Scalability School

Collin Slattery (Taikun Digital) joins Brad and Andrew for a no-fluff breakdown of why Google Ads breaks the brain of most DTC operators who cut their teeth on Meta. The core argument lands early and lands hard: your relationship with Google is structurally adversarial in a way your relationship with Meta isn't, because Google can't manufacture more search inventory the way Meta manufactures more feed inventory. The only lever they have to grow revenue is extracting more from advertisers, which means every default setting, every recommendation, and every "AI enhancement" is built to serve them first.

From that foundation, Collin walks through the operational stack that actually works: ruthlessly segmenting brand from non-brand across both search and shopping, building a real product feed instead of plugging Shopify into Merchant Center and calling it done, structuring shopping into heroes, sidekicks, villains, and zombies, and treating YouTube Shorts as the only YouTube placement worth touching unless you're running holdout tests. Along the way he drops a study Tyken ran across roughly $20M in spend showing that hidden search terms cost advertisers about $0.85 of efficiency per dollar spent, the case for YouTube being the single most incremental channel in digital (87% net-new traffic for one of his nine-figure clients, plus 34 million Americans reachable nowhere else), and a hard truth that Google scaling is brick-by-brick, never one banger creative away.

If you've ever wondered why your Google account "kind of works but never really scales," this is the episode that explains exactly why and exactly what to do about it. Key Takeaways

  • How your "5x Google ROAS" is actually just brand search dragging a broken non-brand campaign across the finish line.
  • How much of your Google spend is being skimmed by search terms Google won't let you see.
  • Why your relationship with Google is fundamentally adversarial.
  • How to reach 34 million potential customers that literally cannot be reached on Meta or TikTok.
  • If you're not running holdout tests, 90% of your YouTube dollars are likely going to the wrong placement.
  • The four shopping campaign buckets every brand over $1M should be using, and the one that is silently eating 80% of your budget.
  • Could this one setting be making your entire Google account non-incremental without you knowing?
  • Why Google scaling looks nothing like Meta scaling and what it actually means for your monthly growth curve.
  • The $50/month tool that fixes the feed quality issue almost every Shopify brand is silently losing money on.
  • When paying for brand search actually makes sense
This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It's a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they're offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you! To connect with Collin, send him a DM at https://x.com/CJSlattery or at: https://taikundigital.com/ To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck Learn More about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com/ Learn More about the The Hive Haus Creators Community at http://HiveHausUGC.com

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

The relationship that you have with

Google is inherently adversarial,

where it is not necessarily

adversarial with Meta.

And the reason it's adversarial with

Google is because Google is a

monopoly, and they don't really have

a direct impact on

search query volume, right?

Like the amount of people who are

going to search for tennis shoes in

any given month is

relatively set, right?

Like they can't really impact that.

And so brand is like this

stereotypical example, and we see it

with brands of all sizes, even from,

you know, seven-figure brands to

ten-figure brands.

You go into their Google Ads

account, and it's very rare that

brand and non-brand is

truly fully segmented apart.

And it has to be.

YouTube today is kind of like Meta

in 2015, where, you know, you do the

1% lookalike audience, right?

Like we on this call all old enough

to remember the old lookalike

audience stacks

and things like that.

So you do have to do

audience targeting there.

But that's kind of like the lowest

form of YouTube advertising.

And now let's take a listen to the

Scalability School podcast.

All right.

Welcome to another episode of

Scalability School.

Incredible guest today.

Longtime friend of the podcast.

Longtime friend of mine and somebody

who I deeply respect and love.

Colin Slattery, the Google Ads

expert of D2C

Twitter, I would say, right?

I mean, can we name you that?

What do we think about that?

I'll take it.

It's a moniker I'll

happily wear for sure.

The person that people are willing

to fight with about

Google Ads on the Internet.

Whether they are

employed by Google or not.

Yeah, exactly.

Who actually is smart and can

respond back to them.

Colin, so glad to have you.

Colin's been an expert in the

Founders community on Google Ads for

a really long time.

And then a couple of years ago,

hired the best in

the game, Phil Kiel.

Previous Scalability School guest.

Now has an absolute empire that is

being built at Tyken Digital.

So we're stoked for you about that.

Good job.

Thanks.

And thanks for having me on.

Excited to check Google.

Excited to hopefully dispel some

myths and share a little bit of

knowledge in the process.

Google is kind of like the ugly

stepchild of DTC Twitter.

People don't want to talk about it.

It seems like you're one of the few

people that want to talk about it.

And I feel like it needs to be

talked about more because I

personally have a ton of questions.

Because I'm curious

how you think through it.

I know you have strong

opinions, which is good.

Because I don't think enough people

have strong enough

opinions that are also thoughtful.

And you have both.

You have both.

So I'm excited to dig in.

I feel like there's a whole other

episode at some point.

We just talk about everything that

you're building agency-wise.

Maybe we've got to get Phil and the

gang back together and

just talk about that.

Get Jake on here too.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Might as well.

Yeah.

Jake the ad nerd.

The OG.

He's in the game now too.

Yeah.

We'll have to get the whole crew on.

But yeah.

Excited to jam Google today.

Yeah.

I think it's going

to be a lot of fun.

And excited to dive in.

Maybe some hot takes.

Or lukewarm takes anyway.

Well, we can kick it off with the

nice original great starting point.

I thought it would

be interesting too.

I know Zach, I was looking back on

this tweet from like almost a year.

It's almost a year ago now.

It was actually June of last year.

It feels like it was just yesterday

that Zach was shitting on

all Google ads agencies.

But I thought this was

a good starting point.

And so Zach's tweet, I'll

probably summarize this.

