's a trust signal
and people are going to click on it.
And so feeding Google good data
is going to impact
how much shopping volume
you're going to be able to acquire.
And then there are other parts
that obviously brands can't control.
So like if you,
the larger your SKU library,
the greater the
surface area you can cover.
And so generally
the higher the scale
that you can conceivably get.
Similarly to that,
the better your
business economics are,
right?
If you think about
search impression share,
like a pie
or a hundred percent of search
impression share,
like no business is going to be able
to economically monetize
a hundred percent of search
impression share.
But if your
economics are not so good,
right?
If your revenue per session
is generally pretty low
or your margins are pretty low,
like the percentage of
the search impressions
where you can profitably target it,
it's going to shrink.
And so
your business
metrics also like dictate
kind of the scale
that you can achieve
on shopping as well.
But
there's a ton of scale
in shopping.
Friends,
quick break.
This episode of Scalability School
is brought to you by
Northbeam Incrementality,
which honestly is so awesome.
Let me just tell you
a little bit about it.
If you're a marketer,
you probably agree
incrementality testing is broken.
It's insane.
You got to do all this crazy stuff.
But with Northbeam,
you do it right in the platform.
It builds tests
using your own MTA data,
launches them directly
in the ad platform
and automatically monitors them
throughout the test.
And if something threatens validity,
you're alerted to it
within Northbeam
before it ruins the results.
The really nice thing
is it solves all these problems
you hear about
incrementality testing
all the time,
like labor,
spreadsheets,
statistical reference,
designing tests
is normally so slow,
right,
and error prone.
So with Northbeam Incrementality,
it's automated and accurate
and your team
is able to spend
with confidence.
Give it a shot
with Northbeam Incrementality.
Really,
the future of incrementality
is here
and Northbeam
has figured out a way
to make it easy.
So, I mean,
it's interesting,
you know,
I've never heard somebody
give the case
for shopping that heavily,
so that's interesting.
I think you've had this thing
about called
hidden search terms
and you have a framework
of Google inventory,
which is premium,
mid-tier,
and garbage.
And that's what,
this is,
you know,
taken from your word.
So talk about
hidden search terms
and the research
around this
and what things
folks can do
to bring some
of these search terms
out that maybe
they weren't,
you know,
aware,
ever familiar with
in terms of targeting.
And this is,
again,
this gets to the whole,
there's additional layers
underneath Google
that when you just
look at it,
it's painting
a very small picture
of what's actually
going on.
so keywords
and search terms
are not even
remotely the same thing,
right?
It's like,
oh,
well,
you know,
I'm targeting blue shoes.
Like,
that's the keyword
that I'm targeting.
That's what I'm bidding.
It's just like,
no,
that can match
to hundreds
of different search queries
that are somewhat related
to completely unrelated
depending on your match type,
right?
And so those are
the search terms
that surface.
And so those are the things,
search terms are what people
are actually typing
into Google to find
and then your ad
is surfing against,
right?
And Google,
up until,
I think it was probably
2020,
like 2021,
I can't remember
the exact year.
At this point,
it was a while ago.
They used to show
95%
of all of the terms
that people typed in
to,
that surfaced your ad.
So you'd have
95% visibility,
90 to 95% visibility
in everything
that people searched for
that your ad surfed against.
And for privacy reasons,
they decided
to hide
a huge percentage
of the search terms
that people searched for
that your ad surfed against.
And they lumped them together
in what is known
as other search terms,
which you can't see
what they searched for.
You can only see
a single line
of the aggregated performance
of what is hidden.
And that's a problem,
right?
Like you're paying for it.
You should know
what people are searching.
And the performance
of the stuff
that is hidden
is generally
worse than
what is visible.
And that's because
in my estimation,
right,
it behooves Google
to hide the stuff
that people would
try to exclude
if it's not related.
Right?
If my keyword is,
you know,
blue shoes
and,
you know,
the matching is
blue tablecloth,
like,
that's
not related.
Right?
But you can get
matches that are
that far away.
It's actually
pretty shocking
how not close
search terms
can be to the keyword
that triggered them.
And now that they
can hide those,
it's easier for you
to keep bidding on them
as opposed to
historically,
you know,
turn them into
negatives and remove them.