But Zach kind of started by saying,

if you're a DTC brand, being your

Google ads agency more

than 10K a month, you are very

likely getting robbed.

Zach is known to

take strong positions.

Usually with good reason.

Usually with good reason.

But sometimes he has strong takes.

And so we don't have to spend a

bunch of time dispelling this.

But just curious if you have a kind

of quick take on your

feeling of, I guess, maybe the

average Google ad agency and what

you guys do differently

that helps set you apart.

Well, obviously, I

think that's bullshit.

And I said as much around that time

and the engagement was fun.

And I know Zach loves to throw bombs

out there and then

turn around and walk away.

But yeah, no, I mean,

that's clearly not true.

Right.

And I actually would say that Google

in particular is one of the places

where investment in top

quality talent is even more

paramount because of the difficulty

and the number of dark patterns

that exist in the platform.

This gets to a foundational concept

around the differences

between Google and Meta.

And one of those is that the

relationship that you have with

Google is inherently adversarial,

where it is not necessarily

adversarial with Meta.

And the reason it's adversarial with

Google is because

Google is a monopoly.

And they don't really have a direct

impact on search query volume.

Right.

Like the amount of people who are

going to search for tennis shoes in

any given month is

relatively set.

Right.

Like they can't really impact that.

And they already

have the full market.

They can't get any

more market share.

And so the only thing that they can

do and speaking primarily around

search and shopping and

things like that is increase the

amount of money that they get paid

for the queries that

already exist.

That's the only lever that they have

to pull to increase

how much money they make.

They're a publicly traded company.

They're in the

business of making money.

Right.

And when they are increasing the

costs, that is born

by the advertiser.

Meta, on the other hand, has the

ability to impact their inventory in

a way that Google

does not.

Right.

They can increase the frequency of

ads in reels or your feed.

They can make the

product more addictive.

So people scroll deeper so they can

be exposed to more ads.

Right.

And so fundamentally, Google is not

playing nicely with advertisers

because it is in their

best interest to.

Take money from advertisers.

And so if you have someone who

doesn't know what they're doing and

doesn't know Google's

dark patterns, it is very easy for

Google to be an absolute waste of

money because that's

good for them.

Right.

Because they need to make money.

So if you don't have someone who's

excellent, and admittedly, there are

not that many excellent

people out there, it's going to be a

non-incremental waste fest.

And I think that's what most people

run into because they're working

with people who don't

know how to do it or

they're working with people who are

meta first and the rules between

meta and Google are completely

different.

And then they're

like, oh, Google's trash.

Everyone who does Google is trash.

And screw this.

I'm known for taking notes.

And the first thing I wrote down is

Zach equals skill issue.

So that's what I heard

from section number one here.

It is, in fact, a skill issue.

A hundred percent.

Good.

Good.

Well, I'm sure Zach will hear this

and we'll remind him.

But that segues nicely into like,

OK, so then what can brands that are

listening to this do and

take away to actually start to make

Google a channel that

is effective for them?

Because I think a

lot of people will.

I mean, our average, the average

client that we work with has Google

and there's brand set up in

some capacity.

Whether or not it's incremental,

there's a bunch of

questions around that.

And yeah, right.

And you mentioned you mentioned

there's there's probably different

things to consider, certainly

across industries and how you should

consider across industries, but even

account spend and

size.

And so I think if you could just

start to kind of take people through

like what what is the

actual account setup

and structure look like?

How does it change as you scale?

I think that could be a really

interesting starting point to just

kick off, you know, where people

can start to get

some tactical takeaways.

Yeah, and I think this is this gets

back to the size and

complexity of Google, which is

material.

It's a materially more complex

platform than meta is.

There's a lot more stuff going on

and there's a lot of

stuff going on that.

Is beneficial to Google, but

detrimental to the advertiser.

And I think if people are.

Looking to succeed on Google, I

think that is a mindset shift that

needs to happen where

when you are in there, the.

Everything you look at, you need to

think this is set up in order to

benefit Google and

not benefit me.

So you should be very skeptical of

anything that Google recommends.

Right.

And we're kind of that way with meta

when they're like auto apply all of

these AI enhancements

and shit like that.

But those are much more visible in

meta than they are in Google.

And so you absolutely have to be

approaching it with that mindset and

trying to make it

harder for Google to succeed.

And so brand is like this

stereotypical example.

And we see it with brands.

Of all sizes, even from, you know,

seven figure brands to 10 figure

brands, you go into their

Google ads account and it's very

rare that brand and non brand is

truly fully segmented

apart.

And it has to be because if you say

I want a five X right.

And you put brand in there, right,

that's going to generate a 20 X.

And then Google is

like, cool, we got a 20.

We banked the 20 X here.

That means we can waste money on

stuff that doesn't perform.

It'll average out to a five.

And the advertiser is

happy because it says a five.

But they haven't dug that layer

below and seen all those conversions

are happening to brand.

80% of the budget is 10% of the

conversion value and 10% of the

budget is 90% of the

conversion value.

And blended, it looks great.

They run a holdout test on it.

Like, hey, this is

not incremental at all.

Like we chopped our Google and

nothing happened.

It's like, well, yeah, of course.

It's because your brand and non

brand are blended together.

And so if there is one thing that

people take away, get them split

apart completely, right?

And split in search.

So negative it out in

all your non brands.

If you want to run it, put in its

own manual CPC search campaign.

But you have to do it

on shopping too, right?

Like shopping inventory serves

against brand queries.

And so if you're not segmenting out

branded queries and shopping,

if you don't have a

branded shopping campaign,

all that's going to roll into your

Pmax is going to roll into your

regular shopping.

And it's going to be the same

problem that you would have with

search as Justin Shopping.

That is, I think, the biggest

problem and also the

easiest problem to fix.

Is that a one-time thing?

Or do you have to

check it regularly?

Because Google is trying to jam

brand back into things

or brand adjacent things.

So if you do a good job with your

negative keyword list,

you're going to get 99% of it out.

It's not going to

cover all misspellings.

And so it does make sense so much in

a while go through and negative out

the misspellings.

When you launch new campaigns,

you do need to apply the negative

keyword list to the campaign.

But it's mostly a one-time, 30

minutes max sort of activity.

So there's a lot of brands.

Brad was saying there's a lot of

small brands or smaller brands that

listen to this podcast.

And I think, you know, have always

wanted to test Google.

And I think people

get excited about brand.

They get excited about launching

Google and they get excited about

launching YouTube ads as well.

So when you're looking at those

brands that you've

worked with in the last,

let's just say 12 months, because I

know it changes over time.

What are they doing?

What's the mix of brand, non-brand?

Are they doing shopping?

Are they doing YouTube?

What does that mix look like?

And what are the things that you've

seen be truly incremental to their

results and their growth?

I'm going to say something, and

maybe this is my first hot take,

even though it's not a hot take

because it's driven by data.

Google and YouTube done well are the

most incremental advertising that

any brand will ever have,

period, full stop, done.

We've done this with nine-figure

brands where 87% of the traffic

coming from YouTube is

net new to the brands,

whereas Meta is

sitting around like 60, 62%.

Google and YouTube are so

incremental and expose so many

people to traffic

that is nowhere else.

There are 34 million Americans that

are not on Meta properties,

are not on TikTok,

are not in any other

digital properties,

but YouTube.

Literally, the only place you can

reach these 34 million

people are on YouTube.

Totally net new,

do not exist anywhere else.

They're only on YouTube.

And you can reach them there, right?

And so,

and that's just the people that

aren't anywhere else, right?

It's not even counting the people

that you don't reach

because they're not in a

conversion-focused audience

in Meta or anything like that.

So,

massively, massively, massively,

massively incremental.

It's just set up

poorly most of the time.

Now,

to kind of like loop

back and it's like,

okay, well, how do you

make Google incremental?

Well,

one is,

it's get brand and non-brand

separated, right?

And then what you're doing is

different based on the scale

of the brand and where

your budget allocation is.

The first thing I'd say is like,

don't run brand at all.

Like negative it out and

then don't have it running,

period.

And I think Zach will probably agree

with me on that, right?

It's generally a waste of money.

And it's one of the very first

holdout tests that we run

with any client that comes on,

whether it's Meta in

Google or just Google only,

is like,

let's test brand,

like see if it's incremental

because it's usually not.

And it's something

you can just turn off,

which is great, right?

If you can allocate

that budget to things,

put it as a YouTube shorts instead.

Like what a better way to do it.

So if you can get away

with not running brand,

don't run brand.

And then the structure is like,

it's going to be pretty consistent,

but the budget

allocations will be different.

So non-brand shopping or like a

non-brand shopping Pmax,

right?

Non-brand search.

And then if you are running brand,

brand search,

brand shopping,

and then some degree

of demand gen shorts

as kind of like the

third component of that.

So,

you know,

we're looking at

three to five campaigns

as kind of like the

default structure.

When do you,

so then,

okay,

so that's for everybody.

So what is scaling it out look like?

Is it horizontally

adding more campaign

by product,

product category?

Is it just scaling it

up by cranking budgets

and sending it to the moon?

Obviously,

YouTube is probably

handled fairly differently

because there's a

creative component to it,

whether that's shorts

or just,

you know,

general YouTube placements.

So you can pick either side,

maybe Google is the place to start

and then work over to YouTube.

But like,

what is actually,

what does it look

like to start scaling up

the Google side?

Yeah.

So I think

the easiest scale to

unlock is shopping,

right?

It's the shopping inventory.

And it's easy,

but it's not simple

because what

dictates how shopping works

is really the structured data

that you're giving Google,

right?

So it's the quality

of your product feed.

It's the descriptions.

It's the images.

It's the secondary images.

The color data,

the size data.

It's how optimized your titles are,

right?

It's making sure that

there aren't price mismatches

or any other issues

that are impacting

the quality of the data

that is being fed to Google

because that's how Google decides,

oh,

this is,

this is,

you know,

a blue sneaker,

right?

It's,

well,

you have to give them all that data.

And so if someone

searches for blue sneaker,

right,

you want to show up for that.

And so the only way

you're going to show up

is if you have good,

clean data.

And reviews are another huge

component of that.

People are going to go,

they're going to

search for blue sneakers.

What's going to get surfaced

and what's going to get clicked on.

Stuff that has good data

so that Google knows

that's what you're selling.

And then things that

have a lot of reviews

because that's a trust signal

and people are going to click on it.

And so feeding Google good data

is going to impact

how much shopping volume

you're going to be able to acquire.

And then there are other parts

that obviously brands can't control.

So like if you,

the larger your SKU library,

the greater the

surface area you can cover.

And so generally

the higher the scale

that you can conceivably get.

Similarly to that,

the better your

business economics are,

right?

If you think about

search impression share,

like a pie

or a hundred percent of search

impression share,

like no business is going to be able

to economically monetize

a hundred percent of search

impression share.

But if your

economics are not so good,

right?

If your revenue per session

is generally pretty low

or your margins are pretty low,

like the percentage of

the search impressions

where you can profitably target it,

it's going to shrink.

And so

your business

metrics also like dictate

kind of the scale

that you can achieve

on shopping as well.

But

there's a ton of scale

in shopping.

Friends,

quick break.