Yeah.
You put together
like a pretty
gnarly report,
like actually
digging into this.
Do you have any
of the numbers
like handy
out of the top
of your head
that you can
just like rip off?
Or is that
a little bit
too specific?
I mean,
do you want,
I have the report
somewhere probably.
Pull it up.
Yeah.
If it's not,
if it's not a huge
pain to pull up,
I'd be super curious
to dig into that
because I remember
reading it
I'm pretty sure
that,
is that what
Ginny responded to?
And I do want to note
this is only for
search campaigns
and shopping campaigns
where you have
full search
career report
data available.
But we looked at
around $20 million
in ad spent
in search
and shopping spent
and found that
for every
dollar of ad
spent
that you are
running through Google,
they're skimming
almost a full dollar.
off of your efficiency
with hidden search terms.
So,
if you were to spend
a million dollars
on ads
and everything
was visible,
you would generate
about $5.6 million
in revenue.
In reality,
you're only generating
about $4.75
million in revenue.
And that $850,000
shortfall
is due to the
inefficiency
of
hidden search terms.
Yeah.
So you're looking at
like
a 5.6x
for visible
versus
a
4.75
for
full blend
including
hidden.
Like worst case scenario,
historically,
before this change,
you could just
exclude them
and,
okay,
I've excluded them,
I'm not wasting money
on them.
And now,
it's just being
lumped in there.
And so,
what you're saying
is best case scenario,
you can actually
exclude them
and then the additional
spend,
you'd be able to continue.
You're spending that money
anyway,
so it's going to be
spent at that more
efficient return number.
Am I understanding
that correctly?
Well,
I mean,
you can't get rid
of the stuff that's hidden,
right?
For sure.
Stuff is always
going to be hidden
and it is a game
of whack-a-mole
to consistently
exclude things
to try and pull
up efficiency numbers.
You can aggregate
data through
what's known
as Ngram analysis
to pull stuff
out of hidden,
like,
and exclude stuff
that would otherwise
be lumped into
hidden search terms.
Generally,
hidden search terms
are stuff
that Google
categorizes
as, like,
low volume,
right?
So it's not getting
a lot of volume
against those queries
and so those
are generally
going to be
longer tail
search queries
and by longer tail,
I mean,
more words
in the query.
And so
you can aggregate
what is visible
and find terms
that are
low performing
and when you
exclude those,
it will also
generally pull out
stuff that was
hidden
that also included
that term
that is
not effective.
Not usually
going to get
like a lower
percentage
of hidden
but you can
reduce the
inefficiency
overall
by going
through and
pulling stuff
out.
Cool.
Personally,
I'm very
interested in
like the
actual
tactical levers
of,
okay,
we can dig
into shopping.
Andrew,
if you're cool
with going
down that route,
I'm just going
to start ripping
some questions.
Absolutely.
Feel free to
take it wherever
direction you want
to.
So you mentioned
you've kind of
got like four
to five campaigns
that are standard.
I think we'll
ignore the brand
side of this
completely for now
because I think
your basic
TLDR is like
turn it off
or highly
limit the spend
that's going
into it at all
if you're going
to spend into it
and just be
thoughtful around
that.
If you're in a
vertical where you
need to spend
on brand,
you'll know
because it's
the exception.
Fair.
Cool.
Maybe worth
coming back to
that because
that's interesting.
But then shopping
is where you're
seeing the majority
of the volume.
You said every
brand could spend
six figures.
It's kind of
like a take.
So as people
are thinking about
setting up shopping,
you said the
biggest lever
is kind of
just like the
inputs to Google
which is
functionally the
feed and maybe
some offshoots
of that.
So what are
brands doing wrong
when they set up
their shopping?
You mentioned
the title and
the actual data
is not set up
properly.
So let's say
that they are
starting to chip
away at updating
that and maybe
their 80%
of what you
call like this
is a good
input.
The feed is
solid.
What's like
what's still
missing?
And then if
they wanted to
increase spend
volume through
shopping,
like what are
they actually
doing?
It is actually
I should say
is one of the
biggest challenges
with Google
is because
everything is
different depending
on small
changes in a
brand, right?
Like if you
have 10,000
SKUs, like
your approach
is going to be
completely different
than if you
have 50 or
100 SKUs
or 10 SKUs,
right?
And so the
feed is table
stakes, right?
And having that
fully optimized
and I will say
like most people
just connect their
Shopify feed to
Google Merchant
Center and
they're like,
I'm done,
right?
Like, no.
And if that is
you, like, go get
data feed watch.
It's not that
expensive.
It's going to
allow you to
really optimize your
Google fields,
which is super
important.
And we're
going to
assume you
have reviews
piping in
because that's
also very
important.
Shopping from
a structural
level and I
think Google
in general,
and this is
something that
we've seen
time and time
again on
search, on
shopping,
absolutely on
YouTube.
Google is not
nearly as
efficient a
budget allocator
as Meta.
And so, so
many people come
from the Meta
space where it's
like, trust
Meta, they
know what they're
doing, go
broad, like drop
it all
together, right?
You cannot do
that with Google.
You're going to
have a bad
time if you're
doing that with
Google.
And that
extends to
shopping as
well.
And then you
need segmentation
and you need
thoughtful segmentation
in order to
unlock volume.
What this
segmentation
looks like is
really dependent
on number of
SKUs and
business
priorities.
If you're
a retailer
and you
carry a
hundred brands,
your shopping
structure is
going to look
materially different
than if you're
a supplement
company and
you've got
20 SKUs.
Just try the
example,
though, Colin,
of let's say
there's this
lower amount
of SKUs,
20 SKUs.
How are they
structured?
Are they
structured based
on which
one's driving
the best
revenue for
you with the
best gross
margin?
How do you
start to
structure that?
I think the
initial structuring
that you're
going to want
to do,
and again,
this is a
phase one,
is you have
one campaign
and you have
ad groups
in the
shopping campaign
that are
segmented either
by a
category or
if you have
really very
few products,
you can even
segment them
individually.
So you're a
supplement company,
you have
supplements for
digestion and
supplements for
sleep, right?
You can break
them up into
those individual
categories and
then make sure
that you have
negative keywords
at the ad
group level to
make sure that
you're routing
queries to the
correct ad
groups.
So that's kind
of like a
we're just
getting started
structure.
And then
once you have
that running,
you're going to
start to see,
okay, this
product is
potentially working
really well and
performing really
well.
Maybe that's
something where
you actually
can, and
we've done
this, like
we'll have a
shopping campaign
with just a
single product in
it so that
it's not
competing for
budget with
the other
products in
that campaign.
It's not super
common where
we'll fully pull
out an
individual product,
but it'll
happen.
Over time,
breaking the
campaigns apart
based on by
performance and
like bucket
them together
really into
like four
main structures
which are like
high spend,
high performing,
high performing,
low spend,
just low
performing,
and then like
no spend,
right?
And so,
you know,
you don't want
like your top
10% of SKUs
to be competing
for budget
with the 80%
of SKUs
that get 2%
of the total
clicks,
right?
It's historically
called, you
know, heroes,
sidekicks,
villains, and
zombies, right?
It's kind of
the four
monikers for
the different
structures.
And you
break them
all apart.
And SKUs
can shift in
between the
different campaigns,
but the
reasoning behind
that is
Google's budget
allocation is
not incredibly
efficient.
And if
you're lumping
them together,
you're just
leaving money
on the table.
But the
first segmentation
starts in
an individual
campaign at
kind of the
accurate level
by grouping
products separately.
And grouping,
does grouping
the products
on its own
give to your
point?
Because it
helps Google
sort out
delivery a bit
better because
you're inserting
kind of an
opinion into
how that should
be structured.
Does that
alone add
more volume?
Or is it,
hey, we need
to split these
things up and
then we go
edit product
titles to have
more, you know,
like, are we
trying to increase
the search volume
by getting more
keywords?
Like, I'm like,
very tactical as
somebody who's not
running Google
accounts.
Like, so you're
segmenting those
things, but like,
what else is the
team doing on a
weekly basis to
try and drive
more volume?
Yeah, so I
mean, you're also
removing inefficient
search terms,
right?
that's just an
ongoing negative
keyword application
is an ongoing
piece of work
in Google,
on shopping,
on search,
everywhere.