This episode of Scalability School

is brought to you by

Northbeam Incrementality,

which honestly is so awesome.

Let me just tell you

a little bit about it.

If you're a marketer,

you probably agree

incrementality testing is broken.

It's insane.

You got to do all this crazy stuff.

But with Northbeam,

you do it right in the platform.

It builds tests

using your own MTA data,

launches them directly

in the ad platform

and automatically monitors them

throughout the test.

And if something threatens validity,

you're alerted to it

within Northbeam

before it ruins the results.

The really nice thing

is it solves all these problems

you hear about

incrementality testing

all the time,

like labor,

spreadsheets,

statistical reference,

designing tests

is normally so slow,

right,

and error prone.

So with Northbeam Incrementality,

it's automated and accurate

and your team

is able to spend

with confidence.

Give it a shot

with Northbeam Incrementality.

Really,

the future of incrementality

is here

and Northbeam

has figured out a way

to make it easy.

So, I mean,

it's interesting,

you know,

I've never heard somebody

give the case

for shopping that heavily,

so that's interesting.

I think you've had this thing

about called

hidden search terms

and you have a framework

of Google inventory,

which is premium,

mid-tier,

and garbage.

And that's what,

this is,

you know,

taken from your word.

So talk about

hidden search terms

and the research

around this

and what things

folks can do

to bring some

of these search terms

out that maybe

they weren't,

you know,

aware,

ever familiar with

in terms of targeting.

And this is,

again,

this gets to the whole,

there's additional layers

underneath Google

that when you just

look at it,

it's painting

a very small picture

of what's actually

going on.

so keywords

and search terms

are not even

remotely the same thing,

right?

It's like,

oh,

well,

you know,

I'm targeting blue shoes.

Like,

that's the keyword

that I'm targeting.

That's what I'm bidding.

It's just like,

no,

that can match

to hundreds

of different search queries

that are somewhat related

to completely unrelated

depending on your match type,

right?

And so those are

the search terms

that surface.

And so those are the things,

search terms are what people

are actually typing

into Google to find

and then your ad

is surfing against,

right?

And Google,

up until,

I think it was probably

2020,

like 2021,

I can't remember

the exact year.

At this point,

it was a while ago.

They used to show

95%

of all of the terms

that people typed in

to,

that surfaced your ad.

So you'd have

95% visibility,

90 to 95% visibility

in everything

that people searched for

that your ad surfed against.

And for privacy reasons,

they decided

to hide

a huge percentage

of the search terms

that people searched for

that your ad surfed against.

And they lumped them together

in what is known

as other search terms,

which you can't see

what they searched for.

You can only see

a single line

of the aggregated performance

of what is hidden.

And that's a problem,

right?

Like you're paying for it.

You should know

what people are searching.

And the performance

of the stuff

that is hidden

is generally

worse than

what is visible.

And that's because

in my estimation,

right,

it behooves Google

to hide the stuff

that people would

try to exclude

if it's not related.

Right?

If my keyword is,

you know,

blue shoes

and,

you know,

the matching is

blue tablecloth,

like,

that's

not related.

Right?

But you can get

matches that are

that far away.

It's actually

pretty shocking

how not close

search terms

can be to the keyword

that triggered them.

And now that they

can hide those,

it's easier for you

to keep bidding on them

as opposed to

historically,

you know,

turn them into

negatives and remove them.

Yeah.

You put together

like a pretty

gnarly report,

like actually

digging into this.

Do you have any

of the numbers

like handy

out of the top

of your head

that you can

just like rip off?

Or is that

a little bit

too specific?

I mean,

do you want,

I have the report

somewhere probably.

Pull it up.

Yeah.

If it's not,

if it's not a huge

pain to pull up,

I'd be super curious

to dig into that

because I remember

reading it

I'm pretty sure

that,

is that what

Ginny responded to?

And I do want to note

this is only for

search campaigns

and shopping campaigns

where you have

full search

career report

data available.

But we looked at

around $20 million

in ad spent

in search

and shopping spent

and found that

for every

dollar of ad

spent

that you are

running through Google,

they're skimming

almost a full dollar.

off of your efficiency

with hidden search terms.

So,

if you were to spend

a million dollars

on ads

and everything

was visible,

you would generate

about $5.6 million

in revenue.

In reality,

you're only generating

about $4.75

million in revenue.

And that $850,000

shortfall

is due to the

inefficiency

of

hidden search terms.

Yeah.

So you're looking at

like

a 5.6x

for visible

versus

a

4.75

for

full blend

including

hidden.

Like worst case scenario,

historically,

before this change,

you could just

exclude them

and,

okay,

I've excluded them,

I'm not wasting money

on them.

And now,

it's just being

lumped in there.

And so,

what you're saying

is best case scenario,

you can actually

exclude them

and then the additional

spend,

you'd be able to continue.

You're spending that money

anyway,

so it's going to be

spent at that more

efficient return number.

Am I understanding

that correctly?

Well,

I mean,

you can't get rid

of the stuff that's hidden,

right?

For sure.

Stuff is always

going to be hidden

and it is a game

of whack-a-mole

to consistently

exclude things

to try and pull

up efficiency numbers.

You can aggregate

data through

what's known

as Ngram analysis

to pull stuff

out of hidden,

like,

and exclude stuff

that would otherwise

be lumped into

hidden search terms.

Generally,

hidden search terms

are stuff

that Google

categorizes

as, like,

low volume,

right?

So it's not getting

a lot of volume

against those queries

and so those

are generally

going to be

longer tail

search queries

and by longer tail,

I mean,

more words

in the query.

And so

you can aggregate

what is visible

and find terms

that are

low performing

and when you

exclude those,

it will also

generally pull out

stuff that was

hidden

that also included

that term

that is

not effective.