Product optimization,
title testing,
that is also a
key component of
it because,
again, like,
you operate
under the
understanding that
there is a
finite amount
of search volume
for whatever it
is that you're
doing, right?
And when you
find things that
work, you want
to be getting a
high, as high a
click share as you
possibly can.
So optimizing to
try and maximize
your click share,
generally, like,
it's through titles,
it's through more
reviews, price,
obviously, also a
component to it,
using promotional
things, promos to
get the sort of
slash through and,
like, sale tags and
things like that.
And then adjusting
targeting, right?
And that's one of
the added benefits
there, too, is,
like, if you have
things broken up,
you can have a
specific target for,
you know, mascara,
whereas blush has a
completely different
target and you can
control those
efficiency targets
individually.
Yeah.
What role do
images play in
shopping?
Like, are you guys
testing images
consistently or is it
not a big lever?
Generally, like,
pretty strict
limitations around
images in
Google.
rules around, like,
not having texts
on the images,
like, not putting
promotional information
on images in the
feed.
So most things do
default to
white box.
You can include
lifestyle images
as well.
There are fields for
lifestyle images that
always worth doing.
Basically, and this is
another general rule,
if there's an
optional field that
you can use, it's
not optional.
Just use it, right?
Like, the more
optional things you
include, the better
your feed score is
going to be in
Google's estimation
and the more
opportunity you have
to surface.
So there's not a
ton that you can do
from an image
standpoint in terms
of testing.
You can do a
little bit, but
it's tough.
We've had clients
where their product
is in a box and the
box has text on it
and they'll reject
the image because
of the amount of
text that's on the
box.
I hate to host this
phrase, but it's kind
of phrased this way
intentionally, but like,
is there anything
hacky in shopping that
you can do that
consistently works?
Like, you know,
there's this theme on
Meta for a while
where everybody did
the we're sorry kind
of ad in that
positioning.
Like, there's a
format that pops up
that you can just
run that playbook
across brands and it
works very consistently.
Is there any
comparable on the
Google side, whether
it's like hacky
feeling?
Maybe it's specific to
shopping, maybe not.
Not really.
And I would say
that in general,
like, it's not
how we like to
approach advertising.
Whatever arbitrage
exists, I mean,
you're opening
yourself up to
potential issues
down the road.
You know, like,
there was a time
where you could
like, get promo
text onto images
by, you know,
making it less
obvious and
tricking the
sort of machine
to think it
wasn't there,
even though it
clearly was.
And you're just
going to get your
feet suspended
and you're going
to have to redo
all the work.
So, you know,
I generally
operate on the
do things the
right way
principle and
you're going to
be in good
shape.
Brad's always
trying to hack
an idea, you
know.
Look, I'm just,
you know, you
never know what
exists to me.
I'm the anti-hack
guy.
I'm the let's
do it by the
book and, you
know, always be
on the right
side.
I also lean that
direction, but,
you know, sometimes
people like, you
know, a little
sauce every once
in a while.
Do not invite the
eye of Sauron,
you know.
That's fair.
So let's just
talk about YouTube
briefly in going
through that, right?
I think this is a
place where people
are doing a ton
with taking stuff
from meta, putting
it on shorts.
What do you see
that works, that
drives incremental
results for folks
and how do you
think they should
approach YouTube?
How much time
do we have?
YouTube is the
most complex
place to
advertise and
the hardest place
to advertise in
digital.
And YouTube
is like six
or seven
different things,
right?
So like when we
talk about YouTube,
I mean, we're
talking about so
many different
things.
And so, you
know, I'll start
with kind of the
the low, lowest
of low-hanging
fruit, which is
that YouTube
shorts thing.
It's the demand
gen conversion
focused YouTube
shorts component
where you can
take your
high-performing
9x16 video
assets from
meta, put them
in a demand
gen campaign,
and run it
purely on
YouTube shorts
placement.
You know, get
kind of click
based, pretty
good click
based attribution
out of it.
you do have
to do
audience
targeting.
That's one
of the things
to remember.
You know, I
always say like
YouTube today
is kind of
like meta
in 2015
where, you
know, you
do the 1%
lookalike
audience, right?