Not usually

going to get

like a lower

percentage

of hidden

but you can

reduce the

inefficiency

overall

by going

through and

pulling stuff

out.

Cool.

Personally,

I'm very

interested in

like the

actual

tactical levers

of,

okay,

we can dig

into shopping.

Andrew,

if you're cool

with going

down that route,

I'm just going

to start ripping

some questions.

Absolutely.

Feel free to

take it wherever

direction you want

to.

So you mentioned

you've kind of

got like four

to five campaigns

that are standard.

I think we'll

ignore the brand

side of this

completely for now

because I think

your basic

TLDR is like

turn it off

or highly

limit the spend

that's going

into it at all

if you're going

to spend into it

and just be

thoughtful around

that.

If you're in a

vertical where you

need to spend

on brand,

you'll know

because it's

the exception.

Fair.

Cool.

Maybe worth

coming back to

that because

that's interesting.

But then shopping

is where you're

seeing the majority

of the volume.

You said every

brand could spend

six figures.

It's kind of

like a take.

So as people

are thinking about

setting up shopping,

you said the

biggest lever

is kind of

just like the

inputs to Google

which is

functionally the

feed and maybe

some offshoots

of that.

So what are

brands doing wrong

when they set up

their shopping?

You mentioned

the title and

the actual data

is not set up

properly.

So let's say

that they are

starting to chip

away at updating

that and maybe

their 80%

of what you

call like this

is a good

input.

The feed is

solid.

What's like

what's still

missing?

And then if

they wanted to

increase spend

volume through

shopping,

like what are

they actually

doing?

It is actually

I should say

is one of the

biggest challenges

with Google

is because

everything is

different depending

on small

changes in a

brand, right?

Like if you

have 10,000

SKUs, like

your approach

is going to be

completely different

than if you

have 50 or

100 SKUs

or 10 SKUs,

right?

And so the

feed is table

stakes, right?

And having that

fully optimized

and I will say

like most people

just connect their

Shopify feed to

Google Merchant

Center and

they're like,

I'm done,

right?

Like, no.

And if that is

you, like, go get

data feed watch.

It's not that

expensive.

It's going to

allow you to

really optimize your

Google fields,

which is super

important.

And we're

going to

assume you

have reviews

piping in

because that's

also very

important.

Shopping from

a structural

level and I

think Google

in general,

and this is

something that

we've seen

time and time

again on

search, on

shopping,

absolutely on

YouTube.

Google is not

nearly as

efficient a

budget allocator

as Meta.

And so, so

many people come

from the Meta

space where it's

like, trust

Meta, they

know what they're

doing, go

broad, like drop

it all

together, right?

You cannot do

that with Google.

You're going to

have a bad

time if you're

doing that with

Google.

And that

extends to

shopping as

well.

And then you

need segmentation

and you need

thoughtful segmentation

in order to

unlock volume.

What this

segmentation

looks like is

really dependent

on number of

SKUs and

business

priorities.

If you're

a retailer

and you

carry a

hundred brands,

your shopping

structure is

going to look

materially different

than if you're

a supplement

company and

you've got

20 SKUs.

Just try the

example,

though, Colin,

of let's say

there's this

lower amount

of SKUs,

20 SKUs.

How are they

structured?

Are they

structured based

on which

one's driving

the best

revenue for

you with the

best gross

margin?

How do you

start to

structure that?

I think the

initial structuring

that you're

going to want

to do,

and again,

this is a

phase one,

is you have

one campaign

and you have

ad groups

in the

shopping campaign

that are

segmented either

by a

category or

if you have

really very

few products,

you can even

segment them

individually.

So you're a

supplement company,

you have

supplements for

digestion and

supplements for

sleep, right?

You can break

them up into

those individual

categories and

then make sure

that you have

negative keywords

at the ad

group level to

make sure that

you're routing

queries to the

correct ad

groups.

So that's kind

of like a

we're just

getting started

structure.

And then

once you have

that running,

you're going to

start to see,

okay, this

product is

potentially working

really well and

performing really

well.

Maybe that's

something where

you actually

can, and

we've done

this, like

we'll have a

shopping campaign

with just a

single product in

it so that

it's not

competing for

budget with

the other

products in

that campaign.

It's not super

common where

we'll fully pull

out an

individual product,

but it'll

happen.

Over time,

breaking the

campaigns apart

based on by

performance and

like bucket

them together

really into

like four

main structures

which are like

high spend,

high performing,

high performing,

low spend,

just low

performing,

and then like

no spend,

right?

And so,

you know,

you don't want

like your top

10% of SKUs

to be competing

for budget

with the 80%

of SKUs

that get 2%

of the total

clicks,

right?

It's historically

called, you

know, heroes,

sidekicks,

villains, and

zombies, right?

It's kind of

the four

monikers for

the different

structures.

And you

break them

all apart.

And SKUs

can shift in

between the

different campaigns,

but the

reasoning behind

that is

Google's budget

allocation is

not incredibly

efficient.

And if

you're lumping

them together,

you're just

leaving money

on the table.

But the

first segmentation

starts in

an individual

campaign at

kind of the

accurate level

by grouping

products separately.

And grouping,

does grouping

the products

on its own

give to your

point?

Because it

helps Google

sort out

delivery a bit

better because

you're inserting

kind of an

opinion into

how that should

be structured.

Does that

alone add

more volume?

Or is it,

hey, we need

to split these

things up and

then we go

edit product

titles to have

more, you know,

like, are we

trying to increase

the search volume

by getting more

keywords?

Like, I'm like,

very tactical as

somebody who's not

running Google

accounts.

Like, so you're

segmenting those

things, but like,

what else is the

team doing on a

weekly basis to

try and drive

more volume?

Yeah, so I

mean, you're also

removing inefficient

search terms,

right?

that's just an

ongoing negative

keyword application

is an ongoing

piece of work

in Google,

on shopping,

on search,

everywhere.

Product optimization,

title testing,

that is also a

key component of

it because,

again, like,

you operate

under the

understanding that

there is a

finite amount

of search volume

for whatever it

is that you're

doing, right?

And when you

find things that

work, you want

to be getting a

high, as high a

click share as you

possibly can.

So optimizing to

try and maximize

your click share,

generally, like,

it's through titles,

it's through more

reviews, price,

obviously, also a

component to it,

using promotional

things, promos to

get the sort of

slash through and,

like, sale tags and

things like that.

And then adjusting

targeting, right?

And that's one of

the added benefits

there, too, is,

like, if you have

things broken up,

you can have a

specific target for,

you know, mascara,

whereas blush has a

completely different

target and you can

control those

efficiency targets

individually.

Yeah.

What role do

images play in

shopping?

Like, are you guys

testing images

consistently or is it

not a big lever?

Generally, like,

pretty strict

limitations around

images in

Google.

rules around, like,

not having texts

on the images,

like, not putting

promotional information

on images in the

feed.

So most things do

default to

white box.

You can include

lifestyle images

as well.

There are fields for

lifestyle images that

always worth doing.

Basically, and this is

another general rule,

if there's an

optional field that

you can use, it's

not optional.

Just use it, right?

Like, the more

optional things you

include, the better

your feed score is

going to be in

Google's estimation

and the more

opportunity you have

to surface.

So there's not a

ton that you can do

from an image

standpoint in terms

of testing.

You can do a

little bit, but

it's tough.

We've had clients

where their product

is in a box and the

box has text on it

and they'll reject

the image because

of the amount of

text that's on the

box.

I hate to host this

phrase, but it's kind

of phrased this way

intentionally, but like,

is there anything

hacky in shopping that

you can do that

consistently works?

Like, you know,

there's this theme on

Meta for a while

where everybody did

the we're sorry kind

of ad in that

positioning.

Like, there's a

format that pops up

that you can just

run that playbook

across brands and it

works very consistently.

Is there any

comparable on the

Google side, whether

it's like hacky

feeling?

Maybe it's specific to

shopping, maybe not.

Not really.

And I would say

that in general,

like, it's not

how we like to

approach advertising.

Whatever arbitrage

exists, I mean,

you're opening

yourself up to

potential issues

down the road.

You know, like,

there was a time

where you could

like, get promo

text onto images

by, you know,

making it less

obvious and

tricking the

sort of machine

to think it

wasn't there,

even though it

clearly was.

And you're just

going to get your

feet suspended

and you're going

to have to redo

all the work.

So, you know,

I generally

operate on the

do things the

right way

principle and

you're going to

be in good

shape.

Brad's always

trying to hack

an idea, you

know.

Look, I'm just,

you know, you

never know what

exists to me.

I'm the anti-hack

guy.

I'm the let's

do it by the

book and, you

know, always be

on the right

side.

I also lean that

direction, but,

you know, sometimes

people like, you

know, a little

sauce every once

in a while.

Do not invite the

eye of Sauron,

you know.

That's fair.

So let's just

talk about YouTube

briefly in going

through that, right?

I think this is a

place where people

are doing a ton

with taking stuff

from meta, putting

it on shorts.

What do you see

that works, that

drives incremental

results for folks

and how do you

think they should

approach YouTube?

How much time

do we have?

YouTube is the

most complex

place to

advertise and

the hardest place

to advertise in

digital.

And YouTube

is like six

or seven

different things,

right?

So like when we

talk about YouTube,

I mean, we're

talking about so

many different

things.

And so, you

know, I'll start

with kind of the

the low, lowest

of low-hanging

fruit, which is

that YouTube

shorts thing.

It's the demand

gen conversion

focused YouTube

shorts component

where you can

take your

high-performing

9x16 video

assets from

meta, put them

in a demand

gen campaign,

and run it

purely on

YouTube shorts

placement.

You know, get

kind of click

based, pretty

good click

based attribution

out of it.

you do have

to do

audience

targeting.

That's one

of the things

to remember.

You know, I

always say like

YouTube today

is kind of

like meta

in 2015

where, you

know, you

do the 1%

lookalike

audience, right?

Like we

were on

this call

all old

enough to

remember the

old lookalike

audience stacks

and things

like that.

So you do

have to do

audience

targeting there.

But that's

kind of like

the lowest

form of

YouTube

advertising.

Do you have

any issues

with the

measurement on

shorts?

Like, is it

cool?

Like, do you

trust what

YouTube is

reporting on

shorts enough?

Or, like, I'm

thinking of the

brand that's

not paying

house.

I'm sure

house is

fantastic.

I know they're

fantastic.

But like,

just a quick

sidebar on

measurement of

shorts.

It sounds like

it's low-hanging

fruit, but

what about the

measurement side?

So, shorts

measurement is

okay, but

not amazing.

And Google

is, it's

always going to

be under

counting the

efficacy of

shorts.

And I will

say this very

declaratively.

If you don't

have the

ability to

do holdout

testing, do

not spend a

dollar on

YouTube outside

of shorts.

Shorts is the

only place you

can spend

money.

Do not

do in

feed, do

not do

in

stream, do

not do

CTV, do

not do

any of

it.

Like, if

you are

not doing

holdout

testing,

don't spend

money on

sort of

traditional

YouTube.