Like we
were on
this call
all old
enough to
remember the
old lookalike
audience stacks
and things
like that.
So you do
have to do
audience
targeting there.
But that's
kind of like
the lowest
form of
YouTube
advertising.
Do you have
any issues
with the
measurement on
shorts?
Like, is it
cool?
Like, do you
trust what
YouTube is
reporting on
shorts enough?
Or, like, I'm
thinking of the
brand that's
not paying
house.
I'm sure
house is
fantastic.
I know they're
fantastic.
But like,
just a quick
sidebar on
measurement of
shorts.
It sounds like
it's low-hanging
fruit, but
what about the
measurement side?
So, shorts
measurement is
okay, but
not amazing.
And Google
is, it's
always going to
be under
counting the
efficacy of
shorts.
And I will
say this very
declaratively.
If you don't
have the
ability to
do holdout
testing, do
not spend a
dollar on
YouTube outside
of shorts.
Shorts is the
only place you
can spend
money.
Do not
do in
feed, do
not do
in
stream, do
not do
CTV, do
not do
any of
it.
Like, if
you are
not doing
holdout
testing,
don't spend
money on
sort of
traditional
YouTube.
Just only
spend money
on shorts
because that's
the place
where you're
going to
get some
click-based
attribution
and the
rest of the
YouTube
inventory.
And this
is why
YouTube
inventory is
so mispriced,
right?
It's like,
it is hard
to measure.
You do
really need
to be doing
those holdout
tests.
So, stay
in shorts
and don't
venture out
of the
shallow
waters into
the deep
end of
YouTube.
I mean, I
think it's a
matter, I
think that's
good about the
measurement and
making sure that
you have a plan
for measurement
and makes a ton
of sense.
To me, it's one
of these things
that you hear
people talking
about.
They don't
really know how
to set it up,
right?
I think a lot
of people spend
a lot of time
optimizing their
meta ads
accounts.
And I
think YouTube
is a place
that takes a
lot of energy
and attention
and people
just want to
repurpose stuff,
which you can
do to a degree,
but I guess I'm
just curious of
any other tips
and tricks
and tactics
that you
believe are
really valuable.
The other big
thing is audience,
right?
Audience still
matters on
YouTube.
And Google's
targeting on
YouTube is the
best and most
granular targeting
that exists today
in digital.
Like, you really
can target your
ICP.
And Google's
bidding algorithm
is not at the
level where you
can just go
broad and it
will find your
ICP, right?
So, you know,
if you sell
beauty products,
like, an in-market
audience for
beauty products is
a good audience
to test on
YouTube, right?
Like, go
narrow.
Go top 10%
household income
women between
the ages of
35 and 54
who have
X, Y, and Z
interests, right?
Like, the kind
of stuff that we
used to do on
Meta, like,
still totally
applicable on
Google.
You should
definitely be
doing that sort
of targeting
with YouTube,
even on
shorts, right?
And, like,
shorts is
huge.
Like, it's
bigger than
reels.
It's bigger
than TikTok.
Two billion
people use
shorts a month.
Like, shorts
is colossal.
So the
inventory is
there for
essentially any
advertiser to
spend thousands
of dollars a
day on just
shorts as a
placement.
But, again,
you gotta
take what's
old is new
again.
You gotta
take the
old rules of
what you did
on Meta,
you know,
back in the
day and get
granular with
your audiences.
And take
your winners,
right?
Like, you
know, I
think short
form video
that performs
well is
short form
video that
performs well.
You know,
obviously, like,
TikTok's kind of
like the gold
standard.
Like, if it
performs on
TikTok, it'll
perform everywhere
else.
Like, it
performs on
Meta, it
might not
necessarily perform
on TikTok.
But take
your winners,
drop them
into a demand
gen shorts
campaign, have
some granular
audience targeting
with different ad
groups and doing
granular audience
targeting.
And, like,
that's a super,
super easy
place to start.
It will have,
like, pretty good
click attribution
to it.
And, you know,
you're not going
to spend $20,000
a day on it,
but $2,000, $3,000,
$4,000, $5,000 a
day, I mean,
it's not nothing.
I'm very curious
about the role of
landing pages
across Google.