Just only

spend money

on shorts

because that's

the place

where you're

going to

get some

click-based

attribution

and the

rest of the

YouTube

inventory.

And this

is why

YouTube

inventory is

so mispriced,

right?

It's like,

it is hard

to measure.

You do

really need

to be doing

those holdout

tests.

So, stay

in shorts

and don't

venture out

of the

shallow

waters into

the deep

end of

YouTube.

I mean, I

think it's a

matter, I

think that's

good about the

measurement and

making sure that

you have a plan

for measurement

and makes a ton

of sense.

To me, it's one

of these things

that you hear

people talking

about.

They don't

really know how

to set it up,

right?

I think a lot

of people spend

a lot of time

optimizing their

meta ads

accounts.

And I

think YouTube

is a place

that takes a

lot of energy

and attention

and people

just want to

repurpose stuff,

which you can

do to a degree,

but I guess I'm

just curious of

any other tips

and tricks

and tactics

that you

believe are

really valuable.

The other big

thing is audience,

right?

Audience still

matters on

YouTube.

And Google's

targeting on

YouTube is the

best and most

granular targeting

that exists today

in digital.

Like, you really

can target your

ICP.

And Google's

bidding algorithm

is not at the

level where you

can just go

broad and it

will find your

ICP, right?

So, you know,

if you sell

beauty products,

like, an in-market

audience for

beauty products is

a good audience

to test on

YouTube, right?

Like, go

narrow.

Go top 10%

household income

women between

the ages of

35 and 54

who have

X, Y, and Z

interests, right?

Like, the kind

of stuff that we

used to do on

Meta, like,

still totally

applicable on

Google.

You should

definitely be

doing that sort

of targeting

with YouTube,

even on

shorts, right?

And, like,

shorts is

huge.

Like, it's

bigger than

reels.

It's bigger

than TikTok.

Two billion

people use

shorts a month.

Like, shorts

is colossal.

So the

inventory is

there for

essentially any

advertiser to

spend thousands

of dollars a

day on just

shorts as a

placement.

But, again,

you gotta

take what's

old is new

again.

You gotta

take the

old rules of

what you did

on Meta,

you know,

back in the

day and get

granular with

your audiences.

And take

your winners,

right?

Like, you

know, I

think short

form video

that performs

well is

short form

video that

performs well.

You know,

obviously, like,

TikTok's kind of

like the gold

standard.

Like, if it

performs on

TikTok, it'll

perform everywhere

else.

Like, it

performs on

Meta, it

might not

necessarily perform

on TikTok.

But take

your winners,

drop them

into a demand

gen shorts

campaign, have

some granular

audience targeting

with different ad

groups and doing

granular audience

targeting.

And, like,

that's a super,

super easy

place to start.

It will have,

like, pretty good

click attribution

to it.

And, you know,

you're not going

to spend $20,000

a day on it,

but $2,000, $3,000,

$4,000, $5,000 a

day, I mean,

it's not nothing.

I'm very curious

about the role of

landing pages

across Google.

I know from a

shopping side,

it would have to

be handled

differently because

it needs to go

to functionally

a PDP.

So, I guess you

could split it

into two parts.

Like, what are

the role of

landing pages from

a search perspective?

I'm assuming you

have a lot more

flexibility in what

you can and can't

do from a search

side.

But, to your

point earlier,

maybe there's a

little bit less

volume overall in

search.

But then I'm just

curious, like,

have you seen,

like, CRO-specific

tests to PDPs that

have been impactful

for Google traffic

specifically?

Like, obviously,

price and offer is,

you know, maybe not

where I'm going

with this.

But I'm just curious

if you've come

across any, like,

CRO wins that

have unlocked

crazy scale,

whether it is a

shopping or search

side.

Absolutely.

Yeah.

Yeah.

And landing page

is huge.

You know,

landing pages are

being important

on Google,

like, predates

them being

important on

Meta.

I mean, it's

historically been

very important

because landing page

quality score

is one of the

components of

quality score.

And quality score

impacts your

CPCs.

And so a

better, higher

converting landing

page will

increase your

quality score,

which means it

helps your ad

rank, which

means your

CPCs are

going to be

lower.

So it's

always been a

key component

to it.

And you can

run shopping

to landing

pages.

And especially

if you are

in, you know,

maybe something

that does not

have a lot of

SKUs, if you're

in kind of like

a, you're a

supplement with

like a massive

hero product,

you probably don't

want to be sending

that to a PDP.

You do want to be

sending that to a

landing page that

is specifically

structured for

that traffic.

Because again,

we get back to

the how can we

maximize the

inventory that we

can target

profitably, right?

Like that's going

to impact your

revenue per session,

right?

And that means

you can adjust

your targets and

you're going to be

able to get a

greater click share,

right?

Like I would

love to have a

90% click share

for search terms

that are good

for me, right?

Because that's

what's going to

increase my volume.

So landing pages

are massively

critical to

search, but

also to shopping.

And I, you

know, I'm not

saying create a

custom landing page

for every single

product that you

have, but if it

gets a lot of

volume and you

look and you

see, okay, my

click share is

relatively low.

Like, okay, well,

how am I

increasing that?

How am I

increasing the

click share for

this specific

product?

Like, let's

make a landing

page for it

because now our

revenue per session

goes up, which

means we can, you

know, adjust our

bids, which

means the

percentage of

the inventory

that we can get

and get profitably

is going to go

up.

So, yeah,

landing page is

massively critical.

It's the key to

unlocking additional

non-brand search

as well because

people are looking

for specific

things and

your products

might have

20 different

angles for what

it does, right?

Like a

magnesium supplement,

like it's great

for sleep, but

it's also like

good for focus

and all these

other things.