I know from a
shopping side,
it would have to
be handled
differently because
it needs to go
to functionally
a PDP.
So, I guess you
could split it
into two parts.
Like, what are
the role of
landing pages from
a search perspective?
I'm assuming you
have a lot more
flexibility in what
you can and can't
do from a search
side.
But, to your
point earlier,
maybe there's a
little bit less
volume overall in
search.
But then I'm just
curious, like,
have you seen,
like, CRO-specific
tests to PDPs that
have been impactful
for Google traffic
specifically?
Like, obviously,
price and offer is,
you know, maybe not
where I'm going
with this.
But I'm just curious
if you've come
across any, like,
CRO wins that
have unlocked
crazy scale,
whether it is a
shopping or search
side.
Absolutely.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And landing page
is huge.
You know,
landing pages are
being important
on Google,
like, predates
them being
important on
Meta.
I mean, it's
historically been
very important
because landing page
quality score
is one of the
components of
quality score.
And quality score
impacts your
CPCs.
And so a
better, higher
converting landing
page will
increase your
quality score,
which means it
helps your ad
rank, which
means your
CPCs are
going to be
lower.
So it's
always been a
key component
to it.
And you can
run shopping
to landing
pages.
And especially
if you are
in, you know,
maybe something
that does not
have a lot of
SKUs, if you're
in kind of like
a, you're a
supplement with
like a massive
hero product,
you probably don't
want to be sending
that to a PDP.
You do want to be
sending that to a
landing page that
is specifically
structured for
that traffic.
Because again,
we get back to
the how can we
maximize the
inventory that we
can target
profitably, right?
Like that's going
to impact your
revenue per session,
right?
And that means
you can adjust
your targets and
you're going to be
able to get a
greater click share,
right?
Like I would
love to have a
90% click share
for search terms
that are good
for me, right?
Because that's
what's going to
increase my volume.
So landing pages
are massively
critical to
search, but
also to shopping.
And I, you
know, I'm not
saying create a
custom landing page
for every single
product that you
have, but if it
gets a lot of
volume and you
look and you
see, okay, my
click share is
relatively low.
Like, okay, well,
how am I
increasing that?
How am I
increasing the
click share for
this specific
product?
Like, let's
make a landing
page for it
because now our
revenue per session
goes up, which
means we can, you
know, adjust our
bids, which
means the
percentage of
the inventory
that we can get
and get profitably
is going to go
up.
So, yeah,
landing page is
massively critical.
It's the key to
unlocking additional
non-brand search
as well because
people are looking
for specific
things and
your products
might have
20 different
angles for what
it does, right?
Like a
magnesium supplement,
like it's great
for sleep, but
it's also like
good for focus
and all these
other things.
And if you're
sending all of
those queries to
your PDP,
that's terrible,
right?
It's like best
supplement for
sleep.
All right, well,
there you go.
Now we're hitting
our sleep queries,
right?
Supplement for
focus.
Now we're hitting
something completely
different.
And so, you
know, and this
is, I think,
the biggest
challenge with
Google is that
outside of
YouTube, there's
not one big
unlock.
You're not going
to find a killer
creative and
scale your
budgets 10x.
Like that's not
how it works.
It is brick
by brick
incremental
layering of a
few percentage
points of
efficiency here.
Unlocking a new
class of keywords
that's going to
add another,
you know,
$3,000, $5,000,
$10,000 of ad
spend a month.
That's running
efficiently, right?
You're layering
on these
bricks and
building it
one piece at a
time.
There's no,
hey, we found
an absolute
banger, like,
let's rip it to
the moon.
Like, that's just
not how it
works.
And, you know,
I think that
lends itself to a
specific type of
person who is
very in the weeds,
who is going to
do all of this
work.
And also why
I think
most people
who deal
with Google
or most
brands are
like, oh,
Google doesn't
work or,
you know,
it's because
they're not
willing to pay
people who can
actually do this
to build it
and build it
over time
because it
does layer
over time.
It is not,
we took it
from $10,000 a
month to
$400,000 a
month in,
you know,
two months
with one
banger ad.
It's layered
over time.
I think we have
a new podcast
called Skill Issue
that can come out
of this to bring
this full circle
where we just
like, we'll just
pull up ad
accounts and
Colin, you can
just publicly
shit on
everybody's
Google account.
It's so hard.
There are not
that many Google
people in the
world who are
good at it.
It is,
and I've seen
this with
clients who
have been
wanting to
fire us
for a very
long time,
not because
we're not
doing a great
job, but
just because
we're expensive
and they're
like, you're
too expensive.
We don't
want to pay
you.
We're going
to in-house
this.
I'm like,
okay, good
luck.
There are
just not
that many
people who
are legitimately
good at
Google because
the number
of years it
takes to be
really good at
Google is a
lot and the
attention to
detail is
massive and
the number
of
individual
settings that
if done
incorrectly
will completely
invalidate
everything else
that you
did is
incredibly
high.
You can do
all of the
things that
I've said
so far
through here
completely
correctly,
but if you
have your
conversion set
up incorrectly,
which is very
common,
let's say you
have two
different primary
conversions,
it's going to
be completely
non-incremental.
It's going to
generate zero
revenue and it's
going to look
great, but
it's so easy
to have
page view
plus purchase
as primary
conversions and
they're the
account defaults
and so they're
there in that
campaign and
you're telling
Google, I
value page
views and I
value purchases
and so obviously
one is much
easier to get
than the other
and so Google
is going to
just be like
generating traffic
that's firing
page views and
it's going to be
racking up like
efficiency in there,
but you're not
going to be seeing
it on your
bottom line and
it's because that
one single
setting was done
incorrectly and
now it's all
worthless, right?
And there's
dozens of
those throughout
the account and
you need someone
who can be
completely on top
of that, knows
where they are
and isn't going
to make a mistake,
right?
And there's just
it's hard work
and there's not
a lot of people
who have that
depth of
knowledge to
do it in a
platform and
then you add on
YouTube, which is
a totally different
platform within the
platform and it's
like, okay.
It's definitely a
lot.
Well, you've given
us a lot to think
about, Colin.
Lots of absolute
sauce for folks.
I appreciate your
time.
Thank you for
coming on and
appreciate you
being here.
Yeah, this was a
lot of fun and
happy to come on
and jam anytime.
Thank you everybody
for listening.
This episode is
brought to you by
Brad's company,
Work Marketing.
If you need a
D2C marketing
agency, let me
tell you,
Homestead is
great, but
Work Marketing
is also fantastic.
And let me tell
you, you
aren't going to
find friendlier
people out there
in the e-commerce
space.
So we decided to
do these little
ads for each
other's companies.
So hopefully you
find it interesting.
But seriously,
great team at
Work Marketing,
very smart.
Brad and Jordan
are incredibly
dialed in.
I just gave them
a lead, already
made this brand
that I gave them
like, I don't
even know,
double the revenue
that they had the
previous month or
something.
So, you know,
it's very exciting
to be connected
with Brad.
And if you need
a great agency,
there's really no
one better.
Zach, anything to
comment on Work
Marketing?
Yeah, I mean,
if you want an
agency that cares
about your business
much more than
they care about
their own website,
I just tried to
load WorkMarketing.com
and it was broken.
So they're definitely
going to give more
of a shit about
your business
than their own.
So I highly
recommend Brad
and the team
over at Work.
They've been
incredible.
We've referred a lot
of business over
to them as well.
Really, really good
as far as like
cracking funnels
and figuring out
like rapid growth
for brands.
So I highly
recommend these guys.
The only way that we
grow this podcast is
by you sharing it
with your friends.
Honestly, like
reviews kind of
don't really mean
anything too much
anymore.
They're really
meaningful, but they
don't do a lot for
the growth of the
podcast.
And so sharing
YouTube links,
sharing Spotify
links, sharing
Apple, whatever we
call it under the
podcast app now,
anything you can
share, the better
we're going to be.
Guys, anything else
you want to say on
this?
Yeah, please go check
us out on YouTube.
Rack up those views
for us.
We'd love to see it.
And then subscribe.
Make sure to subscribe
on YouTube as well.
And I relentlessly
refresh the YouTube
comments because it
dictates my mental
health for the day.
So please say
something nice about
all of us.
Thank you, everyone.
Thanks for listening.
Honestly.