And if you're

sending all of

those queries to

your PDP,

that's terrible,

right?

It's like best

supplement for

sleep.

All right, well,

there you go.

Now we're hitting

our sleep queries,

right?

Supplement for

focus.

Now we're hitting

something completely

different.

And so, you

know, and this

is, I think,

the biggest

challenge with

Google is that

outside of

YouTube, there's

not one big

unlock.

You're not going

to find a killer

creative and

scale your

budgets 10x.

Like that's not

how it works.

It is brick

by brick

incremental

layering of a

few percentage

points of

efficiency here.

Unlocking a new

class of keywords

that's going to

add another,

you know,

$3,000, $5,000,

$10,000 of ad

spend a month.

That's running

efficiently, right?

You're layering

on these

bricks and

building it

one piece at a

time.

There's no,

hey, we found

an absolute

banger, like,

let's rip it to

the moon.

Like, that's just

not how it

works.

And, you know,

I think that

lends itself to a

specific type of

person who is

very in the weeds,

who is going to

do all of this

work.

And also why

I think

most people

who deal

with Google

or most

brands are

like, oh,

Google doesn't

work or,

you know,

it's because

they're not

willing to pay

people who can

actually do this

to build it

and build it

over time

because it

does layer

over time.

It is not,

we took it

from $10,000 a

month to

$400,000 a

month in,

you know,

two months

with one

banger ad.

It's layered

over time.

I think we have

a new podcast

called Skill Issue

that can come out

of this to bring

this full circle

where we just

like, we'll just

pull up ad

accounts and

Colin, you can

just publicly

shit on

everybody's

Google account.

It's so hard.

There are not

that many Google

people in the

world who are

good at it.

It is,

and I've seen

this with

clients who

have been

wanting to

fire us

for a very

long time,

not because

we're not

doing a great

job, but

just because

we're expensive

and they're

like, you're

too expensive.

We don't

want to pay

you.

We're going

to in-house

this.

I'm like,

okay, good

luck.

There are

just not

that many

people who

are legitimately

good at

Google because

the number

of years it

takes to be

really good at

Google is a

lot and the

attention to

detail is

massive and

the number

of

individual

settings that

if done

incorrectly

will completely

invalidate

everything else

that you

did is

incredibly

high.

You can do

all of the

things that

I've said

so far

through here

completely

correctly,

but if you

have your

conversion set

up incorrectly,

which is very

common,

let's say you

have two

different primary

conversions,

it's going to

be completely

non-incremental.

It's going to

generate zero

revenue and it's

going to look

great, but

it's so easy

to have

page view

plus purchase

as primary

conversions and

they're the

account defaults

and so they're

there in that

campaign and

you're telling

Google, I

value page

views and I

value purchases

and so obviously

one is much

easier to get

than the other

and so Google

is going to

just be like

generating traffic

that's firing

page views and

it's going to be

racking up like

efficiency in there,

but you're not

going to be seeing

it on your

bottom line and

it's because that

one single

setting was done

incorrectly and

now it's all

worthless, right?

And there's

dozens of

those throughout

the account and

you need someone

who can be

completely on top

of that, knows

where they are

and isn't going

to make a mistake,

right?

And there's just

it's hard work

and there's not

a lot of people

who have that

depth of

knowledge to

do it in a

platform and

then you add on

YouTube, which is

a totally different

platform within the

platform and it's

like, okay.

It's definitely a

lot.

Well, you've given

us a lot to think

about, Colin.

Lots of absolute

sauce for folks.

I appreciate your

time.

Thank you for

coming on and

appreciate you

being here.

Yeah, this was a

lot of fun and

happy to come on

and jam anytime.

Thank you everybody

for listening.

This episode is

brought to you by

Brad's company,

Work Marketing.

If you need a

D2C marketing

agency, let me

tell you,

Homestead is

great, but

Work Marketing

is also fantastic.

And let me tell

you, you

aren't going to

find friendlier

people out there

in the e-commerce

space.

So we decided to

do these little

ads for each

other's companies.

So hopefully you

find it interesting.

But seriously,

great team at

Work Marketing,

very smart.

Brad and Jordan

are incredibly

dialed in.

I just gave them

a lead, already

made this brand

that I gave them

like, I don't

even know,

double the revenue

that they had the

previous month or

something.

So, you know,

it's very exciting

to be connected

with Brad.

And if you need

a great agency,

there's really no

one better.

Zach, anything to

comment on Work

Marketing?

Yeah, I mean,

if you want an

agency that cares

about your business

much more than

they care about

their own website,

I just tried to

load WorkMarketing.com

and it was broken.

So they're definitely

going to give more

of a shit about

your business

than their own.

So I highly

recommend Brad

and the team

over at Work.

They've been

incredible.

We've referred a lot

of business over

to them as well.

Really, really good

as far as like

cracking funnels

and figuring out

like rapid growth

for brands.

So I highly

recommend these guys.

The only way that we

grow this podcast is

by you sharing it

with your friends.

Honestly, like

reviews kind of

don't really mean

anything too much

anymore.

They're really

meaningful, but they

don't do a lot for

the growth of the

podcast.

And so sharing

YouTube links,

sharing Spotify

links, sharing

Apple, whatever we

call it under the

podcast app now,

anything you can

share, the better

we're going to be.

Guys, anything else

you want to say on

this?

Yeah, please go check

us out on YouTube.

Rack up those views

for us.

We'd love to see it.

And then subscribe.

Make sure to subscribe

on YouTube as well.

And I relentlessly

refresh the YouTube

comments because it

dictates my mental

health for the day.

So please say

something nice about

all of us.

Thank you, everyone.

Thanks for listening.

Honestly.